News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:22AM (#26214074)
What if rather than taxing bitcoin, we just tax carbon usage?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by pyrale on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:43AM (#26214262)
While taxing carbon usage is a good idea, there is something fundamentally wrong with the idea of allocating so much resources, in servers, in power and in space, for what essentially doesn't improve people's lives.

That this craze receives so much attention and funding while we face very real existential challenges is maddening.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by JoshTriplett on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:49AM (#26214315)
> While taxing carbon usage is a good idea, there is something fundamentally wrong with the idea of allocating so much resources, in servers, in power and in space, for what essentially doesn't improve people's lives.

There's something fundamentally wrong with the idea of deciding for people what might improve their lives and what isn't allowed to try, rather than letting them decide for themselves individually. People decide to allocate those resources, for something they consider worthwhile. Some of them think they'll get rich. Some of them think they're changing how the world does business or exchanges money. Perhaps some of them are right; perhaps none are right but a successor that learns from them will be; perhaps they'll solve a novel problem or perhaps they won't. The world needs room to experiment with interesting ideas.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:06AM (#26214452)
> There's something fundamentally wrong with the idea of deciding for people what might improve their lives and what isn't allowed to try

I disagree, I don't think this at all an a priori wrong. It's helpful to consider the limit case.

If we lived in a world, for instance, where one person owned all of the food in the world and didn't want anyone else to eat it, it would be permissible for the other 7 billion people in the world to "decide for" that one that their food will be redistributed.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by vinger on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:18PM (#26217300)
Permissible by whom? The one who owns the food? By the mob of 7 billion? By your own Morality?

What if you are the only one without, would the 7 billion agree the person is morally correct to steal from them?

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by pyrale on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:39AM (#26214827)
> deciding for people what might improve their lives

I don't believe I did this. What I do, though, is measure the actual positive impact this tech has now.

> The world needs room to experiment with interesting ideas.

Bitcoin is way past the experimental phase.

> rather than letting them decide for themselves individually.

We're talking about something that has systemic impacts. Once individual actions reach such a scale that others get impacted, it's normal for society to get involved and set rules.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by rawtxapp on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:33PM (#26215831)
How do you objectively measure the actual positive impact of this tech exactly?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by pyrale on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:09PM (#26216165)
I simply hear to proponents' testimonials.

So far, the prevalent stories have been about servicing people living in countries suffering from hyperinflation, which is just as easily done with a foreign currency.

Another common point is the promotion of smart contracts. It seems to me that these tools are still anecdotal, and don't really provide a significant competitive advantage compared to standard contracts. Besides, cryptos not using pow and incorporating good tooling are much better suited for that.

The decentralized nature of the ledger is another common selling point, but proponents don't really tie it to a material benefit.

Other impacts, usually not really promoted are its support to illegal activities such as digital racketeering, money laundering, etc. For instance, the financial aspect of ransomware is usually supported by this technology.

If you feel I have missed some impacts, feel free to point them out.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by nightski on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:03PM (#26216597)
You've probably missed the most important one - diversification. A lot of people (rightly or wrongly) are concerned about the U.S. Dollar after what has transpired (and is still transpiring) with this pandemic. The Fed has unleashed it's full force and we simply don't know (although many are making their best predictions) what the future holds.

There's a reason companies and major asset holders are putting 1-10% of their portfolios into Btc, and I assure you it's not only speculation.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by pyrale on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:24PM (#26216815)
I understand that people may be interested in finding a safe asset to diversify into, but if there is no underlying asset to anchor btc to, it's purely a social consensus.

If at some point the economy gets better and people want to invest back into actual stuff, what happens to the late leavers?

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by user-the-name on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:44PM (#26215948)
We don't really need to. The damage it does is so incredibly massive that positive impact would have to be gigantic to offset it, and it is blindingly obvious no such massive impact exists.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by samdoidge on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:56PM (#26216055)
> What I do, though, is measure the actual positive impact this tech has now.

I don't think just measuring the carbon footprint is giving you an accurate measurement.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by user-the-name on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:35AM (#26214777)
> There's something fundamentally wrong with the idea of deciding for people what might improve their lives and what isn't allowed to try, rather than letting them decide for themselves individually

This is literally the whole point of having law.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by JumpCrisscross on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:31PM (#26215808)
> there is something fundamentally wrong with the idea of allocating so much resources, in servers, in power and in space, for what essentially doesn't improve people's lives

The track record of “for the people’s good” juntas is poor. When they aren’t venally stripping the populace, they’re squashing any hint of innovative challenge to the incumbency.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by pyrale on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:50PM (#26216004)
I don't believe we have discussed before. Maybe interpreting my words as a call for the establishment of a junta isn't the best start in a constructive discussion. Do you start like that with anyone interested in ethics?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by barneygale on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:19PM (#26216253)
Who suggested juntas?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by renewiltord on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:33PM (#26215829)
It improves people’s lives, just likely not yours. Just like I don’t benefit from caps on medical professionals, or police unions, or health insurance.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by arrosenberg on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:45PM (#26215960)
How? Beyond creating a few lottery winners, it has no utility for the average person.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by WrtCdEvrydy on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:47PM (#26215982)
Neither does a multi-million dollar yacht or companies / foreigners buying billions in properties for investment displacing communities.

In the real world, "utility" doesn't exist unless it benefits a select few.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by renewiltord on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:49PM (#26215990)
Vanishingly few things have substantial utility for the average person. But clearly BTC has utility for those participating in transacting and mining it, or they wouldn’t be doing it.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by arrosenberg on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:55PM (#26216045)
It's not "clear" BTC has utility for anyone. For most people it seems like a speculative investment vehicle (i.e. a lottery ticket).
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by renewiltord on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:56PM (#26216057)
Even granting that, speculative investments have utility. That's why people participate in them.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by grey-area on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:20PM (#26216261)
No, they don't.

Investments have utility, speculation does not.

Time was Bitcoin proponents would talk about the future of money (investment).

Now everyone just wants to get rich at the expense if the poor fool who comes later (speculation). We're now at the mania stage of this bubble, where crazy things happen and ordinary people invest because of the distorted prices.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by arrosenberg on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:59PM (#26216086)
What is their utility beyond being a lottery ticket? That was my original question. Lotto winners have mixed outcomes, so I'm not sure that its clear if those lives were improved. We may come find out they weren't.

State governments have had a monopoly on lotteries for my entire lifetime, so if we've granted that crypto is nothing beyond a lottery ticket, then there is no issue with society regulating it to whatever degree we can agree on.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by renewiltord on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:10PM (#26216172)
Society can regulate whatever it wants. Usually it can attempt to make some sort of justification but the justification can be fairly flimsy (as the marijuana regulations have proven). So sure, society can regulate crypto, as the US Gov already has attempted to do.

For the utility of decentralized currencies, it's best you get information from more than an Internet comment. Which sources have you used already?

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by CamTin on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:49PM (#26215992)
The average person isn't doing any mining, specific people are. It has utility for the people doing it.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by tuesdayrain on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:35PM (#26216912)
It's not just a few lottery winners. Every single person who bought and held BTC for a reasonable amount of time has made money. BTC is an extremely valuable investment vehicle that has no equivalent.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by dylan604 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:46AM (#26214291)
If the owners of the miners are actually able to turn their coins into wealth that increases their lifestyle, then the mining did improve someone's life. Just because it affects a very small number of people isn't much different than most other "traditional" financial products in exsistence.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:49AM (#26214321)
> then the mining did improve someone's life

On net, was it welfare enhancing for our species though? If I make $1 off of emissions that cause external harm worth $2 distributed among the 7 billion people on this planet, I'm basically just laundering money through a loophole in what the law today considers to be harming someone else.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by seibelj on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:22AM (#26214628)
You just keep moving the goalposts by using the most extreme argument you can muster.

To be honest the sports industry uses tons of energy in lighting stadiums, streaming them, training players, it goes on and on. Entertainment could be done much more cheaply and effectively. I think society should outlaw sport - so many people are hurt in injuries, and the climate is just utterly demolished through all the energy waste. I can’t see a reason why society would allow sports. It’s ultimately beneficial to a very small amount of owners and their players (who are exploited!) that take all the cream off the top. Completely immoral honestly. The fact society wastes so much thought, effort, energy, focus, when we could instead be going to Mars or training STEM graduates is just criminal.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:32AM (#26214737)
> You just keep moving the goalposts by using the most extreme argument you can muster.

The most extreme arguments I can muster? There are tons of industries that produce negative net value when accounting for externalities. $1 in profit for $2 in external harm is not at all that ridiculous.

> I think society should outlaw sport - so many people are hurt in injuries

My argument is that we should price carbon usage to account for externalities. I highly doubt sports turns out to be net unprofitable, even once accounting for those externalities.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by imtringued on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:16PM (#26215681)
Okay, lets say we agree that the sports industry causes externalities. The sports industry recognizes this and installs LEDs and other efficient electronics and cuts their energy consumption by 50%. If the sports industry and Bitcoin were equivalently bad the sports industry would immediately respond to the efficiency increase by doubling the number of stadiums and consume the same amount of energy in the end. Worse, they also had to construct new stadiums with concrete and therefore emitted CO2 during the construction process.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by pyrale on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:59AM (#26215023)
Bitcoin is not advertised as entertainment, though. And if it was, gambling industries are heavily regulated. If you argue that bitcoin is essentially a new entrant in gambling, would you support similar regulation? Otherwise, there is not much besides whataboutism here.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by JumpCrisscross on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:35PM (#26215861)
> If the owners of the miners are actually able to turn their coins into wealth that increases their lifestyle, then the mining did improve someone's life

Bitcoin is between high finance and casinos. Both are highly regulated.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by pyrale on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:53AM (#26214960)
It is wealth redistribution, though, not wealth creation. These people essentially take money from newcomers to the btc ecosystem, but btcs themselves are not tied to any tangible asset or value.

More importantly, creating new bitcoins is not tied to the creation of new counterparts. Essentially, when someone mines bitcoins, they are not involved in a productive act.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by undefined1 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:33PM (#26215833)
> we just tax carbon usage?

yes please, that would be the holistic approach. externalities like carbon need to be priced in. if it's in the price, then the market will adjust accordingly. a $4 [thing] will jump to $12, people will buy fewer until producers figure out ways to reduce externalities in order to bring the price down.

what's free will be overused. price it in to force efficiency and alternative seeking.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by xur17 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:30AM (#26214138)
I agree, taxing carbon usage is the correct way to go about this. All the ways I can think of taxing Bitcoin directly wouldn't modify the right behaviors. It seems like the options would be:

* Tax Bitcoin transactions - decreasing Bitcoin transactions wouldn't decrease energy usage

* Tax Bitcoin holdings - this is already accomplished via capital gains taxes, and again, it isn't the holding or usage of Bitcoin that causes the energy usage. It's the fact that Bitcoin has value that causes usage.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by toyg on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:52AM (#26214339)
* Aggressively taxing GPU sales, with exemptions for some sectors and hard monitoring of commercial flows.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by xur17 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:56AM (#26214374)
Well for 1, that won't affect Bitcoin mining since it hasn't been profitable to mine on a GPU for years, and 2 that will just force mining overseas to locales that don't have this tax (possibly to locales that have less carbon efficient energy sources).
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by gruez on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:03AM (#26214428)
GPUs are made in china/taiwan so good luck with that.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by sega_sai on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:29AM (#26214130)
I think it is probably good to tax for Co2 production as a way of addressing global warming. I just don't think we should equate bitcoin production with other CO2 producers. I.e. I personally think that the CPU-cycles used for science on HPCs are much more valuable than the bitcoin mining (that's just my opinion though).
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by xur17 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:35AM (#26214174)
As you noted, this is just your opinion - are we going to have a person or group that decides what forms of Co2 usage are most "worthy", and adjust taxes accordingly? And let's say we do go down that path - one could certainly make the argument that Bitcoin usage from folks fleeing oppressive regimes are much more worthy than Co2 used to search for aliens or participating in far out HPC research.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:43AM (#26214259)
Incentivizing stupid things (like taking on mortgage debt or over-coverage by employer health plan) is already the status quo of the tax code.

> Bitcoin usage from folks fleeing oppressive regimes

Have bitcoin people (I don't know what else to call the people who want to talk about it all the time) actually convinced themselves that this is a substantial share of bitcoin usage?

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by imtringued on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:26PM (#26215765)
>Have bitcoin people (I don't know what else to call the people who want to talk about it all the time) actually convinced themselves that this is a substantial share of bitcoin usage?

It's not because this is literally Monero's value proposition. Why would anyone who wants to flee an oppressive regime publicly announce to their government that they bought Bitcoin in the oppressed country and sold it in a less oppressive country?

Information about Monero (don't dare to even think of buying it for speculation) https://www.monero.how/how-does-monero-work-details-in-plain...

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:55PM (#26216539)
How do I cash out monero?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by noobly on Sunday February 21, 2021 @06:02PM (#26218248)
>don't dare to even think of buying it for speculation

why not?

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by imtringued on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:23PM (#26215737)
This is a terrible argument because the transaction fees on Bitcoin are high enough that anyone who wants to flee an oppressive regime would just buy any other cryptocurrency that isn't suffering from power consumption problems.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by xur17 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:30PM (#26215805)
Fees are $3 if you are willing to wait 12 hours, otherwise $5 for 30 minutes.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by sega_sai on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:49AM (#26214313)
I think, yes, somebody should adjust taxes accordingly. The status quo with existing costs and taxes already effectively establishes some preferences for industries/goals, just implicitely. I think trying to explicitely express those preferences is better. (and it will never be 100% optimal that's for sure)
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by thysultan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:37AM (#26214192)
You tax carbon, country B now has an advantage over you. You loose!

Now all your products are produced in country B, you've changed nothing and country B is probably using coal so you're worse off from your initial goal.

You loose double!

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jcranmer on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:40AM (#26214222)
That's why a lot of carbon tax proposals also impose those taxes on imports.

(Also, you mean to use 'lose' here, not 'loose'.)

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:40AM (#26214230)
> You tax carbon, country B now has an advantage over you. You loose!

Tariff based on carbon expenditure.

It's pretty simple, this has been thought out - and it is pretty clearly a welfare enhancing policy.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by thysultan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:49AM (#26214322)
Add Country C into the mix: It doesn't produce carbon but doesn't have tariff's on Country B.

>It's pretty simple, this has been thought out

You and others alike have clearly not thought this out as the scenario i have layered out is already happening with other tariff-able commodities.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whimsicalism on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:53AM (#26214345)
Why do people think "enforcement is impossible" is such a strong argument against taxes?

If your argument is that tariffs don't disincentivize behaviors because the government is just that bad at collecting taxes, you're not really in step with reality.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by thysultan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:07AM (#26214460)
But you can't enforce your taxes in other governments.

In fact other governments in a game theory like ploy to get ahead of your country may agree to international agreements that they know they can game to their advantage.

The fundamental assumptions are wrong. You're not in this together. All countries are in direct competition, and some a more cut-throat than others. If potential disaster B is coming irregardless, country B can position themselves to come-out on top of country A when it does.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by iso1210 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:37AM (#26214805)
If it imports carbon from Country B then it uses carbon, so treat it as such.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by renewiltord on Sunday February 21, 2021 @01:35PM (#26215851)
Why would it be country-based? Besides the obvious thing that Country of Origin rules apply anyway.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by undersuit on Sunday February 21, 2021 @05:43PM (#26218087)
An argument could be made if we don't apply the Carbon Tax to poor or third-world countries it will help them develop faster... but those third-world countries shouldn't be shipping us resources in the first place!
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by ericd on Sunday February 21, 2021 @02:54PM (#26216529)
Trade blocs and economic sanctions?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jbay808 on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:41AM (#26214241)
This is why you sign up for an international treaty that has teeth, ratify it, and back it up with penalties including carbon tariffs.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by thysultan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @11:14AM (#26214535)
Name one international treaty that has ever had teeth where the benefits of non-conformance out weight the teeth.

Country B could tarrif country A in return and some countries cannot afford the cost of what that may do to them.

So you end up with an international treaty without international conformance or a treaty with no real teeth because the signee's have contributed to it what would allow "them" to game the treaty.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jude- on Sunday February 21, 2021 @04:37PM (#26217491)
Banning CFCs globally via the Montreal Protocol.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by thysultan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @09:02PM (#26219855)
To put it bluntly China still has CFC emissions.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jcranmer on Monday February 22, 2021 @12:23AM (#26221167)
And funnily enough, it's still lower than it would have been without the treaty. It's almost as if compliance doesn't have to be perfect to be effective, fancy that.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by galangalalgol on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:42AM (#26214246)
Nations agreed on laws for ocean and air travel. Countries that disobey them are ostracized or even subject to violence. Nations could in theory do the same for polluting the ocean and air. But that gets viewed as denying developing countries the benefits developed countries had.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by spaced-out on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:41AM (#26214233)
You add tariffs to country B's products to make up the difference.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by thysultan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:46AM (#26214290)
country B sells to country C that does the final packaging and then sells it to you.

This is happening right now if you haven't already noticed.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by jcranmer on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:50AM (#26214324)
Country of origin rules still kick in that case. This is tour de force for rules around tariffs, know you nothing about how these work?
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by thysultan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @10:58AM (#26214383)
If it worked it wouldn't be happening, the fact that it is happening, and to well known country's proofs they don't work and is profitable for country B and C for it to continue to not work.

This not withstanding the obfuscation of country of origin that can happen If country B and C really wanted to work together.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by spaced-out on Sunday February 21, 2021 @03:16PM (#26216736)
You're describing someone evading the law, and your argument boils down to: "if laws worked, people wouldn't get away with breaking them."

We'll have to agree to disagree on that.

Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by thysultan on Sunday February 21, 2021 @08:53PM (#26219790)
We're not talking about people, we're talking about governments, and other governments do not have to obey your governments tax law.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by Qwertious on Sunday February 21, 2021 @08:28PM (#26219561)
I agree with every part of that sentence except the "just". People have been trying desperately to do that for 40+ years without success, it's clearly not easy.
Re:When Bitcoin miners take over a town (2018) by whywhywhywhy on Monday February 22, 2021 @08:37AM (#26224322)
Can we have a solution that doesn't mean giving the government yet more money.