Melvin announced they had cleared their position in GME days ago so is unlikely to be the driver for brokerage behavior today.
Citadel does not buy user data from Robinhood, they are one of Robinhood internalizers. They pay for the privilege of either trading against Robinhood based orders or routing them to an exchange.
Not allowing buys can happen for a wide variety of reasons from technical, business to legal to counterparty demands and isn’t necessarily signs of collusion.
That said there is certainly the appearance of a conflict of interest and I’m sure Robinhood will be addressing that in court and to investigators presently.
> "Robinhood partners with institutional investors and lets them spy on what the average joes are buying and selling. Sometimes, this is just "market intelligence" ("Hey, people like fidget spinners") but the main event is front-running."
> "If you're paying Robinhood to tell you what assets its customers are about to buy, you can go out and buy them up first and sell them for a profit to Robinhood's customers."
> "Or you can buy some of that asset up because you know its price will go up once Robinhood's customers orders are filled."
> "Citadel Securities is Robinhood's main institutional investor partner."
Internalizers do not go out and buy the things they’ve peaked at during the internalization process.
https://twitter.com/justinkan/status/1354853920762253315?s=2...
No, Citadel does not own Melvin Capital. Melvin Capital received an investment from Citadel (the hedge fund, not the market maker) and Point72 this week.
> Robinhood seems to be manipulating the market to make it easier for Melvin Capital to cut their substantial losses.
Melvin already cut its losses this week, as was widely reported. There is no evidence for the counter claims that they're lying, which themselves originate on reddit. In particular: all the widely cited short interest figures on reddit which purport to show this are out of date (usually by weeks), and even if they were true, they would not be proof the short positions weren't closed.
And there is no proof Melvin cut their losses. There is no way to know for sure. The shorts are still there, whether they're Melvin or anyone else.
As for the proof about cutting losses - no, there's no proof. You can question every single fact you read about this story in the media if you want. The reasons most people have given for why they would lie about it instead of just do it kind of strain credulity for me. There are a lot of conspiracies being spread around with much regard for whether or not they are true instead of whether they could be true.
This was widely reported, and Melvin might not be the big bag holder anymore, but the short interest hasn't subsided. It's actually grown.
The squeeze never happened. The squeeze never happened.
https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/we-have-some-bad-news-game...
As far as I can tell they started the year with ~12.5B AUM, and have lost ~30% on the year and received a 2.75B cash infusion from Citadel et al, which I assume was at a discount given their position. So my rough estimate is around ~25-35%, given the uncertainty around those numbers.
https://twitter.com/justinkan/status/1354853920762253315?s=2...
https://www.reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/l747eg/cita...
This seems, at first glance, to be clear and blatant market manipulation by Citadel and Robinhood.
There was someone claiming to be a robin hood employee, that the White House got involved. Obviously I would take this with an extreme pinch of salt but with those numbers there is every motivation from the powers that be
Could it be that other trading platforms use the same clearing firm?
For a small brokerage, they would have to work with other brokerages to help them trade, as they wouldn't have enough shares they already hold to trade them within their users. So Robinhood asks Apex for more shares, and Apex has to ask HSBC/Fidelity/JPMC/Goldman if Apex doesn't have any. At some point, all the other institutions also don't want to give up their shares because they need to satisfy demand from their own users. Trading with other firms tends to be really slow too.
It's a short squeeze too, by definition there's not enough stocks available for everyone who wants to buy. So some firms ran out and couldn't get more.
Same with doing your own clearing, there's complexity involved with clearing and maybe you don't want to implement it all yourself when someone does it better for cheaper.
It's like asking why we don't all program in assembly all the time, or even have the option to mix assembly into our high level code. It's just nice having layers of abstraction that handle the annoying stuff for you, even if there's a minor cost. Why have complexity you don't expect to need?
That's... not how stock markets work. For every buy there must be a seller. If there are too many buyers but not enough sellers the price simply goes up.
https://blog.robinhood.com/news/2018/10/9/introducing-cleari...
Jesus, it kind of shows how corrupt the US really is. We're all basically watching a bunch of people commit crimes that from my quick Google carries a max sentence of 10 years with billons of dollars on the line and we're all pretty sure they're going to get away with it.
Though, I do think if Biden makes sure the justice hammer comes down on this, it'll win over a bunch of Trump supporters.
[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-gamestop-melvin-idUSKBN29...
I'm not sure anyone who still can be considered a “Trump supporter” is swayable; on the other hand, if Biden is seen as politicizing prosecutorial decisiones it’ll lose a bunch of Biden supporters.
It's also questionable how much influences Biden’s preferences have at Justice since his AG nominee hasn't been confirmed and everyone at levels requiring Senate confirmation there is a Trump carryover (though, to be fair, the Acting AG was appointed from within by Biden and wasn't out of order of seniority, IIRC, so he has exert what influence he can to select leadership given the constraints he faces.)
https://twitter.com/AstralTrading/status/1354884246389874689...
By preventing people from buying shares, the short-sellers have less competition to buy the available shares, and will have an easier time getting them, while paying less for them. Robinhood seems to be manipulating the market to make it easier for Melvin Capital to cut their substantial losses.