News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by WJW on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:08PM (#25835653)
Step 1: Look at some law books. If it's in there, then it's definitely a crime.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by Supermancho on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:17PM (#25835782)
> Step 1: Look at some law books. If it's in there, then it's definitely a crime.

Until you go to a US court, you probably think it's that simple. This is very wrong.

There are plenty of US laws that are so broad (or narrow) that nothing or everything fits or are so badly written as to be ineffectual. There are also silly laws in place, which are not enforced. The act is likely going to be adjudicated based on current prevailing influence holders, of the time and area. This is why moving jurisdiction is typically the simplest way to indemnify a defendant.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by damnyou on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:40PM (#25836131)
That is very definitely not how common law systems work. Common law systems rely very heavily on past precedent and case law, not merely the words in a statute.

Take the levels of scrutiny applied to laws and regulations in equal protection lawsuits, for example. Why is judicial review for racial discrimination covered under strict scrutiny, but sex discrimination only covered under intermediate scrutiny? There's no statute prescribing this—American courts invented it.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by dschuler on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:17PM (#25835781)
I think avmich is getting at the idea that some actions may or may not be legal until determined to be a crime, at which point there would be two: the original crime, and using radio to facilitate it.

This reminds me of a question on the US immigration card for non-citizens - it asks if the traveler intends to rob a bank. If you want to be let in, you have to check "no" of course, but anyone who then robs a bank while on vacay will face an additional perjury charge.

I'm not sure if this accomplishes anything other than the usual "tough on crime" stuff.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by vaduz on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:12PM (#25836577)
The goal of similar questions (also, my favourites: have you ever been training child soldiers, or have you been involved in a violent overthrow of a legal government) is to make any discrepancy a separate immigration offense - making it a jurisdiction of Immigration Court, with expedited process whilst you have limited rights and deportation at the end.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by dschuler on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @04:08PM (#25838919)
> making it a jurisdiction of Immigration Court, with expedited process whilst you have limited rights and deportation at the end

Aah got it, that makes sense now. So it's not just political posturing for the extra-tough- on crime stuff.

Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by fredophile on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:37PM (#25836062)
My understanding is that the purpose of those types of questions is to make it easy to deport you for lying on the immigration paperwork.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by avmich on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:14PM (#25836591)
And some immigration lawyers can perhaps successfully argue that it was due to sincere change of heart - no intent at the time of answering the question. /s
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by fredophile on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @05:21AM (#25844670)
I've been through the immigration process to get a green card. The questions I remember answering are all about your past and not so much about what you intend to do in the future.
Re:Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes by nickff on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:14PM (#25835737)
Do you have any idea how many laws there are? In addition to that, regulations aren’t neat and tidy or organized, yet they carry the force of law.