News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by _rebocador_ on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:01AM (#26235220)
Why not? I went vegan, it's pretty good.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by Aromasin on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:22AM (#26235330)
Echoing this sentiment. I spent years doing mental gymnastics to justify my meat and dairy consumption. Going vegan was a great release of that mental tension.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by lotsofpulp on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:35AM (#26235415)
I don’t need to do any gymnastics, cheese just tastes so good. Probably the least healthy thing I eat, and most difficult to limit.

I don’t need or crave sugar, chocolate, alcohol, coffee, tea... but cheese, yogurt, milk, and their derivations are irresistible.

[dead]
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by krageon on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:30AM (#26235696)
If guilt tripping turned people vegan, everyone would be vegan by now (seriously, who hasn't heard at least one berate them like this?). Given that this isn't the case, perhaps you can come up with something that is a little more convincing.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by roebk on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @06:13AM (#26235992)
There's nothing wrong with restating the facts.

Your argument could be applied to a host of topics. The truth is, the vast majority of people aren't willing to change. For example, heart disease is the biggest killer in the world and yet people still don't take the required steps to prevent themselves of suffering from that disease.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by creata on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @06:19AM (#26236032)
> There's nothing wrong with restating the facts.

Sure, but it's still counterproductive. Most people respond to guilt by just digging their heels in. When you want to convince someone to give up something dear to their heart, you have to tread carefully.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by krageon on Thursday February 25, 2021 @05:31AM (#26261576)
> There's nothing wrong with restating the facts.

There's nothing inherently wrong with anything. That said, they're being restated for a reason and unless that reason is the satisfaction of reading the post or hearing the words out of your own mouth, restating these facts doesn't make any sense.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by cpursley on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @09:32AM (#26237677)
The main causes of heart disease in the US are sugar, excessive carbs and smoking, not Saturday morning bacon.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by roebk on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @04:41PM (#26243260)
Highly refined carbs are certainly a problem. Regardless of your opinion, red meat - including processed meat such as bacon - is also a cause of coronary heart disease.

"We found that greater intakes of total, unprocessed, and processed red meat were each associated with a higher risk of CHD. Compared with total, unprocessed, or processed red meat, other dietary components such as soy, nuts, and legumes were associated with a lower risk of CHD." [1]

[1] https://www.bmj.com/content/371/bmj.m4141

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by tpoacher on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @06:34PM (#26244527)
This study suffers from severe methodological flaws, which the authors acknowledge (having made their research questions explicit), but alas it is used in ways that extrapolate the findings to conclusions unsupported by the study.

In particular, the findings are entirely compatible with 1. The possibility that meat will lead to a reduction in risk if used in the same kinds of dishes as the nuts and legumes in this study 2. Nuts and legumes will lead to an increase in risk if used in the same kinds of dishes as the hotdogs and burgers which were the focus of the study.

I've seen people (not you) dump citations like this to claim health benefits for crap like facon, which is deepfried coconut infused in liquid smoke, at the same time as branding a caesar salad a cardiac risk.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by wooger on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:32AM (#26237004)
Your addiction to breathing causes harm to the environment, so selfish.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by Monory on Wednesday February 24, 2021 @04:04AM (#26248078)
You can, however, live without cheese. You cannot without breathing.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by idclip on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @06:49AM (#26236228)
Can u message me ur recipes?
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by whywhywhywhy on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:22AM (#26235652)
Just doesn’t have the same sensation, I’ve tried all the latest modern vegan stuff and it just replaces things that actually would be the lighter more flavorful parts of the meal with stodge.

There is no vegan food alternative to say a rare steak or raw tuna which is extremely flavorful, nutritious and light.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by happyhardcore on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:45AM (#26235787)
I've found that the cheaper processed meats (chicken, burgers etc.) have the most convincing plant-based alternatives, usually from soy protein. Any seafood or dishes where the meat is the main flavour such as steak there's just no alternative that comes anywhere close; same goes for vegan alternatives to cheese. What I found most helpful when going vegetarian was realising that it's not an all-or-nothing type situation, and if I can go completely vegetarian except for eating tuna or steak a couple times a month then that's better than not trying at all, even though that's not an argument I've really seen repeated all that much on the internet.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by cloudier on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @07:22AM (#26236469)
It looks like your stance has a name: https://www.lesswasteworld.com/blog-1/2019/4/24/low-impact-e...

reducitarian: reducing proportion of non vegetarian meals without complete elimination

Some strategies for achieving this include meatless Mondays, weekday vegetarian meals or sticking to vegetarian meals at home.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by chrischen on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:45AM (#26235788)
That’s like saying there is no animal faster than a horse for transportation... until you realize you don’t need animals at all to get you to your goal. Yes you can’t replace the experience of a steak, but you can replace the satisfying meal with something non-meat (I’m not vegetarian).

I agree imitation meat usually tastes like crap but I’ve had great vegan fried chicken in Japan where I didn’t even know it was not meat until after the meal. That and just getting used to all the non-meat stuff you can eat (ramen, MSG, bean curd, legumes, kimchi). In American cuisine i think of vegan food as imitation meat and stramed veggies...

I think what most people associate with meat is actually the flavors that go into the meat-centric dish most cuisine is based on.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by whywhywhywhy on Thursday February 25, 2021 @12:43PM (#26265613)
My point is nothing hits that specific sensation that rare steak and raw tuna hits. Avocado is maybe the closest managing to hit the fatty sensation similar to the tuna but still has a stodge sensation too while the tuna doesn't and can't possibly replicate the mix of freshness and Maillard reaction of steak.

There's a good reason steak is such a common food for vegetarians to give in and eat.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by fragile_frogs on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @08:50AM (#26237178)
"I think what most people associate with meat is actually the flavors that go into the meat-centric dish most cuisine is based on."

Don't forget to add some MSG to get a savory umami flavour.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by scrollaway on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:51AM (#26235828)
Some people enjoy horse riding.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by chrischen on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @05:52AM (#26235842)
And some people are cannibals.
Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by scrollaway on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @06:59AM (#26236290)
Cool, but horse riding is legal, regulated as a sport, whereas cannibalism is, you know, illegal.

Like someone else said downthread, guilt-tripping people into veganism doesn't work. All it achieves is making you look like an ass.

Also, if you use Google Chrome, you're literally a murderer.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by chrischen on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @06:45PM (#26244633)
I'm not a vegan, so I'd be a pretty terrible liar if I was trying to guilt trip others into being something I'm not.

My point was that if you think in terms of meat, or horses, you'll only be able to come up with solutions to your problems in those terms.

If you go one level up and realize that your problem has nothing to do with horses or animals, and deals with transportation then you'll realize you can solve that problem and never have to deal with horses again.

People enjoying horse riding is in fact a completely unrelated problem (entertainment, enjoyment, or whatever you want to call it), as I was making the point by mentioning cannibalism (you're doing it because you enjoy it, not because human flesh is necessary for your sustenance).

If you open your mind to the fact that it may be that what you enjoy about your food isn't the meat but the flavors and effort the chef puts into the dish that just happens to contain meat, you'll see that you're probably associating that deliciousness with the meat when in fact it's just because the deliciousness was imbued onto the meat dish. We started using meat because of its convenience, not because it has some magical properties that make food palatable where other things cannot substitute.

I personally am not vegan because animal welfare is not high enough in my priorities to overcome the hassles of adjusting around the current bias towards meat in most cuisine. But if most cuisine started orienting around non-meat dishes (and a lot of cultures already do this, especially from countries that historically couldn't afford meat), I know I would not complain.

It's uniquely American (maybe European too?) to eat a giant slab of relatively cheap lean steak with just salt and pepper... most other cuisines mix meat with veggies, or in the case of Japan go for slightly higher quality (non-factory farmed) but lower volume meat consumption. Veggies in American cuisine are an afterthought (something you have to eat to "balance" your meal) whereas if you take Chinese dishes (while many feature meat), they can often center around veggies and make them the primary focus.

Re:Is soy a key driver of deforestation? by mixedCase on Tuesday February 23, 2021 @10:44AM (#26238571)
I'll be direct and to the point: I'd rather slit my wrists than drop meat long-term.

I find most vegan food distateful to the point of depression-inducing, and of all diets I've tried nothing has felt better for my body than going low-carb and upping my fat intake; which is nigh-impossible in an already limited vegan diet.

I'm happy that it works for some people, and I'm not against economically reasonable measures to reduce the externalities of meat production. But veganism is absolutely nowhere near being a universally viable diet for human beings.