News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by tomComb on Thursday January 14, 2021 @12:46PM (#25779480)
I'm sure the sentiment here will be very much against this acquisition, but keep in mind that Fitbit was getting killed and would likely have gone out of business without this. It is tough for a company like Fitbit to compete with Apple & Samsung.

This should lead to more competition by making it possible for Fitbit to compete with Apple. If it doesn't then the acquisition was a failure for Google anyway - Fitbit's current market share is not acceptable for a company like Google.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by j0ba on Thursday January 14, 2021 @01:46PM (#25780391)
> Fitbit was getting killed and would likely have gone out of business

If this is a reason for acquisition, then why wouldn't G*gle wait until they were "killed" so they could come in and buy their business for pennies on the dollar?

We're fast approaching a dystopian Snow Crash world of all-powerful corporations, and you people are cheering it along.

How can these both be true?

- it's bad all US legacy media is owned by 5 corporations. - it's good for FB, Apple, Amazon and to buy up all adjacent business.

I don't see how sharing data is a good argument for unchecked consolidation of power. I'm pretty sure Fitbit could export an open standard data format, and Google could consume one. But I guess rich people wouldn't be able to get even richer if they did that.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by thatguy0900 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @02:00PM (#25780608)
>If this is a reason for acquisition, then why wouldn't G*gle wait until they were "killed" so they could come in and buy their business for pennies on the dollar?

Because what Google wants to buy is their marketshare and existing userbase. I very much doubt fitbit has any tech or products google couldn't make themselves in a few months. The longer fitbit sucks compared to their competition the lower that becomes.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:28PM (#25782853)
Hahaha I literally laughed out loud at this. Google making products. Have you seen how they make products? They have killed more physical products than they have delivered. They discontinue them more frequently than an average person throws out a napkin. Their first gen products are usually overpriced trash (Google Glass? Nexus Q?). If Google could pump out electronics with the speed and quality of someone like Anker or Amazon they’d be buying half of Europe for cash right now. I don’t pretend to know why they can’t but empirical evidence shows that it takes them several years and at least a product generation to put out something useful. For them to put out a fitness tracker or a smart watch in a few months that would be remotely competitive with the Apple Watch is just not in the cards.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by reportingsjr on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:18PM (#25784410)
They have an entire hardware division that regularly churns out quite high quality consumer hardware: nest. They also have a pretty big hardware group that makes high performance servers and specialty hardware (TPU servers among other things). They have a few other hardware divisions as well.

Google would have absolutely no issue creating quality fitbit devices. Whether or not the market would be there for them to stay in long term, I don't know.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:50PM (#25784804)
Nest was acquired and was already a mature and popular product. They by no means built it from scratch. And enterprise server products are probably outside the scope of what we are talking about, which is consumer electronics. I can build you a pretty decent server pretty quickly. I wouldn't know where to start to create a smart watch that had good battery life, great screen, great app ecosystem, great sensors, and didn't cost over $400. As far as I know, no consumer electronics Google product had launched and was an instant success. All the first product reviews I've ever read sounded like this: "it's a great first start and as a nerd who knows about these things I enjoyed some innovative parts of it, but it's not ready for prime time. Maybe next year they'll have a more polished product."
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by p49k on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:10PM (#25785028)
> Nest was acquired and was already a mature and popular product. They by no means built it from scratch.

Sure, but they did come in and add real innovation to the product; for example, adding a secret microphone that wasn't disclosed to the customer.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by chanmad29 on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:25AM (#25791252)
Wow is this real? Crazy Google!
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by omosubi on Thursday January 14, 2021 @11:30PM (#25787019)
Google's pixel phones were initially pretty well received, especially the camera
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by andreilys on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:41PM (#25784701)
Nest was an acquisition so not the best example.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by pjmlp on Friday January 15, 2021 @04:44AM (#25788855)
The same hardware division that came up with Brillo, sorry Android Things, never mind, it is gone now after 3 years anyway.

Or those wonderful Android Watches, sorry wearOS, never mind, they aren't getting proper updates for ages now.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by BlueTemplar on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:19PM (#25785129)
Counter-example : Chromecast.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by ohgodplsno on Friday January 15, 2021 @05:07AM (#25789039)
The device that overheats when playing 1080p videos ? Or the one that freezes when just launching Youtube ?

The Chromecast works well most of the time. The ways it fails is ridiculous.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by BlueTemplar on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:46AM (#25789748)
Hmm, I did have minor issues, but IMHO it's much better than your average gadget (the first Chromecast at least). And it's dirt cheap, I think I got it for 4€ ? (though that's because Google subsidizes it).

I did have some issues recently with being unable to pair it with specific Samsung phones, but it's a combination of it getting old and I assume issues with Google killing software (I don't want your Google Home !).

In a way I have worse issues with my Pebble Time… which Google now owns, to my displeasure. (But it is probably more open, so I have better chances fixing the issues myself in the long term…)

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by wlesieutre on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:06PM (#25784251)
They nailed the Nexus 7, but that was a while ago (2012 and 2013)

EDIT - never mind, Asus made both of those

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by 29083011397778 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:39PM (#25784680)
Were you thinking of the 2012 Nexus 7 with the poor-quality NAND that went bad within a couple years, rendering the tablet useless? Or the 2013 that had phantom/unregistering input due to (IIRC) general build-quality and flex issues?

Asus did make both, but I'm not sure either was as good as you recall, sadly.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by spaetzleesser on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:44PM (#25785860)
The Nexus 7 was way ahead of the competition at the time. It was fast, had a great display and cheap. I used mine for 6 years before it stopped working. Unfortunately google didn’t build on its success.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by krzyk on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:30AM (#25792028)
2012 Nexus 7 was the best tablet there was at that time. Yes it started working really slow after few years, but I still have it in my drawer, unfortunately something went wrong after 7 years and it either doesn't charge or the screen died.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by jsheard on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:38PM (#25784666)
All the Nexus devices were made by third parties, it's when they switched to Pixel branding that they started designing them in-house.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by kevin_thibedeau on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:21PM (#25784458)
Glass was never a finished product. It was sold as a dev kit that non-devs snapped up.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:52PM (#25784826)
Right. My point exactly. Google releases half baked consumer goods, then kills them later if they aren't a hugely important strategic line (like the Nexus/Pixel) or not a runaway success. The idea that Google could build a fitness tracker or smartwatch from scratch in a matter of months and it would be better than what FitBit currently has to offer just seems silly.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by dragonwriter on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:24PM (#25784512)
> Glass was never a finished product.

Seems to be a finished-ish enterprise product now.

https://www.google.com/glass/start/

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by halfdan on Thursday January 14, 2021 @02:04PM (#25780668)
This, and they want to hire the talent that built the product. If Fitbit were already a sinking ship for too long most senior folks would have left.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by at-fates-hands on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:17PM (#25783520)
Great point.

Hard to continue developing a product when the most talented people in the company have gone elsewhere already. They need the human capital in order to make sure it stays afloat and they get the requisite knowledge transfer.

Then its anybody's guess what will happen. Google's track record of buying technology and then doing something better with it is not encouraging at all.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by triceratops on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:43PM (#25784714)
> Google's track record of buying technology and then doing something better with it is not encouraging at all.

Err...what? Earth, Maps, Docs, Waymo, Android, YouTube, WebRTC, Flights, Deepmind all come from acquisitions.[1]

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_mergers_and_acquisitio...

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by kiwijamo on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:57PM (#25784885)
They haven't done much better with many of these. And I suspect these would also have succeeded independently of Google.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by jakereps on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:29PM (#25784570)
>Because what Google wants to buy is their marketshare and existing userbase.

Personally, I'm curious how that worked out for them. The announcement of this purchase, and how they handled Nest, is what made me stop using my Fitbit.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by nradov on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:01PM (#25786019)
Google also wanted the Fitbit patents for IP litigation protection.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by ohgodplsno on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:24PM (#25781984)
> very much doubt fitbit has any tech or products google couldn't make themselves in a few months.

Considering how absolutely dreadful Google's hardware (pixel line, pixel watch) is nowadays, and how unfinished all of their software is, no, Google would not be able to make any of that in a few months.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by klmadfejno on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:44PM (#25783060)
My favorite part of snow crash was the corporate mergers with public entities like the library of congress. That one's probably safe for now, but I wonder if we'll see corporate mergers with small local governments when they start to default on their debts.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by cratermoon on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:57PM (#25783240)
https://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/citizen-coup...

"Imagine there was no such thing as a library, and that members of the current neoliberal policy consensus were to sit down today and invent it. They might create complicated tax expenditures to subsidize the poor purchasing and reselling books, like the wage support of the earned income tax credit. They might require people to rent books from approved private libraries, with penalties for those who don’t and vouchers for those who can’t afford it, like the individual mandate in the latest expansion of health care. They might come up with a program where they take on liability for books that go missing from private libraries and thereby boost profits for lenders themselves, like federally backed private student loans. Or maybe they’d create means-tested libraries only accessible to the poor, with a requirement that patrons document how impoverished they are month after month to keep their library card. Maybe they’d exempt the cost of private library cards from payroll taxes, or let anything calling itself a library pay nothing in taxes."

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by xsmasher on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:26PM (#25785195)
If someone invented the concept of a library today wouldn't it sound, you know, kinda socialist?
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by robertlagrant on Friday January 15, 2021 @03:09AM (#25788239)
Only if the state owned all the pens and paper. I guess those are the means of production for authors?
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by msla on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @01:52PM (#25919684)
More like Liberal Capitalism.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by cratermoon on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:40PM (#25785830)
Oh, very.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by h0l0cube on Friday January 15, 2021 @12:50AM (#25787469)
They want their brand recognition, brand loyalty, market share, and specifically they want a watch to compliment their Pixel phones to counter growth of Apple Watch (which locks people into buying iPhones). All those reasons are better now than later
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by stormcode on Thursday January 14, 2021 @10:02PM (#25786480)
If we do enter the Snow Crash mega corp/gated burb future I want to become a Deliverator for the pizza mafia.

I'm also not for this. I wasn't for nest either. I now trust the device on my wrist less.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by willyg123 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:45PM (#25785376)
> why wouldn't G*gle wait until they were "killed" so they could come in and buy their business for pennies on the dollar?

The company waiting for this to happen missed out on the deal.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by krageon on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:18AM (#25790054)
You've hit the nail on the head here. The only arguments in favour of these are money-oriented and therefore celebrating the fundamental move towards a dystopic future (insofar as it isn't already here, which is debatable to a painful degree).

Nobody wins here, except for a very small group of already outrageously powerful and rich people. Any regular human being will at best gain nothing from this and at worst have all of their information inserted into the Google silo.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by black6 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @10:33PM (#25786683)
> We're fast approaching a dystopian Snow Crash world of all-powerful corporations, and you people are cheering it along.

Walmart is uniquely set up to become the first FOQNE.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by nradov on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:59PM (#25785999)
Fitbit is able to export the semi-open FIT file data format.

https://www.thisisant.com/

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by rodgerd on Thursday January 14, 2021 @10:58PM (#25786845)
It's good when companies I want to work with who or give me free candy are winning. They're my team!

It's bad when Nazis and Nazi-adjacent folks don't get a platform because they're my... uh...

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by m00x on Thursday January 14, 2021 @01:32PM (#25780180)
I have a Fitbit and I love this acquisition. I want to be able to put my fitness data in the rest of the Google ecosystem. The more data Google has on me, the more use I get out of Google's tools.

I really don't care that it has tons of data on me, Google has been super responsible of my data and its uses. The risk/reward is 100% worth.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by eins1234 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:02PM (#25781688)
I read this honestly expecting a /s at the end.

If you told me this was a failed attempt at obvious sarcasm now, I'd totally still believe you.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by yomly on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:19PM (#25781917)
It reads like sarcasm but it's more a sign that our views do not leak out of our echo chamber.

I have a friend who works for the government and laments at how much red tape there is to acquire or link any dataset and wishes for more data acquisition.

To be fair, her use cases were sincerely benign - being able to target people who qualify for more welfare/govt assistance, and being able to make the govt website more helpful/discoverable for support.

Though she definitely subscribes to her data being used for helpful purposes from bigtech

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by leokennis on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:29PM (#25782047)
But that’s the thing. I work for a bank. If I had unlimited access to all transaction data without needing to request elevated access and jumping some more hoops, it would greatly speed up my daily work.

But...it would also greatly increase the damage any hacker could do.

Same applies to Google. It’s super convenient to have everything “on Google”. Until the day Google is exposed/hacked/turns evil. Then it’s a disaster.

Hoping the above won’t happen is not a strategy but a gamble.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by Tijdreiziger on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:54PM (#25783212)
> Until the day Google [...] turns evil

You mean this hasn't already happened?

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by tormeh on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:00PM (#25784157)
I hear it's the least evil of the FAANGs. And then there are oil companies etc. I think relative to the average company Google's doing alright.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by kenhwang on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:38PM (#25784662)
Now I'm curious what Apple and Netflix has done to deserve being considered as more evil than Google.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by obmelvin on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:58PM (#25784907)
I'm not really trying to come out against Netflix here, but I personally think their desire to compete with every other way one could spend their time doesn't have human's best interests at heart. I recognize the agency (most) everyone has to spend their time as they will, but I don't like how I feel mentally if all my free time gets sucked into consuming content. YMMV
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by mynameisvlad on Friday January 15, 2021 @12:44AM (#25787437)
But YouTube is ok?

At least Netflix asks you every few hours if you’re still alive. YouTube will happily play you videos forever.

And they’re only a sliver of the company.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by names_are_hard on Friday January 15, 2021 @03:39AM (#25788440)
In my experience Netflix only checks if you're alive for certain content, not all. I believe it has to do with the licensing model, if they're paying someone for the right to stream that episode they want to check you haven't fallen asleep. So I'm pretty sure it's a money-saving technique, not concern for your wellbeing.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by obmelvin on Friday January 15, 2021 @12:10PM (#25793189)
I didn't say that. The GP specifically asked about Apple and Netflix phrased in such a way that Google was already assumed to be 'evil'. I was just giving my 2 cents about how even benign seeming services have their own considerations.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by ZephyrBlu on Friday January 15, 2021 @01:33AM (#25787708)
> YouTube will happily play you videos forever

That's actually not true, at least in playlists. I regularly get the "Are you still watching" or whatever it is for YouTube when I put on music playlists.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by obmelvin on Friday January 15, 2021 @12:11PM (#25793205)
YouTube also now has the ability to toggle Autoplay from the player, whereas that setting is more hidden in Netflix.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by abraae on Thursday January 14, 2021 @11:54PM (#25787164)
> Hoping the above won’t happen is not a strategy but a gamble.

Life's a gamble. Crossing the road on your way to work is gamble. Heck it's a gamble that you won't be taken out in the next 12 months by an insidious disease.

The bet I have placed personally is that Google is better at looking after my personal data that I am - so for example I use gmail instead of my own email server.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by chrisandchris on Friday January 15, 2021 @04:59AM (#25788969)
The difference is you can stop crossing the road and the risk is gone. You can‘t „unexpose“ your data to any company as they most probably will fail to delete your data (or then start to collect again).
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by nl on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:18PM (#25784416)
I agree with this at least to some degree.

I think you'll find a lot of smart tech people do, but don't post on HN because it disagrees with the prevalent view so you just get downvoted, or called an astroturfer.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by tejohnso on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:26PM (#25782830)
Expected /s as well, but at home I often hear the "I don't work for the CIA" argument against privacy paranoia so I'm not surprised.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by krageon on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:21AM (#25790085)
At first I thought this would be a paid positive troll, but then the post went so far into absurd fandom I figured you couldn't make this up if you tried.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by mav3rick on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:14PM (#25781848)
What has Google done with your data ? Even I was expecting a /s at the end of your comment.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by mulletbum on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:46PM (#25783087)
isn't it more "what have they done" with your data that makes you think this needs to be /s?
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by xnx on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:40PM (#25783003)
I'm replying in agreement that this is also my opinion. Google could do bad things with my data in the future, but, to date, there is no company I trust more. Contrary to a very vocal crowd on HN, rankings of most loved brands show that many people like Google https://morningconsult.com/most-loved-brands-2020/
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by at-fates-hands on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:22PM (#25783579)
Liking a company != trusting a company with your data.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by xenihn on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:36PM (#25783822)
I would argue there is a correlation between liking and trusting. Not just data specifically, but overall trust. I'd think data would fall under the umbrella.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by judge2020 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @01:36PM (#25780245)
The assurance that it's not going to be used for Ads is the only thing that makes this acceptable. Instead of it being on some random fitbit server on someone's Cloud, it'll be held securely on Google servers.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by bhk on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:29PM (#25782877)
Are you sure about that?

If you click through to the EU site

https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_20_...

and read "Google's Commitment" on ads:

> Google will not use for Google Ads the health and wellness data collected from wrist-worn wearable devices and other Fitbit devices of users in the EEA, including search advertising, display advertising, and advertising intermediation products. This refers also to data collected via sensors (including GPS) as well as manually inserted data.

So this only covers European Economic Area, and it only covers Google Ads.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by eins1234 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:00PM (#25781660)
Really though, how long do we expect that arrangement to last? The Facebook WhatsApp thing makes it pretty clear to me that they can afford to walk back on that arrangement as soon as they feel they can afford to take the PR hit. For something with as small of a market share as Fitbit, I suspect that won't take very long at all.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by ocdtrekkie on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:37PM (#25782130)
Google/Fitbit has a legally-binding commitment for ten years.

However, there are probably ways they can leap around that. For instance, new devices and a new platform, using the Fitbit talent and technology, but marketed as a new thing, could probably be used for advertising. Then they just need to get everyone over to their new health platform.

I also think a ten year commitment is a very poor concession for the EU to have extracted: It just means they're punting off society being harmed a while. For a company that will likely be around in 100 years or more, IBM-style, that's not a good concession.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by Marsymars on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:54PM (#25785950)
> I also think a ten year commitment is a very poor concession for the EU to have extracted: It just means they're punting off society being harmed a while. For a company that will likely be around in 100 years or more, IBM-style, that's not a good concession.

I agree, but if they were in the business of extracting significant pro-consumer concessions, I can see some weird incentives building up: imagine a dystopian future in several decades where the only semi-pro-consumer companies are the goliaths that have decades’ worth of accumulated concessions, and consumer startups nearly-universally act in their own financial interest, making them unusable for people who care about their data/privacy/ads/etc., and regulators who are unwilling to burden startups with regulations that restrict them from competing with AmaGoogleFlix.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by yjftsjthsd-h on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:39PM (#25782988)
> I want to be able to put my fitness data in the rest of the Google ecosystem. The more data Google has on me, the more use I get out of Google's tools.

It's good to be able to integrate that information. It's bad to be forced to let Google integrate that information. I dislike it because Google isn't known for letting users choose.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by bootlooped on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:52PM (#25783182)
I have an Android phone and use multiple fitness apps/services. Google Fit would be the natural place for me to aggregate all that, so I'm sold on the utility of that. Sadly I think it's at risk of being Google abandonware. I don't recall them ever having added functionality, but I recall at least one time functionality disappeared (they removed the website where you could view your data). The app seemed to keep getting simplified over time.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by kobalsky on Thursday January 14, 2021 @10:26PM (#25786643)
Google can now cross reference your historic heart rate against your ad exposure. I'm pretty sure they will responsibly use that info to tune them out for your enjoyment.

They also know what you searched, watched or visited before and after having sex.

There's a lot of info they can pull out of that little device.

The database they bought is worth every penny.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by gcblkjaidfj on Thursday January 14, 2021 @02:40PM (#25781305)
that's some next level abusive relationship whitewashing.

"google/apple data control monopolies are killing products i like. But that is fine because that makes those products cheap for google/apple and i love them."

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by gretch on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:02PM (#25781683)
The above user is only talking about their personal desires and opinions about Google. They don't speak on behalf of anyone else and don't pass judgement if G is 'good' or 'bad' for society as a whole.

You are claiming that their thoughts are only the result of abusive conditioning.

IMO, that's an extremely arrogant position - "oh, if you disagree with me, it must be because you are not smart enough to actually think for yourself"

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by dr_dshiv on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:26PM (#25782823)
Lol, I totally agree. I actually believe that they care a lot about protecting my data -- more than any other data caretaker. Probably because if they abuse our data it would be financially costly. But that's the beautiful thing about capitalism...
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:31PM (#25782901)
Apple has entered the chat. I am sure you’ve heard the argument before: Google is an advertising company. Using your data to sell you products is why they have your data. The more they can get, the higher their profits.

Apple is a hardware company. They don’t want your data and store it begrudgingly because to them it’s nothing but liability. Whenever they can, they will encrypt your data in a way they can’t access in order to not be liable. Their devices are the product, not you.

Based on the above, which company would you trust more?

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by gretch on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:00PM (#25784162)
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-advertising/apple-c...

Apple makes 2 billion a year on advertising projected to go up to 11 billion in 5 years. While a fraction of total rev, I don’t think it’s correct to round off 2 billion and say they are somehow not an advertising company as well. (You don’t have to be just 1 type of company)

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:09PM (#25785596)
DuckDuckGo makes 100% of its revenue from advertising. How you advertise matters, no?
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by gretch on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:34PM (#25785779)
That’s exactly my point. Put DDG into your original post. It refutes your own argument which was based solely on how google is an ads company and Apple is a hardware company.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:53PM (#25786409)
Except Google has a proven track record of collecting way more data than is reasonable for it and sharing it with partners. DDG was created partially in response to Google’s flagrant disregard for privacy. Apple on the other hand was the one phone manufacturer who straight up told the FBI that it’s latest phones cannot be unlocked by them because of the full device encryption they used.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by gman83 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:47PM (#25783109)
Based on what you wrote I would say Google, because they have so much more to lose. That data is really really valuable to them, whereas to Apple it isn't really.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:41PM (#25783887)
The point is that it’s not their data and they shouldn’t have it in the first place. It’s your data. I mean do what you want, but I believe your logic here is based on fundamentally incorrect initial assumptions.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by confiq on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:18PM (#25783535)
exactly this ^! remember thefappening? Imagine what shitstorm would be if that would happen to google...
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:46PM (#25783964)
The point isn’t which protects your data better from outside breaches (though I would argue Apple does a better job of protecting its phones), but how they use your data and who they can expose it to. Apple provides storage. Google sifts through your data to help them direct you towards products from which they can get kickbacks. It’s not some external entity that you have to worry about. It’s the company to whom you send all your data. And this isn’t conjecture. The only reason Google collects all that data is so they can advertise to you better. The only question is whether you trust that they’ll keep that data usage on the right side of your personal ethical line in the sand. I don’t think Google would sell your dick pics to a third party to make a quick buck. But I also wouldn’t put it past them to use them to figure out what kind of porn you like and help sex toy manufacturers to target you in their ads.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by confiq on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:08PM (#25784264)
It could be that I've blocked ads in my network or my extreme hate for ads lead to have unpopular opinion about it.

Every company uses my data for analytic purposes. Ads that I do see in google play are almost same as I see in apple store. Both take my data and try to serve me the best. In fact, I don't think it's necessary evil but what bothers me is pretending that one company save my data better or make me believe they don't analyse my data.

Everybody does it, who says it does not analyse your data, he is lying.

You know apple has news-advertising and searchads that is based on iAds[1] ? Trust me, they need your data to work properly!

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IAd

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:59PM (#25786456)
If Apple decided to downsize and focus on their core competency, which part of the company do you think they would deem essential to their business? I am sure they make decent money on all their stuff but Apple has also taken a public stance on privacy and their devices aren’t seemingly backdoored as seen in the LEAs trying to get help unlocking them and being told by Apple that they can’t help.

Look it all comes down to trust and I see way fewer reasons to trust Google than Apple. Both deserve a baseline measure of mistrust, but Google has all the incentive to spy on you while Apple has little to none. And when it comes to investigations of “why do you have this data in the first place?” Google’s answer is “we need it to advertise” while Apple’s can only be “we need it for this specific service” and if they fail to show why, they are liable. Google and Facebook have a virtually identical business model: collect, aggregate, advertise. If you don’t trust Facebook, why would you trust Google?

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by confiq on Friday January 15, 2021 @04:58AM (#25788955)
> Apple has also taken a public stance on privacy and their devices aren’t seemingly backdoored as seen in the LEAs

No idea what LEA stands for but apple did not encrypt after FBI complain: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-fbi-icloud-exclusiv...

> dropped plans to let iPhone users fully encrypt backups of their devices in the company's iCloud service after the FBI complained that the move would harm investigations

If you are referring to FBI-Apple dispute, if apple is complying with Chinese government, it will comply with USA government. That is how things are.

I'm not defending google, far away from it. They are not much better but they protect user data exactly because apple make fun of them. They now do extreme measures just to protect the privacy so they will not destroy their reputation even more.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by echelon on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:07PM (#25783381)
Neither.

Apple is attempting to steal the concept of computing and turn it into a protected, arcane art.

You can't even run your own software on a device you own. That's a sure sign of a company that loves you and has your best interests at heart.

Apple is just as cutthroat as any. They only want your money.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:39PM (#25783859)
Last I checked your Google Home wasn’t exactly open either :)

They are both cutthroat but Apple specifically has taken a stance on privacy.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by GeekyBear on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:53PM (#25783194)
No company with surveillance capitalism as their business model should be allowed access to health data from an acquired company without the user explicitly opting in.

However, I sincerely doubt Fitbit would have been worth anywhere near as much under those conditions.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by at-fates-hands on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:25PM (#25783635)
This is the moral razors edge companies have to walk on nowadays.

Do they sell their company out and get rich, or do they stick to their principles and safeguard their users data?

I don't have the right answer. What I do know is when you're facing down a multi-million dollar payout, principles tend to get tossed out the window.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by nradov on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:12PM (#25786107)
Fitbit doesn't sell medical devices. The data they gather is health related but legally it's not "protected health information".
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by Dig1t on Thursday January 14, 2021 @12:53PM (#25779585)
The reason why it's difficult for them to compete with Apple and Samsung isn't readily apparent to me. There still seems to be a large hole in the smartwatch market for a GOOD Android-compatible smartwatch. There are a lot of options, but, to me, none of them are as polished or feature-heavy as the Apple Watch. It doesn't seem that one of these companies would need access to any special internal APIs or anything to be competitive, so I don't see what Google could add other than lots of money and SWE hours.

If Google wants to compete in this space they should have been forced to build it themselves. IMO letting Fitbit die would have been better for users privacy-wise.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by tomComb on Thursday January 14, 2021 @01:02PM (#25779720)
I'm a long time Fitbit user and I think their products are great. From that perspective I'm just happy that they will survive.

> so I don't see what Google could add other than lots of money and SWE hours

That matters.

> IMO letting Fitbit die would have been better for users privacy-wise.

Have you seen what some companies do when they are on the brink of insolvency? They start firing engineers, best practices lapse, and they start monetizing everything.

And have you seen the EU data privacy conditions?

And finally, of the companies that could have bought them, which has a better record of keeping their users' data private then Google?

But also, as a Fitbit user, if I wanted all my data deleted I could do that, but I absolutely do not. I want it kept private, supported, and crunched by a company like Google to our mutual advantage.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by breck on Thursday January 14, 2021 @01:12PM (#25779853)
Fellow long time FitBit user and agree with everything you said.

Furthermore, I pay for FitBit Premium and would strongly encourage Google to always keep FitBit a paid product/service and never monetize it via ads.

I don't have any expertise in this area, but my hunch from what I saw with Apple vs WhatsApp, is that in the long run sticking with paid products and not switching to Ads is better for success. Also, likely a lot harder to build up a base of paying users and if you throw that away would be a colossal mistake.

Anyway, I'm not a business expert but am a passionate FitBit user and very happy about this acquisition because just like you I was worried for their survival.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by IgorPartola on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:35PM (#25782936)
Again, Apple has a much better track record than Google when it comes to privacy. I can’t believe I’m defending them here, but honestly they’ve been the only tech giant that hasn’t sold out every bit of your personal info they had to make a quick buck. I suppose Netflix might be the other one but (a) I don’t know for a fact and (b) they aren’t exactly the fitness brand.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by RHSeeger on Thursday January 14, 2021 @01:07PM (#25779787)
What about the spot it started out in? A watch that keeps track of some vital signs. I don't want an Android-compatible smartwatch. I don't want a smartwatch at all. I want a simple "health" device.

I got a new fitbit for Christmas because I couldn't even initialize it without installing their app on my smartphone. I don't want their app on my phone. I don't want it to report all my info to their servers. I don't want it to have access to my gps location, which is might be reporting in. My old fitbit doesn't need any of that at all, and I don't see the need for a new one (that would meet my needs) to, either.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by Dig1t on Thursday January 14, 2021 @02:49PM (#25781476)
I agree with you here, a simple health tracker is awesome. But also it seems to me that Google has a massive incentive to get as much data about you as possible. Which means releasing devices that collect as much biometric (and location) based data as possible, and setting defaults (just like Maps location history being turned on by default) that will automatically send all of this to Google servers. And as usual with Google, the vast majority will probably be sending their health data to Google unwittingly.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by snowwolf on Thursday January 14, 2021 @01:03PM (#25779727)
The killer feature for me which lead me to me switching away was Fitbit Pay. They just don't have the take up by banks that the competition (Apple and Samsung) have. Maybe that would have changed, but if they integrate Google Pay instead, I may switch back.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by JshWright on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:14PM (#25782662)
I much prefer contactless payment with my phone anyway. I usually find it very awkward trying to position my wrist near the NFC reader on the terminal.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by Marsymars on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:59PM (#25785997)
I’ve always thought they should put the NFC chip on the bottom of the wrist rather than on the top - that seems like a much less awkward position.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by thenewwazoo on Thursday January 14, 2021 @01:03PM (#25779736)
> There still seems to be a large hole in the smartwatch market for a GOOD Android-compatible smartwatch.

In order for there to be a market, both sides have to exist: sellers and buyers. I'm not convinced Android users have the appetite for multi-hundred-dollar accessories the same way Apple users do, and given Apple's engineering skill and vertical integration, nobody is going to sell a smartwatch that's as good for less.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by nradov on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:25PM (#25786195)
Garmin seems to find plenty of customers willing to buy high end smart watches that cost even more than Apple watches. Many of those Garmin devices are paired with Android phones.

As one data point I just spent $1300 on a new top end Garmin watch and use it with Android.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by Marsymars on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:58PM (#25785987)
I’d buy the top-end Apple Watch today if it was compatible with my Android phone; as-is, the slate of compatible watches are too poor for me to bother with any of them.

Though, I’m one person, so that doesn’t invalidate your point.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by 01100011 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:33PM (#25785256)
Yeah, just picked up a Fitbit Sense since it's on sale at Costco. It's almost great, but has some serious flaws. The capacitive button is dumb. Not allowing me to upload music is dumb. The processor is slightly underpowered or the software needs optimizations because occasionally it has serious lag when swiping on the watch face. Having the watch accidentally turn on with full brightness while I'm trying to sleep just sucks.

Other than that, it's a pretty nice device. Unfortunately it requires a subscription to get the most out of it.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by nxc18 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:44PM (#25782221)
Unpopular opinion here, but I think the Fitbit versa (from 2018) was/is better than Apple Watch (latest) in significant ways, even when paired with iPhone.

I replaced my versa with Apple Watch when the versa died. I don’t necessarily regret it, but it didn’t feel like an upgrade and came with significant downsides.

In particular, Fitbit gives far more control over notifications, especially for built-in apps like messages. Fitbit makes media controls easily accessible - on Apple Watch, they’re always moving and hard to get back to especially during a workout. My main use case is skipping podcast commercials, so not being able to do that quickly is a problem.

Battery life was much better on the versa. It also charged faster, so it would almost always be done charging after a shower, Apple Watch only sometimes is.

Tldr there is definitely room to deliver a better product than Apple’s. Whether or not Google is capable of doing that is a different question that I won’t address.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by JshWright on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:12PM (#25782634)
I love my Versa 3. I charge it for ~20 minutes every couple days, and I've literally never seen it below 50%.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by dwighttk on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:22PM (#25784485)
>...media controls easily accessible - on Apple Watch, they’re always moving and hard to get back to especially during a workout.

Swipe right from workout screen.

(Finger moves right to left... not sure if that is swipe right or left :)

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by nxc18 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:49PM (#25786364)
Thank you so much! I’ve had my watch for 4 months, I don’t know why I didn’t see that earlier. I have been going to the app switcher this whole time.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by dwighttk on Friday January 15, 2021 @08:24AM (#25790650)
One other thing is the big (non knob) button brings up three apps and somehow I have it so now playing is always one of them. Can’t remember how I set that up though. (Doesn’t help when someone keeps texting me and I want to stop the audio.)
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by rblatz on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:04PM (#25784966)
I assume it's because every product I've bought from them was terrible quality hardware wise. The Aria scale just randomly can't upload weights, also it will randomly just turn on for a whole day thinking you are trying to weigh yourself and will stay in that mode until it kills the batteries. I've had multiple of their bands and they all lasted less than a year before they had something break. At my work we gave every employee a Fitbit charge hr, and within 6 months half of them had the band separate from the sensor. I had another Charge HR that one day turned off and then never turned back on after 3 months of use.

I wanted to like them, but the quality of the product was lacking, and I'm happier with the Apple Watch.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by Ericson2314 on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:04PM (#25784212)
Google and Apple (or any other big tech pairing) pairing don't compete as strongly as we would like. Even ignoring the fact I don't want a stronger google, I also don't think this will provide meaningful competition to Apple at all.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by nradov on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:57PM (#25785982)
It wasn't just Apple and Samsung that were killing Fitbit. Garmin also took a lot of the fitness market.
Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by HenryBemis on Friday January 15, 2021 @03:25AM (#25788341)
>Fitbit to compete with Apple

Fitbit is/was a mosquito, they could never surive an 'all out war' with Apple. Fitbit does not compete with Apple. Google does.

The problem is that once Google gets their hands on our sweet data (in the off chance you don't have an android phone), then they will definitely put that data in 'good use'.

I see some (marketable) benefits though... Fitbits can be tracked. Imagine walking past a store, a sensor with 'talk' with your fitbit, and pull your G-ad profile and a screen will display the ad you missed to see on your gmail. And this is what I need to see. Walking past a sex shop and being flashed this huge wierd looking dildo with lights and lasers, because Google 'knows' I enjoy sex and Star Wars (not combined though).

And all that thanks to my FitBit bracelet :) (my android phone is security-hardened enough to not run in the background and/or transmit 'stuff')

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by dalbasal on Thursday January 14, 2021 @04:53PM (#25783191)
Does this count as more competition though?

It may provide simple price competition, but I don't think price competition is a main reason for the anti-monopoly sentiment you are referring to. This is more about centralisation/decentralisation, data aggregation.

Re:Fitbit is now officially part of Google by welder on Thursday January 14, 2021 @02:20PM (#25780930)
> This should lead to more competition by making it possible for Fitbit to compete with Apple.

Fitness trackers are too basic. I can't wait to see if the Oneplus smart watch is any good. https://www.theverge.com/2020/12/22/22196180/oneplus-smartwa...