News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by lmilcin on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:24PM (#25897651)
I would say computer revolution still hasn't happened.

We are just starting to learn what computers are for. Hopefully, instead of being tools of stealing our focus and invigilation some day we will collectively figure out how to use computers so that we can live better lives.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by lifeisstillgood on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:02PM (#25897876)
I could not agree more. I keep banging on about what I call a MOOP - Massive open online psychology. These phones we all carry can listen to / video our every interaction, watch our spending habits and our exercise and body functions.

Epidemiology ought to be able to easily tease out ideal "life best practises" - actual good advice given to you by your phone - backed by the mistakes of a million others in just your situation.

if keeping a daily diary helps people make better life decisions imagine what that would do?

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by not_a_moth on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:46PM (#25898144)
Being watched and served recommendations is not the revolutionary paradigm for computers imo.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by bjo590 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:12PM (#25898295)
It would be revolutionary if "recommendations" wasn't a modern synonym for "advertisements"
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by teekert on Monday January 25, 2021 @03:54AM (#25900981)
This exactly. The recommendations are, at best, a win win for you and some 3rd party that paid to be part of the win (but sometimes tries very hard to not make it seem so). It can be different, but only for the tech-savy (open source) and rich people (pay the tech-savy).
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by ozim on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:38AM (#25901713)
I care to disagree, millions of people working from home and huge digital economy is there.

There is already a lot of real value in ubiquitous computing, automated warehouses, supply chain optimizations, digital entertainment, digital government services in many countries, I could go on for couple of pages now.

Recommendations and tracking are just a side effect. FB and Google ads are not whole "digital economy" on their own.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by jhowell on Monday January 25, 2021 @06:51AM (#25902144)
> There is already a lot of real value in ubiquitous computing, automated warehouses, supply chain optimizations, digital entertainment, digital government services in many countries, I could go on for couple of pages now.

Is technology about, or only about optimizing value in supply chains?

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by ozim on Monday January 25, 2021 @08:42AM (#25902986)
I don't understand the question since I pointed out other areas as well like digital entertainment which has nothing to do with optimizing value in supply chains.

Maybe you thought about optimizing content delivery, but I was thinking about computer games, VR, music production, which are digital entertainment and have nothing to do with supply chain optimizations.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by paganel on Monday January 25, 2021 @06:25AM (#25901989)
It's more like a Gattaca-like dystopia.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by Forge36 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:10PM (#25898286)
Why not?
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by cgriswald on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:47PM (#25898478)
What is the purpose of a human life? If my phone is recommending a course of action that is “best practice” for my life, surely the answer to this philosophical and political question has been answered rather than just assumed by engineers based on the perception of current societal norms of a subset of the global population.

Imagine the power you’d have if you had people literally following orders based on a system of life that you’ve designed. And follow it they might if the perception of outcomes is positive.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by Out_of_Characte on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:20PM (#25898652)
The computer revolution is more subtle than that. Just look at chess history and play. the chess abilities of humans has vastly increased and you can thank computers for 95% of that. ELO rankings is a modern invention to play highly competitive games from literally any place in the world. Chess opening theory is no longer a human endeavour, want the best practice in the opening? Ask the computer. Puzzles are being auto-generated and ranked to improve your recognition at record pace. The internet and the computers that run this world have sped up almost every conceivable industry. Computers have led to the creation of new concepts entirely. If you want best practices for your life, google it. ( no, really) Asking a search engine to point you to the person to solve your problem is the feature creep this article is about.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by reificator on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:55PM (#25899385)
> Just look at chess history and play. the chess abilities of humans has vastly increased and you can thank computers for 95% of that. ELO rankings is a modern invention to play highly competitive games from literally any place in the world.

Elo rankings (not ELO) was first adopted in 1960, which while technically overlapping with computing's timeframe, the two are unrelated. Certainly Elo was not invented to play online chess or for the sake of computer-aided chess by any stretch.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by Out_of_Characte on Monday January 25, 2021 @02:10PM (#25907330)
Yeah bit of misphrasing. Point being is that fair rating systems and our computer's ability to keep track of everything has given rise to highly competitive games and very efficient progression.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by simonh on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:06PM (#25898578)
You just described China with it's Social Credit System, pervasive internet monitoring and central control of public discourse.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by patmorgan23 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:17PM (#25899044)
Social credit is different. Social credit imposes penalties for deviating from the norm or even associating with those who do. This is more like feeding apple health and google for data into IBM watson and getting personalized recommendations out.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by franklampard on Monday January 25, 2021 @03:48AM (#25900941)
For the most part, china’s Social Credit System is the same as the credit scores in U.S.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by simonh on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:08AM (#25901084)
That's how it started, but nowadays Credit Score type data is a tiny fraction of what goes into SCS. The SCS is affected by things like playing loud music, eating on public transport, traffic violations, not showing up to restaurant or hotel bookings, not sorting your domestic waste, and loads more. You can gain SCS by donating blood, volunteering, etc. It is widely believed social media posting heavily affects SCS, and there are many example of people's scores diving after they had posts blocked, but the authorities won't come clean about it.

As of mid 2019 26 million air tickets and over 4 million high speed rail tickets were refused based on SCS. Also some personal information is openly published about people with low SCS.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by postingawayonhn on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:43PM (#25898804)
> What is the purpose of a human life?

There isn't one. We're simply the result of a bunch of lucky events and evolutionary forces.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by mewpmewp2 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:59PM (#25899406)
We can create our own goal though. For instance maybe we want to maximize happiness. So this means we should attack the core root of the problem. Our chemicals. We either need to find a drug like heroin that does not have tolerance and withdrawal or find a way to reset chemicals after drugging yourself or thirdly we just must find a way to be able to easily alter this chemical state. Then we will have solved all suffering issues. Right now we are just trying to treat symptoms.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by virgilp on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:20AM (#25899573)
What if brains aren't wired like that, and you become numb? That sounds like an aweful goal to have. Maybe a better one is to minimize misery & unhappiness (ideally, global minimization, not local)
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by mewpmewp2 on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:43AM (#25899719)
Yeah I think what I proposed is an example of what an AI could come up with if it's given a goal of maximising human happiness and reducing misery.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by LocalH on Monday January 25, 2021 @10:42PM (#25912245)
This reeks of scientific hubris, to speak as if we know this to be fact.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by Forge36 on Sunday January 31, 2021 @05:45PM (#25983361)
One of my purposes is to keep living. To that end I exercise, get my heart rate elevated, try to eat better and brush my teeth. I also try (though less successfully and without much attempt) to limit my time watching TV.

I know some of my habits are awful (brushing teeth, exercise as of late, going on any walk outside) so I setup my phone to remind me every date at a specific time.

Can some of these be predetermined by an engineer? Yes! Can all of them? No.

Are not notifications intended by engineers to dictate a behavior? "To use my product" to what end various products are a means (Facebook, reddit, HN etc). I'd argue any product/system to which we join encourages us to follow it if we find it rewarding, regardless of positive outcomes (though surely the short term just look positive else what incentive exists to start?)

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by jamesrcole on Monday January 25, 2021 @04:07AM (#25901076)
I think the point is that a greater amount of more-granular and empirical data could provide the basis for learning more about "the human condition".
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by bregma on Monday January 25, 2021 @06:45AM (#25902108)
Ah, an experiment in the eugenics of human behaviour. One must be careful where one treads.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by sethc2 on Monday January 25, 2021 @02:11AM (#25900227)
I’ve seen that episode of Black Mirror (or it at least sounds like one)

Every technological advance is usually both good and bad. Some are more good, some are more bad. Sometimes we gain a lot by it, and only lose a little, other times what we gain is not worth what we lost.

The problem with this idea is what makes life valuable the machine would not know. “Life’s best practices” is subjective, and therefore the machine could promote what one considers a best practice that another considers a worst practice.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by entropic88 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:20PM (#25899075)
To me, MOOP = self reinforcing echo chamber.

The reverberations of the loudest (most magnified) permeate and shape ideology.

Hopefully the conductors get the frequency right for long term and long distance communication.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by malloryerik on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:19PM (#25897978)
Have you read Homo Deus by Yuval Harari? Mentioning him can sound a bit pseudo as he's become so popular and is such a popularizer of others' ideas, but I believe the main tenet of Homo Deus is his own and comes very much from thinking about what you're calling "massive open online psychology." His notion is that trusting our technology more than trusting our own feelings will be the death of humanism, because in his view humanism is at heart about trusting one's own individual feelings. The entire liberal can be seen as one aspect or outgrowth of humanism.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by devmunchies on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:25PM (#25898361)
I would say Martin Heidegger touched on that (trusting technology over intuition) before Harari in Being and Time (1927). Harari may have brought concepts into the mainstream but these concepts were being discussed in philosophy for over 100 years.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by AlexCoventry on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:50PM (#25898495)
I would say that Harari is probably a good deal more approachable than Heidegger. :)
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by mycall on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:38PM (#25898776)
You are basically describing augmented reality, where devices give you superhuman knowledge to give you advantage in life (know things before they happen). We will get there, but it will be a rocky road if it doesn't destroy us (e.g. China's social credit system). The implicit bias built into such systems is so hard to remove and is part of the Big Sort issue in society today.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by mewpmewp2 on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:01AM (#25899431)
Another question. If China is left free to implement such a device that can completely optimise their people, will they become more powerful than other countries by having wonderfully optimised people to do their bidding?
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by mycall on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @12:09AM (#25912794)
It is definitely possible. It is a better worker bee.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by username90 on Monday January 25, 2021 @03:08AM (#25900673)
The most popular food is fast food. That is the end game. The most popular computer programs will be distractions, we are already there, nothing much will change with respect to personal computing. Next step is a decent AI, before then things will continue to look like now. Or more realistically if food is anything to go by, we will just get more and more information fat just like we got physically fatter, so we aren't "there" yet, it is going to get worse.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by quanto on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:03AM (#25901470)
An interesting analogy with food. There are two assumptions I see in your analogy (1) Development of computer will parallel that of food. This is the raison d'etre of the analogy. (2) The food industry has matured and plateaued.

My personal takes:

For (1), I don't think it is self-evident. I see that the pleasure from the consumption of junk food and that from the mass media has some parallel, but tech has a far greater degree of freedom -- it's potential to truly transform human lives (for good and bad)

For (2), the food industry, although, by its nature, conservative, is going still going through evolution. Maybe fast food doesn't have to be junk food. Maybe nutritional balance can be achieved without compromising taste and cost.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by azeirah on Monday January 25, 2021 @09:13AM (#25903281)
In America.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by Aperocky on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:06PM (#25897903)
We're already there though..

I bought a action camera that is the size of a palm, with hardware 3D gimbal stabilization and can track faces and other objects. The video from which I can stream to my phone via bluetooth and it came to my doorstep 2 days after I ordered it online.

All of that involves computers of various size, sitting either in a miniature hardware in my hand or somewhere in a huge data center, and worked in tandem to provide an experience that is just mindblowing 20 years ago.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by lmilcin on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:20PM (#25897986)
That rather depends on your understanding of good life.

Was that camera somehow necessary for you to lead a good life or is it yet another distraction from it?

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by Aperocky on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:28PM (#25898706)
That is very subjective.

May I ask, what in a good life can not be classified as another distraction? Or are only human activities that someone from 1000 years ago can do pass the purity test?

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by II2II on Monday January 25, 2021 @08:38AM (#25902953)
Perhaps a good life can be defined in terms of a lack of distraction. That does not mean we should value activities from 1000 years ago more. For some it may mean quite the opposite since they are no longer distracted by the struggle to fulfill basic needs so pursuing the benefits of modernity is possible. For others, it may mean ignoring the distractions of modernity while seeking the purity of the past.

The problem with the current trajectory of technology is that it seeks to strip us of autonomy. We are usually presented with means of consumption, rather than courses of action. I suspect that is what people mean when they discuss distraction.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by Aperocky on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:20PM (#25909753)
What distraction means here is still unclear.

I for one would much rather fill my life with pleasant distractions, instead of a Spartan utopian lifestyle that some other people tries to sell me as 'good life'.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by simonh on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:10PM (#25898599)
Hundreds of millions of people are stuck at home due to lockdowns and the only practical way they have of doing their jobs, keeping in touch with loved one and accessing public services and information is through the Internet.

Is the Internet contributing to the good in their lives? A report recently that found children who play social online games and connect with friends online while locked down have better mental health than those that don't.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/nov/23/video-...

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by victordmor on Monday January 25, 2021 @07:39AM (#25902461)
I tend to disagree heavily with that. Social online games are fostering a toxic "win it or die" mentality that is making children anti-social physically and introvert. Bullying practices just got to the next level with games such as Fortnite, Free Fire, etc.

And the industry profits with that by applying psychological gimmicks in their games, the same ones applied by Vegas' casinos. The problem here is that they are applied on children that are unable to fully fathom the mid-long term consequences of their decisions and that keeps them playing and forgetting the external world. Their mental health is better until the day their parents take away their devices and send them to play outside. Suicide rates doubled over the years. Antidepressants use doubled over the years.

Social media by itself is not the problem. How big techs use them to profit (The Social Dilemma) is the problem.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by simonh on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:44PM (#25909976)
Online bullying does happen, for sure, and all those are concerns. But bullying and safety are an issue in any playground or arena in which kids hang out. This study is actual evidence of the positive overall effect on most kids. Do you have any counter evidence that shows the problems actually outweigh the benefits?
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by victordmor on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @08:51AM (#25915722)
The problems are shown only on mid-long term. We are seeing children more introvert and more "scared" of the external world. Children that will grow into adults that are not able to deal with unforeseen negative events.

I agree with you that this is an issue in any kids physical external activity. But the difference is that these activities are often supervised by an adult and in an event of a bullying the participants are removed and also often punished, and also the victim is helped and assisted. Note that I use the word "often" because I know that there are parents that encourage bullying behavior as ~self-defense~, which I also disagree heavily.

We don't have adults supervising every Fortnite lobby. Most children do not know how to use reporting tools to report improper behavior by another player. And while they suffer from bad words, psychological threats and such, they can't just turn off their devices, because the game always offer them a reward, a new skin, virtual coins, lootboxes, etc, so they keep playing, and therefore we have a loop.

Just yesterday I reported a player who cheated on FIFA, by exploiting a glitch that enabled him to play with a team full of superplayers and legends. The whole process took me almost 30 minutes. Sometimes I think that they don't want us to report bad behavior because the process itself is tiring.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by bergstromm466 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:19PM (#25899056)
You didn't talk about action sports cameras...
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by PurpleFoxy on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:11AM (#25899515)
I enjoy watching action can videos of mountain bike riding which shows me all these places around the world for free. They are purely a positive influence on my life and I don’t even own one
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by dokem on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:05AM (#25899468)
We wouldn't be living in the lock down hell hole in a pre internet world. The idea that children playing online games are better off than those that don't is disgusting. It's a relic of this sad excuse for a life we live now. All to help grandma and grandpa, average age 82, to squeeze out another year. Who would happily let go for their grand children. Reprehensible.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by simonh on Monday January 25, 2021 @03:56AM (#25900996)
My wife is a Nurse. It's also to help the millions of health care professionals in the world working gruelling hours and horrible working conditions on wards full of dying patients. The number of health care professionals that have suffered severe stress and trauma, a shocking number of them to the point of suicide, is a horrible bloody stain on the hands of the people not taking these precautions seriously and thus aiding the propagation of this virus. I'm pretty sure the thousands of people dying daily in the US and UK where I am, and millions who have died globally aren't all in their 80s.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by dokem on Monday January 25, 2021 @09:17PM (#25911657)
I also have an immediate family member who is a nurse, and unfortunately our anecdotal, second hand experience, seems disagree. Yes, that's not how statistics work, they are not all 82. Let's also remember that we live in an imperfect world and many, many more of younger age die every day. We are living in a dilution where we forget that everybody dies. A 10% increase is not a 10x increase. We can handle this without the security theater.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by ekianjo on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:54PM (#25898871)
> understanding of good life.

Waiting 1 month to have something delivered is hardly what I call a good life. Let's celebrate the improvements where we can.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by kreeben on Monday January 25, 2021 @06:59AM (#25902191)
What if humanity had solved all grand problems except for shipping. Would that not be a good life worth living? Everyone's happy and fulfilled, except for those who's happiness depend on swift Amazon deliveries which never seem to occur. Day after day they wait endlessly for a shipment of goods, becoming moodier and moodier while the rest of us dance in the streets in perfect joy.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by Aperocky on Monday January 25, 2021 @05:18PM (#25909734)
Except most of us won't dance in the streets in perfect joy, and probably won't ever see it in our lifetime or even in the entirety of humanity's existence.

In lieu of that, I prefer my shipping delivered in 2 days vs. a month.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by GuB-42 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:49PM (#25898490)
Ok, let's take another example.

The leading COVID-19 vaccine involves a lot of computers. From the production of the mRNA strands to the setup of the supply chains to communications between scientists.

And there are few things that we need more than an effective COVID-19 vaccine in order to lead a good life right now.

The computerized chain that got GP his camera is similar the the one that is used in the making of the vaccine.

GP's camera is just icing on the cake.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by morlockabove on Monday January 25, 2021 @08:11AM (#25902722)
Would covid have been made in the wuhan lab without computers?
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by icelancer on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:33PM (#25898388)
What is life?
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by kmstout on Monday January 25, 2021 @08:58AM (#25903125)
David Ackley, an artificial life researcher working on "robust-first computing," has this gem buried in one of his videos: "Life is nature's way of preserving meat."
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by wruza on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:24PM (#25899097)
Is “stealing focus and invigilation” really a problem that computers themselves bring to us? It is like blaming the road for billboards around it. Just find those who install these boards and slap them to their senses.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by Cthulhu_ on Monday January 25, 2021 @07:51AM (#25902554)
I mean yeah, most computer work is voluntary. Facebook is exploitative, but most people choose to go on Facebook and let it happen. They can choose to only occasionally get on there and look up events and happenings, but for a lot of people it's not just that but a time waster, and as it goes from thoughtful / intentful activity, people become less critical of what they're seeing.

I mean I'm guilty of that, I frequently browse reddit mindlessly. At least I'm saved the obvious ads - for now anyway, I'm sure they'll crack down on 3rd party clients soon.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by userbinator on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:48PM (#25898150)
As long as corporate greed continues unhindered, computers will remain a way of controlling and monetising the population.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by d_tr on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:29PM (#25899136)
Complementarily, I would say that because of corporate greed (or corporate behavior / politics more generally), it will be a long time before we can use computers built on the principles Alan Kay outlined in his talk.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by CryptoPunk on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:43PM (#25898454)
Greed motivates corporations to try to provide people with what they demand. It can be channeled for good if consumers inform themselves about what products/services better their lives and actively choose them in the market.

The growth of the health food market - or at least some subcategories of it which are genuinely healthy - would be an example of this happening.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by TeMPOraL on Monday January 25, 2021 @07:02AM (#25902218)
> It can be channeled for good if consumers inform themselves about what products/services better their lives and actively choose them in the market.

...assuming they're given a meaningful choice in the first place. Consumers choose from what's available on the market, not from some abstract space of possible products. Not only is technology too complicated for the mainstream audience (and products on the market do their best to make everything seem like "magic" that cannot be understood casually by non-specialists), the market doesn't really listen to user feedback anyway, preferring to divine everything from telemetry.

Greed, in general, motivates corporations to make money. Sometimes, providing people with what they demand is the easiest way to profit. Oftentimes, there are better ways. Like investing in marketing to make people demand what you want to provide them. Or scam them through convoluted business models.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by zepto on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:20PM (#25898653)
n be channeled for good “if consumers inform themselves about what products/services better their lives and actively choose them in the market.“

Very true. However it’s easier for motivated corporations to steer people away from such information.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by CryptoPunk on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:33PM (#25898740)
That's why we need public resources expended on producing useful and true information and making it available for public consumption.

This can be done through both state-backed initiatives and non-governmental ones like Wikipedia, or speculatively, a public interest DAO that crowdfunds R&D. Gitcoin may be the first iterations of the latter.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by d_tr on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:31PM (#25899158)
This is very true, but the "if" is a big one...
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by CryptoPunk on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:57PM (#25899397)
I think the products/services the market provides mostly enhance our lives. Society works better than than our cynicism would imply, and when you zoom out over a span of a couple centuries, or even 40 years, that becomes apparent.

Of course there are many cases where the consumer is underinformed, and harmed by what the market urges them to buy, and these need to be addressed.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by zelphirkalt on Monday January 25, 2021 @07:10AM (#25902258)
On the other hand, we are potentially now closer to our doom than ever before. If we look at all the things, that _in the short term_ improve our lives, but _in the long run_ might seriously impact future generations, then I am no longer so sure about that statement. Zooming out is fine, but not only looking at the past, but also what the future seems to hold, is a worthy perspective to take sometimes.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by d_tr on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:21AM (#25899578)
Certainly! It was these cases I had in mind. Maybe I should have made it clear.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by ankurdhama on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:54PM (#25898869)
> Hopefully, instead of being tools of stealing our focus and invigilation some day we will collectively figure out how to use computers so that we can live better lives.

This is just a specific narrow view of computers and how they are used by people in day to day life. The larger picture is that computers have impacted every single industry/domain and that impact have indirectly made lives better in some aspect.

In the end, computers are just tools, tools to automate tasks. What task humans want to automate depends on their needs/desires and so does the consequences of them.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by cookiengineer on Monday January 25, 2021 @07:30AM (#25902391)
My personal belief is that single computers themselves are worthless. Their connectivity and the possibility to exchange knowledge and experiences is what makes them so much more efficient than humans (at least in those tasks we automated already) - or when used as an interface - so efficient as an information management tool.

In order to reach a superintelligence level we need to solve the automation of gathering, evaluation and improvement of knowledge first.

And by automation, I don't mean wikis or something you can find via google. Wikis and the web currently are built for humans, not machines. If we are able to automate the semantic knowledge behind it and transfer it to neural networks, we will have limitless capabilities.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by theamk on Sunday January 24, 2021 @10:14PM (#25898610)
Some people already did - it is not that hard, really.

As a kid, I spent countless hours in the underground trains staring out of the window into the moving darkness. Today, if I am on the train, I read interesting stories I like.

As an another example, apparently area about my birth town had all sorts of unique and interesting places to hike. I had no idea that those places even existed before internet - blogs and forums.

And the more unusual hobbies (think aluminum casting for example) - did you know how had was it to find good information before internet?

Please do not equate internet to facebook and twitter. It is so much more than that - you just have to invest a bit of effort instead of blaming it.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by bcrosby95 on Monday January 25, 2021 @01:52AM (#25900124)
> We are just starting to learn what computers are for.

This seems a bit like saying that we're just starting to learn what engines are for. What we use computers for will continue to evolve and we will never arrive at an end state.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by higerordermap on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:21AM (#25899581)
Computer/Smartphone being addictive and time-wasting in personal level doesn't negate the value they created due to automation. That's a revolution too, even if most of value is harvested by the industrial upper class.

If people realized the value computing can give, consumer electronics will be useful for them. But they want instagram and snapchat instead.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by CryptoPunk on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:31AM (#25899651)
>>That's a revolution too, even if most of value is harvested by the industrial upper class.

A significant portion of the value created is not captured by economic statistics, as they mostly deal with measuring economic resources that are scarce enough to have market prices.

Abundant goods are free like air, and are widely distributed, and automation has made many classes of goods/services fall into this category, like many types of information (compare trying to find your way around a city 20 years ago, to today using Google Maps, or trying to read up on some obscure subject 30 years ago by visiting a library, versus finding the Wikipedia page on it via a 3 second Google search on your phone).

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by nathias on Monday January 25, 2021 @02:46AM (#25900501)
In the attention industry content is created to package attention and formalize it enough to be a commodity that can be sold to advertisers. The whole very much depends on this model of production, and if we don't find a good substitute this will continue ...
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by hackerbrother on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:45PM (#25898468)
I guess the way I see it, computers have already changed every aspect of life.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by vishnugupta on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:56AM (#25899807)
This. The last decade saw a massive adoption of computers of all shapes and sizes in India. In the decade before that (2000 - 2010) computers were limited within labs, and offices. But smart phone changed all that. From booking train tickets to access medical health check reports to paying push-cart vendors through mobile wallet, consumers are now using computers in all sorts of ways.

As you rightly said, I just can't think of a domain that's untouched by computers.

Even in the fundamental science it's now impossible to do anything without massive data crunching machines. LIGO detection of gravitational waves, the first black hole images, and the plummeting cost reduction of full DNA over last two decades are a great example of how computers have irreversibly changed the way science is done.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by irjustin on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:19PM (#25897975)
Agreed on the "starting to learn what computers are for", but I'd say it's happened. It's just not the way we wanted it to ideally manifest as a species.

We want to believe that the revolution should be altruistic in nature. Bettering the human race through only "positive" methods - Star Trek style utopia if you will.

But reality shows that even with all this available computing power, it's still a finite resource. Any finite resource is capitalistic in nature and will be subject to the aggressive expansionist.

It needs its checks and balances like other resources.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by sovande on Monday January 25, 2021 @10:45AM (#25904481)
Of course it has. Your smartphone is the manifestation. It replaces at least 40 functions and makes your life better. If you choose to use mostly the bad parts, that is on you. It’s like complaining about your car making your life worse, but you only drive in reverse and bump into things
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by lmilcin on Monday January 25, 2021 @10:59AM (#25904674)
How does it make a life better. Have you made the determination yourself? At least a significant number of people I know personally say otherwise and stick to dumb phones. They are well paid and it doesn't seem they are doing this to save money. So I don't think what you say is objective truth as you try to portray it.

If I leave out the bad parts then the rest is mostly what I need to use because of external demands or because of technology itself (ie. problems that only exist due to technology itself)

I don't need to be available on communicator. My team and my family expects me to be or I am marked as unhelpful. That wasn't a problem when there wasn't expectation to be constantly available.

I don't need to have Uber installed, but it seems to be the only way to get a cab where I live.

I don't need navigation, but roads and intersections got so complicated and I got so reliant that I would not be able to reach my destination without it.

Etc.

Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by psyc on Sunday January 24, 2021 @08:23PM (#25898003)
I’ll consider it a revolution when user friendliness and low-config are the default.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by PurpleFoxy on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:13AM (#25899530)
I guess we are already there then. My grandma has no problems operating an iPad while a laptop is largely too complicated.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by holoduke on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:11PM (#25898997)
A sudden revolution is unlikely anyway. It's more some sort of a gradual process.
Re:The computer revolution hasn’t happened yet (1997) by tim333 on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:57PM (#25906369)
The real revolution will be AGI. Dunno how that'll play out.