Were people skeptical of Moodys A+ ratings of subprime mortgages conspiracy theorists? And that’s far from the only example of financial fraud . There’s a lot of money at stake.
Citadel is most of Robinhoods revenue, they put money on the opposite side of the trade via Melvin, and Robinhoods decision to restrict trading benefited the short position of the trade . The stock markets been around for over a century and online trading around over 20 years, with many volatile stocks and bubbles, yet restricting trading in one direction has no precedent. The conflict of interest Robinhood had is crystal clear and at a minimum calls for a deep investigation. Accepting their PR, which has barely explained anything is about as far from rational as possible. They described the collateral requirements as “opaque” and “pretty technical” with no real clarity, and never explained other details such as why they restricted fully cleared non-margin cash accounts or why they removed tickets from their search bars.
I’m not saying with any confidence there was foul play, but there’s more than enough conflict of interest and unprecedented behavior to call for an investigation far more than what we’re getting. Especially with regards to who was buying when so many retail traders were unable to.
Financial markets should be open and transparent. They are not supposed to be casinos with arbitrary hedge funds playing the house. To resign yourself to that idea is far more irrational than calling for openness and investigation into the many unanswered questions around what happened.
In terms of more popular accusations of wrongdoing among brokerages as they shut down the buy side, that seems plausible but hard to prove coordination unless someone recorded the conversation in a smoke filled room. If there was big money to make and a way to get away with it, I assume most corporations would engage in illegal activities.
It is a fact that the relevant ticker symbols were hidden in Robinhood UI during the restrictions. This could simply be because the UI always hid symbols with restrictions, but that would be a strange decision in the first place (why not just always show the tickers info?) and in context is another oddity worth looking into.
My suggested middle ground is, call for investigation. Maybe there’s no smoking gun but if, for example, it was uncovered that a huge amount of institutional short covering took place during the restrictions that would be more hints that foul play occurred and justify more investigation.
In the future, if we don’t get answers , well connected players can manipulate markets by blaming opaque clearing house requirements unless more transparency is added.
My concern is that by being too dismissive of calls for investigation, we lose the political steam to at least try and get better answers that we deserve.
I don't think it's fair to draw an equivalence between the two theories.
It's pretty easy for a large market participant to impact the bid/offer when there isn't much liquidity, especially if the natural buyers are restricted from trading. The price moves because of supply and demand.
The WSB perspective is perhaps a bit uninformed, but it's not particularly bizarre (unlike the QAnon garbage). They're just asking "when will the price reflect our pent-up demand rather than artificial supply?"
Unfortunately, the reality is that prices get set during these moments of absolute craziness. That's why you sometimes see hedge funds reload after hours after an earnings miss on one of their long positions. They want to absorb the supply so the stock doesn't crash lower.
Look at GME today. The price moved a couple of percent even though nobody has the slightest reason to believe that GME stock is worth this particular price. Some say it should be higher due to flows around positioning, and others say it should be lower because of fundamentals.
Fair. I don't think anyone is reasonably calling for investigations to be halted. At the very least, there is public education required.
But there is a difference between saying "whoah, that's weird" and the combination of trading on it, encouraging others to trade on it, spreading one's hypothesis with zero facts and calling everyone who points out the issues with one's argument [1] a shill. There was a lot of the latter.
[1] With respect to why "fully cleared non-margin cash accounts" got restricted, it's because the bottleneck was clearing collateral. Not Robinhood's margin risk. Clearinghouses don't care about how a trade was financed. They care about the risk of (a) the broker going under and (b) the collateral being insufficient to settle the trades. When their risk limits get hit, the broker has to reduce flow and/or pony up.
Whoa whoa whoa. This is a slippery slope argument.
If everybody is holding their shares as in your scenario, then the only way to buy shares would be to get them from a short seller. Market-makers typically have an obligation to maintain continuous and two-sided quotations, but there are exceptions to this rule in mitigating technical or legal circumstances (solvency risk seems like it would be a valid exception).
If nobody is selling and everyone is buying, the price ought to go higher. That is what happens in unadulterated markets. But the price won't go to "infinity." Rather, it will go to the level at which long holders decide the payoff for selling is irresistible. They will begin to sell. A new price will be set.
It is true that some hedge funds (including Melvin) would potentially have been ruined if the natural buyers had been permitted to bid for the stock. However, exchanges don't halt securities just because a hedge fund is about to go under. That is a fundamentally unfair practice. Hedge funds have failed in the past, too; not every market participant is Too Big To Fail. Their PB would be left to cover the short position, and would be responsible for whatever loss remains after the hedge fund goes broke.
This is not good logic. There may be a lot of dodgy stuff going on and there may even be conspiracies, but even if you accept that there is a conspiracy that doesn't make it any more likely that the conspiracies being peddled by WSB are correct.
It's like I pick a card out of a deck, I tell you my card is 7 of spades but I have a history of lying. Most likely, the card isn't the 7 of spades. But that doesn't mean it's likely that the card is the 9 of diamonds. That's what this logic is saying - that it must be the (often clearly wrong) assertion simply because the only specific alternative is from someone you don't trust.
"I tell you my card is 7 of spades but I have a history of lying. Most likely, the card isn't the 7 of spades. But that doesn't mean it's likely that the card is the 9 of diamonds."
I suggested that such reasoning could, in a nutshell, be summarized as "ad hominem".
Conspiracies happen everywhere, all the time, but you need to avoid applying a bias because of political implications. I highly doubt there are more conspiracies happening anywhere in the private sector than in most large governments.
To offer a hopeful counterpoint, informed comments and rebuttals were honestly engaged with throughout the fiasco. There was active learning, from somewhat experts seeing cracks that hadn't been so apparent before, to novices seeing the magnificent and horrifying complexity behind our abstractions.
I don't see that on Reddit. I don't see that on Twitter. I barely see it in print media, where the focus is on stoking schadenfreude and counting up who's losing to whom and by how much.
Oh, HN is more enlightened and civilized. It's just the bar is incredibly low.
In seriousness, I've received a lot of wisdom on HN, it's just I have to approach it (as I do with any data) with a jaundiced eye, and keep in mind the community: a lot of very experienced software types, from all over the industry. On software topics, I can usually trust HN. Diet/nutrition, philosophy and finance discussions on HN, I take a much more careful view of.
If someone sees that shorts in GME are over leveraged, well in hindsight they were absolutely right to buy in to this "gambling".
I find the most irrational actors with regards to investing are the people who only do "safe" bets and feel like that carries zero risk profile.
The short squeeze wasn't a complete failure. It happened, it was just much smaller than many predicted. I still wonder what would've happened if Robinhood didn't shut off demand by preventing people from buying shares. My investment thesis didn't foresee this happening. I don't think anyone did.
The other large part of the problem was that a lot of people, including myself, were going off of stale short interest data. Updated estimates for GME were reported to be 39% of float vs +100% on 1 Feb [1]. Hedge funds pay for more accurate data which us retail investors don't get visibility on.
It's over for now, but please bear this in mind when talking to people that may have lost money on this. Some people did some research, knew the risk and allocated money they were willing to lose. I learned a lot along the way, it might make some hedge funds think twice about aggressively shorting a stock, and it was just plain fun to be part of it.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-01/gamestop-...
Edit: updated short interest data stats and link.
Big players know that when they plan big market moves, they need to notify their brokers in advance, so the broker can prepare.
What we had here was a bunch of retail investors who are somewhat more informed than the average retail investor, but not well versed in the nuts and bolts of the maneuver they were involved in, and therefore the executed it without sufficient planning.
I think what is required is that you control long interest of 100% or more of the net shares (or float). (The shorts being > 100% is neither necessary nor sufficient for that.)
That's... just not true? Many things have non-arbitrary value. You need dollars to pay taxes. You need real estate to sleep and work. You can make pretty things that last a long time from gold.
My cheeseburger with one bite out of it has a market value of 0.
That scenario is pretty dissimilar to something like the value of a currency, which has value in proportion to the participants' trust in its stable value and how easily they can trade it for goods and services.
So to standardize on terms, I mean "bet" like I am betting on roulette, not "bet" as in I bet my bank will still be solvent tomorrow.
Like convincing the world that 'short ladder attacks' were a thing.
https://money.stackexchange.com/questions/135807/closing-sho...
While wsb is on the verge of going full Q'Anon, I find it equally curious how people seem to be willing to deny foul play when you have people like Jim Cramer confessing/bragging to it.
Beyond that, the burden of proof is clearly on the "short ladder"-believing crowd, and so far what they have come up with is frankly embarasing.
I have zero problem believing that hedge funds would be more than willing to engage in shady behaviour if it can save them a billion or two, but screaming the nonsensical "SHORT LADDER" every time a highly pumped stock drops is ridiculous.
The fact that retail was restricted to selling and hedge funds were not, further corroborates foul play.
This sounds like the interaction between run-of-the-mill execution algorithms.
Bidding algo is likely a market maker putting out small quotes (100 shares is a standard lot) and adjusting down (up) the price each time the bid (offer) is hit (lifted). Selling algo trying to liquidate a larger block without moving the market. It is hitting the top bid from time to time. If those two are the only market participants talking for a few milliseconds, they'll walk down the price in 100-share increments. Given how volatile GameStop was, I suspect the predatory algorithms, who sniff out this sort of stuff, were offline.
One of the things I'm realizing from all this is there aren't many good, succinct sources on market microstructure. It's complicated. But it's not that complicated. (It's just usually boring.)
The best I can recommend is how I learned it. Start with a respected paper [1]. Trace through the references until you find something you understand. Then work your way forward.
[1] https://www.smallake.kr/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/optliq.pd...
It was not. Only retail that played in a couple of YOLO gamified market brokerages that was restricted.
This morning there were two opposing top posts. 1) summarized as gamble your apes, 2) summarized as manage your risk and don't buy stocks with debt.
There was also a post by a legit investor claiming they covered their losses by selling at peak and everyone should have done this explaining the benefits.
Single stock trading is always a gamble, you should spread your risk and manage your losses in such a way that you win in the end (by selling losses to cover taxes on gains etc).
If you want good financial advice you can find it on WSB, but in general (imo) you should go there to make yourself feel good about your index fund or bad about your index fund. Either way, don't get caught up in the fervor.
There were massive gaps of knowledge, sure, but I think the discussion contributed to reducing that.
> If you think any bet is a guaranteed win, you have lost your rationality.
True, but there are of course better and worse opportunities, and occasionally excellent ones. For example, IPO pops are on average a risk-adjusted win, and for good (and well understood) institutional reasons.
I'm currently awaiting 9 February for the shorts interest to be released, to see if they are right or wrong. I think it's really interesting what's happening/happened.
I'm not sure if I see a fallacy, that if you can hold a squeeze that another squeeze could happen if enough shorts stay open. Anyone can elaborate on that?
Taking into account that shorting costs money ( 30% interest at a certain moment, mentioned by S3 partners ), people can hold longer than shorts. And buying them would make the available pool to buy back much smaller.
What is wrong with that theory? It's similar to cornering the market ( if the stocks aren't tradeable again by the brokers) and GME doesn't have that much shares.
Ps. Only put some play money in it, practically nothing. Just curious what the odds are.
And I don't think I'm a meme guy, but to my perception there is logic in it. ( Eg. I'm not buying conspiracy theories about RH, because the flow was logical that they just needed money. ).
For reference, Data from an stock analysis firm https://twitter.com/ihors3?s=09
> Taking into account that shorting costs money, people can hold longer than shorts. And buying them would make the available pool to buy back much smaller.
The volume being traded has been incredibly high, the available pool to buy hasn't been small. More than the total number of outstanding shares has traded per day over the last 10 days. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/GME/key-statistics
The short interest likely isn't constant, either. Some people probably got out and took a bath on old positions, and others got in with new ones when it was super high. Anyone who started shorting at 300 or 400 is feeling pretty good.
This is important, but more important is what percent of those were used to cover shorts. If a large portion wind up in retail's hands or are part of the theory of hedge funds selling back and forth (I haven't seen much concrete evidence of that), that volume doesn't change the math much.
Definitely, but I haven't seen any data sources that tell us exactly that. We see that retail bought a bunch, sold a bunch, institutions bought a bunch, sold a bunch... but we don't know the full path.
And not knowing that is what makes it a huge, at-this-point-irresponsible gamble, in my mind.
9 february is the date the short numbers are released for publication. Why would it be 29 january?
It's not a final date either, it's a date that more is known and people can act on that info.
You can always check the link I gave to see why... Since you obviously didn't.
That's an official date to release short interest.
And I don't disagree with feeling good with shorting at 300-400. But none of the info you just gave me invalidates my reasoning.
Considering there were 139% shorts which is way higher than the normally available pool, which we'll see on the 9th February ( as stated before)
edit: we may be talking about different things here. You're suggesting that if there are still funds very exposed on shorts in the info disclosed 2/9, then there's a potential for trying to make the stock rally again later this month? Vs that anything is already due this month? (I'm just skeptical still because the turnover is so high - I doubt the remaining interest has as high exposure cause I would guess they got in at higher prices.)
What's your formula to state a lack of people holding vs. the amount of shorts that were outstanding?
I don't see how you can easily come to that conclusion with 139% shorts outstanding at a certain moment.
If the amount of shorts were lessened to 50%, which we'll know on 9 February i can agree.
But I can't know for sure now and i want to know with what logic "you can" be sure.
Edit: Yes, I'm suggesting that there are "possibly" still a large amount of shorts and that I can't know till 9 February to see what could happen.
If the amount of shorts is low, than GME will continue to drop to a normal value.
If it's high, it depends on when the shorts were initiated, so it's still unclear then.
There's just a higher possibility to dismiss a potential squeeze on the 9th of February.
So I'm looking for additional info why people can already dismiss this reasoning.
Edit 2: ( can't reply on your comment)
I agree, there's a lot of uncertainty in it... A lot of "unknowns" for now.
I'm just careful dismissing it as a pure meme though. Since I can't fully dismiss it as such and I'm open to additional info surrounding this ( hence my original question).
I think we agree on where the uncertainty is, I just initially read you as saying you believed there was a definite ongoing squeeze, vs a possibility of continuing the play. And I just want to caution people against believing there's any sure things going on here; we don't have enough data in real enough time to know exactly. What we do have data on is that a LOT of shares are being sold every day, more than 100% of outstanding shares, so those could've been used to close out short positions, or they might not have been. And it could've been a few sellers selling a lot, or tons of sellers selling small amounts, etc. We can't know for now.
For example, if you post that putting high efficiency solar panels on an EV could significantly offset the need for charging infrastructure people will respond very differently depending on what the original topic was. Aesthetics, implementation, practicality, cost, and your specific calculation etc go from critical to unimportant depending on the topic.
“I personally am low risk so...”
“Actually I don’t need to wear a mask when I do this in public because...”
“My political leader disagrees with public health officials so...”
when lives are at stake is exactly when we should 'hyper-rationalize' (which doesn't mean don't consider emotion at all). we don't build bridges, go into war, or write aircraft control software thinking we'll wing it.
by your definition, that's hyper-rationalized (missing forest for trees) and exactly the kind of othering belief being highlighting: let's ignore actual risks and shared goals, and instead try to outwit those damn fools that are surely out there trying to kill us.
masks worn outside are largely for signaling (as your example admits) and self-mollification rather than infection reduction. it's unlikely that outdoor mask-wearing has reduced spread meaningfully or measurably.
but outdoor mask-wearing in turn gives us permission to not wear them at home or at private gatherings, because we've already 'done our part' against those selfish others, and this lowering of the guard in private does measurably increase spread. if you're really concerned about spread, you'd focus solely on minimizing close (<3ft) and prolonged (>15min) shared breathing indoors, not showing others outdoors how conformant and fearful you might be.
It seems like something is only a "conspiracy theory" when it contradicts ones priors.
Is that really news? I am fairly certain that has been true ever since humans had a currency.
Wall Street is not a casino in this regard. There is no “house edge”.
They have the odds stacked in their favor by nature of the size of their pockets and the ease by which they can flex this muscle to manipulate stocks in the direction they choose.
Sure, individuals could coordinate to flex similar levels of funds but even ignoring legality it's still difficult.
You either didn't trade options or didn't play casino games. Any trader knows he takes a gamble(calculated but still a gamble) and if something unexpected happens(i.e your stock buying is being halted and people panic for various reasons) you just made the wrong bet. Regardless if you are right you still loose.
Rational and evidence driven? Did HN became a scientific forum while I wasn't looking? This is a social network, which makes it opinion driven. Rationality and evidence are important, but they come second.
Hell, some of us don't even read articles before opining.
I think HN likes to believe it is evidence based and rational instead of emotional and greedy. A more enlightened and civilized corner of the internet. I have not been seeing much of that lately. It turns out the promise of riches is enough to make any community lose it's collective mind.
Here is a truism for you all: In any casino the players may win or lose, but the house always wins. If you think any bet is a guaranteed win, you have lost your rationality.