News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by jjoonathan on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:03PM (#25835572)
I can already hear the cries of censorship. "What do you mean crimes aren't protected speech?"
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by chmod600 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:24PM (#25835889)
There is reason to worry when the tools of defiance or rebellion are taken away. Rebellion is bad, but maitaining some remote possibility is good.

This case isn't really so bad because there's no prior restraint, no tools being taken away, or new tools for the government.

There is still concern that charges could be heaped on someone to the point they feel the need to plea bargain for something that is either a very minor offense or protected speech.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by vaduz on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:24PM (#25836726)
> Rebellion is bad, but maitaining some remote possibility is good.

There is that little affair from 1765 to 1783 that gets generally good press, though. "Context is for kings" is tinged with irony on that one.

> This case isn't really so bad because there's no prior restraint, no tools being taken away, or new tools for the government.

Jokes aside, any sentence which contains "no tools being taken away" around messages such as this one are is assuming too much about the future - it is entirely within the power of both executive (FCC) and legislative (Congress) to curtail the use of specific tools, including radios. It shows that someone in the agency has thought that this particular case warrants making a public statement, which is an escalation.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by freeone3000 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:46PM (#25837011)
>There is that little affair from 1765 to 1783 that gets generally good press, though

Gets good press, but, compared to the Commonwealth countries, it's not clear it was really necessary or beneficial.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by cmelbye on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @07:28PM (#25841009)
Are you talking about a territory like Bermuda, or the independent Commonwealth countries that were inspired by the Revolutionary War?
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by vkou on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @05:02AM (#25844567)
He probably means Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.

When you say countries inspired by the revolutionary war, you probably don't mean "North Vietnam."

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by generalizations on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:52PM (#25836333)
> Rebellion is bad

Not always. Not saying it is here, but I think it depends on the context. Arab Spring, for instance.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by hnuser847 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @02:21PM (#25837567)
What's interesting to note is that the Arab Spring was largely organized on social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter. US media outlets were thrilled about this, and wrote article after article talking about how these platforms gave the common man the opportunity to vent about police brutality, corruption, election fraud, and unemployment in a way that simply wasn't possible previously. The general attitude at the time was that social media platforms, and the free speech they enabled, would be a force for good in the world, despite the Arab Spring involving a fair amount of violence and ultimately leading the upheaval of several countries.

Fast forward a decade later, and now the attitude is the complete opposite.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by xenadu02 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:57PM (#25840696)
A "riot" to eject a dictator vs a "riot" to stop Congress from certifying the winner of the election/install Trump as dictator are - to my eyes - entirely different in character.

People do what it takes to survive. Trump usurping power and ending 230 years of US democracy represents an existential threat. Don't be shocked that a lot of people and companies are not on-board with that idea and are willing to take extreme measures to prevent it.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by stretchcat on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @07:25PM (#25840971)
When the dictator operates a secular government and the alternative is an ochlocratic theocracy, I don't think the morality of the situation is so clear cut.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by xenadu02 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @08:33PM (#25841501)
I didn't mean to imply the result is always ideal or even good. That's one of the dangers of revolutions and suppression of dissent.

I'm saying there is no reason to be surprised when you're asking platforms to ignore Trump's attempt to end democracy and they decline.

To give a hypothetical: if Trump's followers were harassing Matt Prince's family every day at home, work, and school there wouldn't be any hand-wringing about "free speech" or "censorship" from Cloudflare. Anyone related to Trump would find themselves banned in short order. That would be purely a move of self-preservation.

Similarly a lot of platforms (and donors) realize these people are no longer useful idiots but deluded to the point of ransacking the house of Congress in an attempt to overturn the election. That's really dangerous and could destabilize the country and even the world. When faced with an existential threat don't be shocked when people are unwilling to sit down and debate on behalf of MAGAs/Fox News acting in bad faith.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by scythe on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @09:56AM (#25847107)
Another parallel: the Arab Spring revolts were hijacked by Islamists everywhere but Tunisia, and whatever legitimate complaints ("anti-hyperglobalization"?) galvanized the Trump movement in its early days were ultimately drowned out by the much louder voices of white nationalists (QAnon/PB) and apocalypse-seekers[1] who wanted to use the movement to gain power.

1: https://newrepublic.com/article/160922/capitol-riot-revealed...

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by BurningFrog on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @09:35PM (#25841944)
Not that we know how things played out, the Arab Spring was an enormous disaster.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by chmod600 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:03PM (#25836474)
The Arab Spring had mixed results, at best.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by generalizations on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:44PM (#25836978)
Just means it partly succeeded, not that the rebellion was a moral failure.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by umvi on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:21PM (#25836679)
> Rebellion is bad

1776?

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by generalizations on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:31PM (#25835985)
I don't necessarily disagree with you, but I think you've got that backwards: freedom of speech is a right, that a government ought to recognize. "Protected speech" makes it sound like the only speech we're allowed is what is specifically allocated to us.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by Blikkentrekker on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:24PM (#25836728)
Which is the reality.

“Freedom of speech”, much like “freedom of religion”, is an empty statement. — no man wants true freedom in either, so one is only free so long as it not thread over the bounds of the law, and it can thus be surmised as “One has the right to commit legal actions.”.

It's entirely different from such matters as “right to a criminal defence attorney when charged with a crime”, which many do feel should be absolute, and that all other laws must bend and give way to accommodate it.

One already has the freedom to do whatever one wish, so long as it not thread over the bounds of the law.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by generalizations on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:40PM (#25836922)
> no man wants...many do feel

Are you appealing to the desires of the crowd (bandwagon fallacy), or to a moral principle? I'm talking about moral principles, which the laws and the government ought to uphold.

If they don't, the law and/or government is in the wrong. The right to speak your mind is a moral right; arguably, the right to defend yourself with an attourney is a subset of this. The law is not the arbiter of what is right, or what rights humans possess "inalienably". The law only enforces and protects those rights (since it's inefficient for each person to defend their own rights against everyone else: "I will have my attourney at my trial, I challenge you to duel if you disagree").

If freedom of speech is impinged, then a human right has been trampled upon. If a private individual forces someone else to be silent, they are morally in the wrong, even though there's no law against it. If the US government did it, then the US acted against its constitution and broke a moral principle, if not the laws on the books.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by Blikkentrekker on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @02:15PM (#25837481)
Do you believe it should be legal to make death threats, print libel and slander that harm a man's reputation, spread around pictures taken of others in the shower without their consent, and publish stolen personal information?

If not, then you do not believe in absolute freedom of speech, but only freedom of speech within the confines of the law.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by generalizations on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @02:28PM (#25837675)
> If not, then you do not believe in absolute freedom of speech, but only freedom of speech within the confines of the law.

It's a cute 'gotcha', but you're not actually saying anything that relates to what I said. I said 'moral principle', not 'absolute', and you continue to refer to 'the law'. You're not distinguishing between the laws the government decides upon, and the moral principles we use to evaluate good laws and bad ones.

From the outset, I said that there is a difference between saying that freedom of speech is something the government allocates to us, and something which the government ought to allow. Do you think the government gets to decide what we are, and are not, allowed to say?

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by Blikkentrekker on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @03:21PM (#25838356)
I don't believe in morality; it's an indefinable and unfalsifiable concept

I simply said that the claim of believing in “freedom of speech, except where one not” is an empty, useless, and trivial statement.

Everyone believes in “freedom of speech, except where he draw the line”.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by generalizations on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @03:54PM (#25838753)
Where freedom of speech falls in the hierarchy of rights is not my concern. What is my concern, is who gets to choose what that hierarchy is and where freedom of speech exists on it.

I'm arguing that the government is not who gets to determine what that hierarchy is, and thereby determine what gets to superceed freedom of speech.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:43PM (#25840550)
very well, who gets to determine that hierarchy and how will they enforce their determinations?
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by generalizations on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @07:25PM (#25840982)
Not the government. And why should anyone inflict their view of morality on anyone else?

I really don't want anyone - liberal, conservative, Christian or radical Islam - enforcing their determiniation of moral hierarchy on me. Do you?

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by claudiawerner on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @08:54PM (#25841651)
> Not the government. And why should anyone inflict their view of morality on anyone else?

To be clear, are you taking the position of the anarchist here? I mean no disrespect, I only wish to understand your position. I think most people would say, with various exemplars, that the government can legitimately have a blacklist maintained over certain speech, very much in the same way it can have one over certain actions.

This is not an appeal to popularity, it is a statement of the non-anarchist position. You may think it is invalid, but by the same token, I think that consistently you'd have to see laws against murder or child rape to be invalid.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by generalizations on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @10:04PM (#25842138)
Not anarchist. There's another way, as I see it. If you put a liberal, a conservative, a Christian, a follower of radical Islam, an atheist, a Buddhist and a paganist on a desert island together, they could find a way to work things out, and not step on each others toes.

Each does whatever they like, so long as they do no harm to anyone else. Where the least common ground exists, interactions are polite and restrained (to the mathematical extreme of minimizing any information transfer at all, if zero common ground exists); where greater common ground exists, speech and action can be more unrestrained.

If harm is done, then the harm itself is the issue. Hyperbolic example, to make it super clear: it's perfectly fine to shout 'fire' in a crowded building; however, if you cause harm you're on the hook. Not because you shouted "fire", but because you (one way or another, the means is irrelevant) caused people to be trampled.

The difference between that and the similiar position stated earlier is small, but I think there's a bright line: whether the speech is restricted, or the doing of harm is restricted. It's a trivial difference at face value, but the logical derivations are very different.

If one of the desert island castaways attempts to do harm to another, the rest of them might naturally band together to prevent and reconcile it. That's where I see government involved: the banding together, to prevent and reconcile harm done.

In that way, morality is untouched. No one inflicts their views on anyone else. Total ignorance of all moral hierarchies is preserved. Government says nothing about what may or may not be said. The only view inflicted on anyone is the minimum precept, 'do no harm to others'.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @04:26AM (#25844350)
ok well when you say X does not get to determine Y it implies that there is someone who gets to determine Y. I had difficulty imagining anyone who should be allowed to determine Y in this case, unless it was some theological concept, so I wanted some clarification of your position.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by jejkfmgmgk on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @08:07PM (#25841305)
> it can thus be surmised as “One has the right to commit legal actions.”.

The whole point of the constitution is to put a limit on the law. The government cannot pass a law forbidding a certain kind of speech as it would be unconstitutional.

> One already has the freedom to do whatever one wish, so long as it not thread over the bounds of the law.

You have it backwards. The law can dictate whatever it wants so long as it does not thread over the bounds of the constitution.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by damnyou on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:34PM (#25836018)
There were times when being in an intimate relationship with someone of the same gender was a crime, and a lot of sex work is still criminalized, so I'm actually quite bothered by (particularly) the prohibition against using encryption. Obviously I have no sympathy for white nationalists, but "crimes" in general tends to cover both things that are bad and things that aren't.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by chociej on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:40PM (#25836130)
Concealing the meaning of transmissions is contrary to the purposes of the amateur radio service. There are perfectly serviceable radio bands, modes, and services for those wanting to transmit encoded messages, just like there are for those wanting to broadcast, transmit music, engage in commerce, etc.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by damnyou on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:41PM (#25836148)
Personally I think private individuals should have a fundamental right to encryption regardless of the medium.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by remexre on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:02PM (#25836455)
I think the goal is mainly to avoid people doing things that aren't useful to the amateur radio community on the fixed amount of spectrum made available by physics. (Well, and some Cold-War-era paranoia about foreign spies, but...)
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by irscott on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @07:48PM (#25841174)
The idea is that the amateur bands are a commons of sorts for everyone to use and enjoy. As somebody else said you're perfectly welcome to transmit encoded messages on nets designed for that.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by avmich on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:07PM (#25835632)
I think more interesting is how to decide in advance if a particular use is use in crime. Before a judge will decide there is a crime.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by chaorace on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:23PM (#25835869)
I think it's a bit like felony murder. Nobody wants you committing felonies, but, if you do commit a felony, you're incentivized to avoid causing potentially deadly situations. (setting aside the actual efficacy of such incentives, that's just how the law currently is)

To put it another way, you probably won't be charged just for selling drugs over a radio frequency. You'll be charged for the regular crime of selling drugs and an additional charge of using radio to commit that crime.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by WJW on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:08PM (#25835653)
Step 1: Look at some law books. If it's in there, then it's definitely a crime.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by Supermancho on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:17PM (#25835782)
> Step 1: Look at some law books. If it's in there, then it's definitely a crime.

Until you go to a US court, you probably think it's that simple. This is very wrong.

There are plenty of US laws that are so broad (or narrow) that nothing or everything fits or are so badly written as to be ineffectual. There are also silly laws in place, which are not enforced. The act is likely going to be adjudicated based on current prevailing influence holders, of the time and area. This is why moving jurisdiction is typically the simplest way to indemnify a defendant.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by damnyou on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:40PM (#25836131)
That is very definitely not how common law systems work. Common law systems rely very heavily on past precedent and case law, not merely the words in a statute.

Take the levels of scrutiny applied to laws and regulations in equal protection lawsuits, for example. Why is judicial review for racial discrimination covered under strict scrutiny, but sex discrimination only covered under intermediate scrutiny? There's no statute prescribing this—American courts invented it.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by dschuler on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:17PM (#25835781)
I think avmich is getting at the idea that some actions may or may not be legal until determined to be a crime, at which point there would be two: the original crime, and using radio to facilitate it.

This reminds me of a question on the US immigration card for non-citizens - it asks if the traveler intends to rob a bank. If you want to be let in, you have to check "no" of course, but anyone who then robs a bank while on vacay will face an additional perjury charge.

I'm not sure if this accomplishes anything other than the usual "tough on crime" stuff.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by vaduz on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:12PM (#25836577)
The goal of similar questions (also, my favourites: have you ever been training child soldiers, or have you been involved in a violent overthrow of a legal government) is to make any discrepancy a separate immigration offense - making it a jurisdiction of Immigration Court, with expedited process whilst you have limited rights and deportation at the end.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by dschuler on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @04:08PM (#25838919)
> making it a jurisdiction of Immigration Court, with expedited process whilst you have limited rights and deportation at the end

Aah got it, that makes sense now. So it's not just political posturing for the extra-tough- on crime stuff.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by fredophile on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:37PM (#25836062)
My understanding is that the purpose of those types of questions is to make it easy to deport you for lying on the immigration paperwork.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by avmich on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:14PM (#25836591)
And some immigration lawyers can perhaps successfully argue that it was due to sincere change of heart - no intent at the time of answering the question. /s
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by fredophile on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @05:21AM (#25844670)
I've been through the immigration process to get a green card. The questions I remember answering are all about your past and not so much about what you intend to do in the future.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by nickff on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:14PM (#25835737)
Do you have any idea how many laws there are? In addition to that, regulations aren’t neat and tidy or organized, yet they carry the force of law.