News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by neom on Thursday February 25, 2021 @09:35AM (#26263143)
Actually, Ben and Moisey owned a managed hosting company that was coming under a lot of pressure from rackspace. DigitalOcean as a product was a direct response to that market pressure. I think if you ask any of the early executives, none of us loooovveed the venture component, it was a way to grow the business that was already growing rapidly with strong product market fit. Remember, a16z only invested once we were doing millions and millions in ARR. In terms of Linode, I have no idea what you're talking about. DigitalOcean had 1 click $5 SSD offerings years before linode/anyone else made any changes to their business.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by yte14 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @09:48AM (#26263263)
I remember Linode being hesitant to dip below $20 because the thinking was that it would diminish the quality of support. That thinking was reinforced when you started with $10 (if I recall, it’s been nearly a decade) and we started getting large numbers of refugees burned by experiences with your support organization. Neighboring comments tell me it’s still a problem. We consciously didn’t want to grow $5 fast because we didn’t have capital to throw at any problem that developed. We, the market, not just Linode, also knew competing to the bottom on price largely relegated shared/cpanel/etc hosting to $0.99 commodity status and we weren’t keen to kick off such a war for obvious reasons. (That was quite prescient, looking back from outside in 2021.)

Anyway, yes, you eventually reached a position where you dictated the pricing structure, slightly annoyingly because it was a product that looked remarkably similar to ours (down to the incentivized Linode Library clone that’s getting praise elsewhere in this thread). I wasn’t talking about changes you forced. The entire product top to bottom was referenced against Linode’s work to grow you to a position to force those changes. Sorry if I wasn’t clear. I’m also not going after you for it; I’m only responding to fantastic product idea.

It’s just odd that when competitors would ask me my thoughts on the “Linode clone” at 2011-era conferences that’s something that’s news to you. Is that really not apparent to an executive? If not that you did so, at least that seemingly the entire incumbency, not just Linode, thought so?

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jiofih on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:06AM (#26263478)
> it was a product that looked remarkably similar to ours

As a developer, DO never looked anything like it. Linode was expensive and on the same playfield as Rackspace and a ton of other cloud hosts, very different from the instantly-spin-up-a-tiny-vm-for-five-bucks model. Their web UI also has always been miles ahead.

The competition also didn’t have SSD as an option until much later, and that was a HUGE selling point for digital ocean at the time.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by lloeki on Thursday February 25, 2021 @11:14AM (#26264417)
> As a developer, DO never looked anything like it.

The UI, the simplicity, SSDs, additional block storage... but also the API and its doc, as well as IPv6, regions, snapshots/backups, and availability. Later on, load balancers, object storage and k8s. All of that much simpler than AWS and both better thought out and more featureful than Linode or OVH.

DO truly deserved their success.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by viro on Thursday February 25, 2021 @11:36AM (#26264696)
The simper than AWS aspect was one of the main reasons I choose DO to do most of my cloud stuff. Also AWS had this odd habit of not auto charging me so it would go a couple months then I would get hit with multiple months worth of a bill.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by tasogare on Thursday February 25, 2021 @11:35AM (#26264683)
I’m customer for years and I don’t use any of the features you mentioned past the first two; I’m part of the 5$ VM crowd for who this is the killer feature. Should OVH have provided on-demand instead of yearly plans for VPS I would have stayed there as I’ve my domains there already.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by riffic on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:59PM (#26265841)
The API is a key point many people miss when they think of early DigitalOcean as just another VPS host.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by ksec on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:21PM (#26268492)
DO definitely had UI, SSD first. But Block Storage, Regions, Snapshots Backup and Load Balancer all were either first on Linode or being worked on for a long time. Linode also had Pooled Transfer and other tidbit for a long time well before DO.

Remember we are talking about early days of DO. Of course later DO innovate more and Linode had to follow. And the new Linode UI is arguably better than DO. Although it did took them years to make it. The beauty of competition.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by addicted on Friday February 26, 2021 @09:25AM (#26275046)
Before I ever paid DO a cent, I made significant use of a lot of their incredible documentation on setting up various servers, setting up your confide correctly, etc.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by creeble on Friday February 26, 2021 @09:56AM (#26275355)
Gotta +1 that. Whenever I'm looking for a howto, I pray that there's a DO one already done. The quality (and brevity) is usually the best.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by 867-5309 on Friday February 26, 2021 @03:35PM (#26279553)
agreed, the recent HN feature of Cockpit piqued my interest and I prayed DO had a tutorial for debian. of course, they did
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by z92 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:36AM (#26263868)
Right! Linode was $20/month at least and more focused to businesses. Not the then unbelievable $5/month for SSH ssh accessible virtual box with root access that DO started. Plus the SSD. Other hosting providers later caught on with DO.

But the thing I liked best was their "no hidden cost". You pay what you agreed before to pay. No surprise. No upsell, trick sell which were common with all hosting at that time.

DO still maintains that honesty. Not sure what will happen after their IPO.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jjav on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:40PM (#26267234)
> Their web UI also has always been miles ahead.

I'd strongly disagree (been on DO since about 2012 and on Linode a few years earlier; I still use both). DO UI is ok these days but years ago Linode UI was far better in every way.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by shiftpgdn on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:28PM (#26265378)
Lol, what? DO was basically a page for page copy of linode's site and product offering in 2011-2013.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by 1shooner on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:22PM (#26266188)
I remember at that time feeling almost bad for Linode because they had built up so much valuable educational content about what you could run on their services, and I was using it step-by-step on DO. The only differentiator was the price. Of course DO quickly replicated and excelled in providing that tutorial value as well.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by kchr on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:52PM (#26267393)
But were they really doing anything other than copy/pasting HOWTOs by Falko Timme?
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by disgrunt on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:57PM (#26265796)
They were both modeled after services like Slicehost I believe.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by yte15 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:15PM (#26266084)
Negative. Slicehost launched in the middle of Linode pivoting virtualization stacks after proving out the business and running into limitations of their first stack (UML). Slicehost was ... 2006, if memory serves? Linode was a few years old by that point. For those keeping score, Linode then went to Xen and now KVM just like everyone else.

Linode and Slicehost were very similar stories, though. Slicehost bootstrapped as well and was run by good people.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by neom on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:24PM (#26266211)
You do know that Jason Seats, the founder of Slicehost, was pivotal in the DigitalOcean story also?
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by yte15 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:28PM (#26266259)
Yes. What’s your point?
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by havelhovel on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:25AM (#26263714)
Whether your claim is true or not, there’s more to a product than the underlying technology. Frankly, this line of discussion reads as sour grapes and reflects poorly on the Linode team.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by wastedhours on Thursday February 25, 2021 @11:37AM (#26264714)
> more to a product than the underlying technology

Back when I was just hacking about on some SaaS ideas I looked into both Linode and DO. The positioning of both seemed quite separate to me, and DO "felt" more like the product I should be using.

Whether or not the tech was different, or that feeling was justified by anything other than an initial veneer is well up for debate - but entirely agree, they're discreet products, and this doesn't really reflect well on Linode.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by webmobdev on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:55PM (#26266612)
I don't think it reflects poorly on them at all. When DO started everyone still used the help document of Linode and Slicehost to setup and spin a server on DO. They could do that because DO was a clone of these services. To their credit DO improved and grew, and that's no mean feat.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by selcuka on Thursday February 25, 2021 @07:49PM (#26270307)
They all offered a VPS, which is basically a Linux box with root access. Any Linux tutorial would work on all three services.

I'm not arguing if DO was a clone or not, but saying that "you could use Linode/Slicehost documentation because DO was a clone" is a bit of a stretch.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by ksec on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:29PM (#26268571)
Yes. For those of us that actually went through the Slicehost, Linode era, the time when paying per month and not per hour for a simple VPS before everything was rolled into the word Cloud. Those comment read more like an accurate account of history while others read it as an attack of a company.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by thaumaturgy on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:13PM (#26268418)
I've been a customer of both for years -- in Linode's case, since 2009. Your comments are coming across like sour grapes, so I think this is a good opportunity to hear about some of Linode's mistakes from a longtime Linode customer.

First, you guys had the customer support interface compromise in 2013, and the worst part about that was the way that it was handled by your organization. Linode wouldn't own up to the compromise initially, dragged their feet on announcing anything about it, and then tried to downplay it.

Then there was another similar incident in 2016, and, amazingly, the response from Linode was nearly identical to 2013. No lessons learned. After that, I started seeing influential people on HN say things like, "don't use Linode". I stayed on Linode, but I also started using DigitalOcean after the 2013 compromise and split my hosted services evenly between the two of you after 2016.

DigitalOcean aggressively iterated multiple aspects of their products in that time period. They announced block storage in 2016. Your customers immediately started asking when Linode would come out with a competing service, and that didn't happen until 2018. Here, it was Linode rushing to build a DigitalOcean feature.

Linode initially focused on expanding RAM and disk space for your customers' instances at the same price points. Every year, you'd announce, "hey, we're doubling your RAM!" or some such thing. It was awesome, but I also thought at the time that you were shooting yourselves in the foot. How many customers looked at that and went, "yep, cool, now I can downsize my Linode and give them less money each month"? I know I did, at least a couple of times.

Then, you chose to try to compete with DigitalOcean on price. As a long time Linode customer, I never wanted that. If I want a $5 VPS, I'll just go to DigitalOcean. Hell, you shouldn't even want me as a customer for $5. Let them deal with me instead. I wanted Linode to be the larger, slightly more expensive provider with the even better support.

I've had to deal with Linode support a few times over the years. They've mostly been awesome and first class. I've never been unhappy enough with Linode to want to leave altogether. Both of you should be focused on eating AWS, not each other; showing up to a competitor's HN thread to complain about them being copycats is really poor form.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by ObsoleteNerd on Thursday February 25, 2021 @05:39PM (#26269244)
This just nailed just about everything I was going to say. I’ve used and liked both since both started and this entire thread is pretty embarrassing.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by fastball on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:03AM (#26263449)
You might be experiencing a form of survivorship bias / confirmation bias here.

If you work at Linode, presumably people would come up to you asking about something they then couched to you as a Linode clone. That doesn't mean it's how people were talking about DO when not directly speaking with someone at Linode.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by yte14 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:06AM (#26263475)
I don’t understand how that impacts my point at all. If an opinion is only held in one context it’s not actually held? Is that what you’re saying? I’m sorry, I don’t follow.

Before DO VPS was (and somewhat remains) a community even among competition. I’m not basing what I’m saying solely on the example given.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jiofih on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:12AM (#26263541)
He is saying that your perspective as a Linode employee might not represent how others saw Digital Ocean at the time. Which for me is glaringly obvious from your comments.

EDIT: s/general public/others

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by hobs on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:26AM (#26263720)
Well a non-DO employee (and someone who ran things on linode and then on DO) I would say its a fair read and what the mindshare at the time was.

Linode had decent service but honestly the irc channel was pretty toxic to noobs (one of the reasons I left!) and finding a "cheaper linode option" was great.

That might have switched quickly, but it was definitely a thing.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by yte14 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:13AM (#26263549)
I wasn’t talking about the general public. I was talking about the incumbents. I said competitors, not customers, and that wasn’t a corrected typo.

Edit: I responded to something that’s now been silently edited out and replaced with “others”.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by random5634 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @11:47AM (#26264842)
I've noticed that the folks who aren't so attentive to product / market fit and other items (customer ergonomics maybe?) tend not to really see what they are missing, what's different about the "other" guy that means they are in some ways cleaning up. I wonder if that describes linode a bit.

Security:

One issue early on for Linode was just abysmal security despite claims. Lots of denial and lack of transparency too which was even worse. For a biz focused offering that was just a no go.

Even 8 year ago there was stuff with the bitcoin hacks? Do folks remember any of this?

They might have been using cold fusion or something because they got hacked again I think just like a year later?

These weren't just little corner case hacks / issues - but major with plenty of denial and obfuscation from linode.

There was this hack here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10845170

I'm sure I'm missing others (unsecured mysql databases etc?).

---

Anyways, at least in my world linode was actually seen as the cheap/crappy offering even though they actually cost more which was weird. But I def told folks to stay away just because of the repeated lack of care around security.

I had no idea DO was at 350M+ ARR - nice job by them - wow!

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jiofih on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:19AM (#26263637)
I guess you may think of that in the same way the incumbents considered Amazon “another e-commerce play” or Google as “another search engine” while being blind to the real changes happening underneath.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by derefr on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:18AM (#26263625)
Perhaps it wasn’t their own mental model of the landscape at all, but just what they considered to be the most expedient way of getting the message across in terms customers would understand.

Hypothetical analogy: if I were describing my very-first-ever PaaS service, to competitors who’d only ever heard of IaaS services — and this wasn’t the point of the conversation (i.e. I wasn’t trying to sell them on the benefits of PaaS), but rather just a supporting statement to talking about how we do/don’t offer an IaaS feature, because we’re a PaaS — then I’d probably describe my PaaS by analogy to some popular IaaS that has a feature-set closest to a PaaS.

In my own mental model, I have a separate node for “PaaS”; but if I know that the people I’m communicating with don’t — and teaching them what a PaaS is would take time away from the real topic we’re trying to focus on — then I’m going to describe my PaaS provider as “basically like $foo IaaS provider” when talking about how it has the same feature X. To them.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by yte14 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:19AM (#26263642)
Again, I’m not basing what I’m saying solely on the conference example. I’m not arguing over the psychology of multiple conference conversations from ten years ago any further because it’s completely immaterial to my point (and one example of many; the point of the example was that it was openly discussed among competition, not “let’s go to the mat on what constitutes an actual opinion with the assumption that I don’t perceive conversation appropriately”).
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by Closi on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:45PM (#26268744)
Have you ever watched Kitchen Nightmares? Bad chef's are often surprised to get told their food tastes bad because everyone always tells them how good their food is!

If you know someone is from a particular company, you don't badmouth the company in front of them, but you might badmouth the competitors.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by fastball on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:38AM (#26263894)
Your point makes sweeping claims that "the entire incumbency" thought of DO as a Linode clone.

Can I see your survey results from 10 years ago, or is this an opinion formed by a Linode employee from a handful of conference conversations?

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by webmobdev on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:02PM (#26266722)
As a user, I agree - DO was seen a cheaper clone of Linode / Slicehost when they launched. I used to usually recommend Pair and Linode to my clients and, later DO to my more cost-conscious clients. At that time, I preferred Linode over DO, because the support was better and the prevalent practice than was to look suspiciously at new hosts because a lot of them folded up. You looked to older hosts, like Pair (and later Rackspace and Linode) because you knew they were reliable in both tech and the hosting business.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by temp667 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @05:02PM (#26268892)
I loved pair! Never followed what happened to them!
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by webmobdev on Sunday February 28, 2021 @01:48PM (#26295918)
They still seem to be doing really well - last heard, they've migrated most of their servers from FreeBSD to Linux and also offer Linode and DO like VPS hosting.
[dead]
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jiofih on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:15AM (#26263589)
You seem to be in the wrong forum - personal attacks are not welcome here.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jcampbell1 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @11:21AM (#26264521)
As an original Slicehost customer, and long time Digital Ocean and Linode customer, your version of history is bullshit. I was looking to move from Rackspace after the Slicehost aquisition. Moved to Digital Ocean because of the SSD offering. It performed wonderfully. Needed bigger servers, and Linode had just created an offering competitive with Digital Ocean. I signed up and ran some benchmarks and Linode was about 25% faster than DO. I moved everything to Linode and the company has been there ever since. For what it is worth, my Linode bill is currently about $2000, and DO is $40. I am calling you out as a loyal Linode customer who thinks Linode is great.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by stanmancan on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:35AM (#26263854)
I was a huge Linode fan for years. I used them exclusively. DO showed up and slowly but surely started being the better deal. Lower entry points, better specs, and then finally a more robust product line. I slowly found myself going to DO for new servers and eventually moved everything there for simplicities sake.

Linode still has a special place in my heart, but they have some work to do if they want to remain competitive.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jamroom on Thursday February 25, 2021 @10:42AM (#26263964)
Wow - really? I use both Linode and DO extensively and Linode is better on almost all fronts in my experience. Faster servers, better network, Linode's Object Storage is way better than DO's "spaces" and Linode's support is hands down the better of the two. If you're going to spend $5 on a server why would you go with DO unless you're already there?
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by maximus024 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @11:49AM (#26264860)
> If you're going to spend $5 on a server why would you go with DO unless you're already there?

I would go with anyone other than Linode, considering they left the control plane running a publicly accessible unpatched version of ColdFusion, which led to multiple instances of them losing control of customer's data.

Anyone but Linode.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jjav on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:48PM (#26267338)
I mean that was terrible, but I know full well that every company ever will have dumb vulnerabilities occasionally, so by that metric I could never use anyone.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jamroom on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:12PM (#26265153)
Yeah I know about that incident - but also believe companies have the ability to learn from past mistakes and do better.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by maximus024 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:29PM (#26265402)
Unfortunately it wasn't a single incident.. fool me once..
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by vinger on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:41PM (#26265587)
Last time I provision on linode and do at the same time a created a ubuntu box. I found I had to setup a few additional things in linode. Linode never felt as polished which is fine.

The one thing that made do better was they had a datacenter in my region.

No one mentioned vultr killer $2.50 which is where I would go if I wanted a dev box to play around on.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by smarx007 on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:32PM (#26267121)
I remember something being off in Vultr $2.50 offer which made me stop halfway during sign-up. Had to go to https://www.vultr.com/products/cloud-compute/ again to remind myself: $2.50 VPS does not come with an IPv4 address. At least today they openly mark it and I think 5 years ago you'd only find it after a few clicks.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by voltagex_ on Thursday February 25, 2021 @06:11PM (#26269561)
This was an advantage to me at the time. My ISP (Internode) had enabled dual-stack v6, and a few of the other options I was looking at on LowEndBox came with a NATed v4 address. Here was Vultr offering an IP I could fully control, even point real domains to!

I don't know if this is still the case, but I also got no SSH logspam from bots trying to log in on a v6 host.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by jjav on Thursday February 25, 2021 @02:47PM (#26267319)
Same here, I use both but prefer Linode in every aspect. Much better support and reliability in particular.

I moved a few very low-end hosts to DO when the $5 price point appeared but have never been overly impressed. Later Linode matched prices so no real reason to look into DO anymore.

But I do still use both. Partly to avoid migrating the DO hosts I have but more because I just like to keep aware of how both are evolving.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by stanmancan on Thursday February 25, 2021 @04:47PM (#26268757)
Linodes support is great; I can't say much about DO because I haven't had to use them.

Around the time I switched there was a lot going on. DO had released their $5 droplets. Linode was still stuck on their old, clunky UI, and the migration to the new "Cloud UI" wasn't executed well. Then there was a few DDOS attacks that took stuff down, and the multiple serious security vulnerabilities that they did a -horrible- job managing.

I've been at DO for a number of years now and it's been solid. I have a few dozen servers and take advantage of a few of their services. Their Managed Databases are incredibly well executed.

I've been happy over all so no reason to look elsewhere.

Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by bombcar on Thursday February 25, 2021 @09:48AM (#26263260)
Which is amusing because Rackspace is now overpriced garbage as far as I can tell, or a wrapper around public cloud.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by codegeek on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:57PM (#26266648)
I have dealt with Rackspace exact 2 times and both times, it has been a horrendous experience.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by bombcar on Thursday February 25, 2021 @07:53PM (#26270333)
They make you call support to delete a “cloud server” - glad I’ll only have to do that once more.
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by paulie_a on Saturday February 27, 2021 @07:46PM (#26289644)
Rackspace was always overpriced garbage
Re:DigitalOcean S-1 by CerealFounder on Thursday February 25, 2021 @01:46PM (#26266506)
The real story is Ben and Moisey were running one of the largest hosting co's in porn and then there was a security problem via one of their upstream providers and it created a DISASTER. Thats how DO was born from what I understand.