News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by fossuser on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:22PM (#25962733)
The best analysis of this is from Stratechery: https://stratechery.com/2020/privacy-labels-and-lookalike-au...

--

"Amazon, meanwhile, is increasingly where shopping searches start, particularly for Prime customers, and the company’s ad business is exploding. Needless to say, Amazon doesn’t need to request special permission for IDFAs or to share emails with 3rd parties to finely target its ads: everything is self-contained, and to the extent the company advertises on platforms like Google, it can still keep information about customer interests and conversions to itself. That means that in the long run, independent merchants who wish to actually find their customers will have no choice but to be an Amazon third-party merchant instead of setting up an independent shop on a platform like Shopify.

This decision, to be clear, will not be because Amazon was acting anticompetitively; the biggest driver — which, by the way, will also benefit Facebook’s on-platform commerce efforts — will be Apple, which, in the pursuit of privacy, is systematically destroying the ability of platform-driven small businesses to compete with the Internet giants."

--

FB has a point here, but I'm still hoping Apple wins - I'd rather the tracking model not be viable.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by mrtksn on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:06PM (#25963324)
So to break Amazon monopoly, the users must be tracked all day long, have complete profile of every living person and these people should not be asked first?

Why not break Amazon through regulatory power instead of total population tracking?

I also don't buy the small local business argument. If a local bakery wants to reach me, they can put a sign or do a promotion like giving a free cookie with the coffee on my way to work. It will also benefit the local community instead of a soulless corporation in SV.

When there's no Facebook, there's no FB for all of these bakeries. I don't die out of hunger because I failed to see targeted ad, instead I look at the maps or walk around and find the shops or ask a friend for a recommendation. The bakeries can excel in quality, have amazing prices etc. to reach me, like the old days.

An optimised version of FB's business is one where all the 3 bakeries in my neighbourhood give all their margin to FB in attempt to sell me cookies. Even better for FB if they optimize their cookies for lowest possible quality, just enough that the ads can drive me to buy one.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Justsignedup on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:31PM (#25964256)
This.

Its like arguing: Timmy steals money all day. I also want to steal money but Timmy steals from his rich parents, but since I can't I steal from my neighbors. Big poo poo cops said that stealing is not okay, but that's bad! I want to also steal because Timmy gets to steal from his parents!

Instead of "The cops said stealing is no longer permitted, also take a look at Timmy."

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by strulovich on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:42PM (#25965491)
Putting a sign or giving you freebies is orders of magnitude more expensive than getting some impressions on Facebook.

And this scenario where bakeries grind their margins in an endless ad fight is a bit far fetched, all the bakeries need to do is get your attention enough so that you know/remember they’re there. It’s a few cents with online advertising, FB makes billions because there’s a lot of users.

You’re also forgetting that such ads are about telling you about products you didn’t even consider you need. So yeah, you’re not going to die out of hunger due to lack of ads, but you may not learn of more luxurious items that you may want.

(Disclaimer, I work at FB, not on ads, and don’t know anything an outsider wouldn’t know)

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by newscracker on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:26PM (#25966041)
You seem to be missing the point of conversions, word of mouth, etc. Ads may cost pennies on your company’s user tracking platform, but what about the real cost of acquiring and retaining a customer? Those need good products and good service in a case like this. Buying ads for what seems like pennies can hurt businesses as they keep chasing “engagement” while waiting for revenue and profits. The reach of an online platform may be high compared to a sign, but that alone can’t help a business survive (especially small businesses that need local customers).
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by stretchcat on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:06PM (#25965618)
A chaulkboard / whiteboard costs fuck-all and is a one time expense. I've seen innumerable small businesses using such on the sidewalk. They seem to be very popular and have a homey authentic aesthetic you will never get with Facebook ads.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by strulovich on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:14PM (#25965663)
Sure, if I pass next to your business you get cheap advertising. But what if you’re off my path? Or just off the main street of the town? Also note that being on my path to work costs even more money - location is expensive and businesses will pay extra to be in high visibility spaces.

Facebook ads work for physical businesses because they’re competitive on price with their other options.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by stretchcat on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:19PM (#25965687)
How do you think those of us not using facebook manage to not starve to death for want of a bakery? Trust me, I can find local businesses just fine without Zuck crawling up my ass.

Bakery A feels compelled to buy ads from Facebook because Bakery B does. Bakery B has to because Bakery C does. Bakery C has to because Bakery A does. Facebook isn't providing value here. Facebook is a parasite that specializes in creating prisoner dilemmas used to bleed small businesses dry. Facebook is lower than mosquitoes, who at least provide nourishment to birds.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by strulovich on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:16PM (#25965976)
No one ever starves due to lack of advertising, advertising is not needed to let you know you need food.

And your contrived bakery example is unlikely. Ads are about letting you know a business exist, or convince you to give them another chance. Once everyone in town knows of all the bakeries, people will just pick favorites. If you’re the most famous bakery in town, you don’t need advertising. If you just started your cookie business, you do. Choose whatever advertising that works for you: signs, flyers, word of mouth, vitality stunts or just online ads. You will find that online ads are astoundingly cheap.

Again, if you serve the best croissants in town, customers will come back. (Reality is more sophisticated than that due general demand generation ideas such as just reminding you of croissants vs inferior pastries)

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by smichel17 on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:50PM (#25965849)
Amazon even splits into three very cleanly separate pieces: AWS // Amazon.com // Fulfilment
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by walrus01 on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:25PM (#25962781)
> FB has a point here, but I'm still hoping Apple wins - I'd rather than tracking model not be viable.

I think it's possible for two things to be true simultaneously:

a) it's bad and wrong for apple to demand 30%, or whatever it is, as a cut of any payment made inside an app distributed through their app store

b) apple blocking tracking and advertising networks at the operating system level (API calls between the app running on a phone or tablet, and the underlying OS) is a net benefit for the consumer end user. obviously apple has a very different perspective on this since they are not facebook, or google, and not dependent upon advertising revenue.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Forge36 on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:36PM (#25962929)
What's up stop b) from being "goodbye api" and completely removing it? I'd assume at some point any App could be expected to make required updates for a variety of reasons. Like any other tool: what obligations does a manufacturer have to continue creating replacement parts?
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by vineyardmike on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:05PM (#25965281)
B would result in more law suits faster, this way apple can claim "its the customers decision". Right now, people complain about apple making decisions for them. And, fwiw, i know people who actually opt-in to tracking (no idea why...)
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by dylan604 on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:53PM (#25963159)
If it is truly a manufacturer making replacement parts, then they have to have enough stock to fulfill warranty requests for the life of the warranty. Otherwise, they have to replace the entire thing.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by pradn on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:48PM (#25963822)
b) Apple blocking tracking is only a net benefit if you value privacy enough to overweigh the drop in customers for niche businesses well served by targeted ads.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by kergonath on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:07PM (#25964014)
Apple is not blocking tracking, though. Apple is putting the decision in the hands of the user.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by pradn on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:39PM (#25971067)
The practical effect is a massive decrease in tracking information for companies- defaults are powerful.

I agree with Apple’s decision. It’s just going to have negative effects for some businesses, which is a price that must be considered against the gain in privacy.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by kergonath on Sunday January 31, 2021 @04:12AM (#25977345)
It will have effects, sure. But they still don’t prevent tracking, and if the trade off is so compelling for users as some people here seem to imply, then users will just accept it.

It is difficult to say that the users being aware of what they are giving away is a bad thing, unless you are a crook whose business model is based on deception.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by sahila on Friday January 29, 2021 @07:20PM (#25964648)
That's not you evaluate giving up a person's privacy. Otherwise your argument is akin to saying we should force X millionaire to give up all his money to y group of people because of the net benefit.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by mrzimmerman on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:36PM (#25965451)
Well in the case of the USA taxation is part of the constitution. Privacy is too but that relates to how the government surveils you and not necessarily how a private company collects info on you as you use their product.

So I guess I’m saying your comparison is specious.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by dereg on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:48PM (#25963083)
I do not agree with the quoted train of logic in the context of an antitrust suit. It leads to the conclusion that X (Facebook) should wage an antitrust lawsuit against Y (Apple) in order to achieve an outcome that would help tame the growth of Z's (Amazon) market position.

If the United States feels that Amazon is an anticompetitive company, then that position should be litigated in and of itself.

It's understandable that Facebook feels righteous in filing a proxy lawsuit for its advertisers. They've had their hand in the cookie jar of so many internet transactions for so long that they cannot imagine the horror of not knowing about any of them.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by vineyardmike on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:08PM (#25965303)
Its not actually about Amazon. The point is just that Apple limitations will help "self contained" data holders like amazon because they don't need the tracking data that apple is limiting.

Amazon is just a simpler target to explain the small-biz impact than "facebook with its marketplace and shopify integration and existing data sources and abilities and pending future products they've announced"

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by fossuser on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:54PM (#25963170)
It's worth reading the entire blog post I linked - it's good and provides more context.

I only quoted a relevant subsection because I know otherwise 99% of people won't click through to read any of it.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by dalbasal on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:25PM (#25963543)
There is the "technically true" way of looking at this, and there's the non-legalistic, subjective judgement of these companies.

FB, their business model and modus operandi is filthy. They really moved the overton window on what is morally normative in terms of advertising... and then applied those norms to everything... content, not just advertising.

Apple do stuff you might disagree on. They normalised demoting applications to "apps," which exist inside a walled garden, pay rent and play by Apple's rules. This might not be a good vibe. But, the app store isn't their product.

Monopoly, by and large, is not Apple's business model. Apple are big enough that they do monopolize markets, like the app store. But the app store isn't the product or business model. Selling phones is. They don't generally pursue dominant market shares, prefering to cream the high end.

A business model that isn't inherently monopoly seeking at its core, isn't mostly about data, advertising or somesuch... that basically makes Apple a shining example. Everything is relative.

That said, despite hoping FB lose generally, I do hope that antitrust builds up to something meaningful. I'll be hoping for a guilty.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Epskampie on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:48AM (#25966863)
You must have missed the last five years where Apple is looking to extract increasingly more value from “services” i.e. the app store. They very very much want to retain their monopoly there.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by dalbasal on Saturday January 30, 2021 @05:49AM (#25968036)
Yes. I think I was clear enough that I'm speaking in relatives, not absolutes.

Apple's size, platform positioning and the fundamental microeconomics of Apple's markets all drives towards "competition for monopoly," to use the term of art. They're not above customer lock ins, closed ecosystems. They're not above creating little tyrannical kingdoms... Apple may become a Facebook (ar amazon/google) eventually, but atm they are not.. and the opportunities have been many.

Apple still, essentially, makes new products and hopes people like them enough to overpay for it. They actually exposed themselves to risk of failure if new products aren't good/popular enough. Who does that?

One or two Windows Vista level failures could kill Apple. There is no guaranteed income for macs or iphones in 2022. Facebook, Google, MSFT. even amazon... the quality of their work does not pose a risk of failure in the medium term. Google's user base is protected by default. They own android, and pay for iphone defaults. Own youtube, your emails. The search data. On the customer side, they have a (recognised by courts) monopoly. Search advertising is non-optional for many, many businesses. Adwords is the only seller.

For a (old) counterexample, think of rss podcasts. Apple named it, popularized it, dealt with a bullshit one-click-like patent claim on subscription audio as a whole. Meanwhile, Apple never tried to dominate, close, or "own" podcasting. Podcast today is the only free, popular medium.

Currently, Spotify's is literally trying to buy up all the top podcasts just to exclude them from the open protocol. The aim, naturally, is to own podcasting.. at which point they can force all the little guys to give them content for free and on their terms.

Podcasters, they think, are totally disunited, unlike recording artists. That means once spotify has market share, they can dictate terms like youtube does for video. I bet they already have a cute name for podcasters picked out. Vloggers are called "youtubers." Maybe podcasters will be "spotters." Has a nice ring to it.

I'm not calling them angels. Half of it is probably being boomer and being slow to adapt to modern ways. That said, if you compare Apple core business models to the other guys...

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by saltedonion on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:41PM (#25963023)
This is true but the solution should be anti trust action against amazon as well, as opposed to let fb be monopolistic and “give small business a chance”
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by m-ee on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:44PM (#25963049)
This presupposes that this tracking heavy targeted advertising has positive ROI for these small businesses. Is there any evidence this is actually true?
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by manigandham on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:55PM (#25963189)
Yes. This question seems to come up constantly as if advertising is still some arcane art. Facebook and Google are incredibly good at this and have the valuations to show for it.

Highly targeted advertising can produce great results and there was a time where Facebook was basically a money-printing machine for affiliate and ecommerce because it was so good at finding and reaching the perfect customer. This has become saturated and results have dissipated somewhat but it's still very strong.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Retric on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:03PM (#25963286)
Small business are well known for making very poor decisions on average. Just look at Groupon and Food Delivery App XYZ. Moving lots of inventory at negative margins is much easier than doing so profitability, which is one of the reasons they so frequently fail.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by ummonk on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:42PM (#25964362)
I think small businesses are intended to refer to e.g. mom and pop businesses, not moderate sized startups. Not that that necessarily detracts from your point.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Retric on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:53PM (#25964445)
My point was a huge number of businesses failed to benefit from Groupon etc. Profitable small business are on a tightrope with failure on one side and growth on the other. The kinds of businesses that can really leverage targeted advertising are exactly the kinds of companies that stop being small businesses.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by manigandham on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:54PM (#25963895)
Sure, nothing prevents a business from making poor decisions that puts them out of business. Why is that specific to ads?
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Retric on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:40PM (#25965480)
It was a question of ROI, and targeted ads are simply more difficult to use well.

Putting up a large sign outside convince store is going to target people in the area well enough. Giant companies like Disney can easily produce different ads to target individual slices of the population for similar results. But, how well can a small river rafting company for example leverage demographics data? Meanwhile because some companies find this data useful they suddenly need to pay a premium, which just doesn’t seem likely to pay off on average.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by manigandham on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:56PM (#25965570)
Ads aren't magic. When and how you use them has a significant impact on actual ROI, just like anything else in business. Part of the value of these adtech companies is that they can do most of the heavy lifting for you, so even small businesses can target and optimize without a large team.

If you want to target river rafters then you can just target people with "river rafting, outdoors, adventurer, travel" interests, or followers of your page, or upload emails of existing customers. Then let Facebook find similar people automatically. It's that easy.

Everything else being equal, targeted ads still do better than non-targeted ads. I don't see how this is so controversial.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Retric on Friday January 29, 2021 @11:25PM (#25966037)
They could clearly target say “river rafters” but it’s less clear if such a group going to cost effectively bring in new customers. The risk is if you target people that are looking into river rafting your simply poaching current or future customers who would know about you either way.

That’s the thing, it’s very easy to advertise to existing customers, worse your competitors are likely to bid up any easy associations. So, the most common case ends up in failure. Perhaps you didn’t something that works you can double down on, but that’s in practice extremely rare these days. Far more common is to realize after the fact you just spent a lot of money on a negative return.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by manigandham on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:32PM (#25974504)
I think you're arguing for the sake of argument here.

Targeting people who have obvious self-selected and data-driven interests in what you're selling is going to do better than generic ads with no specific audience. This is practically science at this point. However nothing is guaranteed and a specific campaign not providing results doesn't have anything to do with the concept of targeted advertising.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by mattkrause on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:11PM (#25963382)
I'm not sure that answers the question.

It's not impossible that Facebook and Google capture all of the value--or more--that their clients generate by running ads: Bob's Burgers runs $500/mo worth of ads, only generates $400 in (new) profit from them, but is afraid to stop because Paul's Pizza is also running ads and they might lose even more marketshare.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by jamiequint on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:25PM (#25963542)
That's theoretically true but not true in reality, ask one of any of the thousands of new (in the last ~8 years, since FB launched lookalike targeting) businesses that grew to millions of dollars of revenue off of FB ads. I personally know at least 10 whose primary early growth mechanism was Facebook ads. They work.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by mattkrause on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:08PM (#25964026)
As a counterpoint, you may be interested in this 2015 paper by Blake, Nosko, and Taldelis: https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w20171/w201...

They found that paid (i.e., ads) and unpaid traffic were nearly perfect substitutes for brand names: people will either to get to eBay. For non-brands, clicks go down, but sales don’t; ads are mostly attracting “browsers”, rather than buyers.

The real answer is that it probably depends a lot on the industry, market, and individual business.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by jamiequint on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:32PM (#25964270)
That paper is mostly referencing brand search at large companies which is completely different than lookalike ads for small, unknown companies. I'm not really sure how the comparison is relevant.

If your point is that effective advertising strategies vary by company then I agree, but that is a tangential and meaningless point in the context of the above conversation.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by mattkrause on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:04PM (#25965276)
You pointed out a niche where internet ads apparently worked well (though isn’t some of that just survivorship bias?)

I found the eBay data interesting because AI had assumed that they would have a fairly sophisticated online operation, and yet neither the branded nor non-brand ads really helped (for the latter, removing ads led to -40% on clicks, but -2% on sales).

I can’t imagine that the neighborhood pizza place is really doing a top-notch job on ad attribution; it seems a heck of a lot more likely that they throw a few ads up because everyone else does too.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by jamiequint on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:50PM (#25965848)
That “niche” is the reason Shopify is a 100+ billion dollar company.

With respect to eBay, proving someone sucks at running ads isn’t the same as proving ads suck. (also it matters a lot more what % of sales the ads in this case represented, rather than just the absolute change in sales).

I agree with you about the neighborhood businesses fwiw.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by manigandham on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:04PM (#25963986)
The increase (or lack of decrease) in marketshare has to be factored as part of the return on investment, in which case the result is positive.

Otherwise why continue to run the ads? A smaller but profitable marketshare is better than a larger but negative one.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by ummonk on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:40PM (#25964342)
If it's about lack of decrease in market share, then the existence of the ads product is not a net positive for small businesses. It is potentially just extracting a rent out of them without any aggregate benefit by pitting businesses against each other in a coordination problem.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by manigandham on Friday January 29, 2021 @08:12PM (#25964979)
If a company creates better kitchen equipment that allows one shop to make better food, isn't that the same thing? Is it now rent-seeking that anyone who can provide an advantage can potentially sell that to all the shops so they all remain competitive and not lose market share?

All competition is a coordination problem.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by mattkrause on Friday January 29, 2021 @08:54PM (#25965237)
Uncertainty, perhaps?

Prediction and attribution are really hard. I linked a paper below showing that eBay was wasting money on entirely ineffective keyword ads. I can’t imagine that most small businesses (especially brick and mortar ones) are much savvier.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by manigandham on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:43PM (#25974572)
Why is uncertainty specific to ads? That's part of anything in business whether it's a new office, new equipment or new salesperson.

Whether something provides a return or not for your specific situation doesn't have anything to do with whether the product itself is working and valid.

Ebay situation is different because search is as close as you can get to "intent" in advertising. You don't need user-targeting when you have a search query telling you exactly what they're looking for. Targeting is a proxy for that kind of intent when it's not available.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by mattkrause on Saturday January 30, 2021 @11:37PM (#25976002)
Look, I am not arguing that ads, of whatever sort, cannot ever work for anyone. I'm sure that internet marketing is a key part of some companies' business plans. Warby Parker, perhaps.

What I'm not yet convinced of is that they're a panacea for all small businesses. Details aside, one moral of the eBay paper is that a $50B business, with a whole dedicated department, still managed to make a dog's breakfast of their online advertising; Uber reported similar problems earlier this winter.

It seems hard and it's not obvious to me that every business has the aptitude, market, or business model to do it well. At the same time, I can easily imagine people deciding "We need to do something about advertising" and then forging ahead with whatever something they land on. This is especially true with the ROI is difficult to calculate--and I do think it's probably harder to calculate for an ad than for something with very standardized cost/performance characteristics like new equipment.

Google, Facebook, and Shopify making money doesn't really answer this question. As an analogy: "Is there gold in them there hills?" "Sure, even the guy selling shovels is making money!"

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by manigandham on Sunday January 31, 2021 @01:16AM (#25976534)
I just told you why Ebay's situation is different. Uber was defrauded and wasn't a failure of advertising.

Advertising can be complicated, but part of the value of these giant networks is helping to run those campaigns effectively. I'm not sure why you think everyone has to put in similar amounts of effort. That's not necessary at all. You have tools from simply setting the budget and targeting lookalikes of people liking your posts (what most small businesses do) to running your own bidder stack (for larger brands that have entire agencies working for them).

While attribution will never be perfect, it's not guessing either. Ecommerce only makes it easier as you can track all the way from exposure to checkout, and in some ways can be more attributable than other businesses expenses.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by newfeatureok on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:02PM (#25963281)
I'd love to see some research about this from an unbiased source showing that targeted advertising produces great results in small businesses (<100 employees, or <5M revenue yearly).
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by ta1234567890 on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:42PM (#25963755)
It would also be important to know, not if ads can produce great results, but how many companies do they provide great results for? Even better, what percentage of all business that run online ads get a positive return on their investment, and what is the average of that return.

My personal experience is that it is pretty hard to get consistently good performance running campaigns on FB or Google. It requires a lot of learning and a lot of trial and error. On top of that, they constantly push you to spend more by giving you dubious recommendations on how to “improve” your campaigns. Very hard to believe that the average small business is actually capable of running good campaigns and consistently make money from them.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by aardvarkr on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:55PM (#25963907)
Anecdotal but I’ve always heard from marketing friends that Facebook ads are hands down the best ads and yield many multiples of the cost of the ads
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by manigandham on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:56PM (#25963909)
What about all the actual small businesses that have positive ROAS? There are millions of them on Facebook's platform. What kind of other research are you looking for?
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by newfeatureok on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:48PM (#25965839)
Sure I'd love to see something concrete about the "actual small businesses that have positive ROAS." You have any research to cite?

Keep in mind I'm talking about targeted advertising, not advertising in general.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by llbeansandrice on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:09PM (#25963365)
Yes. I know someone who runs a blog that shows ads. Since Google adwords/sense and modern targeted ads became a thing their revenue from the business has basically doubled if not more.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by mattkrause on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:09PM (#25965309)
ITT: Ad-tech people, talking up their own book.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by matheusmoreira on Friday January 29, 2021 @07:46PM (#25964796)
> Apple, which, in the pursuit of privacy, is systematically destroying the ability of platform-driven small businesses to compete with the Internet giants

Awesome, that's really good news. Now we need to figure out how to destroy the business models of these giants as well so that competing with corrupt global surveillance corporations is no longer necessary.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by noobquestion81 on Friday January 29, 2021 @10:41PM (#25965784)
I’ve thought hard about the summary for this, I think this is a good one:

Facebook: we don’t provide anything of tangible physical value. Other people do, and they make money off of it. Where’s our money?!?!

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by echelon on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:51PM (#25963135)
The solution is this:

1. Apple iPhone needs to be an open platform. Users can install apps from wherever and don't have to go through Apple distribution. (But Apple can still provide this for convenience and discovery, and still charge a fee.)

2. Installing apps includes a strong permissions API. The filesystem, sensor access, GPS, etc. can be cordoned off and requires user intervention. Heuristics and isolation can prevent apps from sharing data for tracking/identification.

The reality is that Apple outgrew their platform and it can't continue to exist as a walled garden without being a monopoly. They can't have their cake and eat it too. Otherwise Facebook has a case. Epic has a case. Etc.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by fossuser on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:57PM (#25963212)
I don't agree with this or want this.

I like that Apple has leverage to tell app developers to adhere to their platform rules in ways that benefit Apple's users.

If Apple was wielding this to harm users that'd be one thing, but they're not, they wield it to prevent spammy crap, to make it easy to subscribe and unsubscribe, to prevent spying and tracking, etc.

That's why I value and buy Apple products, if someone wants an open platform they can buy something else. They're not a monopoly and they don't act in a way that harms their users.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by matheusmoreira on Friday January 29, 2021 @07:58PM (#25964883)
It's true that Apple's gatekeeping gives it a lot of leverage. In this case they're using their power in a way that benefits their users and that's great. Still, it shouldn't be necessary for a corporation to own its users and decide what's best for them on their behalf just so other corporations will stop abusing people's privacy.

In an ideal world, governments would step in and tell them straight up to stop invading people's privacy or face punishment. Obviously that's not going to happen: any proposed law would immediately be defanged by the industry's lobbyists on the basis it would hurt their "legitimate" business interests. Not to mention the fact governments would love to keep these global surveillance tools around.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by echelon on Friday January 29, 2021 @09:53PM (#25965555)
It's not about what you want, it's about what the market needs to remain healthy and competitive.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by fossuser on Saturday January 30, 2021 @12:16AM (#25966381)
It’s not about that either.

There is a healthy market here. Forcing Apple to do what you suggest is harmful to users and reduces user choice by making the Apple ecosystem like Android. This removes Apple’s ability to do things like block tracking and force store compliance which is the reason I and others choose them.

An option exists for people that don’t want a curated ecosystem. This is about you forcing your preferences on everyone else, specifically users that prefer and chose Apple’s model.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Mindwipe on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:43PM (#25963766)
> If Apple was wielding this to harm users that'd be one thing,

The ones who have been killed in Hong Kong by Apple throwing protestors under a bus might disagree with this.

Or a variety of sexual subcultures, or sex workers, who Apple relentlessly attack.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by IOT_Apprentice on Friday January 29, 2021 @07:23PM (#25964660)
Instead look at the literal millions of people who have fallen down the Q-Anon hellhole because of Facebook. And those that have been radicalized by YouTubes algorithms. The rampant disinformation that oozes from both platforms. Both firms should be charged with crimes against Humanity alongside Rupert Murdoch and his Fox News.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by fossuser on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:59PM (#25963936)
You won’t find any disagreement from me on this. Western company deference to China is wrong: https://zalberico.com/essay/2020/06/13/zoom-in-china.html

That’s mostly a separate issue though.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by asiachick on Friday January 29, 2021 @07:22PM (#25964654)
Why do you need the platform to be locked down to achieve this?

You can choose to only download apps from the Apple app store that follow those rules. You will in no way be effected whatsoever by the platform being open. For you, nothing will change.

Why do you feel everyone else in the world must live with in your limits and not limits they choose for themselves?

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by fossuser on Friday January 29, 2021 @08:32PM (#25965108)
The lock down gives Apple the leverage to force good behavior and policy.

If it was left to choice the companies are incentivized to be shitty.

Users are unsophisticated so the incentive will be for companies to track, mine, and sell data and most will do it.

> “You can choose to only download apps from the Apple store that follow those rules”

There will be way fewer of them, if it’s even possible to tell them apart at all.

> “Why do you feel everyone else in the world must live in your limits...”

I don’t - they can buy android and side load if they want to.

Why do you feel I must be forced to suffer an open platform as well? Forcing Apple to do this removes consumer choice, it doesn’t add to it.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Barrin92 on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:28PM (#25963585)
>if Apple was wielding this to harm users that'd be one thing

walled gardens harm users by definition because they reduce competition. Forcing an open API would immediately create the opportunity for people to offer competing clients for any Apple (or Facebook etc) service, drive down costs, produce new ways to interact with the services of large companies and so on, it would immediately unlock the ability of countless of independent creators to produce new products.

In fact if you were to open up Facebook, Apple's apis and so on and turned them into open protocols you would not even necessarily need invasive privacy regulation, people could just build a privacy respecting Facebook client that lets people interact with the service in a way they want, getting an algorithm free news feed if they want, stripping out baggage they don't need. It would solve a large majority of the exact issues that we have with large tech companies.

Apple does hold a monopoly over all Apple users, which gives them market power the same way a monopolistic company in a larger market exercises power. It's actually straight up depressing for someone to say "well I benefit from the walled garden". It's no different than someone saying "I like the oligarch because he treats me nicely"

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by spideymans on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:34PM (#25963657)
Sure, but consumers should be free to make that decision themselves. The government shouldn't force it upon them.

Apple has not deceived consumers with regards to their App Store practices. On the contrary, they've been quite boastful about it. There are (and were) plenty of open computing platforms, allowing consumers to experience their benefits and tradeoffs. If consumers prefer to use a more locked down platform, then so be it.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Barrin92 on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:40PM (#25963727)
Most people don't even know what a world would look like in which power was taken away from large companies and a genuine market of services would exists that gives power back to the users and developers rather than platform owners. The hold that Apple has on its billion users and that Facebook has on its 2 billion is too strong to be solved by some magical third party. None of the large firms which control our digital infrastructure provides an actual protocols.

The government should absolutely force it on Facebook and Apple and Google the same way the American government forced it on railroad barons a hundred years ago, when they were forced to make their networks interoperable.

Imagine if Volkswagen owned the streets and you could only drive your car on 30% of all roads. Sure you can go to Toyota, you just have to drive in circles. We'd laugh anyone out of the room who actually defended this. Yet this is literally how the internet is structured right now. We live in little fiefdoms where Android users can't talk to imessage users because feudal lords have decided to draw a line across the territory.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by spideymans on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:55PM (#25963903)
>Most people don't even know what a world would look like in which power was taken away from large companies and a genuine market of services would exists that gives power back to the users and developers rather than platform owners.

Consumers knew exactly what more open computing was like prior to the App Store. There were no App Store for Windows or OS X back in 2005, and you could largely install whatever applications you like onto the smartphone operating systems of the day. Evidently, a pretty large chunk of users decided the preferred the more restricted operating system with the "curated" store.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Mindwipe on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:45PM (#25963788)
> Sure, but consumers should be free to make that decision themselves.

Why? The state makes a variety of judgements that corporations cannot leave things up to user choice because that's too dangerous to wider society.

Apple can't sell an iPhone that occasionally electrocutes users and out it down to "user choice." We rightly ban that.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by stale2002 on Friday January 29, 2021 @07:37PM (#25964739)
> If consumers prefer to use a more locked down platform, then so be it.

There is nothing wrong with a consumer being allowed to choose to keep their own phone locked down.

Thats not the problem. The problem is when you go to a consumer and tell them that they aren't allowed to open up their own property, in an easy way.

You can keep your phone locked down. Just give other people the choice to also open up their own phone, easily, if they choose to do so.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Jtsummers on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:16PM (#25964109)
> Apple does hold a monopoly over all Apple users

Starbucks holds a monopoly over all Starbucks customers.

If I want to be a Starbucks customer I have to go to Starbucks. Goddamn them I want to get my overpriced Starbucks coffee from Dairy Queen!

Speaking of Dairy Queen, why are they the only ones that get to sell a Blizzard??!?

*****

Your statement is just as nonsensical to me.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by fossuser on Friday January 29, 2021 @08:39PM (#25965141)
A closer analogy is Walmart deciding what goes on its shelves and it being hard for users to buy from any other store besides Walmart once they choose a “Walmart” device which locks them into their choice a bit.

I can see the argument, I just don’t think the power is being wielded for consumer harm - if it was that’d be different.

If Apple was blocking some company from their store everyone wanted because they were competing with an Apple product that’d be an issue. As it is they’re making it easy for their users to not be spied on.

In the analogy it’d be Walmart checking that what they stock on shelves doesn’t poison their customers.

Are they wielding power? Sure - is that monopoly abuse? No.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by echelon on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:56PM (#25964477)
Starbucks is pretty generic. I'm not locked into Starbucks coffee.

In fact, in the past week alone I've bought coffee at both Starbucks and Dunkin. The product lines are similar and buying one does not preclude buying the other. There's zero lock in.

Once you start using your iPhone, you stop buying Android apps. You also don't use Google Wallet.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by IOT_Apprentice on Friday January 29, 2021 @07:18PM (#25964636)
Starbucks is a corporation, it is not generic. You can't buy Dunkin at Starbucks.

It is your choice to shop at either. Just as it is your choice to use either an iPhone using iOS or a phone using Android/Google etc.

Just as it is your choice to choose a car from a particular manufacturer.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by dawg- on Sunday January 31, 2021 @11:19AM (#25979853)
The big point here is that Apple users choose the walled garden for themselves. Many people buy apple products specifically because of it.

Of course apple holds a “monopoly” over their own users, exactly the same as how Walmart and Target hold a “monopoly” over the space within their own stores.

If you don’t like the business model of Walmart because of how they have ruined local businesses, you can go shop at the farmers market or local organic shops. But you wouldn’t file a lawsuit which would demand that Walmart host the local farmers market in their own parking lot.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by dwaite on Saturday January 30, 2021 @05:39AM (#25967983)
The reality is that the decision to use alternate stores will not be from user choice - it will be from large internet companies telling them the only way to get Facebook is via the Facebook store, to get Fortnight is from the Epic Games Store, to get Netflix is via the Netflix store, etc.

And the purpose of these stores will be to skirt Apple requirements on apps in their store - not just payment, but things like network traffic surveillance.

These stores will also not be pitched by companies based on informed user decisions. They will be pitched in order to get users to sign up in whatever way they can drive taps through consent screens.

So unfortunately to remain a user choice, there needs to be a strong disincentive for parties to force a customer into a third party store, but not so strong that it looks like antitrust.

Google Play for instance has tons of "Play Services" which are not available to apps from alt-stores.

The Mac has certain security settings which can only be disabled through a process requiring a reboot and command-line action as a way to limit vendors from driving customers through disabling essential security features without proper education.

Mac applications are also notarized, so whether they are downloaded through the official app store or a third party channel they can be scanned for static issues and revoked after the fact as malware in the case of dynamic issues.

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by fiddlerwoaroof on Friday January 29, 2021 @04:58PM (#25963227)
I dunno, hasn’t Apple always been the choice for people who want a walled garden? Whether it was the old Macs, iPod or iPhone, Apple’s value proposition has always been a curated experience. Given the availability of Android, I have very little sympathy for claims that Apple is doing something wrong by setting the terms of access to its user-base.
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by design-material on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:08PM (#25963356)
Isn't this essentially saying:

1. Make Apple build a strong permissions API that covers the filesystem, sensors, GPS, isolation, privacy, tracking protection etc.

2. Force Apple to provide this for free to all developers (allowing them to charge for access to list on the App Store)

?

Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by Rumudiez on Friday January 29, 2021 @05:33PM (#25963639)
They already do. It's called Safari
Re:Facebook reportedly prepping antitrust lawsuit against Ap... by vbezhenar on Friday January 29, 2021 @06:16PM (#25964107)
The question is whether iOS is ready to run truly untrusted code. So far only web demonstrated proper sandbox which is rarely penetraded. Take Linux server for example, only few days ago sudo bug was found which could be used to escalate user privileges to root.

I'm not iOS expert, but the mere fact that there's private API which is forbidden to use by ordinary apps but that's only implemented by some static code checking rather than by OS means that iOS does not have proper security model ready to withstand arbitrary code execution.