News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by dzonga on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @12:12PM (#26636394)
one of those times, you wish every working man knew what efforts are made into bursting unions. And then reflect internally, are unions bad for a company to put in such an effort to keep their works unorganized.

once unions disappeared in america, the working man lost wages, political representation and so on.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by lnanek2 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @01:17PM (#26637397)
> once unions disappeared in america, the working man lost wages

I've worked the same role in union shops and non-union before. Non-union paid more and had less deadbeat co-workers to navigate around. Depends on your profession and skills, honestly. Probably a benefit for amazon pick and drop workers.

Really sucks at mixed union and non-union tech companies, though. At my current company programmers aren't even allowed to move our own computer between desks because only union people are allowed to do that, and getting the union people to do it will take over a week and be done at an inconvenient time interrupting work.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by cblackthornekc on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @02:23PM (#26638295)
> At my current company programmers aren't even allowed to move our own computer between desks because only union people are allowed to do that

This is also likely an insurance limitation as well. Where I work most employees are insured for basic injuries on site. Only those required to move equipment have the add on that they might move equipment weighing 50 lbs or more.

So if I move a desk that weighs 51 pounds and throw out my back, getting work to pay for it might be difficult because I should have gotten facilities to do it as they have the heavy weight add on.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by bluGill on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @03:51PM (#26639524)
The network cable I want to plug into a open jack doesn't weight 50lbs though. I've worked in places where I need a union electrician to do that task though. Fortunately the union was cool in that location and just ignored my crawling under my desk, I'm told in other offices they were a lot more strict.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by cblackthornekc on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @11:04AM (#26648217)
I work in a secure facility, when not WFH due to the pandemic. Each jack is numbered, and my computer is tied to that number. If I plug into another jack, I won't connect. I have to get IT to move it for me because it requires them to make some changes to switches. We're not union, but have the same rules.

It feels like you're trying to blame the union for pretty standard practices at established companies.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by labawi on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @03:20PM (#26651778)
Does an electrician configure switches at your facility?

I think this was a case where no reconfiguration was involved.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by lukewrites on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @01:14AM (#26643768)
I work in a non-union office and we also have the same policy. I don’t think this reflects it all upon unions.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by babelfish on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @01:27PM (#26637524)
At non-union shops it's not like you can move your desk wherever you want either, most offices without hot desks have a floor plan and an office manager who all seating changes go through. Don't blame the union for that.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by BitwiseFool on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @02:10PM (#26638128)
I'm pretty sure the OP is talking about how the Union requires that the equipment transfer is only done by a union employee. And, you'd get fined if you did it yourself. I don't think they're talking about the process being complicated, but rather that the union forcefully inserts itself into the process.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by asdff on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @04:46PM (#26640220)
I don't see that as an issue, I see that as a feature. What good is the union if a company can just remove union workers from the process in the name of "efficiency" or whatever metric increases profit at the expense of the employees? The other commenter complained it took a week to get a new desk. To me that's another great thing. That means the staff doing this sort of thing aren't over worked and have some agency to dictate their workload, and me as a worker would respect that system since I too benefit from this ability to collectively negotiate the terms of my job. Personally, I don't care if my company is running the most efficient operation, because usually that means overworking and underpaying your staff to do so.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by 1123581321 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @05:12PM (#26640591)
The culture these policies create isn’t proactive and healthy. It’s hard to explain if you haven’t experienced it. It’s dismaying and demoralizing to see someone deliberately punt on their job for hours or days without trying to hide it, just because they can. It makes you want to work somewhere else before you turn into them.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by asdff on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @05:58PM (#26641104)
I've seen that behavior all the time in my work experience and I've never been in a union job. There are shitty, frusterating, lazy workers in every job at every level, from entry level to the C level, and plenty of them find a way to not get fired and keep skirting by. I don't think saying workers can be lazy in a union is a very compelling argument, especially considering the collective negotiating ability the union gives you that will just be gone if everyone was left to negotiate with management themselves. I've set to see an argument against a union that couldn't simply be pointed to a non union workplace just as well.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by 1123581321 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @06:07PM (#26641190)
Yes, I don’t think there is any argument you cannot simply assert against to the negative or nullify with the same argument against other kinds of organizations on the Internet.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by asdff on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @06:28PM (#26641347)
Oh come on, no need for this cynical sentence that gave me a headache just to parse in the afternoon :)

The two big arguments I see against unions are

1. lazy workers

2. corruption

And in the case of 1., I mean come on. Lazy workers are everywhere union or no. In the case of 2., yes this happens. Wage theft from the worker by management happens probably a lot more, on the other hand. It impacts at least 1/3 of minimum wage earners in cities like LA and Chicago, and for those who have experienced a pay violation on average they loose out on 12.5% of their actual paycheck (1). Just look at the second page of this report and see the horrors for the working poor in our country who are under very little labor protections; all of these issues would have been stymied by a union protecting labor.

At least with a corrupt union you have some recourse where you can drum up internal support among similarly exploited people, and change your organization via vote. As a nonunion worker, in contrast, you can't do anything to enact change if management isn't playing ball with labor, short of quitting your job and losing any and all your benefits like healthcare in the process.

1. https://irle.ucla.edu/old/publications/documents/LAwagetheft...

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by 1123581321 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @07:07PM (#26641645)
Sorry, yes, that wasn't the best written sentence. :) I wouldn't actually say the problem is laziness. Developers are famously lazy. It's more of a problem of malignantly wielded protected status. A helpful analogy to the non-unionized world might be a manager's pet employee or a nepotic hire. A bad union environment systemically rewards this in addition to reducing wages through dues and reduced opportunity for good workers.

Wage theft is serious, but has enforcement paths independent of the presence of a union and if reform is needed, it should start there.

I am sympathetic to the plight of the poor but they can be harmed by labor practices supposedly friendly to them.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by ddingus on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @12:40AM (#26643585)
That kind of thing can happen in any work environment, frankly.

Sometimes people end up in the "yes I can do that" status group.

Could be they have union representation and contract rules that give them considerable agency coupled with low cost and risk.

Could be they are untouchable for some other reason too, principle friend, family, lover, child, sibling... Or, could be they have secured it through various relationships, power, leverage.

Unions do not cause this.

Poorly functioning workplaces can permit it to happen, and any workplace, union or not, can be poorly functioning for a ton of reasons, legal, contractual, managerial, financial...

Where that agency exists, sometimes people exercise it, simple as that.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by bendbro on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @01:32PM (#26637597)
And this office is not an office with hot desks, and not every office even wants hot desks. The behavior of unions monopolizing a job type in a company is absolutely to blame.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by jstanley on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @01:32PM (#26637584)
> are unions bad for a company to put in such an effort to keep their works unorganized.

It's completely plausible that unions are bad for both employers and employees.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by simion314 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @01:41PM (#26637723)
Only a good union example will invalidate your argument, maybe check history and find such a good example then attempt to reformulate some valid hypothesis or try something not that easy to disprove.

While you try to find some bad example of unions and show us how they ruined some companies consider that I will respond with similar examples where the CEO and the board did even worse stuff - so maybe we skip the examples comments and we can conclude that there can be bad unions and bad CEOs (or board/whatever), the main difference is that one group controls a lot of money and can create a lot of PR to present the other group as evil.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by toast0 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @02:28PM (#26638384)
> one group controls a lot of money and can create a lot of PR to present the other group as evil.

CEOs also control a lot of money and create a lot of PR, so don't try to paint them as always the good guys.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by wizzwizz4 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @02:41PM (#26638557)
I'd be surprised if unions controlled as much money as CEOs; union reps aren't generally on rich lists.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by salawat on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @05:26PM (#26640759)
Unions don't control as much money by definition. Any Union's coffers are pulled from dues coming out of the pay of the workers. While theoretically, a Union may make more than the employees of a particular Union workplace, it would be only because you took into account cash flow from other Union workplaces.

Statistical multiplexing is the only thing that makes unions viable to my understanding, and I may be wrong on that, as warchests may be partitioned by workplace, I can't confirm whether or not that is the case.

This is also one of the reasons why I'm not sold on the illegalization of secondary strikes. Labor should absolutely exploit network effects to make up for the fact that the capital class will pretty much by default.

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by sli on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @03:02PM (#26638870)
If they did, wouldn't the money be in the organization's control and not be the personal wealth of the rep?
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by smsm42 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @04:08PM (#26639744)
Check out the lists of top political donations some time - e.g. on https://www.opensecrets.org/. Unions have tons of money, and they spend it lavishly on lobbying, political donations and PR.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by laurent92 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @01:51PM (#26637888)
> check history

Classic. But historically, advances in wages and advantages tightly follow the economic curve: Employers increase wages when skills and economic development gets better. Not correlated with unionization, even when the union is here when the paper is signed and brandish it as a success (looking at you, Congé Payés in France in 1936, many companies were already doing it when the union gathered with the bosses to say “We do it”).

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by simion314 on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @02:03PM (#26638041)
I think you were manipulated with some examples, so let me know such example that you are thinking of, also try to fit your view with my examples: "miners union demand pay on time and safer conditions", "actors union demand safety", "teacher union demands a raise equal with inflation" . Your view is that this groups should wait until the free market will solve their issue? Many people here are comparing their programming job with someone that works an unskilled low paying job, this people can't individually demand things like "hey, put it in my contract that you will allow me 2 minutes toilet breaks, not 1 like the others, I am a 10X worker see my CV on GitHub"
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by dontreact on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @02:06PM (#26638071)
Wages have stagnated since sometime around unions started to lose power. Wage growth has certainly not kept up with GDP. And the decoupling of these two things happened around the time unions started to lose power.
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by ric2b on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @08:50AM (#26646577)
> But historically, advances in wages and advantages tightly follow the economic curve: Employers increase wages when skills and economic development gets better.

Except that hasn't been the case since the 70's

Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by robomartin on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @02:53PM (#26638737)
> While you try to find some bad example of unions and show us how they ruined some companies

I think your perspective does not match the reality of the last 50 years or so. We are not in the 1800's or early 1900's, when unions were super important in shaping our labor laws and actually helping workers. Nobody can deny that.

Since then?

To reuse a phrase: The huge sucking sound you've been hearing are jobs --union and otherwise-- going to China by the millions. Unions, and their aggressive anti-business stance in the US, have been a part of this exodus. I know people who forcefully retired from a number of union jobs as their unions decimated their respective industries and their jobs went to China.

Sure, of course, reality isn't a single variable problem and we can't just blame unions for the erosion of our industrial base. There are many factors that led to this, including our incompetent politicians and their never ending quest for party power rather than what's good for the nation.

Unions in the US have become distinctly different from their European counterparts. Our unions use the threat of destroying a business as a way to get what they want. European unions have somehow reached a balance where they understand protecting the business is just as important as protecting workers. It's a far more symbiotic relationship rather than a brutally adversarial one.

No love lost of Amazon here. I just think it is important to understand history so we don't repeat our painfully-learned mistakes. The US and Europe are out of time. We can't make more mistakes. We have been helping China achieve the rank of second economy in the world for fifty years. How much more self-harm is enough?

I desperately want to go back to having manufacturing in the US as an option. Today, that option does not exist but within very specific boundaries. Anything "union" is dead, whether they know it or not. Save this message and read it again in 10, 15 or 20 years.

[dead]
Re:Amazon loses effort to install camera to watch counting o... by dang on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @04:49PM (#26652991)
You broke the site guidelines badly with this comment. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here.