News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by overcast on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:20PM (#26135291)
The Moderna dose is already more than 3x the dosage of the Pfizer ones. 100mcg vs 30mcg. Would be great if they could cut that down and still be effective.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by CyanLite2 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:31PM (#26135395)
They're not the same formulation, so you can't compare the dosing, it's Apples vs. Walnuts

The problem with the 50mcg dose is that there is justifiable concern that if you error on the side of low-dosing that the mass vaccination won't work and the public sentiment will turn against it. We'd rather see 95% efficacy with the 100mcg than risk the POSSIBILITY of 60% efficacy with the 50mcg dose. We literally have one shot (or two, pun intended) to get it right the first time. Only 4 months ago, most of the world hadn't even heard of mRNA vaccines or somehow believed it was micro-chipped by Bill Gates. Much of that nonsense has gone away because they're getting unbelievable efficacy that's higher than the traditionally-made vaccines from Astra-Zeneca and JnJ.

Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by barapa on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:21PM (#26137624)
Just use your pun - no need to point it out every time.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by IgorPartola on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:53PM (#26135623)
Yeah. And a dose of vitamin C at 3000 mg is 30,000 larger than Moderna’s. You are comparing apples and cheese. Simply weighing them won’t tell you anything.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by overcast on Sunday February 14, 2021 @11:49PM (#26139214)
They are both messenger RNA vaccines, so it's more like comparing two types of apples. But thank you for your sarcastic response, very helpful.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by tempestn on Monday February 15, 2021 @03:50AM (#26140577)
The issue is that mRNA is only a tiny fraction of the vaccine by weight. The rest is made up of the lipids that hold it, plus stabilizers and such. The ratio of those to the mRNA core varies between the two vaccines. So comparing their weights is meaningless. The fact that Moderna's dose is several times larger doesn't mean you're getting several times as much mRNA. Hence, it's like comparing the weights of two different foods with different calorie densities - ie, apples and cheese.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by DrAwdeOccarim on Monday February 15, 2021 @05:37AM (#26141349)
The microgram dose refers only to the mRNA, not the lipids, stabilizers, and such. You're right that is is only a tiny fraction of the vaccine by weight, but the dose mass refers only to the mRNA amount. So you are getting 3.33x more mRNA in the Moderna vaccines compared to the Pfizer/BioNTech vaccine.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by tempestn on Tuesday February 16, 2021 @01:28AM (#26151488)
Ah, thank you for that correction. In retrospect I should have realized that since 100mcg is a tiny amount.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by protomyth on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:58PM (#26135667)
I gotta say that the dose really is a pain in the arm. We ended up on the list at work and the first dose hurt for a good four days. Others had a similar outcome. My father got the first Pfizer and he reported no issues with his arm hurting. I doubt he was not telling the truth on that one.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by scottru on Sunday February 14, 2021 @07:02PM (#26137513)
This could be because of the manufacturer, or it could be because your father is older than you. There's a small amount of actual data (https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/covid-19/info-by-product/pfizer..., which just talks about injection site pain) and anecdata/implied wisdom (https://www.aarp.org/health/conditions-treatments/info-2020/...) that says that older recipients are dealing with fewer side effects than younger recipients.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by protomyth on Sunday February 14, 2021 @10:05PM (#26138610)
Well, I'm the youngest of our group that got it and I'm 50. The older folks all had arm pain for days. We had a lot of grumpy folks on a video call three days later.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by jek0 on Monday February 15, 2021 @08:06AM (#26142339)
Nocebo effect is proven for vaccines. Even if we inject salted water: many will develop fevers, arm pain, headaches, nausea, ... (because they expect such symptoms). In some cases, as many as 90% of observed side effects are nocebo. i.e. if 100 people get the real vaccine and 100 people get salted water, 10 will get side effects on the first group, 9 will get the same side effects on the control group.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by blhack on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:03PM (#26135721)
Got Pfizer. Zero arm pain. Same for my wife.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by haggy on Sunday February 14, 2021 @10:08PM (#26138622)
Moderna is well known to have more injection site pain and greater immune response for the second dose but it's showing vastly greater efficacy percentages than all other manufacturers
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by boc on Monday February 15, 2021 @12:27AM (#26139410)
More than Pfizer?
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by yyyk on Monday February 15, 2021 @06:27AM (#26141696)
It hurt a bit for two days, then subsided. No other side-effects aside from better 5G reception /jk .
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by HenryBemis on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:26PM (#26135340)
So... if that plays out, perhaps split the doses in half, cover twice the people, so we can all go back to our normal pre-COVID life (or what's left of it).

Of course this won't double the number of people vaccinated since Moderna doesn't cover 100%. But every little helps.

Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by downrightmike on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:34PM (#26135426)
We're not going back to pre covid lives period. Even if everyone was vaxxed there would still be more moderate cases that our hospitals can handle. And then that allows the virus millions of chances to mutate and then, just like we're seeing with the UK and South Africa strains. Which as we're seeing all but nullifies the vaccine. The vaccines we're seeing are only 10% effective against the SA strain. Statistically >5% is great, but that's not a risk the vast majority of people want to run with.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by grey-area on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:43PM (#26135509)
The vaccines we're seeing are only 10% effective against the SA strain.

This is not accurate.

The AZ vaccine was only 10% effective in a study in SA. That's the only one that was shown to be vastly less effective.

The Pfizer vaccine is believed to be effective against the SA variant (though I think it used In Vitro studies) and there are lots of other vaccines on the way. We will get this under control but it will be a long slow process over several years.

Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by downrightmike on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:26PM (#26135921)
So far it is the only one.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by ingenium on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:47PM (#26136119)
I believe Moderna was also shown to be effective.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by vmception on Sunday February 14, 2021 @10:43PM (#26138802)
Astrazeneca is not an mRNA vaccine so there’s that
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by Denvercoder9 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:44PM (#26135523)
> We're not going back to pre covid lives period.

We are. Most people, myself included, won't accept living like this forever. If vaccination fails and no treatment will be found, we'll expand healthcare capacity and accept that people will die.

Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by downrightmike on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:28PM (#26135942)
We're already taxing our medical system. Personnel will wear down.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by Denvercoder9 on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:43PM (#26136085)
Hence I said to expand healthcare capacity. If there's not enough personnel, we should educate and hire more personnel. I'm not saying this is something we should do tomorrow -- only in the hypothetical case that we haven't found an effective prevention and/or cure in 5 years or so.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by maxerickson on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:20PM (#26137984)
Pausing the entire global economy for 5 weeks would be vastly less costly than training personnel while we deal with it for 5 years.

I do get that it would never happen, because people would refuse to do it (their belief that it wouldn't work would, in a sublime irony, prevent it from working).

Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by giantDinosaur on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:38PM (#26138102)
Can you put a figure on 'pausing the global economy for 5 weeks'? How do you know it would be less expensive? The global economy is massive so you'll have to provide some well reasoned figures to support such a claim. Such a pause could easily trigger much larger problems, how do you know it wouldn't? And why did you pick five weeks? The disease won't be eliminated in five weeks of everyone doing nothing; plus a lot of the global economy is essential to human civilisation.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by maxerickson on Sunday February 14, 2021 @08:46PM (#26138151)
The net cost would be very small. There would be a planned period of increased activity prior and a period of make up after. And then you'd have 5 years of the economy running without a pandemic to make up any loss.

Substitute some other plan of coordinated action for the five weeks if you want. I don't care to argue about it, it's clear from New Zealand and Taiwan and so on that coordinated action works very well, if it is made to happen. It's also reasonably clear that it's cheaper than dealing with a raging pandemic.

Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by giantDinosaur on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:01PM (#26138230)
You said 'pause the global economy', and now wish for me to substitute in any other effective plan, which kind of begs the question, doesn't it?
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by maxerickson on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:07PM (#26138266)
Right, I was just suggesting a severe coordinated action for the sake of making the comment. I don't care about convincing you.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by giantDinosaur on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:12PM (#26138294)
So not only do you admit it would never happen, you cannot even provide any actual figures to support your claim. New Zealand and Taiwan have had success because they effectively eliminated the disease at the start of the pandemic, they didn't shut down with 30% of their population infected and millions of current infections, which is why that particular comparison is poor.

It isn't unreasonable to ask for justification of your claim that it'd be so much cheaper to shut down the global economy or take 'severe' action at this time. So, thanks for providing absolutely nothing beyond some vague claims about ideal actions that won't happen?

Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by j4yav on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:09AM (#26139644)
It may be helpful to look at HN comments more as a discussion forum than a peer reviewed journal with documented justification for claims and so on.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by maxerickson on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:19PM (#26138331)
Yeah, you should probably discount my comment if those are problems for you.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by imwillofficial on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:04PM (#26135726)
Didn’t we move this way with the flu?
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by downrightmike on Sunday February 14, 2021 @03:25PM (#26135918)
People couldn't behave back then for real reasons, most people that are the problem today are just spoiled brats. Back then they didn't have the century of epidemiology knowledge that was outright ignored and trivialized.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by sschueller on Sunday February 14, 2021 @04:09PM (#26136284)
If we vaccinate enough people to get the fatally rate well below the flu there is absolutely no reason not to go back to the old way. There is no 100% safe but there is a level at which hospitals are not overwhelmed and people are accepting the risk of being alive.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by Zanni on Sunday February 14, 2021 @02:58PM (#26135671)
The efficacy number is about preventing cases of Covid-19, but in fact, even the "low" efficacy vaccines are extremely good at preventing severe illness and death. Once we get everyone vaccinated, we should be good.

https://www.vox.com/22273502/covid-vaccines-pfizer-moderna-j...

Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by IAmGraydon on Sunday February 14, 2021 @09:05PM (#26138255)
Wow. You’ve really been hitting the doomer echo chambers hard, huh? Literally nothing in your post is accurate.
Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by otabdeveloper4 on Monday February 15, 2021 @01:54AM (#26139898)
There's no point in sending people with Covid to the hospital. We can't cure viral infections anyways, all it does is just facilitate spread.

Eventually we'll just figure out prophylactic measures for those groups most at risk and leave it at that. It's what we do already with the "common cold", even though the cold can be very dangerous and deadly to some people.

Re:Half Doses of Moderna Vaccine Produce Neutralizing Antibo... by tempestn on Monday February 15, 2021 @03:54AM (#26140620)
You don't send everyone with covid (or a cold) to the hospital, but if they're having trouble breathing you certainly do, and of course there are things that can be done there to help. Even at the beginning of the pandemic before the disease was well understood mortality was several times higher without access to hospital. Now as more has been learned the standard of care has improved further. Just because they can't wave a wand and cure the virus doesn't mean they can't do anything.