Re:AMC, GameStop Give Hedge Fund Mudrick Capital $200M in Gains
by cromka on Thursday February 04, 2021 @01:12AM
(#26023104)
What you described is called "ad hominem" fallacy.
Re:AMC, GameStop Give Hedge Fund Mudrick Capital $200M in Gains
by Traster on Thursday February 04, 2021 @02:51AM
(#26023506)
It's absolutely not, I know nothing about the guy on WSB, it's not an attack against him to simply say that the average person on the internet claiming something extremely unlikely is just most likely lying.
Re:AMC, GameStop Give Hedge Fund Mudrick Capital $200M in Gains
by cromka on Friday February 05, 2021 @03:01PM
(#26040542)
What I was referring to is this:
"I tell you my card is 7 of spades but I have a history of lying. Most likely, the card isn't the 7 of spades. But that doesn't mean it's likely that the card is the 9 of diamonds."
I suggested that such reasoning could, in a nutshell, be summarized as "ad hominem".
This is not good logic. There may be a lot of dodgy stuff going on and there may even be conspiracies, but even if you accept that there is a conspiracy that doesn't make it any more likely that the conspiracies being peddled by WSB are correct.
It's like I pick a card out of a deck, I tell you my card is 7 of spades but I have a history of lying. Most likely, the card isn't the 7 of spades. But that doesn't mean it's likely that the card is the 9 of diamonds. That's what this logic is saying - that it must be the (often clearly wrong) assertion simply because the only specific alternative is from someone you don't trust.