News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Demoted by saurik on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @01:07PM (#2629963)
On mobile, these "corner cases" are the majority of sales: every year there is some "new king of the hill", from random Nokia or Motorola devices, through Palm, Windows Mobile, and BlackBerry.

And, even on desktop with our example: Windows itself was the lock-in, not the sale; if a competitor to Windows did show up, the apps would rapidly move (and were in fact already selling both executables): if the sales were caught up in a monolithic App Store, users would balk at developer's inabilities to give them upgrade discounts, and are much more likely to stick to their platform.

Re:Demoted by niels_olson on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @06:32PM (#2631193)
I was just aiming for the cornerstone of your argument

> cross-device upgrade pricing was very common

Perhaps from within the industry having a lateral path was a common denominator, something every company had, and in that definition, it may have been "common", but not from a consumer perspective. The opportunity to buy PC software for a Mac was quite unusual for a consumer. There are still plenty of full time Windows folks thinking about getting Macs and asking their friends "Will I be able to use <app> on it?". Maybe not in SF, but most of the people I work with (and we're talking doctors, military planners, etc) are still in a Windows world, at work and at home.

Re:Demoted by saurik on Tuesday June 07, 2011 @10:51PM (#2631848)
My argument mentioned Windows and Mac only because most people are more comfortable with that example. As end-to-end App Stores have only become popular recently on mobile, I only consider this conversation to currently apply there. However, the premise of the Mac App Store also /assumes/ a non-Windows-dominated world /by definition/, so I fail to see why you feel your comment attacks my argument... :(.