News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by Zhenya on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:10PM (#26666070)
It seems backwards that Apple acknowledges the issue, PATCHES it, but still hasn't paid out.

Maybe a good business is bug escrow company.

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by spitfire on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:40PM (#26667643)
Bug bounty factoring!

From wikipedia:

> Factoring is a financial transaction and a type of debtor finance in which a business sells its accounts receivable (i.e., invoices) to a third party (called a factor) at a discount.[1][2][3] A business will sometimes factor its receivable assets to meet its present and immediate cash needs.[4][5] Forfaiting is a factoring arrangement used in international trade finance by exporters who wish to sell their receivables to a forfaiter.[6] Factoring is commonly referred to as accounts receivable factoring, invoice factoring, and sometimes accounts receivable financing. Accounts receivable financing is a term more accurately used to describe a form of asset based lending against accounts receivable. The Commercial Finance Association is the leading trade association of the asset-based lending and factoring industries.[7]

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by runeks on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:41AM (#26669692)
This sounds like discounting a Bill of Exchange. Although the Bill of Exchange is drawn only against the delivery of a physical good, so this may be the difference between the two.

For example, let's say I own a sheep farm. I hire people to trim the sheep, and they produce a bunch of cotton. Without the Bill of Exchange, if I want to pay the people I've hired then I will need to ship this cotton to the spinner, who then ships the spun cotton to the weaver, who then ships the woven cotton to the clothier, who then makes clothes and sells it to a consumer. Only after this has happened can I pay my employees with the money of the paying consumer.

With the Bill of Exchange, a bill is created when I deliver cotton to the spinner. This bill will require the spinner to pay me for the cotton delivered in e.g. three months. I can then take this bill to someone who trusts that the spinner will pay me in three months and ask them to buy the bill at a discount, such that they are paid in three months (when the bill expires). I can then use the proceeds from the sale of the bill to pay my employees immediately. And the buyer of the bill earns a bit of interest because he pays less for the bill than he is paid at maturity.

[1] https://professorfekete.com/articles/AEFMonEcon101Lecture5.p...

[2] https://professorfekete.com/articles/AEFMonEcon101Lecture6.p...

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by tonyarkles on Saturday April 03, 2021 @10:07AM (#26681161)
Small nit: you get wool from sheep, not cotton :). Otherwise, that’s really interesting and I didn’t know that was a thing!
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by spockz on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:35AM (#26672290)
I think the general category this falls under is supply chain finance.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by philosopher1234 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:02PM (#26667786)
I like this idea.

1. Company verifies the bug

2. Assigns it a price according to impact

3. Keeps details hidden until Apple pays them, then reveals the bug. Thus Apple is forced to pay, but bad actors dont get access.

Different bug markets can compete to correctly price bugs.

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by fractionalhare on Friday April 02, 2021 @09:56AM (#26671439)
In all likelihood, Apple would just refuse to play ball and tell them to go ahead and sell it to someone else if they're so confident. Zerodium and other markets already exist, and I don't think people at Apple lose much sleep over it. And you better hope you close that deal before Google Project Zero finds it independently and tells Apple for free. Plus the mere mention that a vulnerability exists in a specific piece of software may lead Apple engineers to finding and patching it before you can sell it. Give away too many details and it's burned.

People tend to vastly overestimate the economic impact of an exploited security vulnerability. A vulnerability which can be patched in a centralized manner has a low value half-life: it rapidly decreases in value over time. I would guess over 90% of active daily users of macOS already have the patch for this bug due to automatic updates. New buyers are essentially guaranteed not to have the vulnerability at all. The vulnerability would have to be absolutely catastrophic to be worth something, and in that case it would probably be used for targeted exploitation and burned after a short period of time.

Contrast with something like heartbleed, which is still around. That is a vulnerability with serious half-life and significant economic impact. The pool of available victims who can be exploited by heartbleed is nontrivial and persistent years later. Criminals will actually pay for something like that.

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by jonny_eh on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:09PM (#26668441)
That may be considered black-mail by some courts.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by lovelyviking on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:37PM (#26668563)
Can you explain it more? What can make it a black-mail and why?

If there is no intent to abuse the bug when not paied then there is no additional threat there from simply notifying the company that some threat is already present. How it can become a black-mail?

So every report about discovered bug can be considered as black-mail? If one discovers a bug, reports it to the company and says that after 3 months it will be public it's a black-mail too?

Or the payment request makes it different? And if person doesn't threat to publish the bug then it's ok?

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by IncRnd on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:38PM (#26668830)
Definition: Blackmail involves a threat to do something that would cause a person to suffer embarrassment or financial loss, unless that person meets certain demands. [0]

[0] https://www.justia.com/criminal/offenses/white-collar-crimes...

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by fouc on Friday April 02, 2021 @04:03AM (#26669808)
The longer a bug goes without being reported, the greater the potential impact. So not reporting a bug could be considered a form of abusing the bug. There's probably a moral obligation to report bugs promptly. Bug bounty programs that companies have are ultimately a reward for being a nice person, as opposed to being a payment for services rendered.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by fractionalhare on Friday April 02, 2021 @09:38AM (#26671304)
Yes, it's the payment request.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by downandout on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:39AM (#26669451)
In the US, blackmail has a very specific meaning: it is a threat to inform law enforcement of a violation of federal law under demand of a thing of value. This would actually be extortion, which is defined in 18 USC 875(d):

Whoever, with intent to extort from any person, firm, association, or corporation, any money or other thing of value, transmits in interstate or foreign commerce any communication containing any threat to injure the property or reputation of the addressee or of another or the reputation of a deceased person or any threat to accuse the addressee or any other person of a crime, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than two years, or both.

https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?path=/prelim@title18/par...

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by ClumsyPilot on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:18PM (#26668483)
I dont think apple is entitled to that information on any basis, and i dont think its a legitimate threat to expose actual ill behaviour
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by mdpopescu on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:24AM (#26670097)
All blackmail involves exposing something that someone doesn't want exposed - usually because the "something" is illegal. And yet, blackmail itself is illegal.

Most countries have a culture against whistleblowers, starting from childhood ("don't be a tattletale", "don't be a rat").

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by ClumsyPilot on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:11AM (#26672043)
And that anti-whistleblower culture enables fraud like theranos to be undiscovered for years
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by young_unixer on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:02AM (#26669128)
I think they're talking about the implication that if Apple don't pay, then the vulnerability is published.

I agree with you on a moral basis: what difference does it make if I get payed not to publish it vs. If I just publish it without even asking to get paid. But I'm not sure the law would agree with us.

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by ClumsyPilot on Friday April 02, 2021 @04:33AM (#26669931)
I think, like in many legal matters, precedent and intent is key. Without ill intent there is no 'mens rea', or "guilty mind".

In this case you aren't just a vigilante targetting apple, there is established practice stretching decades.

There is also a duty on you as a security proffeshional, and there is a significant public interest in knowing about the vulnerability. So , most likely, it will be you doing your job.

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by asdfasgasdgasdg on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:45AM (#26669270)
It's only blackmail if the threat is to do something you are not otherwise legally allowed to do. It is legal to, say, announce a zero-day on Twitter. Or to sell the zero-day to the NSA, or some grey hat broker like Zerodium.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by treis on Friday April 02, 2021 @11:55AM (#26672537)
No it's not. Pay me $10,000 or I tell everyone you slept with your secretary is blackmail.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by asdfasgasdgasdg on Friday April 02, 2021 @04:00PM (#26675330)
Ok, you got me. But there must be more to the definition of blackmail than simply, pay me or else. If that were the definition, then everyone would be a blackmailer by virtue of "pay me for this or else I'll sell it to someone else," which is a "threat" we all implicitly make every day.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by j4yav on Friday April 02, 2021 @02:00AM (#26669314)
In the US at least I don’t believe the act has to be illegal.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by Itsdijital on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:12PM (#26668463)
I guess that's true. Whats the end state if Apple refuses to pay?
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by albntomat0 on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:33PM (#26675120)
Then Apple gets a reputation for refusing to pay, less folks look for and responsibly disclose vulns in Apple products, and their security posture as as whole suffers.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by eyelidlessness on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:52PM (#26668890)
“It would be a shame if someone used this vulnerability”
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by twox2 on Friday April 02, 2021 @09:48AM (#26671377)
Bug bounty doesn't mean that the reporter is selling the bug they find for a reward. It's a gesture of gratitude from the company. This whole conversation is coming from a place of entitlement.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by albntomat0 on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:31PM (#26675098)
Here's an alternative view:

- Apple is a $2T company, that we trust with our data. That valuation is in part based on that trust. It's entitled of Apple to produce a product that contains shitty exploitable symlink handling and continue to have no meaningful repercussions (which is true in the industry as a whole).

If this was a bug in a small, under-resourced FOSS email client, or the exploit required many highly skilled person-years to find, maybe I'd feel differently.

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by twox2 on Monday April 05, 2021 @10:25AM (#26699400)
Both of these points can be true.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by cortesoft on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:18PM (#26668484)
How would price discovery work to "correctly price bugs"

What is a bugs correct price? The price that a bad actor would pay for it?

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by eyelidlessness on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:54PM (#26668898)
Some value between the cost of not fixing it and the value of exploiting it
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by llarsson on Friday April 02, 2021 @03:18AM (#26669598)
We have CVSS scores for grading vulnerabilities. So that could be useful as a start.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by saagarjha on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:14AM (#26670070)
CVSS is pretty useless for categorizing severity.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by saagarjha on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:05PM (#26668164)
Who does the verification?
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by adolph on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:33PM (#26668305)
NSA front company probably. They will do it for free so they can front-run the zero days.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by GoblinSlayer on Friday April 02, 2021 @04:18AM (#26669866)
Apple's own subdivision :)

An alternative is public offer when Apple promises to not release a fix without payment. If it's not a bug, no need for a fix.

Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by willyt on Friday April 02, 2021 @05:56AM (#26670229)
Did he phone them to check? I get a lot of fake invoices in my junk mail. I also know someone who lost £50k paying an invoice with bank details that had been tampered with by hackers. I hate phoning people but I always phone about invoices.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by hnick on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:50PM (#26667705)
Places like Bugcrowd act as a go-between but the company will have to be on there.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by megablast on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:12PM (#26667452)
Does it? It seems the priority should be fixing the issue.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by Zhenya on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:27PM (#26667931)
Do you think the finance department is pushing the changes?
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by whimsicalism on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:44PM (#26668048)
Presumably not paying out has a chilling effect on bug identification by good guys.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by smoldesu on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:05PM (#26668169)
A considerably larger priority is identifying the issues before bad actors can take advantage of it.
Re:Zero click vulnerability in Apple’s macOS Mail by hbbio on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:57PM (#26666656)
zerodium