News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by Jonnax on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:13AM (#25746349)
Any service you are a customer of have clauses with say that they terminate your service if they want.

Republicans have fought for people's right to do so. If you recall the case of baker that didn't want to make a gay wedding cake.

Now companies in the tech business are doing the same but to some of the groups that campaigned for that freedom.

Sure there's some argument that Twitter and Facebook are giant monopolies in the social media space.

But Salesforce? There's like a 1000 CRMs

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by themaninthedark on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:39AM (#25746672)
>Republicans have fought for people's right to do so. If you recall the case of baker that didn't want to make a gay wedding cake.

IIRC The baker had no problem with supplying a cake, the only thing the baker did not want to do is custom decorate the cake. The nuance being, they would supply the base product to everyone but did not want to endorse something they object to.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by birdyrooster on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:00PM (#25757037)
The issue is that they wouldn’t provide full service because it was in service of a gay wedding. You are splitting hairs and it makes no difference morally.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by acegopher on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:21AM (#25746423)
This isn't so much a case of allowing a baker to make a gay wedding cake, as that's discrimination.

This is more like the bar kicking out an unruly patron, which is a terms-of-service violation.

It's a big distinction, unless you want to argue that discrimination is ok.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by prepend on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:48AM (#25746791)
I think it’s like a bar kicking out a patron saying “they weren’t adhering to our values.”

The bar can certainly refuse service to anyone, but if they act in such a manner they will affect their clientele.

And then imagine there’s only three bars (aws, azure, gcp) and if you get thrown out of the bar, you die (go out of business).

I don’t think this is where we are now, but I think this is a step toward this dystopian state where corporate bureaucracies make these decisions.

I think the real risk is that amidst banning all the clearly bad people, they will also convenience ban anyone they like since it’s impossible to audit since they have information.

It’s kind of like not being able to do discovery in a lawsuit.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by alisonkisk on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:21AM (#25747203)
A large part of the reason there are only 3 large "bars" (ignoring the fact that there's no need to use cloud computing to run a service, it's merely convenient) is that the RNC had worked hard for decades to protect the financial moats of large wealthy businesses.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by prepend on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:56PM (#25753514)
While this may have some poetic justice for the RNC, my concern is how this will be used on others where there is no poetic justice.

I think there is also a principle of rule of law where the law must apply to law breakers as well. The police shouldn’t be allowed to violate the 4 amendment for assholes and criminals. Not because they don’t deserve it, but because it results in injustice for innocents.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by bobthechef on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:40AM (#25748266)
You're presuming something that baker does not agree to. The baker views gay marriage as morally wrong or even an absurd notion. Punishing him because he has moral objections that you disagree with by framing it as a matter of "discrimination" (understood as bigoted treatment) is to ignore that his motives and perceptions may involve no bigotry at all in his view.

Soapboxy post scriptum:

This is what I dislike about these "neutrality meta" discourses. "Neutrality" is ultimately just another word for "common ground", but the less common ground you share, the less of this neutrality there is to work from. Now, in this case, your characterization of the baker's actions as "discrimination" is completely opposed to his view of his actions, but you presuppose your characterization as an element of this neutral common ground by which we can judge him. From his point of view, he may see this as an act of virtue. He may even see this as an act of love for the gay customers by communicating to them that their relationship is illicit and self-destructive. Indeed, that would be the traditional view. If someone's an alcoholic, you might kindly inform them for their own good.

So not only do I see little point in pretending to a false neutrality, but you can't both reduce everything to a mere matter of interpretation and opinion, a plurality of incommensurate views, and then turn around and elevate your view as the neutral one. Either there is a truth of the matter about which we may disagree but which can in principle be resolved reasonably or which can be tolerated, or there is no truth of the matter and it's all at bottom merely a matter of power and accident. In which case, it seems a little silly and contradictory to hold the latter and simultaneously express moral indignation at someone who is behaving in accordance with his own views. You only get to do that, maybe, if you believe there is a truth of the matter to which this other person is bound but egregiously violating.

But if you believe you're right, or you love the truth and believe that it can in principle be known, have a humble and sincere desire to know it and a willingness to discuss and consider and respectfully argue, as well as the courage to humbly accept conclusions that would put you at odds with others you would rather not be at odds with, then it should be possible to arrive at some measure of agreement. I think it is much better to start there with the hope that over time we can make progress, not through force but through reason, rather than to give up on the possibility.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by Jonnax on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:25AM (#25746480)
The idea that was put forward by the Repuican party is that people had a right to refuse service.

I'm not arguing that discrimination is okay. But the RNC did argue that.

So it's entertaining to see.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by DaniloDias on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:28AM (#25746510)
I don’t follow your logic. 70m Americans are represented by the RNC. Your metaphor breaks immediately.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by DaniloDias on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @12:37PM (#25750252)
Downvotes here sadden me.

If you insist on dehumanizing people you disagree with, violence is the only destination.

We have got to stop demonizing people who don’t share our perspective.

The outcome is predictable, avoidable and undesirable. Maintain the current course and you will pull everyone over the cliff with you.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by confidantlake on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:15PM (#25757123)
I get downvoted all the time, I never threaten violence over it. It may sting the ego a bit but come on man, it is just internet points.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by DaniloDias on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:04PM (#25757945)
That is not what I was expressing. I am observing that this censorious behavior will predictably lead to others using violence. 70 million Americans voted for trump. How do you expect them to respond to this censorship?

We have got to find a way to get along.

Those who leverage their power this way will create the outcome they claim they want to prevent.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by confidantlake on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @09:13AM (#25762144)
I expect them to not resort to violence because the guy they supported was banned from twitter.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by heyoni on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:54PM (#25758334)
There’s a time for getting along, and now is absolutely not that time. The fact that 74 million voted for Trump, who is inciting violence against our democratic process means that this is the time to choose a side. It’s been forced upon us and the dust is far from settling. This is NOT a slippery slope or censorship, jfc...to do nothing at this point is unfathomable.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by DaniloDias on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @12:19AM (#25758507)
Are you calling for violence against them???
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by heyoni on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @12:27AM (#25758560)
No.

Is that what you’re getting from my comment?

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by DaniloDias on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @12:48AM (#25758677)
Yes? What possible solution is there for 74m people who you disagree with that have to have something done to them?

You said “to do nothing is unfathomable.”

If the solution is to rob them of representation, what the hell are they going to resort to????

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by heyoni on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @01:20AM (#25758851)
And violence is the only thing you can think of in a thread about a cms revoking services to said opposition?

That’s all I meant. If you’re American, you have to pick a side. Do you condemn or condone? No one is sitting around going like “I feel like they had some good points but I donnu”.

This is bigger than covid, and at some point, at this point in my opinion, we have to make a decision. We either nip this in the bud now or watch it get worse. And if you work at Twitter, that might mean pushing to ban Trump for the last four years. Some tech savvy individual went and reverse engineered Parler’s API and archived 96% of public content. All this in the hopes that it’ll dissuade any further escalation. And if that isn’t a good enough explanation, then maybe people are just fucking tired of enabling or doing business with people they consider to be deranged and dangerous.

I realize you want everyone to come together and find some compromise or common ground but like, where do we even begin? There was no election fraud. Not even Trump’s lawyers could utter those words in court, because they understood that repeating their clients’ overt lies could get them disbarred. I genuinely think that the stop the steal is run by opportunistic leeches who prey on the mentally ill. And that taking away their platforms on private social media might actually give us the pause we need for a peaceful transfer of power. No one should be forced to bake a cake at gunpoint and no one should be forced to go to work on making an online platform work for people we (and the law) view as terrorists.

That’s my rant. You can disagree with all of if you want, but you can’t argue with individuals not wanting to go to work for other individuals. Whether it be Salesforce or Twitter or Facebook...they chose to do something and frankly, those who are worried about this potentially happening to them need to realize how bad what happened at the capitol was, and how rare it is. There’s no slippery slope here.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by DaniloDias on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:20AM (#25761111)
We are doomed if more people think like you.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by heyoni on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @09:20AM (#25762215)
Then I feel sorry for you.

You have now resorted to attacking the person rather than the idea. Move along. It’s unconstructive, but know this: I am infinitely further away from attacking the capitol than some. Your fearmongering is misplaced.

There, that should help you sleep at night.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by ehnto on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:37AM (#25746641)
I would argue Facebook and Twitter's function as a social communications enabler can be replaced with any number of services, devices, even just real life. A meeting at a table is obviously not the same as a Facebook group chat, and a poster on a power pole isn't the same as a tweet, but if both platforms shut down tomorrow we'd just use one of the myriad other communication and organizing techniques we all have at our disposal.

Notably, a building owner can take down your posters, and a hotel can refuse to host your conference.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by insickness on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:20AM (#25747202)
The same argument could be made to allow companies to do whatever they want, including discriminate based on race, etc. And in some sense, if the market were efficient enough, we wouldn't need laws against discrimination, sexual harassment, etc. The problem is that the market is not so efficient that you can just replace Facebook and Twitter with any number of services, at least not readily.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by ehnto on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @10:05AM (#25747791)
Admittedly I am still on the fence about this whole thing (the denying of services), and can't fully articulate my thoughts.

I do believe that these platforms are not infrastructure, that they are not public spaces, but I am no corporate apologist; from that view point, what we've done is given up control over our public discourse to corporate bodies, and I think that is the crux of the problem and what actually needs to be rectified.

To put the problem into the physical world, it's as if we've decided to have all of our Town Halls and court hearings at a McDonalds, and now McDonalds won't let the people threatening violence in because they'd disturb the customers.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by insickness on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:35PM (#25754115)
To go along with your analogy, it's as if McDonald's won't let people in who McDonald's has accused of threatening violence. These corporations have made the determination without due process. At least when the government accuses you of doing something wrong, there's ostensibly some recourse.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by nradov on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:04PM (#25756557)
McDonald's and other businesses already do that all the time. If you threaten someone in the restaurant then the manager might refuse service, order you to leave, and barr you from ever returning. There's no due process.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by ehnto on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @04:42AM (#25760020)
A great point, and probably why corporate censorship is so insidious.

So we have handed over control of our discourse to the companies, and we have no policy to help us.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by ballenf on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:41AM (#25746696)
And hand writing post it notes is the same as owning a newspaper?
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by ehnto on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:38AM (#25747425)
I'm thinking of this from the users perspective, of course Facebook has an enormous amount of soft-power with it's media empire. That is an extremely worrying thing.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by tomp on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:03AM (#25746995)
Wait, there's obviously a big difference.

This is more akin to you phoning the baker, explaining that you're gay, asking them to write "happy gay wedding" on the cake, the baker agrees, ... the day comes and you call the baker and he's like "you want me to write GAY on your cake?!" and you're without cake.

What salesforce did here is basically collective punishment.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by alisonkisk on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:18AM (#25747177)
There's no collective punishment here. The RNC is a single legal person. All the individual members of the RNC are still welcome to use SalesForce themselves or in other organizations.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by jojobas on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:21AM (#25746418)
Any CRM supplier that would dare to deal with RNC would be barraged on social media and lose other business.

That sounds a lot like USSR.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by Jonnax on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:30AM (#25746537)
There's a difference between people giving them negative press and the USSR.

One was a government and the other is random people saying "I'm not going to be your customer anymore"

There's also plenty of open source CRMs they could deploy.

If they're afraid of the cloud they could rent a dedicated server or colocate.

I'm sure if they host in a very pro Republican state they wouldn't have issues.

They could even host it in another country if they wanted to as well.

They've got a lot of freedom

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by jojobas on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:50AM (#25746810)
The implementation is different, the effect is the same: do something against the wishes of a small powerful group and you're a pariah. Not because many people think you've done something wrong, because these people would join you in the pariah ditch if they talk to you.

That's not how it should be.

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by confidantlake on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @09:22PM (#25757185)
I have my doubts the USSR would allow a private CRM supplier not controlled by the state to exist. Criticism of any sort on social media also seems dubious.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by maxehmookau on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:22AM (#25746448)
At no point in human history has the USSR existed at the same time as modern social media.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by heyoni on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @11:56PM (#25758347)
Oh man, I totally forget how much overlap there is between communist Russia and cancel culture.

/s just in case

Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by secfirstmd on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:20AM (#25746411)
True. And one big difference. You don't get to choose to be gay, have a disability or be from a minority or whatever. You do however choose to go to a Capital Hill riot or be complicit in supporting a dangerous man with autocratic tendencies.
Re:Salesforce says it has 'taken action' to prevent further ... by themaninthedark on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:42AM (#25746711)
You do however choose your religion and yet that is a protected class...

This is not a road we should be going down.