Republicans have fought for people's right to do so. If you recall the case of baker that didn't want to make a gay wedding cake.
Now companies in the tech business are doing the same but to some of the groups that campaigned for that freedom.
Sure there's some argument that Twitter and Facebook are giant monopolies in the social media space.
But Salesforce? There's like a 1000 CRMs
IIRC The baker had no problem with supplying a cake, the only thing the baker did not want to do is custom decorate the cake. The nuance being, they would supply the base product to everyone but did not want to endorse something they object to.
This is more like the bar kicking out an unruly patron, which is a terms-of-service violation.
It's a big distinction, unless you want to argue that discrimination is ok.
The bar can certainly refuse service to anyone, but if they act in such a manner they will affect their clientele.
And then imagine there’s only three bars (aws, azure, gcp) and if you get thrown out of the bar, you die (go out of business).
I don’t think this is where we are now, but I think this is a step toward this dystopian state where corporate bureaucracies make these decisions.
I think the real risk is that amidst banning all the clearly bad people, they will also convenience ban anyone they like since it’s impossible to audit since they have information.
It’s kind of like not being able to do discovery in a lawsuit.
I think there is also a principle of rule of law where the law must apply to law breakers as well. The police shouldn’t be allowed to violate the 4 amendment for assholes and criminals. Not because they don’t deserve it, but because it results in injustice for innocents.
Soapboxy post scriptum:
This is what I dislike about these "neutrality meta" discourses. "Neutrality" is ultimately just another word for "common ground", but the less common ground you share, the less of this neutrality there is to work from. Now, in this case, your characterization of the baker's actions as "discrimination" is completely opposed to his view of his actions, but you presuppose your characterization as an element of this neutral common ground by which we can judge him. From his point of view, he may see this as an act of virtue. He may even see this as an act of love for the gay customers by communicating to them that their relationship is illicit and self-destructive. Indeed, that would be the traditional view. If someone's an alcoholic, you might kindly inform them for their own good.
So not only do I see little point in pretending to a false neutrality, but you can't both reduce everything to a mere matter of interpretation and opinion, a plurality of incommensurate views, and then turn around and elevate your view as the neutral one. Either there is a truth of the matter about which we may disagree but which can in principle be resolved reasonably or which can be tolerated, or there is no truth of the matter and it's all at bottom merely a matter of power and accident. In which case, it seems a little silly and contradictory to hold the latter and simultaneously express moral indignation at someone who is behaving in accordance with his own views. You only get to do that, maybe, if you believe there is a truth of the matter to which this other person is bound but egregiously violating.
But if you believe you're right, or you love the truth and believe that it can in principle be known, have a humble and sincere desire to know it and a willingness to discuss and consider and respectfully argue, as well as the courage to humbly accept conclusions that would put you at odds with others you would rather not be at odds with, then it should be possible to arrive at some measure of agreement. I think it is much better to start there with the hope that over time we can make progress, not through force but through reason, rather than to give up on the possibility.
I'm not arguing that discrimination is okay. But the RNC did argue that.
So it's entertaining to see.
If you insist on dehumanizing people you disagree with, violence is the only destination.
We have got to stop demonizing people who don’t share our perspective.
The outcome is predictable, avoidable and undesirable. Maintain the current course and you will pull everyone over the cliff with you.
We have got to find a way to get along.
Those who leverage their power this way will create the outcome they claim they want to prevent.
Is that what you’re getting from my comment?
You said “to do nothing is unfathomable.”
If the solution is to rob them of representation, what the hell are they going to resort to????
That’s all I meant. If you’re American, you have to pick a side. Do you condemn or condone? No one is sitting around going like “I feel like they had some good points but I donnu”.
This is bigger than covid, and at some point, at this point in my opinion, we have to make a decision. We either nip this in the bud now or watch it get worse. And if you work at Twitter, that might mean pushing to ban Trump for the last four years. Some tech savvy individual went and reverse engineered Parler’s API and archived 96% of public content. All this in the hopes that it’ll dissuade any further escalation. And if that isn’t a good enough explanation, then maybe people are just fucking tired of enabling or doing business with people they consider to be deranged and dangerous.
I realize you want everyone to come together and find some compromise or common ground but like, where do we even begin? There was no election fraud. Not even Trump’s lawyers could utter those words in court, because they understood that repeating their clients’ overt lies could get them disbarred. I genuinely think that the stop the steal is run by opportunistic leeches who prey on the mentally ill. And that taking away their platforms on private social media might actually give us the pause we need for a peaceful transfer of power. No one should be forced to bake a cake at gunpoint and no one should be forced to go to work on making an online platform work for people we (and the law) view as terrorists.
That’s my rant. You can disagree with all of if you want, but you can’t argue with individuals not wanting to go to work for other individuals. Whether it be Salesforce or Twitter or Facebook...they chose to do something and frankly, those who are worried about this potentially happening to them need to realize how bad what happened at the capitol was, and how rare it is. There’s no slippery slope here.
You have now resorted to attacking the person rather than the idea. Move along. It’s unconstructive, but know this: I am infinitely further away from attacking the capitol than some. Your fearmongering is misplaced.
There, that should help you sleep at night.
Notably, a building owner can take down your posters, and a hotel can refuse to host your conference.
I do believe that these platforms are not infrastructure, that they are not public spaces, but I am no corporate apologist; from that view point, what we've done is given up control over our public discourse to corporate bodies, and I think that is the crux of the problem and what actually needs to be rectified.
To put the problem into the physical world, it's as if we've decided to have all of our Town Halls and court hearings at a McDonalds, and now McDonalds won't let the people threatening violence in because they'd disturb the customers.
So we have handed over control of our discourse to the companies, and we have no policy to help us.
This is more akin to you phoning the baker, explaining that you're gay, asking them to write "happy gay wedding" on the cake, the baker agrees, ... the day comes and you call the baker and he's like "you want me to write GAY on your cake?!" and you're without cake.
What salesforce did here is basically collective punishment.
That sounds a lot like USSR.
One was a government and the other is random people saying "I'm not going to be your customer anymore"
There's also plenty of open source CRMs they could deploy.
If they're afraid of the cloud they could rent a dedicated server or colocate.
I'm sure if they host in a very pro Republican state they wouldn't have issues.
They could even host it in another country if they wanted to as well.
They've got a lot of freedom
That's not how it should be.
/s just in case
This is not a road we should be going down.
Seems like the market at some point is going to step in here and serve - wait for it - about half the country, 150m people. (and then let's not forget about the rest of the world, who probably don't want to get involved in US politics, and aren't particularly happy seeing the interference of silicon valley companies in everything - see Merkel and France's ministers statement in the last few days).
The remaining people on social networks are the centrists. You could argue that the extreme left will also be booted off soon, if not already. Anyone seriously or credibly proposing storming Amazon HQ on socialist / communist grounds will get kicked off as well. Both to preserve the optics of fairness and because they should be.
The only people left are those sharing pictures of their kids and food - and that’s actually fine by me. Political talk will remain, but stay non-violent, which doesn’t sound too bad.
You are also assuming the censorship is only of people calling for violence. This morning Ron Paul's facebook page was blocked. I don't think he's ever called for violence. If the loudest voices on the left expand their definition is hate speech more and more, the less it is the fringe who get banned.
It’s not a slippery slope argument, either. It’s already happened to one of the two most powerful groups in the US. On what basis do you think they would hesitate to cancel you?
I have no comment on the rest of your commentary, but the reason this happened is one of the few things in this story that is quite clear.
I’m not clear on why the RNC would be kicked off.
I’m not being facetious, why was the RNC whatevered by Salesforce?
[0] https://sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2021/01/11/salesforce-says...
It’s hard to say without seeing the actual text but unless they were saying to burn down the capitol, I don’t think political emails saying the election was stolen are noteworthy. This is based on my own experience of getting large numbers of spam letters making all sorts of stupid claims “Jane Doe is a terrorist” “Nancy Pelosi is going to take your guns” “Trump is going to put your kids in cages” “Biden will destroy America”
While I would like to block all this crap, if Salesforce is going to drop RNC over “donate to us because the election is stolen” they they will need to drop many other people.
And it goes without saying, racists and racial supremacists have no place in modern society!
So you hate SaaS. Potential unclear reasons can will and have included 'changing our focus', 'being acquired', 'fire your customer', etc.
Im not entirely clear who would have any other expectation for any SaaS product.
Your hosting/cloud was always willing to drop your ass the moment you made bad PR for them.
This is one of many reasons I think going full lock-in on a proprietary cloud service that you can't ever self-host or migrate to a different cloud in a more favorable jurisdiction is crazy for a business that needs continuity.
Who knows which way the wind blows in a quarter or a year or a decade?
Take it from the porn industry: you have to be prepared to host it yourself one day.
Let's hope the wind is always blowing against trying to violently overthrow a government after a free and fair election in the United States of America.
This was a riot comprised of mostly unarmed people, not a battle, and certainly not an insurrection. No power was seized nor was attempted to be seized, no territory was taken or held.
Please, let's stick to the facts.
An angry mob breaking stuff for a couple hours is not a real attempt at overthrowing the state, no matter how much you are upset about the matter, or how much you wish there to be consequences for same.
How is interrupting the democratic certification of election results by one of the branches of government _not_ an attempt at seizing power from them?
They were only temporarily successful and largely an incompetent mob but it doesn't change what happened.
Perhaps society might be in a better place if we all switched our TVs off. I know it's done me wonders.
The idea that there are impartial or neutral news sources in 2021, is a bit of a laugh, to be honest. The best thing one could do, is read both sides of an argument, and come to one's own conclusions - based on the balance of probabilities.
Anyways, as far as news sources go, I’ve been pretty happy with Reuters.
The end game is obviously that anyone that is not a woke liberal will be cancelled. For the good of the country of course.
This is pretty subjective. Should we just have a real-time poll to determine who is an asshole?
Separately from that, I think society needs assholes and trying to sanitize this element entirely will make us worse (queue Team America video).
Global corporations are for global corporations. If you think that Nike, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft, et al. are going to be good companies that help the human condition and raise people up...you are not looking at the actions of these companies.
There have been many times in history when positions that you undoubtedly take were considered "asshole positions" by those in power. Those time will come again.
We need to figure out how to live together.
At what point exactly do people start to get uncomfortable enough to spring into action? No one knows for sure, but this seems like a pretty good place.
People wearing Camp Auschwitz t-shirts are declaring themselves to be Nazis.
People wearing 6MWNE t-shirts are declaring themselves to be Nazis.
A new congressional rep quoting Hitler approvingly is a Nazi:
https://www.wcia.com/news/politics/lawmakers-governor-condem...
People supporting Nazis are Nazis.
Salesforce doesn't want to be aligned with Nazis. Neither do I.
People wearing Che Guevara t-shirts are declaring themselves to be Communists.
People wearing hammer and sickle t-shirts are declaring themselves to be Communists.
People supporting Communists are Communists.
Communism killed many more people than Nazism did.
Democrats have an even worse track record with that if you check the statistics for Democrat ran cities.
> Rights are not gifts from government, so the government cannot restrict them unless we engage in force or fraud. The bakery did not use force to stop any same-sex couple from getting a wedding cake. It simply exercised its right to decide who it would accept as a customer. No one would support private individuals forcing bakery employees to bake a cake at gunpoint, so why is it right for the government to do it?
I’m alarmed when they start censoring people without even pretending they’re remotely dangerous. He simply has the wrong politics and is too popular.
Saying someone did X, Y, and Z, then refusing to produce evidence is the problem there.
You have the right to paint your house polka dot pink but everyone is still going to think it was the wrong choice.
They very likely violated the terms of service of ExactTarget, their bulk email sender.
Get some perspective.
Candidate which managed two start two wars, didn't end a third war and managed to increase drone based deaths.
So much for tolerance, less hate and protecting the marginalised.
I'm sad it's come to that for us as a nation, but it's galvanized me to work with the handful of people I hold close to start building up Nexii of good business. So there is that.
The American Ideal, and the values we're supposed to stand up for do not look like how people are acting right now. The rest of the world is watching this meltdown, and our wholesale burning ofany high ground we managed to achieve, and well... That's it. Sad to see is all.
I am interested in what makes you think a large chunk of the population can not be trusted?
I think that the news has acted as a wedge to drive people apart as much as possible. The BLM protests have some good points but also have violence surrounding it. Trump supporters may not have the best points but there has been evidence of voter fraud in the past and asking for investigation is not a bad thing, violence is unacceptable.
And yet your proposal would absolutely undermine the democratic process and encourage additional violence.
We don’t know what was done to the RNC, or why. It’s odd to release such a non-statement, but if the RNC is encouraging violence, that’s breaking laws and should be prosecuted.
If they haven’t violated laws, and there’s no injunction then Salesforce is serving in the role of punisher.
I get that it’s their service and they can legally serve whomever they like, but line item vetoing people and companies based on an arbitrary, changing criteria leads to mistakes and generally bad business.
If I have to think about whether one day my dashboard software will turn off because one of my executives does something bad, then that’s going to make me not want to use it.
This is a slippery slope argument, of course, and I should have good executives. But I don’t think I want to buy software from services that could just one day decide to stop serving me for an unclear reason.