News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by alfl on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @10:55AM (#26090845)
Tesla's not trying to reduce the number of cars, it's trying to replace the existing fleet with electric. This will likely increase consumption of electricity.

Wider adoption of bitcoin will likewise increase the consumption of electricity.

Electricity production (not consumption) is what causes emissions. More consumption will increase the demand for production, which will increase investment in production.

Given that we're in the middle of a green energy transition, increasing investment in production will likely accelerate that transition -- the stated goal of Tesla.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by betterunix2 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:05AM (#26090976)
A key difference: replacing gas-powered cars with electric takes a carbon-emitting engine off the road, opting instead to potentially emit carbon at a centralized power plant (which is typically more efficient and emits less carbon per joule). Bitcoin increases electricity consumption without offsetting any carbon emissions elsewhere.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by firebird84 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:47AM (#26091527)
I actually did the math on this once, believe it or not. Based on where I live (fairly high carbon emissions from our local utility, though they have deployed more solar recently), switching to an all-electric car would have roughly the same effect carbon-wise as moving to a 60mpg car. YMMV. My math may not be perfect, but it seems that while not a perfect solution, switching to electric cars DOES improve efficiency somewhat carbon-wise. I'm on the side of not letting perfect become the enemy of good.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by RussianCow on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @02:58PM (#26093884)
Does this factor in the emissions cost of producing a new car? Because a common counter-argument to switching to EVs is that the environmental cost of the new car far outweighs any gains from increased efficiency, at least for many years.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by Weebs on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @04:40PM (#26095194)
If they're in an area with a higher number of renewables, then possibly yes. I live in an area that gets about half of its power from nuclear, and the other half from hydrocarbons. When I did my research I estimated over a lifespan of some ~150k miles, a Model 3's carbon production would be roughly equivalent to a 43mpg vehicle assuming the grid stays the same. As the grid introduces more renewables, that number continues to climb.

I haven't checked on this in a while, but the most energy intensive portion of overall production seemed to be the treatment of batteries during their production. Development for an alternative to the current treatment process to use significantly less energy seemed promising

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by npsimons on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @04:34PM (#26095142)
Emissions from production are miniscule compared to emissions from use: https://youtu.be/K9m9WDxmSN8
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by npsimons on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @04:34PM (#26095132)
Your math is backed up by others' math:

https://youtu.be/6RhtiPefVzM

https://youtu.be/K9m9WDxmSN8

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by api on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:58AM (#26091716)
EVs can be better even if they're powered by coal:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/mikescott/2020/03/30/yes-electr...

There are numerous reasons for this. One is that oil drilling, shipping, and refining is dirty and uses a ton of energy. Another is that large heat engines are often many times more efficient than small ones. A huge 100+ megawatt steam turbine at a coal plant is going to have 2-3X the thermal efficiency of a small ICE in a car, especially if it's a newer or recently upgraded supercritical steam system.

I recall reading that CO2/mile for a coal powered EV is typically similar to driving a high efficiency hybrid gasoline car like a Prius, but I can't find the reference right now.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by qwytw on Thursday February 11, 2021 @05:24AM (#26100033)
"I recall reading that CO2/mile for a coal powered EV is typically similar to driving a high efficiency hybrid gasoline car like a Prius, but I can't find the reference right now."

No, that's not even close to being correct, the most efficient Prius model you can currently buy supposedly only emits 75g per km.

Tesla Model 3 consumes 14.9 kWh per 100 km, coal plants in the US on average emit ~1kg of CO2 per kWh. The energy loss between the power plant and consumer seems to be between 8 and 15%. So using 8% it's 160g of CO2 per km. I'm not sure if the data reported by Tesla accounts for charger efficiency (which is at maximum 92% and might be as low as 70-80% if you're charging at home) if not that would at least another 8% making it 173g per km or more.

Even a very efficient petrol car like for example WV Golf Rr 1.5 TSI is quite a bit lower than that at 116g per km.

https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11

Switching to Natural gas would decrease CO2 per kWH more than twice, from 1kg to 0.41 kg per kWh would make Model 3 about even with the Prius (71 vs 75 g per km).

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by api on Thursday February 11, 2021 @10:28AM (#26102477)
Does this count all the energy required to drill, ship, and refine oil? I’ve read that refineries use a ton of power usually in the form of gas, electricity, or burning part of the oil. Coal is mined too but it doesn’t require much processing.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by camjohnson26 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:36AM (#26091365)
Even worse, the Bitcoin hashrate goes up as energy costs come down. The amount of energy burned is an equilibrium. But you can’t compare the costs of banking or the costs of dollar bill production to the cost of Bitcoin transactions for one fundamental reason: Bitcoin transactions are irreversible, traditional transactions are not. Bitcoin is the only way to mark information in a decentralized ledger without a trusted 3rd party and we don’t know if there’s a way to get the same functionality with less energy use, since the energy use provides the security by making it extremely hard to fake a transaction.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by rlpb on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:40PM (#26092293)
> Even worse, the Bitcoin hashrate goes up as energy costs come down. The amount of energy burned is an equilibrium.

Sort of. What you say is true because the energy spent on mining is in equilibrium with the value of the Bitcoin produced by the miners (both the block reward and transaction fees). As the value of Bitcoin goes up, so does the energy they're prepared to buy to mine it.

As the block reward halves, the profitability of mining declines, and so does the energy miners are prepared to buy to mine it (otherwise they make losses).

The final equilibrium will be reached when the block reward goes to zero. At that point it'll be down to transaction fees only, which is proportional to transaction demand. If there's pressure there, then people will be incentivized to transact off-chain and use the chain for clearance only.

In the meantime, the energy spent (in fiat currency) is primarily a function of 1) block reward size; and 2) BTC value.

What's interesting about this is that the block reward schedule is fixed, but BTC value isn't. The energy "burned" is a consequence of Bitcoin's success - it's the area between the two curves. But had the block reward schedule tapered off faster, then Bitcoin might not have successfully bootstrapped at all.

The other interesting aspect is that the block reward, being inflationary, produces downward pressure on Bitcoin's value. It's the upward pressure (whatever its source) that is exceeding this that is creating the energy consumption (since energy consumption is proportional to BTC value, as above).

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by dzamo_norton on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:51PM (#26098368)
> Bitcoin transactions are irreversible

Surely the reversibility of transactions by a trusted, appointed authority is a feature, not a bug. It's an important safeguard against fraud, money laundering, etc. I've never heard of it being abused, while cryptocurrencies are (so far) a paradise for fraudsters and launderers.

Where I live we had large scale state capture for years. A pivotal moment in clipping the kingpins' wings was when all of the South African banks simultaneously cut off their banking in 2016. That was a good day, now we only have medium scale state capture.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by camjohnson26 on Thursday February 11, 2021 @12:23AM (#26098521)
That’s a good point, but without Bitcoin those trusted authorities have no irreversible way to transact between themselves, it’s an infrastructure technology not a customer facing one.

Similar to how no one says we shouldn’t have encrypted web traffic because sometimes you want to see the raw message, you don’t need to weaken the protocol to solve a higher up issue.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:56AM (#26091679)
> Bitcoin transactions are irreversible, traditional transactions are not.

What about paying someone with cash, or gold?

You could even send cash in the mail. It would still use less energy than Bitcoin...

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by temp8964 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:12PM (#26091908)
> You could even send cash in the mail. It would still use less energy than Bitcoin...

Are you sure? What's the energy use of sending $1000 cash in the mail from the US to France?

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:31PM (#26092159)
From another HN thread today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26090317

> If you want to transfer money and the recipient is closer than 660 miles from you it's more efficient to just get a bunch of bills, drive there with a Tesla rather than send a Bitcoin transaction. Or alternatively 330 miles roundtrip. For each single transaction.

France is further than 660 miles from the US, and airplanes use more energy than electric cars. However, letters are also shipped in bulk, dramatically cutting down on the energy use of an individual parcel.

So, yes, even though I don't currently have the inclination to calculate the energy use of sending a letter to France, I am very confident it would be more efficient than sending Bitcoin.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by temp8964 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @04:25PM (#26095028)
I found all the answers to my questions unsatisfied. It seems everyone only see the transportation part of the work, but totally forgot human/machine processing at different stages. Mail doesn't just jump on a truck and then jump off the truck. The process is much more complicated and expensive than that.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by Wowfunhappy on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @06:32PM (#26096302)
Sure, none of these answers are 100%, but IMO the rough calculation is so heavily against Bitcoin that I don't see how it could catch up.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by camjohnson26 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @07:07PM (#26096564)
I don’t know about that, there’s so many advantages to a digital transaction over a physical one that you can accept a lot of extra cost. Send any amount of money in about 30 minutes with absolute guarantee that it won’t be rolled back is a powerful ability. Shipping boxes of cash may be cheaper in energy expenses but has lots of risks and inefficiencies of its own.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by temp8964 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @08:34PM (#26097202)
Your assumption is that transportation takes the majority of the mailing cost. I don't think it is self-evident. Do you have any data to back it up?
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by camjohnson26 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:37PM (#26092245)
You take on a lot more risk doing that though, there’s an advantage to doing it digitally. Faster and less likely to catastrophically fail.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by FabHK on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @02:03PM (#26093327)
I found data hard to come by, but quick googling gives a carbon footprint of around 300 kg for one BTC transaction, and between 25-150 g for one letter sent (including production of the paper for letter and envelope). So BTC is around 1000 to 10000 times worse.

Would be interesting to see it sourced/researched properly, but at first glance I'd say that, yes, it is much more efficient to send a letter, even if you drive to the mail box.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by gamblor956 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:32PM (#26092173)
Presumably by plane?

Carbon cost is apparently about 986 kg/passenger, based on average passenger weight of 60kg, so for a 0.5kg bundle of cash, that would be approximately 986/120 = 8.2kg of carbon to send a bundle of cash from NY to Paris, assuming it travels in the cargo hold.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by bananabiscuit on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:38PM (#26092256)
I’m guessing if you are putting the $1000 on it’s own private charter jet, then maybe it would cost more than a single btc transaction.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by reportgunner on Thursday February 11, 2021 @07:43AM (#26100858)
You too can send bitcoin in the mail.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by willis936 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:35AM (#26091346)
Centralized plants emit less carbon per joule of useable energy, but mechanical-electrical-mechanical conversions end up making the process overall less efficient. The real win is decoupling energy consumption from energy production.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by buzzerbetrayed on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:45AM (#26091506)
Do you mind explaining how this relates to Telsa? Is generating power in a power plant, getting it to a Tesla battery, then using it to move a car a "mechanical-electrical-mechanical" conversion?
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by willis936 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:55AM (#26091664)
Yes. Combustion vehicles never have to convert to electrical energy. Big steam plants are more efficient at turning fuel into torque than small combustion engines, but that increase is offset by having to spin generators.

Edit: Well, at least that is what my impression was. DoE has a paper on this. The example numbers used in this paper seem typical from me taking a brief look at power plant and EV efficiency. I thought the extra energy conversion steps added up to more than 20% thermodynamic efficiency loss. I was wrong.

https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2000-06-12/pdf/00-144...

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by brentjanderson on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:24AM (#26091195)
> Bitcoin increases electricity consumption without offsetting any carbon emissions elsewhere.

Isn't that the same as a Tesla opting to potentially emit carbon at a centralized power plant? Bitcoin rigs don't burn gasoline directly, but rely on whatever source of power is available at their location. Bitcoin does waste a lot of energy, hopefully we can draw from cleaner sources in the long-run to operate it (and find ways to move Bitcoin off of proof-of-work).

UPCO2 is a new token from Uphold.com, and BTC0 is Bitcoin backed by UPCO2 tokens to offset carbon emissions. Using these crypto assets is one way to offset carbon while still using Crypto.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by Jtsummers on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:40AM (#26091430)
GP's point is about the tradeoff that switching to electric cars versus ICE provides, and BTC does not.

Let's assume that switching to electric does not, itself, cause an increase in total cars on the road. Let's also assume that both ICE and electric vehicles require roughly equal amounts of energy to travel equivalent distances (this is probably not true, but helps in the analysis). The tradeoff between an ICE or electric vehicle, then, is which produces more carbon emissions for the same amount of energy: the gas/diesel combustion engine or the power plant?

If the plant is more efficient, converting to electric vehicles will produce a net reduction globally, but a net increase locally (at the power plant) in carbon emissions.

If it's equal, then we just shift the source of emissions to the power plants.

If plant is less efficient, then there will be a global increase. This is the worst case, it's also not the likely case.

This gets improved later with the ability to switch to cleaner energy production methods than burning oil, coal, or natural gas. This is not an option if we remain with ICE vehicles, we can't put a wind turbine on them or a nuclear reactor.

BTC doesn't trade anything, it just increases energy consumption (and therefore production). In the near term, at least, BTC will increase carbon emissions because that's how most energy is produced. Not just exchange the location of emissions. BTC isn't replacing oil burning bank ledgers. It's just consuming orders of magnitude more energy to do a similar job.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by npsimons on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:10PM (#26091892)
Another big difference: I can fuel my EV at home with my solar panels. Can't do that with an ICE vehicle.

I bicycle commute to and from work (before the quarantines, and now I'm moving to 100% WFH), as well to get groceries and other errands around town. The big vehicle is for weekend adventures.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by danielrpa on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:55PM (#26092502)
This. Removing the commute has a much higher impact on emissions than changing your car.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by m463 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:20AM (#26091155)
What is the energy use to produce a dollar bill? It uses plant matter - paper and linen. Coin production uses refined metal (although is more durable).

;)

[more seriously, I wonder what percentage of USD currency is physical vs an entry in a database]

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by betterunix2 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @02:00PM (#26093298)
Production is only relevant if you divide by the number of transactions a bill or coin can be used in. Bitcoin miners must compute at least one new block before a group of transactions can be committed to the block chain. For physical money the energy spent per transaction is relatively low, basically the energy spent opening a cash register drawer or for a large transaction the energy spent by a counting machine. I suspect that paper money is far more efficient than Bitcoin, just given the amount of power Bitcoin consumes and the tiny number of transactions processed in a given time period by the Bitcoin system (tiny compared to the number paper money/coin that occur in a given day and basically irrelevant compared to the number of electronic payments made every day).
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by navls on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:30AM (#26091287)
Apparently, out of a 19.08 trillion M3 USD supply [1], 2.04 trillion is in notes [2].

[1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MABMM301USM189S [2] https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/currency_12773.htm M3 more info https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/m3.asp

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by yellowapple on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:52PM (#26092469)
> Bitcoin increases electricity consumption without offsetting any carbon emissions elsewhere.

Does printing/minting physical money not have a carbon footprint? What about transporting it everywhere?

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by betterunix2 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @02:19PM (#26093474)
It does, but it is almost certainly less than Bitcoin on a per-transaction basis. If the energy cost of physical money were comparable to the average energy spent per Bitcoin transactions we would already have a cashless society; in fact, if the energy cost was so high, we may never have used cash/coins in the first place.

To put this in perspective, Bitcoin consumes about as much energy as Argentina (a country with tens of millions of residents), about 121 TWh/year, but for all that energy the network only processes 4-7 transactions per second. Visa processes an average of 1700 transactions per second on its own, and is just one of many large payment processors in the mainstream financial system. Visa's 2018 report (first thing I found on Google) stated a consumption of about 720000GJ, which is 0.1TWh. That is a massive difference, so if cash was anything as energy-intensive as Bitcoin the banks would have figured it out by now and ditched it to save a ton of money (keeping in mind that banks account for the bulk of the overhead spent on cash and coins).

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by MauranKilom on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @01:18PM (#26092828)
According to [0], a single bitcoin transaction has a CO2 footprint of 300 kg.

Printing a $100 bill costs 20 cents according to [1]. I don't think there is a meaningful way to produce 300 kg of CO2 by spending 20 cents, even if that was all you were trying to do. And then consider that a bill sees on the order of 100 reuses (and coins live significantly longer).

Transportation is far harder to estimate, but unless you're driving hundreds of miles for each (average) transaction, you're not going to get anywhere near 300 kg, as road vehicles are in the ballpark of 20 kg CO2 per 100 km.

So no, CO2 impact of physical money is orders of magnitude below bitcoin. Bitcoin is not remotely offsetting anything there.

[0]: https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/

[1]: https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/currency_12771.htm

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by maxwell on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:25PM (#26092068)
What's the carbon footprint of the conventional financial system?
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by betterunix2 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @02:24PM (#26093514)
According to Visa's 2018 report, they consumed about 0.1TWh while processing an average of 4000 transactions per second [1]. Bitcoin consumes 121TWh per year to process 4-7 transactions per second [2].

[1] https://usa.visa.com/dam/VCOM/download/corporate-responsibil...

[2] https://cbeci.org/cbeci/comparisons

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by gamblor956 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:27PM (#26092098)
Just the tech parts of it?

Significantly less than cryptocurrency, and it handles more than a million concurrent transactions every second, with capacity to handle loads in the tens of millions of transactions per second.

Bitcoin can handle 7 transactions for second, and requires more electricity than a small country to do so.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by maxwell on Thursday February 11, 2021 @09:54PM (#26110268)
Thanks for the numbers.

I mentioned the other day that "one of the bad things" about Bitcoin was that it consumed the energy equiv of Ireland.

Then heard yesterday that it's up to Argentina.

Sounded like order of mag change, and yep—🇮🇪 is about to again surpass 5M people, 🇦🇷 approaching 45M. Almost into top 30 countries.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by c22 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:20AM (#26091157)
Don't bitcoin transactions offset from transactions within the classical banking network? How much electricity do banks use?
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by PeterisP on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:45AM (#26091507)
Bitcoin settles a very, very tiny proportion of transactions. All of crypto has <1% of global amount of transactions, so they aren't offsetting anything meaningful.

Visa, Mastercard, Unionpay, SEPA each settle more than 100 billion transactions per year, bitcoin has less than 0.2 billion transactions per year. Currently bitcoin consumes something like 0.25% of world's electricity for much less than 0.25% of world's transactions, so if we processed all transactions this wastefully, it wouldn't be enough to divert all the power production in the world to do so.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by rojeee on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:43AM (#26091475)
It's a good point and I'd love to see an analysis of how much electricity an average bank uses or a country's payment system uses. But until now I haven't seen one.

I think another point to note is that Bitcoin (and Crypto/DeFi in general) is really just a censorship resistant Casino, and I say this having worked in blockchain and crypto for the last 6 years. As such, the massive electricity usage is all the more egregious.

On the other hand. Banks actually add a lot of value whether we care to admit it or not. They provide a working payment network. They provide credit when you need it etc. Yes, the banking infrastructure probably uses a lot of electricity too - somehow those mainframes need to be powered but I'd like to think we can all agree that society benefits from this. Where as, with Bitcoin, only a small few benefit but the cost of running the infrastructure is so high.

Maybe a better comparison is how much energy the gold industry uses vs bitcoin mining?

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by jabberwcky on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:28AM (#26091240)
Nothing close to 120 gigawatt/sec (going by one estimate)
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by c22 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:46AM (#26091519)
This first-google-result analysis[0] from a couple years ago puts the global banking system at around 100 TWh a year which is pretty close to the currently estimated "121.36TWh" for bitcoin[1].

Incidentally, that 2nd article mentions that this is equivalent to the power used by inactive-but-on electronic devices in US households alone.

I guess PC gaming was at 75TWh 5 years ago [2], so I'm not going to worry too much yet.

[0] http://climatestate.com/2018/01/15/energy-consumption-bitcoi...

[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-56012952

[2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelkanellos/2015/09/07/the-...

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by betterunix2 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @01:50PM (#26093188)
Total power consumption is the wrong metric; we should talk about the average consumption per transaction. If the totals are close, it means Bitcoin is an extremely inefficient system, since it only processes a fraction of the number of transaction per year that the mainstream financial system processes.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by c22 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @03:02PM (#26093928)
I agree, and I don't think bitcoin will ever be efficient. But I don't think any of us can stop it at this point and it still seems less frivolous than many of the things we spend energy on.

Since energy consumption has historically always increased and since it drives all of human progress and innovation I'm not convinced that the demand side is where we should focus on solving our problems.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by Taylor_OD on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:16AM (#26091120)
Sure. But a centralized power plant could be surrounded by solar panels that offset the carbon costs.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by sn_master on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:18AM (#26091139)
The best way to reduce carbon emissions is to keep using existing cars, whether gas or electric for as long as they're drivable. Electric (and ICE, to a lesser extent) cars have a very significant carbon footprint when they're newly produced.

Abandoning cars after a few years is far worse to the environment.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by titzer on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:29AM (#26091261)
It'd be best to just...not drive. Second best would be to actively pursue a mass-scale electric conversion so that we could reuse all those big metal chassis, tires, seats, etc in existing cars. It'd be far cheaper in terms of carbon footprint to replace a combustion engine with electric. Why aren't we doing that? Because retrofitting is hard and not very profitable. And yeah, we need a place to put the batteries too. Much better to just junk everything and build more stuff!

(Yes I know, most of the materials of a car will be recycled. But it's just another expression of our throwaway/can't fix that culture).

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by FooHentai on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:48AM (#26091541)
You missed a key reason - batteries are very heavy, and to achieve the kind of range that makes it practical for drivers to switch from ICE requires specifically-designed chassis layout and materials to accomodate battery weight in a suitable location to maintain acceptable weight distribution

With a breakthrough in energy storage technology e.g. solid state, this issue might go away, but right now it compels the production of vehicles specifically designed to be EV and relegates retrofitting to a hobbyist discipline providing relatively disappointing results in range and/or handling.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by titzer on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:51AM (#26091596)
I get that, but cars have gas tanks, back seats, and trunks, too. Also, the actual electric engine is very small, leaving a lot of room in engine compartments themselves. The only reason we would need very large batteries is to have a very long range, which would not be necessary if we could have removable, modular batteries that are easy to replace at (what was formerly) a gas station.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by FooHentai on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:16PM (#26091960)
EVa have back seats and trunks just like ICE, and they need to be usable by the vehicle owner just the same so I’m not sure I see the relevance.

For retrofitting, locating some batteries in the engine bay is possible. This seems to be avoided by ev manufacturers in favour of locating a monolithic battery pack under the passenger compartment, for weight distribution, simplicity, and (I assume) safety reasons.

Physically swappable battery packs isn’t feasible because of the sheer weight of the packs (a leaf 40k pack for example is 210kg). Plus each car manufacturer has different specs and shape packs. Fortunately we already have a completely fungible, extremely portable unit that can be hot-swapped into every EV at nearly any location just like petrol - a kWh of electricity. Today it takes a bit of time to fast charge, but again with visible-on-the-horizon breakthroughs in battery tech e.g. solid state, fast charge times could drop from ~30 minutes to 3.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by titzer on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:41PM (#26092295)
Of course if you are designing an EV from scratch you want to put the weight of the battery low and in the center for best stability, but with a conversion you gotta find space wherever. Gas tanks are already pretty low and central for the same reason, but clearly an EV battery pack is a lot denser than a full tank of gasoline.

Swappable battery packs clearly wouldn't be a single piece, as there are going to be a variety of different bays and sizes. They'd need to be smaller, portable, and stackable, like rectangles or hexagons. It's not really that hard to do if you design for it. If the batteries are under the car then a lift or underground bay you drive onto is fairly easy to do. Or you could just have a kind of dolly that slides under the car and can detach/reattach them.

The fact that we never really thought in this direction seems like a blind spot. I mean, look at how pit crews for racing work. The whole car is designed to be swappable in seconds flat, and also for minimum weight and maximum speed. It's just engineering and design investment.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by yellowapple on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @01:16PM (#26092787)
As a further elaboration on this point: range becomes far less of a concern with widespread charging stations. If every parking lot was covered with solar panels and every space had a charger on it, the "range" concern would evaporate pretty much immediately for day-to-day use; just plug the car in at every stop to top it off.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by sn_master on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @01:25PM (#26092906)
Range concern won't evaporate in the US anytime soon simply because of how far spread cities and forests are and how much people like to roadtrip, specially in the Summer. When I used to hike pre-COVID, I used to do 150 miles one-way easy, and sometimes even return same day.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by sn_master on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:50AM (#26091584)
yup, most retrofitted cars get way less mileage than regular EVs (150 miles or less).
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by sn_master on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:47AM (#26091532)
> It'd be best to just...not drive.

I wish it was that easy of a choice. Pre-COVID, using public transit would have made my daily commute (one-way) between 1.5 and 2 hours, compared to 20-30 minutes by car.

And where I live, we've been paying hundreds-thousands of dollars on each car registration renewal (% of the car's estimated value) for that new transit system, which might not even get used that much post-COVID because of the germophobia that inflicted society.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by alfl on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:07PM (#26091846)
I have back-of-the-napkin tried to scale mass conversion. The gotchas are (very) nice-to-have things like power steering that rely on engine pressure. Actual drivetrain is solved.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by jbarrs on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:43AM (#26091471)
According to a relative who's worked in the industry most of his life, the carbon footprint just from manufacturing and disposing of batteries for electric vehicles is not compensated by the decreased emissions. I think the lifetime is ~5 years shorter than the "carbon neutral time" of using a battery over conventional fuel. Much of the research now is to either reduce the carbon footprint of battery manufacture, or to increase the lifetime of the battery to compensate, but the batteries themselves are apparently worse for the environment than the engines they're replacing.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by belltaco on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @02:37PM (#26093651)
Literally no one buying an EV is junking their car if its drivable. They trade it in where it offsets manufacturing another car.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by sn_master on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @03:38PM (#26094426)
And then someone buys it on the other end and junks their own car vs driving it for another 2-3 years. The more new cars getting bought, the cheaper used cars become and more inclined people become to junk their 100k miles used cars vs using them until they hit 200k miles.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by imtringued on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @05:03PM (#26095417)
You underestimate the size of the used car market. It's bigger than just one country.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by npsimons on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:12PM (#26091906)
Going to need to see numbers to back these claims; what I've seen says otherwise, granted the breakeven point is different depending on where you live:

https://youtu.be/6RhtiPefVzM

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by sn_master on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:26PM (#26092088)
This video is comparing a new EV with a new ICE. I was talking about using an existing EV or ICE for longer time rather than buying an entirely new car. Of course it's easier to re-use ICE than most older EVs which don't have durable enough batteries.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by npsimons on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @04:31PM (#26095090)
Battery longevity is getting better; I need to find sources, but last I heard is with new cooling technology, they are starting to put lifetime estimates at 500K miles.

As for the tradeoff of new EV versus used ICE, the numbers in the video seemed to suggest to me that it's still in favor of EVs, just that the break even point is farther out. Other sources have run the numbers to show it's not the construction or EOL that is the largest factor in emissions, it's the actual use: https://youtu.be/K9m9WDxmSN8

It's really clear that EV's are just the better option for the environment. The only thing that beats them is public/mass transit or human powered (walking, cycling) transportation.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by loceng on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:30AM (#26091278)
The issue is whether there's any real competitive value to Bitcoin et al - or if it's simply driven by its financial incentive structure, MLM scheme - and if there's a better option, where it isn't financial gain that leads to alignment/consensus, but instead actual consensus - arguably a blockchain structured and decided by democratically elected governments, designing in whatever failsafes are necessary, save regulatory capture for those who want to unnecessarily and unreasonably transfer wealth to themselves from the greater society they're currently attempting to lead into adopting the status quo incumbent(s); the energy consumption is a arguably moot point and a distraction from the important conversation(s) to be having.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by alfl on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:49AM (#26091567)
I think bitcoin is a classic "worse is better" disruptive innovation. There are arguably better blockchain/blockdag implementations now, but it has a huge first-mover advantage and name recognition, which are important economic features of Bitcoin.

As a value store it is arguably a hedge against M2 inflation, which is wildly out of control right now. All sources of perceived growth are absorbing funds like mad in an attempt to outrace the growth of the money supply.

So: is there a "better" option -- depends on the dimensions along which "better" has utility. I think there's a value in trustless value exchange, there's a value in the brand of Bitcoin, and a value in trying to hedge central bank M2 inflation.

I am a big believer in blockchain/blockdag smart contracts as a future implementation of the capital allocation function of government, especially if the implementation includes a national currency. Built-in taxation through demurrage, funding of proposals voted on and executed automatically as a smart contract, fully auditable and transparent operations -- there are a lot of technical, societal benefits.

I agree that energy consumption is largely a moot point.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by loceng on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:53AM (#26091630)
" I think there's a value in trustless value exchange"

There are huge pitfalls to "trustless" value exchange, e.g. you can't implement policy like Magnitsky Act - to through economic means "attack" known bad actors, to try to incentivize them financially to play well before it becomes physical.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by slg on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:22AM (#26091179)
>Tesla's not trying to reduce the number of cars, it's trying to replace the existing fleet with electric.

This isn't completely accurate. A big motivator for self-driving cars is to increase the efficiency of their usage. Currently cars sit unused some 90-95% of the day. Once cars are driverless, they can be delivered quickly and automatically to users on demand. This removes a big motivator for individual ownership and can help usher in an era in which most cars are centrally owned. This is exactly what Tesla is planning to do with a fleet of self-driving vehicles. I have no idea when or even if they will get there, but it is a goal that is closely aligned with reducing the number of cars.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by jeromegv on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:34AM (#26091340)
All public transit initiatives from Elon Musk seem to show that he's entertaining a vision where everyone keeps their own car, with their own Tesla tunnels to get home. I find this idea that people would be willing to share a car with the whole world pretty naive, majority of car owners are likely to want to keep their cars for themselves.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by rglullis on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:45AM (#26091500)
> majority of car owners are likely to want to keep their cars for themselves.

I can bet that in most big European cities, relying on public transportation + renting a car whenever you need is cheaper than the maintenance costs of car ownership (parking + insurance + gas).

Making the car rental more efficient on a global scale will reduce the need and the utilitarian value of car ownership. There will be of course those that will want to have their own car, but that will be more and more considered a luxury item or status symbol than a need for anyone living in urban areas.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by anon98356 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:53AM (#26091637)
> I can bet that in most big European cities, relying on public transportation + renting a car whenever you need is cheaper than the maintenance costs of car ownership (parking + insurance + gas).

That's already the case though. Having self driving cars doesn't really change the equation on that.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by rglullis on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @01:11PM (#26092725)
It changes the amplitude of the difference, it makes the contrast more and more clear and it expands the dimension of what we can consider a "city center".

I could live carless in Boston when I was living in Cambridge or downtown Boston. I could not make that if I wanted to live in Medford, even though that is a bare 10-minute drive from Cambridge. A fleet of self-driving cars could be spread around more efficiently in metro areas and suburbs.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by slg on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:43AM (#26091484)
>All public transit initiatives from Elon Musk seem to show that he's entertaining a vision where everyone keeps their own car, with their own Tesla tunnels to get home.

I'm not a fan of most of his public transit projects, however there is nothing about them that dictates who owns the cars. It isn't likely that Tesla would block a Tesla owned Tesla vehicle from using those tunnels in favor of a privately owned Tesla vehicle.

>I find this idea that people would be willing to share a car with the whole world pretty naive, majority of car owners are likely to want to keep their cars for themselves.

Will everyone participate? Obviously not. However, the Ubers, Lyfts, ZipCars, Turos, and even the Enterprises and Hertz of the world show that many people would happily share a car given the right circumstances. There doesn't need to be 100% participation to reduce the number of cars in existence.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by rblatz on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:36AM (#26091359)
People who say that we are moving away from individually owned to centralized ownership on-demand vehicle usage obviously don’t have families.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by robotresearcher on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:55AM (#26091670)
For many years my family had one car instead of two because we were able to use a shared car co-op for the occasional need for a second.

I bet a good car share service raises the average duty cycle of cars in the city by a useful amount.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by rblatz on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @01:36PM (#26093040)
That’s fair. In a two car household both cars aren’t typically used for hauling the kids around.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by Isinlor on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @03:04PM (#26093952)
Wouldn't it be easier to not own a car with family?

Everyone older than lets say 13 years old could go their own way as needed when needed.

No need to leave work earlier to pick up kids or to send them on after school activities.

As more people switch to not owning the need for parking spots disappears.

Cities can be more dense, real estate cheaper.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by CamelCaseName on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:32AM (#26091304)
Cars may sit unused for 90-95% of the day, but does the density of its usage change how many miles it will drive over its life?
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by CDSlice on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:37AM (#26091383)
Aren't most cars unused for 90% of the day because that is when everyone is working? In that case won't we still have to have around the same number of cars to take people to and from work?
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by anon98356 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:58AM (#26091713)
I can actually see self driving making this worse. If the cars can drive themselves there is less need for parking in the city. Cars can drive themselves out of the city for cheaper parking. So on top of the trip in and out taken by the passenger to get to/from work, there is a second round trip for the car to park all day while it isn't needed by anyone.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by pr0zac on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:27PM (#26092095)
I'm not a fan of Musk and am very skeptical of his vision of the future and self-driving cars in general but assuming these vehicles all have a low carbon footprint this seems like a possible net win considering the improvements to cities this could help drive.

Parking needs are a scourge on city density since office buildings and the like require parking structures increasing sprawl as well as the ability to build things like safe bike lanes, wider sidewalks, or pedestrian thoroughfares since street parking is needed for shorter term trips. Reducing parking inside cities would help make them more livable for those of us who do not own vehicles and would hopefully make that type of lifestyle more appealing to more people reducing the number of vehicles on the road.

All that of course would require a level of city leadership I'm also skeptical of but taken on its own the idea of cars being able to self-park further from city centers doesn't immediately strike me as a bad one.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by imtringued on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @04:43PM (#26095212)
> This will likely increase consumption of electricity.

But when you point out that primary energy consumption will decrease people laugh at you.

When you have a 50% efficient thermal power plant it generates 1 kWh worth of electricity for 2 kWh worth of thermal energy in coal or gas. Solar panels are roughly 20% efficient but nobody is counting that 5kWh solar energy hitting the solar panel as primary energy when the solar panel is feeding in 1kWH of energy.

The end result is that you have a meaningless statistic that doesn't tell you anything but makes some people smug that renewables can't ever work and makes others feel helpless when they are posed with the problem of replacing all that waste heat with renewables.

I'm not saying that the way primary energy is counted should be changed. Instead, we should stop looking at primary energy as interchangeable.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by Tiktaalik on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:52AM (#26091619)
And fundamentally commuting by car, often with a single person in a single car, is a woefully resource intensive and inefficient way of transporting people.

Versus other forms of transportation cars are bad for the environment whether they're electric or ICE period.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by eeZah7Ux on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @02:04PM (#26093339)
> Electricity production (not consumption) is what causes emissions

Electricity consumption (as well as other energy sources) causes plenty of heat release in the atmosphere.

With the ongoing climate catastrophe, this is a problem.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by kraemate on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:55AM (#26091660)
You can apply this logic for any wasteful activity. Lets boil the ocean with coal-fired plants, because something something production vs. consumption.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by api on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:57AM (#26091691)
Yeah, and I had another thought about what at first seemed to be an insane move: it's a sales ploy to get people who rode BTC up to buy Teslas.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:48AM (#26091543)
If bitcoin adoption really takes off then more of the transactions will go to layer-2 options like the Lightning network.
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by fastball on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @11:47AM (#26091539)
Reposting my perennial comment about solving global warming:

"""

Hence why the real solution has always been:

1. Electrify everything possible

2. Shift all electricity production to renewables, massively increase power output with nuclear nuclear nuclear.

3. Carbon capture.

"""

Bitcoin can be included in "electrify everything", as there are a number of problems with our current financial systems which are very hard to electrify as easily, whereas BTC is electricity-native.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by beefield on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:01PM (#26091753)
> there are a number of problems with our current financial systems which are very hard to electrify as easily, whereas BTC is electricity-native

Any examples? To me, current financial systems are very much information management systems and information managament is quite easy to electrify.

One of the main problems with bitcoin is that current financial system (well, whole society) is built on the idea that money is credit and credit is money. and bitcoin is anti-credit. I have not heard anyone ever even try to reconcile that seriously. Like, how do you do mortgage with bitcoin without ending up with fractional reserve banking and uncontrolled money supply? I have no clue. But then, I don't think nowadays anyone even thinks that BTC would be money, but something like gold instead. With the distinction that gold actually has some use cases outside crimnal activites and gambling.

Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by fastball on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:11PM (#26091899)
Re:Elon Musk wants clean power. But Tesla's carrying Bitcoin... by beefield on Wednesday February 10, 2021 @12:41PM (#26092297)
Sorry for laughing and shaking my head, but the bitcoiners really do not seem to grasp how minuscule (if important core, I agree!) part of the financial system the settlement of the payments is. And that is the only part bitcoin does. Bitcoin does not do mortgages. Bitcoin does not do corporate finance. Swapping central bank money to bitcoin would not change that much (except make monetary supply and inflation uncontrollable, which, of course, is really much in the end. But that is not what bitcoiners get.)

And the US Army is used not only to protetct USD payment settlements but the whole society around it. Visa and BTC are really apples to apples in this sense.