The short squeeze wasn't a complete failure. It happened, it was just much smaller than many predicted. I still wonder what would've happened if Robinhood didn't shut off demand by preventing people from buying shares. My investment thesis didn't foresee this happening. I don't think anyone did.
The other large part of the problem was that a lot of people, including myself, were going off of stale short interest data. Updated estimates for GME were reported to be 39% of float vs +100% on 1 Feb [1]. Hedge funds pay for more accurate data which us retail investors don't get visibility on.
It's over for now, but please bear this in mind when talking to people that may have lost money on this. Some people did some research, knew the risk and allocated money they were willing to lose. I learned a lot along the way, it might make some hedge funds think twice about aggressively shorting a stock, and it was just plain fun to be part of it.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-02-01/gamestop-...
Edit: updated short interest data stats and link.
Big players know that when they plan big market moves, they need to notify their brokers in advance, so the broker can prepare.
What we had here was a bunch of retail investors who are somewhat more informed than the average retail investor, but not well versed in the nuts and bolts of the maneuver they were involved in, and therefore the executed it without sufficient planning.
I think what is required is that you control long interest of 100% or more of the net shares (or float). (The shorts being > 100% is neither necessary nor sufficient for that.)
That's... just not true? Many things have non-arbitrary value. You need dollars to pay taxes. You need real estate to sleep and work. You can make pretty things that last a long time from gold.
My cheeseburger with one bite out of it has a market value of 0.
That scenario is pretty dissimilar to something like the value of a currency, which has value in proportion to the participants' trust in its stable value and how easily they can trade it for goods and services.
So to standardize on terms, I mean "bet" like I am betting on roulette, not "bet" as in I bet my bank will still be solvent tomorrow.
If someone sees that shorts in GME are over leveraged, well in hindsight they were absolutely right to buy in to this "gambling".
I find the most irrational actors with regards to investing are the people who only do "safe" bets and feel like that carries zero risk profile.