News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:41AM (#26124198)
Rust, Python and now Kotlin.

Just as PSF promoted Google to visionary sponsor, although I understand Jetbrains, but we see yet again our saviour Google on the board of yet another language, even after Rust formed its foundation.

I guess I have no choice to accept this future we've put ourselves in.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by ta988 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:48AM (#26124245)
I understand that side (and I'm personally against Google's behavior, hegemony and influence on almost everything). But Google is one of the few companies that gives back to projects they use. You can't say that of many other companies that use tools and make sure they never contribute back (either financially or as code). As long as they don't put their adcrap in any of those languages or the things around them...
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:55AM (#26124296)
> But Google is one of the few companies that gives back to projects they use.

Apple gives back to open source projects. Isn't Swift open source as well as LLVM and Webkit?

Makes sense because they made them and a long time user of them.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by nolok on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:07AM (#26124374)
I'm not sure why the victim complex about Apple in your comment, he said too few companies do it and that remains true whether or not Apple is in that group. In fact that conversation has nothing to do with Apple.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:26AM (#26124489)
> I'm not sure why the victim complex about Apple in your comment, he said too few companies do it

Sure it's all good when companies fund projects they use, but that does not mean they should instantly get a board seat.

It makes sense why Jane Street sponsors OCaml, does not mean they instantly get a board seat. I don't see Jane Street sponsoring RISC-V and getting a board seat do I?

And it doesn't make sense to do so.

I find is suspicious for companies to join or create a foundation and get automatically propped up on the board, especially Google.

It's going to be much harder to remove them if your values are not aligned with theirs or you dare criticise them.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by no_wizard on Saturday February 13, 2021 @12:25PM (#26124953)
Google is highly invested Kotlin and it’s success with Android and what I’m certain is the fact that they have huge Java code adds that I could see them having real value in slowly converting to kotlin and allowing Kotlin to be the first class choice where Java would be.

Honestly I just don’t see it here. Google’s marketplace ambitions have not surfaced in these foundations. I would Love a real tangible counter example of Google leveraging their seat on a language committee to control the language in such a way it only furthers Googles interests. Even with the browser I don’t see them outright controlling tc39 or WHATWG/W3C or the CSS working group. Otherwise HTML imports would be a thing right now (and arguably they should be but that’s another debate)

I don’t defend what they’re doing with Chrome the product but they so far have seemed to be pretty sane with standards bodies

The thing about Google or any entity of their size is that they’re huge and lots of different types of people work there, and I’d wave most aren’t malicious

That doesn’t handwave legitimate complaints here and I don’t like Google have arbitrary outsized influence either but I don’t think that’s the case with these commuters/foundations

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @12:58PM (#26125237)
> Google is highly invested Kotlin

I don't see what benefit of putting them on the board would give them, same thing with Rust, just because it's used on Android? Was a gold sponsorship not enough?

> Honestly I just don’t see it here.

You're not looking hard enough, they are bearing 'generous' gifts to these foundations, Example: OpenAI was all about openness weren't they?

But a big somebody bared a huge gift and so much for 'Open AI'.

Don't you think Google and others like them are doing the same thing such that they are getting you to use their products through their 'donations'?

> That doesn’t handwave legitimate complaints here and I don’t like Google have arbitrary outsized influence either but I don’t think that’s the case with these commuters/foundations

Again we shall see, but I am seeing this everywhere and I am not happy with the shift from community to corporation led open source projects. A sponsorship should be enough but they want more as always.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by no_wizard on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:10PM (#26126355)
I can understand caution and concern and it’s healthy to have it.

That said, I’m unable to think of or find obvious examples of them having a track record of using foundations like this for their own agenda at the expense of the community, language or only to further their own ends. Even with the browser stuff there’s Chrome the product which makes a lot of changes that does hurt the community but then there’s Googles representation on tc39 and in the web standards groups. With that I haven’t found evidence of malpractice or foul play. Please give me some concrete evidence that they have a history of this as I’m not finding it.

Doesn’t mean that as a whole these companies get a pass for Bad behavior, I think a key to a great argument against something is to be able to scope what it does and doesn’t do, so I hate to say they are doing this for malicious reasons only to be wrong (and again I’m not seeing evidence) and undercutting more legitimate arguments. Fundamentally that’s the arching issue we end up with by just making assumptions without evidence at a minimum

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by ta988 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @01:17PM (#26125401)
Kotlin is not a community led project. It has always been a Jetbrains led project, and that move to a foundation is a way to try to distribute responsibilities a bit more. At least thats how they sell it.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by arusahni on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:00AM (#26124335)
WebKit has to be open source because it's a KHTML fork.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by cwzwarich on Saturday February 13, 2021 @12:11PM (#26124828)
This isn't actually true. KHTML is LGPL 2.0, so you can release source code for the pieces you modified and binary blobs for the rest. WebKit proper (as opposed to WebCore, which was based on KHTML, and JavaScriptCore, which was based on KJS) was originally not open source.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by arusahni on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:52PM (#26127766)
Interesting. Thanks for the correction!
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by ta988 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:00AM (#26124332)
I didn't say some other companies don't give back either

If you compare the number of companies using a project and how many contribute, you will likely only need one hand to count the later...

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:30AM (#26124516)
I don't think this is a good thing in the long term, a conflict of interest can arise, then Google would pull out.

But then again, I guess I have no choice to accept this future we've put ourselves in.

At least I can as an individual give back to Kotlin, no wait...

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by blacktriangle on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:00AM (#26124331)
I agree with your general Google paranoia, but in this case I'm okay with it since Google is easily the number 1 user of Kotlin thanks to its roll in making Android development infinitely more productive.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:34AM (#26124542)
Jane Street is the No. 1 user of OCaml for a very long time, although sponsoring it, they don't have a board seat on the OCaml Foundation.

You don't need to provide a board seat to any company that tries to throw money at you, just because they use your language.

Just make them a sponsor, and there are examples of this.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by high_density on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:45AM (#26124225)
well Google's using all three in different ways...

and another trend on prog. langs: they're becoming more and more similar feature-wise (eg. pattern matching)

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @10:57AM (#26124316)
> well Google's using all three in different ways...

So that justifies giving them a seat at the board of directors and not just a sponsorship?

Apple and Facebook both use Rust but I don't see anything about them being on the board (at least Facebook for now), the least I expect is sponsorship.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by ta988 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:02AM (#26124342)
Google contributes a lot to Kotlin though. So they are not just sponsors.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:12AM (#26124410)
Interesting perspective, so just like Rust then? Seems like Google can just buy board seats then.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by ta988 on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:23AM (#26124475)
If you mean by dedicating workforce (which costs money, and a lot for them because of their salaries policies) they are buying a seat? Yes. The same way a major contributor (not just code, but doc, funding, community building...) to a FOSS project often has more power on the decisions than users.

Now I would be unhappy to see a company that just pours millions in a project, gets to take decisions but doesn't do anything else to make the project better. But I don't believe that's the case here.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:46AM (#26124627)
You can do all of this without getting a board seat.

It seems we are all OK with allowing this to happen, but we shall see.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by dieortin on Saturday February 13, 2021 @11:52AM (#26124676)
I’m curious, what does Apple use Rust for?
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by steveklabnik on Saturday February 13, 2021 @12:22PM (#26124920)
They were hiring for their storage and networking groups, but that’s all we know.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by steveklabnik on Saturday February 13, 2021 @12:23PM (#26124931)
What is your specific dislike about Google on the Rust Foundation board?
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @01:42PM (#26125591)
Steve, I don't understand why Google, Microsoft and AWS et. al are on a board of this new foundation. Who had a say on this decision?

And the special guest is Huawei as well just because they use Rust in some way.

I'd rather have them sponsor Rust without giving them too much control by placing them on the board.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by steveklabnik on Saturday February 13, 2021 @02:38PM (#26126077)
The foundation was created as a project of the core team. Nobody was a "special guest." All parties agreed to the terms. That's what the founders of an organization does.

Again, specifically: what control are you worried about? I suspect that you think the foundation has powers it does not have.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @02:44PM (#26126126)
It is the structure that I am concerned about.

Again, I'd rather have them just sponsor Rust, why wasn't a gold or platinum sponsorship like structure considered without placing them on the board of directors.

How about a corporate membership without voting rights?

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by steveklabnik on Saturday February 13, 2021 @03:15PM (#26126383)
Right, but the structure is a secondary concern, in that you're concerned about the structure because it enables particular actions. What kind of vote are you worried about?
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by yannoninator on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:14PM (#26127474)
> Right, but the structure is a secondary concern,

If it was the primary concern we wouldn't be having this conversation, lots of foundations have this structure.

Right now, it is more likely that Facebook would get on the board before I can even donate.

Re:The Kotlin Foundation by steveklabnik on Saturday February 13, 2021 @05:32PM (#26127615)
Okay. I still don’t understand specifically what your concern is. I would love to understand, but I’ll drop it. Given the scope of the foundation and what it is and is not in charge of, I find this attitude very confusing.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by impulser_ on Saturday February 13, 2021 @01:38PM (#26125570)
Well Google does run and control the largest Java platform in the world by far. I think it would be a good thing to have them on your side when you are developing a language that interoperate with Java.
Re:The Kotlin Foundation by pjmlp on Saturday February 13, 2021 @04:10PM (#26126955)
One would think, yet Android Java is stuck in a Java 8 subset with cherry picked features from OpenJDK.