News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by oli5679 on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:08PM (#25797192)
The founder of Whatsapp

(1) claims that Facebook promised Whatsapp would not be monetised, and that Facebook and and Whatsapp's data would not be combined. This information was also provided to European antitrust regulators

(2) missed out on $850 stock option grants vesting by quitting early over disputes with Facebook about monetisation strategy involving advertising

(3) promoted #deletefacebook on Whatsapp following the Cambridge Anlalytica scandal

(4) Donated $50m to the non-for-profit alternative, Signal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Acton

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by fastball on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:15PM (#25797269)
Technically it's not a donation, it's a 0% interest loan that doesn't need to be repaid until 2068. And $50M was the initial amount, but it's up to ~$100M now.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signal_Foundation

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by Niten on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:15PM (#25797875)
This is a tangent, but what's the financial rationale for setting up this kind of an arrangement instead of a donation?
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by OJFord on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:55PM (#25798283)
To whom? To the 'donor' (as it were) it's probably (jurisdiction varies, IANA tax advisor, etc.) a decent inheritance tax avoidance (obligatory 'as opposed to evasion') - helps out a cause he believes in, while leaving the capital (hopefully/in theory) for his inheritants.

To the recipient.. I don't know why you'd prefer it to a (stipulation-free) donation, but in general it's probably easier to get big loans than big donations.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by sammax on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:37PM (#25798630)
Since it's 0% interest you could probably make enough profit by investing it in the stock market instead that you could pay inheritance tax and still get more than the initial amount out of it after 50 years. So I would not call this a tax avoidance scheme, it seems more like "help this cause I care about and if it becomes successful enough to be able to pay my children back then that's great".
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by OJFord on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:45PM (#25798705)
Oh absolutely, but we're comparing donations and loans to the same cause, not arbitrary 0% loans and more efficient/profitable 'schemes' right?
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by idrios on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:06PM (#25799238)
I think it actually is more helpful to the business to get a loan instead of a donation. With a huge donation you can do whatever you want with it and may overinvest or spend wastefully, until the cash reserves run out. A loan means that the business has X-many years to be self-sufficient. So I think it helps the business's culture as it's developing.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by crusty on Saturday January 16, 2021 @07:37PM (#25806964)
This is like the awful paternalistic version of my thought. Ha. My guess is that there's a implied agreement, "keep to your promises about how Signal will be run and developed and eventually the loan will be forgiven altogether; try to burn me on those promises, like Zuck did, and that'll be a $100 million gamble." And sure, with inflation, the longer they're around, the less daunting the figure will be, but that may be the point, or the loan could be refreshed with more money that just keeps the prospect of repayment a perpetually serious prospect (it was doubled once already).
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by idrios on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:20PM (#25807771)
Oh, I like that explanation better actually. They very well may have an agreement like that where he'll forgive the loan as long as he's still happy with how they're running it
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by sathishmanohar on Saturday January 16, 2021 @01:40AM (#25800582)
> while leaving the capital (hopefully/in theory) for his inheritants.

With inflation $100M will probably buy an ice pop in 50 years.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by joshxyz on Saturday January 16, 2021 @01:04AM (#25800455)
Sir that's a 300 IQ move, admirable.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by jee1shi on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:06PM (#25798377)
In the event of a sale, the loan remains and will either be paid out or carried on to the new owner.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by marricks on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:44PM (#25799506)
This is an extremely good point. So many small idealistic companies are bought out, with the "baggage" of a big loan anyone who did want to buy out Signal for profit would have to now pay 100 million dollars.

If I had oodles of money I'd probably do this, "I'm just giving you this money now, but if you got bought up by someone without those same ideals they need to pay up.”

Given it’s the former WhatsApp CEO even more reason to be skeptical.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by 3np on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:04PM (#25799917)
Why the skepticism? Sounds great to me.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by andreareina on Saturday January 16, 2021 @02:17AM (#25800709)
I'm reading it as, "Given it’s the former WhatsApp CEO [who's already been burned once, they have] even more reason to be skeptical [of acquirers holding to the values of the acquired]".
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by 3np on Saturday January 16, 2021 @02:18AM (#25800713)
Ah yeah, that makes sense!
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by marricks on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:31AM (#25802802)
Yep that was the correct interpretation! CEO being reasonable.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by graiz on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:19PM (#25797938)
Loans get paid back... donations don't. An organization that takes donations (like wikipedia) will have to keep asking for donations... while an organization that has a debt can take the time to figure out a revenue model not driven by ads to allow them to repay the debt.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by crusty on Saturday January 16, 2021 @07:47PM (#25807022)
Wikipedia's average donation is tiny. That's why they keep asking. The way you've written this it suggests that if instead of giving wikipedia a $2 donation, we have them $2 no-interest loans, weed be helping them prepare for the future and they wouldn't have to ask for more donations (or loans) from us. That's not how it works.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by markdown on Saturday January 16, 2021 @03:24AM (#25800932)
We went on this tangent yesterday in this very same discussion. HN needs better search.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by ant6n on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:10PM (#25797823)
Sounds like mostly a donation to me. In 70 years, assuming 2% inflation, inflation will have reduced the value of the debt by 70%.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by latexr on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:08PM (#25799256)
> In 70 years

2068 is in 47 years. A long way away, yes, but still a big difference.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by mancerayder on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:32PM (#25798082)
"In January 2009, Koum bought an iPhone and realized that the then seven-month-old App Store was about to spawn a whole new industry of apps. He visited his friend Alex Fishman and talked about developing an app.[11] Koum almost immediately chose the name WhatsApp because it sounded like "what's up", and a week later on his birthday, Feb. 24, 2009, he incorporated WhatsApp Inc. in California."

..

"In 2014, Koum and Brian Acton agreed to sell WhatsApp to Facebook for approximately US$19 billion in cash and stock.[9] Forbes estimates that Acton held over 20% stake in the company, making his net worth around $3.8 billion.[12] According to Acton's personal Twitter feed, he was turned down for employment by both Twitter and Facebook in 2009."

3.8B in 5 years of work? It's scarcely conceivable to me after 20 years of salaried grind. These people are well-connected (fine), but they're also geniuses at spotting opportunities.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by jeffnappi on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:09PM (#25799265)
Geniuses, maybe, but also exceedingly lucky - right place, right time, right idea, right connections etc :)
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by brutus1213 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @12:35AM (#25800331)
The tech behind whatsapp was pretty cool IIRC .. that's how I got interested in Erlang/Beam. These people were not your average CS grad or even your average googler.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by patrickaljord on Saturday January 16, 2021 @12:48AM (#25800386)
WhatsApp could have been coded in any language. The first version was a very simple app but it promised free SMS alternative with some great marketing campaign. Still amazing how they managed to grow the user base using this marketing when there were tons of apps doing the same thing.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by brutus1213 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:37PM (#25807565)
I don't believe the backend would be as scalable (with the same amount of ease) on JVM (Akka) or straight C/C++. Erlang, Beam bring a lot of value to the table for this specific application:

http://www.erlang-factory.com/upload/presentations/558/efsf2...

Also, I got interested in Elixir/Phoenix after I learned about what WhatsApp accomplished.

I'm a bit surprised people are downvoting a technical point on HN but whatever.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by drevil-v2 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @04:16AM (#25801126)
Where can I read more about this?
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by brutus1213 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:34PM (#25807544)
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by jeffnappi on Saturday January 16, 2021 @08:28PM (#25807209)
The brilliance wasn't in building the core software but rather leveraging the right technology for scalable low cost messaging. WhatsApp's core messaging infrastructure is built on top of a modified version of the open source project Ejabberd. The technology heavy lifting has largely been done by Erlang and Ejabberd. In my opinion WhatsApp was brilliant to leverage those existing systems - but it wasn't the computer science skills that made them successful.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by brutus1213 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:40PM (#25807580)
I thought they did some fine tuning to the BEAM VM to get an extreme amount of scale. I didn't know people had Ejabberd deployments at such high scale (2 million+ concurrent connections per server) in that time period. I never got into details of scaling XMPP so you might be right.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by jojobas on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:11PM (#25799665)
Plenty of people sink years and life savings into opportunities that never take off. It's like saying that roulette winners are geniuses at sensing red.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by mancerayder on Sunday January 17, 2021 @11:53AM (#25812255)
So the takeaway from your statement is that entrepreneurial success is akin to playing Roulette? That's awfully cynical, enough to put off even trying.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by tinyhouse on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:45PM (#25797553)
He seems like an amazing guy and that we need more people like him in tech, esp in leadership positions. However, I'm not sure why he was so against monetization. If whatsapp was still an independent company, they would have to monetize somehow. Why cannot FB monetize? As a user of whatsapp I wouldn't even care if the showed ads in big group chats. As long as there would be zero tracking or leaking of data and ads would be solely based on location and maybe chat info.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by pmlnr on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:53PM (#25797619)
> If whatsapp was still an independent company, they would have to monetize somehow.

No, they wouldn't. This thinking is what has lead the world where it is.

Say you have 2 billion (10^9) users paying $1 per year. You follow inflation. That's 2 billion a year. That covers a lot of workforce, and a lot of servers.

This idea of infinite growth boggles me - how can people with math background insist on such impossible thought?

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by 3np on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:08PM (#25799935)
Do we have different definitions of monetization? Because to me that's exactly what charging $1 per year sounds like.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by pmlnr on Saturday January 16, 2021 @05:56AM (#25801483)
Fair point. The problem with the word `monetization` probably comes from recent times, when it sort of became the corporate bs equivalent of squeezing more money out of the same thing by adding ads, selling data, etc.

I'm unable to find the exact quote but soon after the WhatsApp acquisition, when the $1 fee was waived there was a message that went along the lines of "imagine how much more money WhatsApp could make". If someone has it, please send a link.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by tinyhouse on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:57PM (#25797666)
Good luck having 2 billion people paying you $1 when there are free alternatives.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by kshacker on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:39PM (#25798644)
I paid a buck when I got whatsapp, I see my first chat backup from October 2012 :) I did so because my friends were on whatsapp, and I think all of us would have paid a buck a year if that's what the model evolved to.

Unfortunately, the world turned towards 1) freemium, and 2) 'consumer as a product', and it will not be easy to roll back the free chat. But I think it is possible. Make signal survive for 2 years based on donations, or this 1 buck a year/month, and we may be able to have a long term alternative to whatsapp.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by denysvitali on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:07PM (#25797795)
Honestly, up until a couple of years ago, WhatsApp wasn't free for iPhone. Yet people still downloaded it and bought it
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by Jommi on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:05PM (#25798364)
They didn't pay it. It was mostly just testing on a subset of US users.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by Aeolun on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:57PM (#25800173)
I paid, and I wasn’t in the US.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by konjin on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:02PM (#25797724)
There are free alternatives for food (soup kitchens), yet people still go to restaurants.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by tinyhouse on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:53PM (#25798258)
I didn't say people are not willing to pay money to use an app that has free alternatives. I said good luck finding 2 billion such people. Whatsapp today is used by everyone. 8 year old kids and 85 year olds. The network effect. Its biggest asset is the number of users which makes it easy to communicate with everyone you know on it (not everywhere but in many countries). If they charged money it would've been different. It's not about the money. Everyone can afford $1/year. Even kids in poor countries. But not everyone has access to a credit card for example. Many wouldn't bother and use a free alternative like FB messenger or Telegram or whatever.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by goldenManatee on Friday January 15, 2021 @08:08PM (#25798848)
When you have that many users, their yearly dues is no longer as valuable to the company and its partners, as user data.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by pmontra on Saturday January 16, 2021 @03:09AM (#25800877)
I agree. I've been switching messaging apps (first on Windows in the 90s then on phones in the 00s) when a new free one with better features appeared or the previous one asked for money. Then WhatsApp got such a user base to make switching nearly impossible. But if they really enforced the $1 payment everybody would have switched to something else.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by korijn on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:11PM (#25797834)
As popular as it is in Europe today, I imagine they may have actually reached a number like that
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by mnl on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:47PM (#25798214)
It was this popular in 2012 already. For Android users first year was free and then you could be charged €0.89/year. I knew paying customers and was willing to do the same. It's a great product at a great price without ads, just take my money. I'd rather pay for a service than be monetized in exchange for using it.

BTW, they had just 50 engineers when FB bought them with 450M users (+1M/day) and they supported more devices back then. Just with those costs and the network effect, keeping the subscription model would have meant a solid source of honest revenue.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by tho24u023402934 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @12:10AM (#25800223)
$1 a year ? There'll be plenty of takers even in India for this.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by thegreatpeter on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:56PM (#25798286)
10% of that is 200 million.

5% of that is 50 million.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by the_gipsy on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:33PM (#25798088)
> As a user of whatsapp I wouldn't even care if the showed ads in big group chats. As long as there would be zero tracking or leaking of data and ads would be solely based on location and maybe chat info.

For Christ's sake NO!

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by eps on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:50PM (#25797591)
WhatsApp had a $1 annual fee and 400M users prior to FB acquisition. Just FYI.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by tinyhouse on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:53PM (#25797621)
I know that but it's not that they had $400M in revenue. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25666270

FB never charged for whatsapp for a good reason.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by themoose8 on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:43PM (#25798684)
In the UK I remember it being both a small required annual fee and very popular - but that's just as anecdotal as the comments in your link.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by Daho0n on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:27PM (#25798552)
They did/do, just not in direct payment.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by nitrogen on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:54PM (#25797640)
Even if you downloaded all ads in advance and ran all the logic client side, basing ads on chat info would inevitably leak information if the ad was ever clicked.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by tinyhouse on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:01PM (#25797707)
True but I'm sure they can come up with something. Maybe unclickable ads like "buy dominos pizza, only today 5% off" or "watch NBA on Prime today 7pm"...
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by somedude895 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @11:51AM (#25803411)
Unclickable ads are a super interesting idea, I've never thought about that. It would change so much of the internet if ads were that simplistic.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by nitrogen on Saturday January 16, 2021 @04:48PM (#25805812)
Inevitably advertisers will want to measure the effectiveness of their advertising, so "use code XYZ at checkout" will, and "mention this ad" could, still leak targeting information.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:13PM (#25799675)
Because Facebook acquired WhatsApp we never got to see what would have happened with WhatsApp as more and more people discovered it. WhatsApp was charging users some token amount like $1 before it merged with Facebook. Could that sort of small donation model work to keep a service like WhatsApp (or Signal) running? If 50 million people donate $1 to Signal, does he get his $50 million donation refunded. Shares of FB are down^1 while shares of SIGL are up (again).^2,3

1. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/FB/history?p=FB

2. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/SIGL/history?p=SIGL

3. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25770464 <-- Suggested reading before replying ;)

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by mfenniak on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:21PM (#25800004)
SIGL is not the makers of the Signal communication app. SIGL is a company called Signal Advance (https://www.signaladvance.com/), which makes medical and industrial systems.

Signal, the app (https://signal.org/en/), is a 501c3 nonprofit.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by piva00 on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:20AM (#25802283)
Wikipedia ran in 2018 on about US$ ~80 million, can't see why WhatsApp or Signal can't keep up a messaging service for much more than that.

Even more given WhatsApp history of being a very efficient company, supporting hundreds of millions of users with 50 engineers.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by suyash on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:37PM (#25797467)
At this point Facebook's best interest is to sell WhatsApp or make it a separate entity, completely out of Facebook's reach and control if they want to win users trust again.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by Kadin on Saturday January 16, 2021 @12:29AM (#25800300)
I can't really see why Facebook would care; even if they drive off 50% of WhatsApp's userbase, that's 50% they get to keep, analyze, and monetize. If they made WhatsApp a separate entity, they lose 100% of its users. Half of something is better than all of nothing.

The acquisition cost of WhatsApp is sunk at this point—the only thing left is to wring as much money out of it as possible.

Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by jonny_eh on Saturday January 16, 2021 @01:04AM (#25800454)
It's putting them at risk with regulators.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by mkl on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:39PM (#25797487)
Re (2), it was $850 million.
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by throwaway6497 on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:33PM (#25799418)
I think you meant $850 million stock option grants
Re:WhatsApp delays privacy changes following backlash by tinyhouse on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:39PM (#25797488)
typo: $850 million.