https://medium.com/@nic__carter/assessing-bitcoins-liquidity...
[0] https://wallet.tether.to/transparency [1] https://mobile.twitter.com/bitcoinlawyer/status/135164200602... [2] https://modernconsensus.com/cryptocurrencies/tether/feds-jus...
Here is a study arguing the opposite - https://voxeu.org/article/stable-coins-dont-inflate-crypto-m...
> The right to have Tether Tokens redeemed or issued is a contractual right personal to you. Tether reserves the right to delay the redemption or withdrawal of Tether Tokens if such delay is necessitated by the illiquidity or unavailability or loss of any Reserves held by Tether to back the Tether Tokens, and Tether reserves the right to redeem Tether Tokens by in-kind redemptions of securities and other assets held in the Reserves. Tether makes no representations or warranties about whether Tether Tokens that may be traded on the Site may be traded on the Site at any point in the future, if at all.
> The following Persons are prohibited from depositing to, or withdrawing from, any Digital Tokens Wallet on the Site: > any Person that resides, is located, has a place of business, or conducts business in the State of New York; and > U.S. Persons.
[1] Volume charts and breakdowns are available in lots of places as the data is public, but the easiest chart is halfway down the right side of the page here. "Money flow from/to Bitcoin in the last 24 hours" https://coinlib.io/coin/BTC/Bitcoin
[2] there used to be a site called "omniexplorer" for navigating the Tether chain transactions, but it seems it went down. Now you have to piece it together using tools like blockchair, but it's far more difficult to read to find the coinbase transactions. https://blockchair.com/ethereum/erc-20/token/0xdac17f958d2ee...
Additionally, if that bank goes bankrupt, the money is not secured.
If people are thinking of buying and selling BTC, should they start with another crypto currency until the Tether issue is resolved?
If you have an IOU from the US government for $100 it's worth about $99 on the open market.
If you have an IOU from a highly rated US company (e.g. Ford) for $100 you'd expect it to be worth about $94.
Yet we're somehow supposed to believe than an equivalent IOU from tether is worth more?!
Oh and the US Government and Ford will probably pay you some form of interest if you hold it long enough...
It simply doesn't add up!
If the market believes Tether is not backed by real currency, shouldn't it be trading at a discount to USD?
What's the opposite of FUD, when people with a massive financial stake in something do nothing but tell everyone everything is great all the time, and never acknowledge any issues?
But thanks for the link to a person who clearly has no financial stake in the success of Bitcoin, right?
It seems pretty natural to me that someone who believes in Bitcoin would also purchase it.
I think it's cool too, and have ~5% of my portfolio allocated to BTC, ETH and XRP.
But I don't go around pretending it solves all of the problems of the monetary system. It's better in some ways, and (much) worse in others. I also don't dedicate my life to pumping it on social media.
>It seems pretty natural to me that someone who believes in Bitcoin would also purchase it.
If only we'd have the same mentality with short sellers, but instead we label them FUD.
That's important to note, but where does he argue that the central and most important claim - i.e., that Tether isn't fully backed and is therefore liable to collapse like a house of cards - is false?
What other asset has this situation where the reason for the movement of its price is so obfuscated?
This seems like begging the question to me. Was bitcoin ever supposed to be some sort of asset where the pricing is transparent?
Now don't get me wrong. Transparency in the financial system is good. But a public blockchain as is, does not provide any transparency at all.
Now that I am thinking about it, they probably mean something else entirely by transparency. They probably mean, they know the total amount of BTC out there.
welcome to currency trading
If people realized that bitcoin's -average- transaction fee is around $25 USD because it is restricted (for no technical reason) to a few transactions per second (less throughput than 240p youtube videos) they would at least move on to other cryptocurrencies.
If people realized that a sudden drop in price will mean a sudden drop in mining power, which will mean a sudden drop in blocks being generated, which will mean a sudden drop in throughput, they might be even more eager to get out of it. Since transactions are already so extremely limited purely by choice of the people that took it over, sudden drops in price mean less utility while in practice sudden rises in price lead to lots of transactions for speculation, which also prices out any utility.
One transaction is now 4x the hard drive cost to store the entire chain (and users don't even need to store the chain at all).
Lower prices have always led to less transaction volume which has always made it cheaper and easier to get your own transaction confirmed.
"don't invest in something you don't understand", can I ask that you don't spread FUD about something you don't understand?
> a sudden drop in price will mean a sudden drop in mining power, which will mean a sudden drop in blocks being generated, which will mean a sudden drop in throughput
Over time (and blocks) the proof of work difficulty adjusts, but that isn't what I was talking about, which is why I said "sudden" over and over.
It takes the generation of blocks to adjust the proof of work difficulty and if the price goes down, miners shut off and the blocks needed to adjust the proof of work will get generated more slowly. Less blocks on average means the adjustment skews into the future as the throughput goes down.
Two factors that go _against_ a death spiral is that transactions typically go down when the price goes down, and when the transaction throughput is low, people with actual balances on the chain can't get their btc off of it.
When the price goes up and mining power increases (sooner or later) this isn't a problem, because faster blocks aren't a problem - they just make calibrating back down to a 10 minute happen quicker.
> "don't invest in something you don't understand", can I ask that you don't spread FUD about something you don't understand?
Easy there, you can always ask questions instead of making bold assumptions like this.
I agree with your overall argument but as I understand it, this is false. If the mining power of the whole network drops, the proof of work will become simpler so as to have a roughly constant block throughput. Or am I missing something here ?
The problem was how the difficulty was decided -- it looked at the last N blocks that were successfully mined to decide whether it needed to up or down the difficulty. If you suddenly lost 90% of your mining capacity, it would only adjust the difficulty after several more blocks were mined, each of which would take ~100 minutes instead of the usual ~10. The system would eventually right itself, but it wasn't fast.
I can't recall if this ever became a problem in practice, or whether there was a code change to make it resolve faster.
It is also telling that you didn't say what the value actually is. If you do explain that, make sure to mention it relative to other cryptocurrencies that have all the same properties (except for name recognition) but don't have throughput problems because they did what everyone saw coming 8 years ago and allowed larger blocks, faster blocks, or both.
In regards to value relative to other crypto, this is a valid point but ultimately doesn't matter at all. Why does Craigslist still make 100s of millions of dollars every year when it is clearly an inferior product?
compared to the endless money printing done by the fed that still seems like a bargain.
https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren...
I really have no idea why, it seems sketchy.
The point is that 1 dollar buys the exact same amount of bitcoin as 1 tether.
Price rises seems to be driven heavily by more tether being created out of nothing, leading to another speculation and news frenzy, leading their btc being more valuable and safety from default despite creating more tether.
If bitcoin goes down rapidly or people start exchanging lots of tether for bitcoin (because you can't actually get USD from it) I think it will end up exposed, since as btc goes down their backing value goes down.
To be fair, this already happened. Bitcoin crashed from $22k to $4k, and this was at the height of tether worry.
I actually wrote a comment about their dynamic two years ago when this happened.
How do you know that? Can you see Tether USD bank account, and can confirm that no USD is deposited there when Tether is created?
https://crypto-anonymous-2021.medium.com/the-bit-short-insid...
The last nail in the coffin was when I found out about the lack of visible reserves. If Tether Ltd. really was taking in 1 USD for each Tether it issued, then it should have as many dollars in its bank account as there are issued Tethers. And it turns out we can check if that’s true! Tether Ltd.’s bank is Deltec bank in the Bahamas, and the Bahamas discloses how much foreign currency its domestic banks hold each month.
The answer was — at least up to the end of September 2020 — not nearly enough:
From January 2020 to September 2020, the amount of all foreign currencies held by all the domestic banks in the Bahamas increases by only $600 million — going from $4.7B to $5.3B. (The table is in Bahamian dollars, but the Bahamian dollar is pegged to the US dollar, so 1 BSD = 1 USD.)
But during the same period, total issued Tethers increased by almost $5.4 billion — going from $4.6B to $10B!
Stop presenting FUD if you don't yourself want to back it.
So if you were a big company, let's say Tesla, which wanted to buy a lot of bitcoin, let's say 1.5 bil, would that mean that you first need to convert that 1.5 bil to Tether, since that's the most liquid denomination of BTC?
Could it be that some of those "fake" $500 mil daily Tethers were actually really backed by Tesla dollars?
When you do that kind of buying, you need to go to the most liquid exchange (Binance), and that uses Tether.
Keep in mind that in relationship to tether, $1.5 billion is tiny. It's only 3 days of tether printing.
So Tether is depositing, USD, $6.5B A WEEK. Over the last year this would make them one of the richest entities in the world.
Oh wait, they haven't actually been audited, they won't tell anyone which institution/s actually hold this trove of funds, they've already lost more than a billion to people to who effectively said "yeah, we're not giving you back the money you gave us", and they're fighting and delaying multiple investigations and prosecutions of financial crimes.
Perhaps when Tether's USD holding exceed even Apple's (which, according to you, is less than a year away, at the absolute max), you'll realize that this is all a house of cards.
If AAPL trades $15 bil per day, that doesn't mean that you can easily buy $1 bil without huge market impact.
Every day that goes by it's becoming more clear that Dalio's "genius" was nothing more than a product of being in the right-place-right-time of an extraordinary 20+ year bond run and Chinese money connections.
Scratch that, US and UK banks, for example, now have 0% reserve requirements.
Here is the documentation that explains the capital requirements for a regulated entity (not just banks, but including banks) in the UK
https://www.handbook.fca.org.uk/handbook/glossary/G1567.html
There are also requirements for particular proportions of the capital base to be held in liquid assets (cash and near cash) in order to pay back deposits etc.
//edited to make the point about liquidity
Are you claiming Tether has other assets that are not being counted?
I’d you’re curious to understand more: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_run
For those not aware, Tether is a "stable coin" that issues tokens that supposedly represent dollars and can be used as a medium of exchange. However, it's widely suspected that Tether is unbacked and printing fake dollars and even Tether itself has admitted that at least 26% of their tokens have no backing [1]. Tether has never been audited so we have no clue how much of it is actually backed and how much of it is fake.
This is extremely problematic because Tether is currently printing around $500 million per day and is a source of a significant amount of buy pressure in the market. Tether is used on almost every exchange and is the vast majority of Bitcoin buy orders so Tether can be used to artificially pump the price of Bitcoin quite effectively.
Ray points out Tether as a risk to Bitcoin's value, but I don't think he does an adequate job explaining the risk. Tether isn't a small component of the Bitcoin ecosystem. It's at the heart of Bitcoin with it being the primary currency used to buy Bitcoin with at most exchanges. Most of the buy volume is with Tether and that $500 million per day is huge.
Regardless of what one thinks about the value of Bitcoin, it's irrational to invest while $500 million of fake dollars are being pumped in every day. Once that artificial $500 million buy pressure is removed, the market will face an existential risk. Who knows what the real price of Bitcoin would be without all that fake money?
https://davidgerard.co.uk/blockchain/2021/02/03/tether-print... is a good article for additional context on Tether.
1. https://www.coindesk.com/tether-lawyer-confirms-stablecoin-7...