News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by clouddrover on Saturday March 13, 2021 @12:13AM (#26444170)
The problem is the same as its always been: the batteries still aren't quite good enough. Batteries still need to become cheaper, safer, more energy dense, more durable, and faster charging.

But the good news is that batteries are improving year by year. Probably by 2025 there will be large scale production of EVs with solid-state batteries with better energy density, safety, and charging speeds.

It'll also be good to see cars start to make use of ultra-capacitor buffers to more efficiently recuperate braking energy. The more you can protect the main battery with a capacitor buffer, the longer it'll last.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @12:51AM (#26444338)
I think they are. Most new electric cars are like at least 250 mile range, and Tesla's flagship Model S starts out at over 400 mile range (and their 520 mile range version will be available in about 12 months... that's more than most conventionally fueled cars). Charge speed is fine (you'll spend less time overall than you spend at gas stations) and safety is overall superior. Battery life is also not a concern as the battery in these vehicles will outlast the car.

I just don't think people realize that batteries actually are plenty good enough now. No breakthrough is needed. It's about driving down the cost to as low as possible and scaling out charging standards and networks. And ultimately, just banning new conventional cars outright (starting out by requiring all new vehicles to have a plug in a few years).

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by literallycancer on Saturday March 13, 2021 @12:02PM (#26447884)
Let's see. A 2011 diesel sedan can go about 900km before refueling. There's maybe 2 charging stations within 50 km of my central European location. So, the best experience I can have with an electric car right now is to spend a 100k on a car that doesn't work unless I live next to the charging station, or takes a day to charge. Oh and the car that I already have is not designed by Californians, so there's no stupid shit like a trunk full of snow every time you open it.

I think I'll still go with the autism causing, dinosaur burning dumpster fire on wheels for now.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @12:37PM (#26448179)
That would explain why Electric cars aren’t popular in Norway... oh wait: https://cleantechnica.com/2021/03/02/norway-at-79-1-plugin-e...
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by literallycancer on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:14PM (#26450551)
Norway just taxes fossil fuel cars so much that it's cheaper to buy a Tesla. They are like a Gulf state. Low population and a lot of oil. Plus the abundant hydro. I wouldn't draw too many conclusions from that.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by clouddrover on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:13AM (#26444427)
No, you need to think about what it means when all cars are electric. Current charging speeds lead to long queues at chargers like this:

https://www.thedrive.com/news/31274/more-teslas-on-the-road-...

No car on the road at the moment is capable of making full use of 350 kW CCS chargers (the Porsche Taycan comes closest at 270 kW). Ideally you'd want a flat charging curve at 350 kW to allow for more cars to be served by each charger.

If you had a flat charging curve at 350 kW it would take about 13 minutes to go from 0 to 80% state of charge on a 100 kWh battery. Still slower than fueling an ICE car and still not full battery capacity, but you should be able handle 4 cars per hour per charger.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @04:06PM (#26449987)
This is just the wrong way to think about scaling electric cars.

Current electric cars do about 90% of their charging at home. As the battery size increases, this number would (for the same people) actually INCREASE. I do DC fast charging for my 80 mile range Leaf, but for well over a year I haven’t gone more than 100 miles from home with it. If I had a 250 mile Bolt or whatever, I would’ve had no reason for any away from home charging. 300, 400, and 500 mile electric cars (like Tesla offers) have even less reason to charge not-at-home.

And Level 1 and 2 charging at home or work or other destinations is WAY cheaper per watt of installed charging capacity than DC fast chargers. So if you want ubiquitous electric cars, the solution isn’t to just scale out DC fast charging, but instead make exterior outlets ubiquitous. Add a relay-controlled outlet to every light pole and parking meter. All apartment parking lots. Many business parking lots.

Cost per watt for DC fast chargers is around $1. For a home charger, it’s about $0.10 to $0.20, and often essentially “free” as you just use the included charger and plug into an external outlet or a drier outlet in a garage.

DC fast charging stations should be reduced in cost, but you don’t need to increase the speed that much as there are diminishing returns to doing so. Just add more slots.

It is on long trips where DC fast charging is largely unavoidable, but even still, 500 mile range covers quite a lot of area and all but likely-multi-day trips. If I can charge at my destination, I don’t necessarily need a fast charger.

The solution is to make sure there’s enough L1 (external outlets, which are only like $100 apiece) and L2 chargers (can be bought for as low as $200 now... with installation cost no more than, say, an RV or drier outlet) so that you DON’T need such massive DC fast charging infrastructure.

This is hard when few people have electric cars but becomes much easier when most people do as apartment complexes will install outlets on parking spaces as a matter of course. Same for workplaces, metered parking spots, etc.

A cheap IOT-controlled-relay external outlet is something that would really help make this more practical. Hard to get traction when electric cars are a small portion of overall cars.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by clouddrover on Saturday March 13, 2021 @04:12PM (#26450034)
> This is just the wrong way to think about scaling electric cars.

Nope. It's the practical reality of what needs to happen when there are ever more electric cars on the road.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by _ph_ on Saturday March 13, 2021 @04:49AM (#26445398)
It is less about charging speed but rather charger availability vs. demand. Of course, it is easer to provide high availability if the charging/refueling ist relatively fast, but at any given speed you can compute the number of charge/refueling points needed to prevent waiting times beyond a given limit. There can be hour-long queues at fuel stations too, just there are enough fuel stations that this is a very rare thing, but just look at the people queuing up at fuel stations when a hurricane approaches.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by lenkite on Saturday March 13, 2021 @12:37PM (#26448176)
They really need to make swappable batteries which are pre-charged and ready to 'fit in'. This current charging network simply does not scale IMHO.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:41PM (#26449806)
They don’t. Tesla tried and stopped after a short time. It’s just not worth it as charging has got much better.

Charging scales better than any other new load we’ve added to the grid (such as air conditioning) as the vast majority of charging will be flexible within roughly 24 hours. After doubling like once a decade or so for a century, electricity demand has been constant or even falling for the last 5-10 years, which has been a major strain on utility finances. The extra flexible demand from electric cars is going to be hugely important for funding the maintenance and upgrading of our electric grid.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by clouddrover on Saturday March 13, 2021 @04:09PM (#26450009)
> Tesla tried and stopped after a short time. It’s just not worth it as charging has got much better.

Nio has succeeded where Tesla failed. Nio does swapping and charging:

https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a33670482/nio-swappable-ba...

https://insideevs.com/news/448165/nio-completed-1-millionth-...

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @10:47PM (#26452634)
Tesla succeeded. It just wasn't worth it. Not in the States, at least. It's quite possible it makes more sense elsewhere.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by dmitriid on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:23AM (#26444474)
> you should be able handle 4 cars per hour per charger.

It's still abysmally slow.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by clouddrover on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:44AM (#26444562)
Yes, there will still need to be more charge points than there are fuel pumps but your charging won't necessarily be exclusively at DC fast chargers. It will be a mix of DC and AC charging.

For example, if you're on a road trip you might DC fast charge during the day and then slow charge overnight at a hotel so you start the day with a full battery.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by erik_seaberg on Saturday March 13, 2021 @02:05AM (#26444649)
I guess it's feasible, but as of last year I've never seen a charger at a hotel.

My office had maybe a dozen, which is already not enough—EV drivers were required to go outside and move their cars after a few hours. I don't know how often someone who needs one is screwed.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @04:08PM (#26449999)
I always charge at my AirBNB. Just need an external 120V outlet. An RV-style outlet would work for L2 power levels. That’s not that uncommon.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by erik_seaberg on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:24PM (#26450658)
Is it hard to find one with a garage rather than street parking? They don’t seem to offer a search filter for that.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @10:50PM (#26452649)
Each time I've just parked in a driveway and ran a cord to an external outlet.

BTW, 63% of US housing units have a garage or a carport. That doesn't even count those that have just a driveway. I have a garage, but I solely park and charge outside (my garage is my COVID work-from-home office space away from the kids...). In a place that experiences 4 seasons.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by erik_seaberg on Sunday March 14, 2021 @06:13PM (#26459890)
I’m a little dubious about that stat. I’ve had a carport space, but it had no power and was hundreds of yards away from my (upstairs) apartment. It’s not an impossible problem but it’ll take a ton of installations approved by property managers and that work has barely started.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by rsj_hn on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:12AM (#26444417)
> (you'll spend less time overall than you spend at gas stations)

Curious how you are calculating this. I usually spend about 60-120 seconds refilling my tank once every 300 miles. (15 gallon tank, about 30 mpg).

Because gas stations are everywhere, I never have to plan a specific route based on availability of gas stations, or use an app to find where the stations are, or even think about how much gas I have, as I know there is a station on the way to wherever I am going, and all I need to do is pull over. I even have the luxury of refusing to stop at gas stations on the left side of the road because there will be another station a block down on the right side.

But with electric you have to go out of your way to find a charging station and it takes longer than 100 seconds to fully charge your car. So how can it be less time overall?

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by samcheng on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:17AM (#26444447)
With electric you plug the car in overnight while it is parked. It is full every morning, and you never need to go out of your way to charge it unless you are on an intercity trip.

It really is more convenient than gasoline!

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by rsj_hn on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:24AM (#26444477)
I don't think most people would consider only charging at home an advantage or "convenience". If you even need to go to a charging station once and spend a half hour to an hour there, that becomes very inconvenient, even if you only need to do that once a month.

Most people would like to have a charging station always nearby so that it becomes stateless for them, so that they don't need to think about how much they drove that day, and they want the charging to happen within a minute or so to view it as equally convenient as gas.

PEV have many advantages, but let's be realistic -- the convenience of charging is a disadvantage.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Andys on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:46AM (#26444576)
If you have a garage and a power point at home, you just leave it plugged in while you're not using it. You don't really even have to think about it - definitely more convenient than having to find a gas station once a week
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by bobthepanda on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:36AM (#26444536)
Also this assumes you have a driveway that has a charge point hooked up.

This does nothing for, say, most apartment buildings which don’t have charge points, or people who park on the street.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by samcheng on Saturday March 13, 2021 @02:20AM (#26444701)
That’s true; we’re going to want a substantial improvement in charging infrastructure over the next decade.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @12:54PM (#26448362)
We need outlets in apartment parking lots (they already have light poles, and block heater outlets are common in northern areas) and off-street parking. It’s pretty cheap to just add outlets.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by sidpatil on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:02PM (#26450450)
Assuming that the existing wiring can support the increased demand.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @10:44PM (#26452618)
It used to be pretty common for electricity demand to double every decade. Residential electricity usage more than doubled from 1950 to 1960, and then again more than doubled from 1960 to 1970 (and then about doubling again by 1990). A lot of that was air conditioning becoming common and then ubiquitous. Electric cars will be able to be more responsive to grid constraints than air conditioners ever were.

https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=38572

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by bobthepanda on Sunday March 14, 2021 @05:14AM (#26453812)
EVs are very energy intensive, and in a location of the building that never had such high energy requirements; parking garages are one of the pieces of the building that is extremely optimized and so may be complicated or expensive to retrofit.

Building codes have had to be adjusted to accommodate, but new housing is a fraction of the total building supply in any given area, and retrofitting can be nearly four times the cost of a new installation. And these building codes usually target a <10% amount of EV spaces. Anecdotally, I work in an office building that meets these codes and is all LEED-compliant and stuff, yet demand for the limited EV spaces outstrips supply and you basically get rationed access to it on a first-come first-serve basis.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by FullyFunctional on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:40AM (#26445065)
It's a huge convenience! I love not having to get to the gas station (it always at the least convenient time).
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by clouddrover on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:15AM (#26444435)
> So how can it be less time overall?

If you can charge at home overnight (or at work during the day) then you won't need to go anywhere else.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by rsj_hn on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:30AM (#26444504)
If a car never breaks down, then you don't need to waste time at a mechanic, either.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by samcheng on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:15AM (#26444956)
This metaphor doesn’t make sense to me. As a matter of course, a gasoline car needs gasoline; unless you live on a farm with delivered fuel, that means going to the gas station for it.

An electric car needs only electricity to operate, which is already distributed via wires to everyone’s home.

Both cars need tires; electric cars also need significantly less scheduled maintenance. No oil changes, no timing belt, etc.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by rsj_hn on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:46AM (#26445095)
The point being that estimating the expectation of something by excluding an important part of the event space yields a false estimate. No one believes that everyone always charges their cars at home and that charging stations are not needed, otherwise there would be no demand to build them. But when called out on the inconvenience of these stations there is a retreat to "oh, I only charge at home" and so that is the only case in which to take charge convenience into account.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Robotbeat on Saturday March 13, 2021 @01:01PM (#26448437)
It’s not a retreat. I drive a plug-in electric hybrid car, and I almost never visit a gas or charging station. Maybe every 6 months (I only use a little gas if I exceed the 35 mile electric range... I never drive 400 miles a day except on long road trips). I just charge at home. It’s way more convenient than gas stations.

People who have never owned electric cars just don’t grok this. Yes, some people live in apartments which often have no outlets for charging your car (altho they definitely do some places), but this is a minority of people in the US and so it’s fair to say that overall you likely will spend a lot less time charging than a typical gas car owner spends at gas stations. It’s a perfectly defensible statement.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by allannienhuis on Saturday March 13, 2021 @09:52PM (#26452371)
I've had my model y for six months now, and I have not needed to charge it away from home once yet. Yes, it's the pandemic so I'm not making long trips, but it's met my regular trip needs without compromise.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by sokoloff on Saturday March 13, 2021 @12:16PM (#26447992)
I’d time your next fuel stop. Start a phone video recording and measure the time from making the right turn into the station and stop it once you’re back on the road. It’s never going to be 2 minutes and will often be more like 10 minutes.

In contrast, if you have a plug at your house, you spend well under a minute to plug and unplug.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by mettamage on Saturday March 13, 2021 @02:09AM (#26444663)
Silly question: to what extent can you extend the range of a car by adding solar panels on the roof in cloudy conditions? If that adds range of 10% extra, then why not do it?

I figured they thought about this a long time ago, so I'm just wondering.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by clouddrover on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:27AM (#26445010)
It depends how efficient the car is and how efficient the solar panels are.

Here are some examples of solar cars and their solar range estimates:

- Aptera: https://www.aptera.us/never-charge

- Lightyear One: https://lightyear.one/technology

- Sono Motors Sion: https://sonomotors.com/en/solar-integration/

- Toyota Prius experimental prototype: https://newatlas.com/toyota-prius-solar-roof/60461/

- The Hyundai Ioniq 5 has a small panel as an option, but you won't get much range out of it: https://pvbuzz.com/hyundai-ioniq-5-solar-panels/

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by TylerE on Saturday March 13, 2021 @02:23AM (#26444720)
Not nearly enough. Solar panels, under absolutely perfect conditions (perfect angling, no clouds, etc) produce about 15w per square foot. Even if you covered every bit of the upward facing surfaces, including the hood, with panels, that's going to peak at about 1kw of input - and since you'll be off axis all the time it'll be less than that.

A Tesla battery pack is 100kw/h. So under perfect conditions you'd need 100 hours of charging to get one charge.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by fy20 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @04:45AM (#26445381)
The Prius Gen 3 had an option for a 'solar roof', but it's pretty much just a gimmick. The whole roof is 40W. All the panels do is power a fan to bring exterior air into the cabin, to keep it cooler during hot weather.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by rsj_hn on Saturday March 13, 2021 @02:12AM (#26444669)
Honestly I think the issue isn't with batteries or current technology. My lay view is that the technology to make PEVs attractive is already here. What is not here is the eco-system.

* Can you get the car serviced at an independent mechanic or do you have to go to the dealer and pay whatever they decide to charge you? No amount of battery innovation will overcome $1000 bills to replace a door handle. Check out Rich Rebuild's youtube channel for a description of the service costs of keeping a Tesla running out of warranty: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nq5c4jGR2gM&t=302s

* Is there a large eco-system of after-market parts and third party warranty issuers? This is required to drive repair costs down.

* Do we have good data on the lifetime of critical parts under actual use? This is required for consumers to estimate the operating costs over the life of the vehicle (whether or not they plan on selling it doesn't matter, as they will pay for those operating costs either in depreciation or in paying for repairs themselves)

* Is there a robust country-wide charge network that compete with gas stations?

* Is there a system to quickly get energy when you need it -- e.g. either very fast (10 min) charging or a swap-in battery system to give you a quick 100 miles of range.

These are not issues that require breakthroughs in solid state science. If the batteries don't last long, make it easier to service them or swap them out. If the range isn't so great, create a wider network of chargers. If the parts don't last as long, make them cheaper and easier to service by independent mechanics. Force a right to repair and diagnose for PEVs as we have for gas powered cars.

IOW, rather than waiting on breakthroughs in materials science, infrastructure upgrades can solve these issues, but lack of infrastructure can't be solved by breakthroughs in battery life. As long as Tesla is a monopoly provider of parts and service, and as long as the infrastructure isn't there, upping the power to weight ratio of batteries by 30% isn't going to do much to reduce ownership risk to consumers, and PEVs will remain a niche market dominated by wealthy consumers who can bear ownership cost risk better than middle class people.

* And of course, the electric grid needs a massive upgrade.

All of the above is well within the reach of existing tech. Whether it's financially feasible is another question.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by geoduck14 on Saturday March 13, 2021 @02:14AM (#26444678)
In my opinion, we are trying to solve the "EV range issue" all wrong. We are looking at gas cars, and asking "how can we do the same thing, but with electricity" - and we get a substandard result.

What we SHOULD do is: take a step back and ask "what do we REALLY want to achieve".

We don't really want long range and fast charge. We DO want worry-free power wherever we choose to go. It isn't a novel concept to suggest: inductive charging from the road into the car (as you drive). There are probably other more practical ideas, too, but - and this is critical- you have to start asking the right questions.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by TylerE on Saturday March 13, 2021 @02:17AM (#26444688)
That's insane. Inductive charging is wildly inefficient.

On typical phone chargers efficiency is about 60-70% max..and it goes down with distance.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Nition on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:07AM (#26444912)
So what we really need is a big network of overhead wires, trolleybus style.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by bobthepanda on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:46AM (#26445099)
Trolleybuses are very niche. The networks at least in North America have not expanded much, and many have shrunk since their heyday, because people find the wires a visual nuisance.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by Nition on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:53AM (#26445116)
I wasn't really serious. Although I do quite like trolleybuses. Even if the infrastructure existed I'm sure you could never trust the average driver to keep their car attached to the rails; even the buses come off sometimes.
Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by jjav on Saturday March 13, 2021 @02:29AM (#26444751)
> inductive charging from the road into the car

Society can't (for $REASONS) even get potholes reliably fixed in roads. The probability of something like installing inductive charging on every mile of interstate is effectively zero.

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by clouddrover on Saturday March 13, 2021 @02:18AM (#26444692)
> We don't really want long range and fast charge

Yes we do. As the article demonstrates, they were making the same arguments 100 years ago.

Lack of range and charging speed is why electric cars lost out to ICE cars 100 years ago. ICE cars simply took you further, faster (and still do).

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by FullyFunctional on Saturday March 13, 2021 @03:45AM (#26445092)
more than 412 mi, faster than a Model S? This argument is completely ridiculous.

Electric is already far superior for every day driving and close to parity for long distance (super charger is fast, but not yet quiet as fast as pumping gas - but if you have kids you'll welcome the break)

Re:Overview of Early Electric Cars by clouddrover on Saturday March 13, 2021 @05:43AM (#26445661)
> more than 412 mi

No, 400 miles is about right as an average range as long as your charging is fast. ICE cars achieve that easily. The Toyota Prius has 640 miles of range.

> faster than a Model S

Yes.

> close to parity for long distance

It isn't. There's no point pretending the situation is other than it is. You can do long distance driving in an EV but you are going to spend more time charging than you would spend fueling. That's just a practical reality.

The Porsche Taycan is the fastest road tripping EV at the moment. It's helped by its fast charging capability:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GFsjMvCFlig

It's an expensive sports car and on price alone it will never be a mass market vehicle. EVs still need to charge faster than the Taycan.

> super charger is fast, but not yet quiet as fast as pumping gas

It's nowhere near as fast as pumping gas.