One thing that did jump out at me was that it seemed to be best suited for a tablet and NOT a desktop computer. Hopefully MS keeps building on it and the new desktop doesn't turn out to be Bob 2.0 :)
The first thing I try with any new Windows release is to add a font using their interface (not just dragging it into the fonts folder). The "Add font" dialog box is STILL circa Windows NT/3.1 era.
http://windows.microsoft.com/en-US/windows-vista/Install-or-...
http://windows.microsoft.com/en-US/windows7/Install-or-delet...
Here's the instruction for those that don't want to click the linK:
Right-click the font you want to install and click Install.
This is one of those features that seems really cool in a demo, but in practice...well, even decades later my shoulder hurts just thinking about the hour I spent using a "light pen" interface on a vertical "touch" screen.
Sure, some Apps will only be available as desktop apps at the start, but they will just function as low hanging fruit for developers.
My dad spends minimum 4-5 hours of his day in Excel. He's an accountant and uses it to organize all types of info on clients.
On the other hand I almost never use excel. About the only time (and I use google docs anyway) is for managing bills.
- the entire desktop metaphor (tired, outdated, can be improved upon)
- the entire hierarchical filesystem metaphor likewise
- application installation
- the registry
- WinSxs - seriously, take a look at how much space this directory "wastes" (increasingly important with virtualisation and SSDs)
- the start menu - it's not useable, honestly
- ribbon UI (don't even get me started)
- the whole look and feel of Windows (more akin to Fisher Price than polished glass and aluminium)
- the quality of bundled applications - notepad and paint - seriously? in 2011?
- I could go on and on and on. If it weren't for the quality of the .NET stack and the jobs market for .NET I would be on Linux/OSX in a flash
IMO, Windows merely reflects the beuraucratic uninspired organisation that creates it. This will never change, so really, I shouldn't get so upset, but I have to work with this goddam OS, so it grates a little.
I would be surprised if we don't see new/better bundled applications (particularly for photo/music management, as their other platforms do this better), a different application install paradigm (more akin to OS X or iOS installs), the ribbon was not shown...
What they're showing here is intent. That's all. They've shown their intent to do something different. That might well mean they have intent to start changing things under the hood, which was not spoken about at all in that video. It's too early to judge anything but the intent.
And in defence of the bundled apps, 7 does come with both Wordpad and Notepad. So much better than what OS X bundles.
http://www.webtechpoint.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/12/wordp...
http://developer.apple.com/ue/accessibility/images/TextEdit....
But this isn't starting off on the right foot
Where did you expect them to start from? Build the kernel from scratch?
That actually wouldn't be a bad idea. As someone pointed out, I also feel that filesystem hierarchy, window frames and the desktop metaphor is now outdated and overly stretched. Imho, they would be better come out with a whole new OS with no backwards compatibility, while keeping developing windows for the time necessary (10-15 years) to allow most of its users and software a 'transition' to the new system.
If they don't do it, someone else will do.
I guess the easiest one-liner to describe it is: In bash, you can build tiny apps and pipe textual output from one to another.
In PowerShell, you can pipe objects.
As a developer I doubt I would use the Metro UI a lot, so it would mostly be a shiny thing to randomly switch to.
It also worries me a bit that so many OS:es are moving away from keyboard-based navigation. One can always hope for good keyboard shortcuts, Win 7 has some good quite hidden keyboard shortcuts after all.
Also, how does it scale to my 3-display development machine? Multi-monitor may not be the standard, but it is quite common with monitor-prices going down. Mac OS X is quite random when it comes to scaling to multi-monitor.
I guess we'll eventually figure these things out, but a lot of uncertainties so far.
With apple you have to buy/carry/maintain two physical devices (ipad, notebook) and here you potentially can choose/switch within the same device. Way smarter and more environment friendly too.
The Metro UI is great. The tiles are smart, the apps are beautiful, the solution to multitasking is promising, but this whole new approach cannot coexist with a Windows desktop. I almost fell out of my seat when the demonstrator nonchalantly switched back to the Windows 7-style desktop, complete with start menu, taskbar, and maximized MS Office.
This the old curse of Windows backward-compatibility in a new form – not in system-level cruft this time, but in incompatible UIs from completely different worlds. You can't put a new tablet UI and a traditional desktop UI next to each other on the same device and expect users to use them together.
It's as if Microsoft is attempting its own "Back to the Mac," only they never actually left. Apple got it right, starting fresh with a new form factor and adapting appropriate elements of it to the desktop. Microsoft is also starting fresh with a new form factor, but then trying to shoehorn the whole thing onto the desktop.
Of course, this is just a preview. I'm sure things will change a lot between now and the next preview, let alone the final release. But this isn't starting off on the right foot.