News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by alevskaya on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:37PM (#25697075)
Sadly, note that the study talked about here [1] is investigating the effect of the N501Y mutation, not the more worrying E484K mutation found in the South African 501.v2 strain that likely does escape antibody drugs and reduces neutralization by convalescent sera from past infections. [2]

[1]: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.01.07.425740v1

[2]: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.12.31.425021v1

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by partingshots on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:45AM (#25701274)
For the vaccine to lose effectiveness, the mutation would have to drastically alter the spike protein of the virus.

This is effectively impossible as the virus is dependent on a functioning spike protein in order to infect cells, and the machinery involved with the mechanics of the spike are extremely delicate. Errant mutations that would cause compositional changes to the shape of the protein are almost guaranteed to cause functional failure. Using terminology, this is what we call a highly conserved area.

In both cases for the South African or UK strain, if you take a look at the areas where mutations have occurred, you’ll see that the code responsible for generating the spike protein is basically completely unaffected. This will generally hold true for any successive future strains.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:27PM (#25702994)
This doesn't make much sense to me, given that coronaviruses, with spike proteins, have existed for eons, and humans have had lots of time to build up immunity to previous coronaviruses (ones that cause colds, for example). So there was something about the Covid-19 coronavirus spike proteins that was different enough where it didn't look like "familiar" coronaviruses, so I see no reason why it couldn't evolve further to evade whatever antibodies humans are able to build up to the vaccines.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by sudosysgen on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:47PM (#25703212)
You can make multiple spike proteins that target the same receptor.

This generally happens when a virus from another animal (and thus with a slightly different version of the receptor) adapts to humans.

Basically, a gradient descent from a very different starting point ending up in a different local minima.

The question is, is the spike protein at a local minima (very probably quite close to it), and could it jump to another local minima then? Most likely not.

It's possible it will evolve to make our antibodies slightly less effective, likely as a trade off for infectiousness, but incredibly unlikely the spike protein would evolve to be unrecognizable to our immune systems. Historically, this doesn't happen all that often, except for viruses with chronic infections over years that can do a deeper search over the gradient, but even then it generally takes years to decades.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by lawrenceyan on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:55PM (#25704638)
Given the non-linear dynamics that proteins must live under, I like the usage of local minima as an analogy. It feels apt.

Generally though, within the context of machine learning, one of the benefits of gradient descent, especially when stochastic, is that we can get past those local minima humps. Does this hold less true with respect to the process of sequence mutation that viruses go through?

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by jhrmnn on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:50AM (#25712482)
Another way how to characterize the "context of [deep] machine learning" is that it is the regime of high temperature (stochasticity) as a result of small batches and/or large learning rates, and/or the regime of high momentum (Adam et al.). The evolutionary dynamics in the genetic space is (intuitively) at much lower temperature (shorter jumps) and with no momentum (because of the evolutionary pressure).
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by sudosysgen on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:55PM (#25707778)
The difference in viruses is that if you get on the hump, you are outcompeted by other viruses that stayed in the minimum, which makes it a lot more difficult.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by lawrenceyan on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:59PM (#25719735)
That makes a lot of sense. Thanks!
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dimgl on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:50PM (#25704605)
This is extremely interesting. Thanks for this context. Detailed and thoughtful explanations like this help to understand the news.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by rolph on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:58PM (#25703345)
you are speaking about a general case scenario, there is conservation of sequence region and variation of sequence region. to wit one protien encoding sequence has separate regions corresponding to regions of the product protien, the receptor binding domain[RBD] is a moderately conserved region ; the ImmunoAntigenic regions are not tightly linked to the protiens receptor binding function thus may vary at a greater rate than the RBD regions
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by alevskaya on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:44PM (#25703163)
This isn't correct. The constraints placed upon epitopes by the cell receptor vs antibodies aren't the same. Rhinoviruses and Influenza viruses escape past immunity without fundamentally altering their biology all the time! The 2nd paper cited does in fact show functional virus with a charge-shifting E->K mutation in its receptor binding domain that escape many antibodies raised against earlier strains. I used to engineer viruses and human immune cells for a living - maybe read a little more virology/immunology.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by enchiridion on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:03AM (#25701437)
While that may be true, I think that scale plays a role here.

The ancestors of this virus were bouncing around between a relatively small set of humans and animals for a while before becoming SARS-CoV-2.

Now with a significant portion of the world infected, it does not seem unreasonable that it would mutate. Although at that point it probably would not be considered the same virus anymore.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by whoisburbansky on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:46PM (#25697148)
Am I reading the second paper correctly when I say this was conducted on a sample size of 11, and they found that the E484K mutation had saw no reduction in neutralization in some of those subjects? I’m trying to get a better sense of the numbers involved to figure out how much credence to lend to the dangers posed by the second mutation.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by alevskaya on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:55PM (#25697226)
It's unlikely to _completely_ escape immunity - humans will raise antibodies against different regions of the spike protein, but it does seem to confer a pretty significant average resistance to patient sera. There's another study looking specifically at several different monoclonal antibodies against this mutation at: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7723407/
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by robbiep on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:54AM (#25698504)
No idea why the downvotes here (at initial time of writing), that’s literally how the immune system functions, it’s a random process and everybody’s antibody DNA will be different to someone else’s antibody sequence against the same antigen.

No vaccine is training the body on the exact antibody to raise, it’s training it to (hopefully, because sometimes the stochastic process missed) recognise particular epitopes.

Important to also note that generally (and particularly during early infection) there will be many antibodies that recognise parts of an antigen.

Affinity Maturation through somatic hypermutation is one of the most amazing processes the body does - look it up or for a very brief summary look at my notes on page 32 (or the whole mechanism of adaptive immunity from 27) with a little diagram on page 28

https://www.dropbox.com/s/4ldgs4v9y99anm8/BCHM%203072%20Note...

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by l33tman on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:30AM (#25699525)
It truly is. In early medschool we had a group student session on the adaptive immune system where we had to brainstorm on antibody generation and nobody in the group even came up with an idea remotely close to how it actually works. Robust and amazing. Talk about brute-force searching.

Still, at this day my hope is that we'll be able to do the body's work even better at some point using computer designed antibodies (or similar) at least for therapies. There are some notable bottlenecks in the adaptive system where antigen fragments have to be broken down and shown to potential antibodies and this is a bit different between humans etc. The human antibody molecule is also very large and it's particular design doesn't fit some epitopes you'd want to hit (not an expert on it but I remember one of the HIV proteins having an area you'd want to train on but that can't accommodate the antibody variable fragments well).

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by vendiddy on Sunday January 10, 2021 @07:44AM (#25714147)
I have only a high school biology background so I had trouble understanding.

Could you please explain in simpler terms what this means?

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by whoisburbansky on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:03AM (#25697305)
When you say average here, is that in the sense of average resistance over time for a given patient or average resistance across a population? The paper seemed to imply a great deal of heterogeneity in individual responses to the variant, so significant average would just be something like part of the population affected very badly, another part not at all, vs everyone affected mildly?
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by alevskaya on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:14AM (#25697411)
Averaged over a population - some people will have resistant sera and others not depending on the parts of sars-cov-2 targeted by their polyvalent antibody response. Note that this is only looking at antibodies, not T-cell responses... so the clinical consequences are harder to predict, but it's certainly a bit concerning.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by whoisburbansky on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:20AM (#25697471)
Ah, I see. Thanks, that clears things up quite a bit. It’s potentially mildly bad news but not the end of the world, is what it sounds like then.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by mvanaltvorst on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:26AM (#25699790)
Say that Pfizer were able to simulate 50 possible mutations and put all of them into a single vaccine, would there be any risk that the antibodies could interact with each other in some way that makes the vaccines less effective?

Also another scenario: say that we get yearly Covid shots that contain the latest strains, would these accumulate over the years and start interacting with each other?

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Retric on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:29AM (#25700168)
As I understand it, the second isn’t an issue so 50 vaccines over 50 years would be fine, that’s how seasonal flu vaccines are done.

The first is mostly a question of how similar they are. Best case original vaccine covers all strains without modification, worst case you need 50 different vaccines. But the most likely combination is a mix where you might need say 5 vaccines, each of which over an overlapping subset of the 50 strains to various degrees of effectiveness.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by danarmak on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:55AM (#25700353)
The immune system presumably has a limited capacity of circulating antibodies. By introducing new antibodies, do we reduce the amount of previous antibodies, and does this reduce their immune response? Is there a concept or metric of "antibody dilution"?
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Retric on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:57AM (#25700376)
Antibody production ramps up and down rapidly, it’s memory cells that get altered by vaccines. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immunological_memory

That said the immune system is extremely complex, but here is a simplified version, which gives a reasonable overview: https://microbenotes.com/cells-of-the-immune-system/

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dannyw on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:41PM (#25702445)
While correlation is not causation, I find it interesting that the human immune system only remembers the common cold and seasonal influenza for several months, but diseases like the polio for much longer.

https://biology.stackexchange.com/a/21802

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by TylerE on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:47PM (#25704569)
"The common cold" is a loose nebula of hundreds of different, unrelated, virus strains. They're not even all the same TYPE of virus.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by f430 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:18AM (#25697907)
> does escape antibody drugs and reduces neutralization by convalescent sera from past infections

what does this mean in plain words? this SA variant has a totally new evasion system?

what exactly are we dealing with here? what causes it to rapidly mutate like this?

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dnautics on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:05AM (#25698207)
Viruses are typically rapidly mutating so you should consider them to be a fuzzy statistical ensemble around the "official" sequence, even in one patient. Therefore these viruses can facilely jump over hills in the gradient descent of optimization; but keep in mind optimization is not just a one-factor thing. If you are interested in this the keyword is "viral metagenome"

An E to K mutation converts a surface negative charge to a surface positive charge. So if your antibodies were expecting a negative charge and therefore putting positive charges near that place when they attach to the virus, the polarity on the mutant has now shifted and the antibodies will be repelled from the mutant virus.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by martin_bech on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:02AM (#25700869)
Afaik not all rapidly mutating, HIV seems to be mutating at a rapid pace, yet measels apparently largely never mutates.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dnautics on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:42AM (#25701841)
That's why I said typically, not always.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by sudosysgen on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:55PM (#25703299)
The majority of viruses do not mutate rapidly enough to evade immunity. The exceptions are virus with chronic infections because they can mutate much more easily, and some viruses like Influenza that can use antigenic shifts.

It's really not typical. Even in all of the human cold coronaviruses, only one seems to be evolving its spike protein, and it does so quite slowly.

If it was typical, we wouldn't see the amazing efficacy of vaccines against endemic diseases.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Erlich_Bachman on Saturday January 09, 2021 @05:03AM (#25699073)
> Therefore these viruses can facilely jump over hills in the gradient descent of optimization

It warms to see that the similarities of some aspects of biological life to the current AI/ML terms has entered the lexicon, well at least on HN crowd. The fact that it makes a lot of sense to use those terms hints that we might indeed be on the right track to building AGI and understnding the life itself in general.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dnautics on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:41AM (#25701818)
Objective cost surfaces have been around way longer than ml. It's been in the genetic algorithm lexicon for a long time, and more true to form, in stuff like actual potential energy diagrams of high dimensional degrees of freedom spaces in enzymology. Also having been a professional biochemist and worked in AI infrastructure, I know the commonalities well and know how to avoid faux-amis.

Note that this process is NOT backpropagation.

"The fact that it makes a lot of sense to use those terms hints that we might indeed be on the right track to building AGI and understnding the life itself in general"

Nope, it's a residual of the fact that AI stole ideas from other fields, and ran with the terminology as marketing. Sometimes even to the point of extreme divergence from the original ("neural" nets).

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by hutzlibu on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:44AM (#25699913)
"The fact that it makes a lot of sense to use those terms hints that we might indeed be on the right track to building AGI "

But there is also the danger of false analogies doing damage, by creating the illusion of understanding something because the wording feels familiar.

There are no doubts similarities, but that does not mean, it is the same.

That happened a couple of times already with progess in technology and then simplified applied technical models to biological life.

So sure, I think so too, that we are on the right track, I am just a bit more hesistant.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by quonn on Saturday January 09, 2021 @05:40AM (#25699264)
How is there gradient descent or even a gradient in biological mutations? If anything there could be an analogy to undirected trial & error as in genetic algorithms.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Erlich_Bachman on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:06AM (#25700053)
It's directed by the survival and spreading of the virus.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by RobertoG on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:13AM (#25699432)
I think that they are using "gradient descend" when they should be using "space of the problem". Otherwise is a good comment.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by jsinai on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:42AM (#25699578)
meta, what if it was just GPT-3 commenting and there was just leakage from the ML community
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by mvanaltvorst on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:15AM (#25699733)
Gradient descent is a subset of survival of the fittest, described by Darwin in 1800-1900, and has been in applied in computer science since the 70's. An AGI will probably use some form of gradient descent during its training, yes, but I wouldn't argue that this has brought us even close to an AGI.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dnautics on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:29PM (#25702311)
This is wrong. Gradient descent derives from multivariate calculus, not evolution.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by esyir on Saturday January 09, 2021 @01:25AM (#25697949)
It's a virus. Mutation to avoid detection is par the course.

Essentially, each replication means mutation, and over time, variants emerge. Think of why you need a seasonal flu vaccine and not one flu vaccine.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by jonplackett on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:29AM (#25698642)
It’s just evolution - we put social distancing and masks in place, so variants that can overcome those emerged and spread.

Think of it like antibiotic resistance - our crappy attempt at lockdown was like not finishing the course. We gave it loads of places to multiply but didn’t finish it off so it just adapted

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by FuckButtons on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:18AM (#25700552)
The mutations don’t arise because of selection pressure against masks and social distancing, that is dangerously wrong. They arise in an individual patient who has a poor immune response who can’t clear the virus for a long time. As their immune response tries to clear the virus it adapts to be more effective over many generations inside that patient. That’s why we have distinct lineages, each of these variants with multiple distinct mutations probably arose in a single person.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dnautics on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:01AM (#25698174)
An N to Y mutation is associated with tighter specificity in binding protein protein interfaces. An E to K mutation is changing the surface charge from negative to positive so it shouldn't be surprising that it reduces antibody's ability to recognize, assuming it's in the most recognized pocket. Hopefully this will be a relatively easy cut and paste into the existing vaccine cassette if it turns out to spread really widely.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by JamesBarney on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:30AM (#25698359)
I'm far more worried about the FDA and logistics than technical limitations.

Even if you could make this fix in a day, it'll take months to get FDA approval, and then you still have to manufacture and distribute it. And by that time the populous will have gotten immunity the old fashion way.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dnautics on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:38AM (#25698408)
Indeed. And the likelihood of escape are worse the greater the infected population x time to new vaccine. I'm increasingly worried that covid-19 is the slow loris of viruses. Too slow and mild to warrant panic-mode measures (I don't mean lockdowns), just gonna be an annual millimation of the population.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by howlgarnish on Saturday January 09, 2021 @03:07AM (#25698566)
Aren't we in panic mode measures already? I'm not sure there's much more most countries can realistically implement even if there's a 10x more lethal variant.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by the8472 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @05:55AM (#25699333)
During initial containment china welded apartments shut and organized essentials deliveries by dedicated couriers for each city block. And then there's the option of military-enforced cordons. There are multiple levels of panic left untapped.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by howlgarnish on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:09AM (#25700479)
That's why I said "most countries", because in (say) the US the government couldn't pull that off even if they tried. (For one thing, it's hard to weld shut suburban housing.)
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by nicoburns on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:42AM (#25701837)
Perhaps, but if the virus was as transmissible as sars-cov-2, but had a much higher fatality rate (say 60% like Ebola). Then you would get a lot more support for strict measures amongst the general population.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by meddlepal on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:08AM (#25698806)
I think Parents point was that eventually we will have to give up on panic mode and accept deaths from this each year.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dnautics on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:43AM (#25701855)
I said "not lockdowns". I meant things like "strip down the phase testing" etc.

I see no evidence we are doing that.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by jb1991 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:18AM (#25698847)
I wonder why it says:

> works against a key mutation in the highly transmissible new variants of the coronavirus discovered in Britain and South Africa

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dmix on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:59AM (#25701400)
Both the South African and UK variant seem to be under the name 501Y.V2 but the South African version has a mutation not seen in the UK strain:

> The variant in South Africa carries two other mutations in the spike protein (E484K and K417N, among others) which are not present in the U.K. strain

This three day old article also anticipated this study results:

> While scientists believe the U.K. variant is not likely to affect the efficacy of the vaccines currently being rolled out in the West, there is more uncertainty regarding the other strain.

https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/06/south-africa-covid-strain-a-...

I’m guessing they are both of the same “strain” but of different “variant”. But I don’t know enough about how virus taxonomy works to validate that. Sounds like two levels of mutation...

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by zebrafish on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:19PM (#25702211)
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by pageandrew on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:40PM (#25697102)
Does the 501.v2 strain resist vaccine antibodies as well, or only things like the antibody cocktail / convalescent plasma therapy?
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by whoisburbansky on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:48PM (#25697169)
The first paper describes the effect of mRNA based vaccine derived serum on both variants, showing that both variants are affected about equally by the vaccine, if I’m not horribly mistaken?
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by alevskaya on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:56PM (#25697234)
The first study is only studying the effect of the N501Y mutation as found in several emergent strains, not the E484K mutation.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by whoisburbansky on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:01AM (#25697282)
Yes, sorry, I phrased that badly. I meant N501 and Y501 when I said both variants here.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by alevskaya on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:48PM (#25697176)
What I meant by sera above was general adaptive immunity. It's likely to partially resist past immunity from both vaccines (esp. from the spike-only vaccines: moderna, pfizer, etc) and natural infections from older strains. We'll probably know a lot more about it soon, but we may need to update our vaccines to include this mutant class.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by TheRealSteel on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:29AM (#25700171)
Does this mean there's now a variant that is immune to all the vaccines, and we're basically back at square one with the pandemic?!?! :( or am I misunderstanding? Is it still protected against from mRNA vaccines, but just not prevented by immunity from past infections?

I have no knowledge of biology whatsoever.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by graeme on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:43AM (#25700258)
Not square one. It’s unlikely there would be 0% efficacy. But it could be less.

But also not square one because it takes literally a day to redesign mrna vaccines for new variants. Then hopefully they can be approved faster the second go and manufactured/distributed more quickly.

But I’d say all northern hemisphere countries should do their best to focus on local elimination in summer 2021. Most of europe had it in reach summer 2020 but decided to reopen early and keep the virus at a low level.

That was an abject failure. It probably only would have taken another month of heavy restrictions to eliminate.

The mutations we’re seeing in the winter of high case volumes caution against doing another cycle like this.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:55AM (#25700805)
> But I’d say all northern hemisphere countries should do their best to focus on local elimination in summer 2021.

This isn’t realistic. Fatigue with COVID restrictions has already set in across Europe: people are wearing masks in sloppy ways (not covering the nose, or even just putting the mask over their chin) and returning to socializing or even leisure travel. The authorities know this, and while they can do things like keep restaurants and theatres closed, they appear to feel little democratic mandate for using the police to enforce strict social separation between individuals. And that is in the winter: once the warm weather comes back, expect even more flaunting of restrictions.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by graeme on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:05AM (#25701465)
That happened summer 2020 and look where things ended up. There are a few factors I think you’re missing:

1. The virus is seasonal. Substantially less restrictions are needed over the summer. Outdoor socialization really isn’t high risk

2. School is out. This naturally lowers spread

3. A bunch of people will be vaccinated. This will surely make it easier

4. We’ll probably have new rapid tests by the summer. They go a long way to reducing spread without much inconvenience. Michael Mina has been banging his head against the wall for months to get people to listen: these can be as effective as lockdowns and much less burdensome.

5. At least some countries will figure this out, go for elimination, and require a vaccine/negative test for entry and make travel arrangements with other covid zero areas

Now it might be the vaccines work perfectly, no mutant strains escape them, and we won’t have a repeat of this in fall/winter 2021/22.

But if that scenario does seem likely them elimination is overwhelmingly the best option. And society that can’t pull itself together to do that will live in a purgatory.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by disabled on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:55PM (#25707771)
> 4. We’ll probably have new rapid tests by the summer. They go a long way to reducing spread without much inconvenience. Michael Mina has been banging his head against the wall for months to get people to listen: these can be as effective as lockdowns and much less burdensome.

The “inconvenience” in the USA (besides outright coronavirus deniers and people who flout restrictions in contempt of expert and professional public health officials) is that there is no guaranteed paid sick/isolation leave if one is ordered to go into isolation. Given that 40% of Americans have less than $400 for a “rainy day”, going to work while sick may be necessary. Also, in a lot of cases, no job: no health insurance, which is tragic and consequential during a pandemic.

You also need to have a strong public health system in place well in advance, where citizens already have been following and adhering to prevention programs for a long time, along with trust in the system. The EU countries generally do better with this, in the most general sense, but it depends on the country. For example, there are published reports of what percent of the country’s population washes their hands every time after they use the restroom. Some of the more “eastern” EU countries (which are now westernized) do way better that west/north Europe.

Also, some countries routinely issue self-isolation orders for 14 days, and the police will check, multiple times. In some countries these fines are over $1,200 for the first offense, and for the second offense, it’s $20,000. Both of these fines are unaffordable for the majority of the population.

Anyways, my point is that rapid self tests do work, but it requires a properly functioning government, with a strong public health system, and a cooperative public that trusts their officials and adheres to public health recommendations well before a pandemic occurs.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by graeme on Sunday January 10, 2021 @07:34AM (#25714067)
This is true about the US. Nonetheless, every day people need to be hospitalized with covid or stay home because they’re too sick to work.

So over the long run there’s much more turmoil of the type you speak of. But I agree the US needs a better system for letting the contagious stay home.

Perfect needn’t be the enemy of the good though. If, say, 45% of people could isolate, then having them know they’re positive could help too.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by FuckButtons on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:13AM (#25700509)
That was very much the opinion of the immunologists I have been reading the opinions of recently. Giving this virus opportunity to mutate through allowing circulation is playing with fire next to a dynamite factory.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by TheRealSteel on Saturday January 09, 2021 @09:47AM (#25700755)
Great, thanks for the info. mRNA tech really is amazing!!

I agree. Everywhere should've pursued elimination strategy like Australia and New Zealand, and even at this late stage would be the best option.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:05AM (#25701467)
> Everywhere should've pursued elimination strategy like Australia and New Zealand

Australia and New Zealand were very unusual in having that possibility, not everyone could have followed such a strategy. The EU had to move thousands and thousands of migrant agricultural workers from Eastern Europe to Western Europe for the harvests, otherwise there would have been scarcities of common foodstuffs. Also goods move through Europe largely through freight trucks that mean drivers moving about, not container shipping like the two island nations you mention.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by graeme on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:21AM (#25701617)
I’m in Atlantic Canada, where we had eliminated it locally. We moved in agricultural workers, it was fine. We just had an isolation requirement and testing.

We have freight trucks from the US too! A lot of obstacles are not, in fact, insurmountable. The actual issue is that most places weren’t aiming at elimination.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:25AM (#25701653)
> We moved in agricultural workers, it was fine. We just had an isolation requirement and testing.

As you might remember, there was a shortage of tests the first time that the EU needed to move its agricultural workers en masse (which happened already in the spring – harvests in Spain are more or less continuous, unlike Atlantic Canada where it is much more restricted seasonally). Also, many of those agricultural laborers live in precarious working conditions that the state has little insight into, and arranging any kind of isolation on short notice was not possible.

The EU was not aiming at total elimination because the virus had already spread throughout the bloc practically before the authorities were even aware of it and again, these are not island nations.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by graeme on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:33AM (#25701740)
Sure but you had until the end of August to end it. Spring was the early days. And it would have been conceivable to try to eliminate it locally in sectors other than agriculture. Deal with the easy buts first and then the hard bits after. Often the hard bits become easier in so doing.

You could have kept internal border controls except for essential work. We did that in Atlantic Canada. Australian states did that. We’re just as integrated as the EU is! We never had a border at any point in our history. So we set one up.

There are non islands that more or less eliminated it. China, vietnam for example.

Harder in the EU? More complicated? Absolutely. But the policy the EU pursued was an abject failure, so merely saying “there would have been difficulties” doesn’t show that elimination would have been worse. The places that reduced covid better generally saw better economic results too.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Mediterraneo10 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @02:01PM (#25703381)
> You could have kept internal border controls except for essential work.

Lack of internal borders in the EU is one of the most important features of the bloc, both in terms of maintaining close integration that could prevent more intra-European wars and in terms of mere everyday convenience. I would gladly sacrifice the demographic most at risk of COVID (about half of all deaths in the EU so far have been in care homes) in order to avoid internal borders.

Also, China has been able to eliminate COVID (and even that is subject to doubt) only through civil-rights violations that the West would not tolerate. Pointing to China and saying "They did it, so the EU could too" misses the point. Vietnam was able to avoid a surge in COVID cases only because they hadn’t yet got the huge number of cases that the EU had first without even being aware of it; of course if somewhere else is already suffering, and you aren’t, you can close the borders and avoid the problems from the start.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by mckirk on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:34AM (#25700201)
From what I've gathered, it's more like: It's likely that the vaccine will have reduced efficacy (seen over the whole population) against this new strain. That's because your immune system essentially learns to recognize a random part of the virus, and if it ends up "training" itself using that part of the spike protein that's changed in this strain, it won't detect the virus.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by ksk on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:55AM (#25701362)
The pfizer vaccine also elicits T Cell response/cell mediated immunity. I'm guessing there are a few more studies in the pipeline..