News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Demoted by kenjackson on Monday June 06, 2011 @08:17PM (#2627364)
Gruber is repeating the obvious, but in a convoluted way.

Apple is about selling HW. Google is about selling ads.

That's it. Everything else falls from that.

Google's goal is to commodotize HW, and I this is, at least theoretically, doable. Apple can't really commodotize ads, at least in no way I can think of.

Re:Demoted by tedunangst on Monday June 06, 2011 @10:09PM (#2627616)
The past is not always a good predictor of the future, but I think 10 years ago most people would have said that PC hardware was commoditized. You had your choice of a beige box running Windows from HP/Dell/Gateway. Apple has done a pretty good uncommoditizing it.
Re:Demoted by ChrisLTD on Monday June 06, 2011 @08:46PM (#2627436)
Exactly. A lot of Apple's big announcements today were about features that create lock-in. Your music is tied to a $25 iTunes subscriptions; your reading list, email, calendar, to do list, and office documents are tied to iCloud; they even want your text messaging tied to your iOS devices. Then there's all those apps you bought on the Mac and iOS App Stores that you'll never be able to transfer to another system.

If you start using enough of these new features, switching away to Android, WebOS or Windows will be a nightmare.

Re:Demoted by rimantas on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:47AM (#2628056)

  > Your music is tied to a $25 iTunes subscriptions
But it is not.

  > they even want your text messaging tied to your iOS
  > devices
Another way to look at it: your text messaging is freed from your carrier.

  > Then there's all those apps you bought on the Mac and iOS App
  > Stores that you'll never be able to transfer to another system.
How is that different from any other system?
Re:Demoted by saurik on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @07:10AM (#2628637)
Seriously? Before the unified App Store concept, cross-device upgrade pricing was very common. You get Word for Mac one year, and then you pay a fraction of the price to upgrade to word for Windows the next; you get a medical dictionary for your Palm Treo one year, and then pay a fraction of the price to upgrade to the same app for your new BlackBerry the next... Apple wants to control the business of software sale, and in so doing control what those practices mean for their platform: developers are then kept from seeing their customer lists, forcing everyone to get a new kind of "lock in" to the platform that has never before been common.
Re:Demoted by niels_olson on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @12:53PM (#2629892)
Your examples seem to be pretty small corner cases. I'll add one though: when I got the Adobe Lightroom beta, I got executables for Windows and Mac. And with my upgrades, I still get both executables. But the elephant in the room at the time was that the vast majority of software was being sold into Windows boxes and the only upgrade path was up. the lateral transfer schemes were many and varied, but all trivial compared to the big pipe called Windows XP.
Re:Demoted by saurik on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:07PM (#2629963)
On mobile, these "corner cases" are the majority of sales: every year there is some "new king of the hill", from random Nokia or Motorola devices, through Palm, Windows Mobile, and BlackBerry.

And, even on desktop with our example: Windows itself was the lock-in, not the sale; if a competitor to Windows did show up, the apps would rapidly move (and were in fact already selling both executables): if the sales were caught up in a monolithic App Store, users would balk at developer's inabilities to give them upgrade discounts, and are much more likely to stick to their platform.

Re:Demoted by niels_olson on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @06:32PM (#2631193)
I was just aiming for the cornerstone of your argument

> cross-device upgrade pricing was very common

Perhaps from within the industry having a lateral path was a common denominator, something every company had, and in that definition, it may have been "common", but not from a consumer perspective. The opportunity to buy PC software for a Mac was quite unusual for a consumer. There are still plenty of full time Windows folks thinking about getting Macs and asking their friends "Will I be able to use <app> on it?". Maybe not in SF, but most of the people I work with (and we're talking doctors, military planners, etc) are still in a Windows world, at work and at home.

Re:Demoted by saurik on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:51PM (#2631848)
My argument mentioned Windows and Mac only because most people are more comfortable with that example. As end-to-end App Stores have only become popular recently on mobile, I only consider this conversation to currently apply there. However, the premise of the Mac App Store also /assumes/ a non-Windows-dominated world /by definition/, so I fail to see why you feel your comment attacks my argument... :(.
Re:Demoted by tedunangst on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:59PM (#2627590)
Are your reading list, email, calendar, to do list, and office documents not tied to the google cloud? If you use enough of them, isn't switching to yahoo/msn/apple going to be a nightmare? There doesn't appear to be much difference to me.

Also, minor point, your music is not tied to a subscription. The syncing is. Cancel the subscription, keep the files.

Re:Demoted by joev on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @12:01AM (#2627859)
The Data Liberation project is at least a token attempt to ward off accusations of Google lock-in:

http://www.dataliberation.org/

Re:Demoted by mhansen on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @12:14AM (#2627892)
All those things you mention are exportable, and yahoo/msn/apple could write an importer against these APIs to make it easy.
Re:Demoted by gfodor on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:00PM (#2627457)
This is a striking point. Up until now, switching costs off of the iPhone were basically a matter of dealing with AT&T. Once the iCloud tentacles are in deep enough it will be nearly impossible to say goodbye to all the licensed content that I only can access through Apple devices.
Re:Demoted by guptaneil on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:20AM (#2628015)
How does iCloud make it harder to move away from iOS? All of my apps are already locked into iOS, regardless of iCloud. This is true of any OS though.
Re:Demoted by mcherm on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @08:42AM (#2628845)
I'm not tethered to my apps... I can, if necessary, move to new apps. Once I did everything in Emacs, but I have moved on.

I AM, however, tethered to my data.

Re:Demoted by pyre on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:07PM (#2627469)
Though it depends on Apple's licensing terms, Apps that work on multiple platforms have an incentive to allow you to export the data that it syncs with iCloud. They want to keep you as a customer if you jump ship to Android.
Re:Demoted by thought_alarm on Monday June 06, 2011 @10:10PM (#2627620)

    > A lot of Apple's big announcements today were
    > about features that create lock-in.
Nonsense. It's only lock-in in that the user is locked into a feature that's really great and useful. In other words, no lock-in at all.

Their music and their content hasn't gone anywhere. Their contacts and calendar events are easily shared and exported via standard formats. They only thing they lose by leaving is the great software.

Re:Demoted by reemrevnivek on Monday June 06, 2011 @10:56PM (#2627717)
Agreed, the key here is that everything is easily shared and exported via standard formats. If that's the case, there is no lock-in.

The fact that Windows/Android/Linux doesn't have a feature or tool that you can import the data to also doesn't mean you have lock-in. It just means the market is a little inelastic, that's all.

Re:Demoted by sesqu on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @06:57AM (#2628617)

  It's only lock-in in that the user is locked in [--] In other words, no lock-in at all.
I really don't understand what you're trying to say here. Vendor lock-in doesn't only apply when you don't like the product. Now, if there were no other products you could switch to, that would invalidate lock-in, but it's reasonable to assume that the product being initially good is essential for lock-in to work at all.
Re:Demoted by swombat on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @07:14AM (#2628648)
No one is forcing you to use Apple's messaging platform. You can pay for SMS instead, if you feel that's the "free" option.

No one is forcing you to upload your music to the iCloud. You can keep syncing it the same way you always have (afaict, anyway).

No one is forcing you to buy an iPhone, iPad, or any other Apple product. What kind of lock-in are you on about?

No one is even forcing you to upgrade to Lion. Keep running Snow Leopard if you want.

If you don't like it, don't buy it. There are plenty of other vendors. The only way in which you could claim that Apple was "locking people in" is that they offer an integrated experience, so that if you go all-Apple, things work better.

Well, damn them, they should be shot! How dare they try to offer an integrated user experience to their paying customers? What bastards!

Re:Demoted by sesqu on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @09:05AM (#2628937)

  If you don't like it, don't buy it.
That's not what vendor lock-in is about. Lock-in means that after you bought it, you can't reasonably switch to something better, something that commonly you didn't know about or that didn't exist when you made the initial buy. For example, when offering integrated services, lock-in might mean that they won't allow a third party to integrate with their suite.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vendor_lock-in

Re:Demoted by swombat on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:06AM (#2629146)
Well, I just bought car X, but then car Y came out and I like it better, but they won't allow me to switch without buying a whole new car!

I guess car makers practice vendor lock-in too by your definition.

In fact, almost anyone who sells something practices some form of lock-in.

Re:Demoted by sesqu on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:15PM (#2629993)
No. For the car example, lock-in means you aren't able to use off-brand accessories, or service your car in an unlicensed shop. However, cars are mostly self-contained, so this mostly only comes up with aftermarket stereo systems and membership programs.

And yes, mild lock-in is very common. That doesn't make it a good practice from the consumer's point of view.

Re:Demoted by swombat on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @02:31PM (#2630323)
Considering how hard it is to get people to agree on interoperability standards even if they want to agree, I think lock-in is simply inevitable.
Re:Demoted by lurker14 on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:13AM (#2627999)
10 years after release, iPhoto still cannot export a complete set of user-created photo metadata. 10 years and counting.
Re:Demoted by sambeau on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @08:04AM (#2628756)
It does title, keywords and location. What else does a casual photographer need?
Re:Demoted by napierzaza on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:08PM (#2627475)
This is a very narrow understanding about what businesses do. They don't think of things that lock in users. They think of features that people will want to use. Solutions to peoples problems, even ones they didn't know they had.

So if you're good enough at that, people have trouble giving up your platform or service. Calling it lock in is just good features and service in a negative light.

"Oh, Apple does great to replace things when they break, but it's just lock in. It's not actually good service."

Re:Demoted by c0riander on Monday June 06, 2011 @10:01PM (#2627595)
Creating switching costs is in fact a regular market strategy and is certainly more than just doing something so well that people will have trouble giving it up.

Facebook has switching costs because all your friends are on it, not on another network, plus you'd have to learn a whole new set of privacy settings, right? The Kindle has switching costs because all your books are in your Kindle library and you can't transfer them to the Nook. Moving has switching costs because you have to give people a new address, learn a new neighborhood, memorize new driving routes, etc.

Strong businesses often have very natural switching costs built in.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switching_costs

Re:Demoted by napierzaza on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:41PM (#2627802)
There will always be a switching cost, even just remembering a new URL.

Surely companies do things to make the switching cost higher. Like as you said, locking ebooks to a particular device.

But creating a service or feature that is only on your platform just means you're doing something no one else is doing; making you more attractive to consumers (and creating a higher switching cost).

Re:Demoted by click170 on Monday June 06, 2011 @10:26PM (#2627658)
I think one of the biggest reasons your being down-voted is because your confusing the act of creating solutions to problems with what lock-in actually is.

Arguments can be made that because it costs more to switch from one platform to another, that is lock-in. IMO though, lock-in specifically refers to acts where a company intentionally tries to prevent people from moving away from their product or platform, most often manifesting as closed data formats or an inability to extract data that you yourself deposited in a system.

Re:Demoted by napierzaza on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:37PM (#2627790)
All the features Apple announced today are features that people have been demanding from Apple and any other vendor. What's the lock in?

Putting DRM on music so you can only play it on iPod is lock in.

Though I agree Apple is integrating services into iOS that are only available to iOS.So I imagine that gives them lock in.

I don't want to start trying to guess as Apple's motivations, but I don't see them coming out with demanded features as intentional lock in as it appears to be their solution to the problem.

Re:Demoted by click170 on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @12:31AM (#2627917)
>> What's the lock in?

I never said there was lock-in with this new update, I was pointing out what I perceived to be one of the biggest reasons your comment was down-voted.

From the brief bits and pieces I've read about this, I've heard of nothing so far that smells like lock-in. And I'm by no stretch an Apple fanboy either.

Re:Demoted by napierzaza on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @08:01AM (#2628747)
I was responding to your comment while restating my point. Not arguing with your comment. :-)
Re:Demoted by ChrisLTD on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:21PM (#2627507)
Sure, thinking of good features is the first step. But then isn't the next step figuring out how to make money?
Re:Demoted by napierzaza on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:38PM (#2627793)
If you have all the features you make the money on the hardware with the features. But describing things as only "lock in" is pretty meaningless as a comment. It implies that all it's doing is increasing switching costs and not actually offering anything to the user.

But it would only increase switching costs in the event that it WAS an attractive feature. Features that are not useful or interesting to users aren't going to affect switching costs, or lock in.

Re:Demoted by adambyrtek on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @03:27AM (#2628223)
Counterexample: Company X using a proprietary file format for their office suite. This is neither useful nor interesting to users, but definitely creates a lock-in.
Re:Demoted by zipdog on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @12:14AM (#2627890)
Except that ads are not a core aspect of anything. Businesses don't need (many) ads if they can get targetted access to customers through other means (ie Facebook, Groupon). Applications don't need ads if they can get funding from other means (ie micropayments, app store dollars), and customers don't need ads, especially if they can become aware of interesting products in other ways (forums for the like-minded, such as reddit). Ads in the way that Google is selling them may be a declining market to dominate.
Re:Demoted by bane on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:08PM (#2627472)
It almost sounds like your conjecture is that, in the long run, Apple is destined to lose this.
Re:Demoted by Tiomaidh on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:18PM (#2627502)
If Google wins, hardware will be secondary, and Apple--that thrives on selling hardware--will decline. And it's possible that that will happen...it's also possible that it won't. Apple isn't destined to lose anything. It's just that they have the potential to lose much more than Google does--even if everyone uses Apple hardware, Google can still serve ads to a certain extent.
Re:Demoted by meric on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:21PM (#2627767)
If Google wins, Apple can still sell commoditized hardware to a certain extent.
Re:Demoted by marshray on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:11AM (#2627993)
No, Apple has never been able to sell commoditized hardware.
Re:Demoted by meric on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:03AM (#2629136)
I'm sure if the iPhone ran Android they will receive a fraction of their current sales.
Re:Demoted by sshumaker on Monday June 06, 2011 @08:42PM (#2627421)
Apple's goal isn't to commoditize ads, but to commoditize the software that runs on their hardware. And they've done an excellent job of that with the app store - with hundreds of thousands of apps available.
Re:Demoted by pyre on Monday June 06, 2011 @09:04PM (#2627462)
I think that the point was that Google's revenue stream doesn't seem to be easily commodotizable, while Apple's (at least theoretically) is.

update: Downvotes? In my HN? I was just clarifying what I thought the original author was getting at, which wasn't what the parent post to mine was arguing against. If you have a disagreement with what I say, then argue against it, rather than just down-voting. Then maybe we can both learn something, instead of "I disagree with you, and I want to let people know that, but I don't want to expose my ideas to possible ridicule so I'll lurk in the background."

Re:Demoted by othermaciej on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:49AM (#2628061)
The point of commoditization is to commoditize your complements. It's clear that hardware and software are a complement to ads, and software is a complement to hardware. Are ads a complement to hardware?
Re:Demoted by pyre on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @02:02AM (#2628091)
It's not necessarily a comparison of how Apple and Google will 'attack' each other. Just a statement of their situations. Apple's primary goal could be commoditized out from under it, while Google's is less likely to see that happen.
Re:Demoted by sambeau on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @08:07AM (#2628765)
I don't agree. It's not just about money. Both companies are more complex & emotional than that. Apple really cares about creating well-designed technology and Google really care about indexing the world's information.

It's in their DNAs.

Re:Demoted by gaius on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @03:28AM (#2628226)
True but there is one crucial difference: people have to want a) Apple products and b) products advertised by Google. No end user actually wants ads.
Re:Demoted by philwelch on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @02:20AM (#2628120)
People don't want ads--but they do want hardware, and software, that's better than a mere commodity.
Re:Demoted by Tichy on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @04:24AM (#2628326)
I think Google is more about collecting data. Ads are just a byproduct.
Re:Demoted by ordinary on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @05:54AM (#2628483)
I think you're confusing the end with the means. Collecting data is a method Google uses to be able to sell (more expensive) ads. The data collection is not where the money comes from, the ads are.
Re:Demoted by Tichy on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @06:15AM (#2628528)
It may be where most of the money comes from at the moment. But Google did not start out as an advertising company, and I don't think (from reading "In The Plex") they really want to be one, either. If they could kill ads, they would do it.
Re:Demoted by extension on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:55AM (#2628074)
Hardware is already commodotized but hardware+design is still Apple's monopoly. The thing that can change that is desktop manufacturing.
Re:Demoted by norswap on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @03:18AM (#2628212)
And Gruber is about selling Apple. grin