News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Erlich_Bachman on Saturday January 09, 2021 @05:03AM (#25699073)
> Therefore these viruses can facilely jump over hills in the gradient descent of optimization

It warms to see that the similarities of some aspects of biological life to the current AI/ML terms has entered the lexicon, well at least on HN crowd. The fact that it makes a lot of sense to use those terms hints that we might indeed be on the right track to building AGI and understnding the life itself in general.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dnautics on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:41AM (#25701818)
Objective cost surfaces have been around way longer than ml. It's been in the genetic algorithm lexicon for a long time, and more true to form, in stuff like actual potential energy diagrams of high dimensional degrees of freedom spaces in enzymology. Also having been a professional biochemist and worked in AI infrastructure, I know the commonalities well and know how to avoid faux-amis.

Note that this process is NOT backpropagation.

"The fact that it makes a lot of sense to use those terms hints that we might indeed be on the right track to building AGI and understnding the life itself in general"

Nope, it's a residual of the fact that AI stole ideas from other fields, and ran with the terminology as marketing. Sometimes even to the point of extreme divergence from the original ("neural" nets).

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by hutzlibu on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:44AM (#25699913)
"The fact that it makes a lot of sense to use those terms hints that we might indeed be on the right track to building AGI "

But there is also the danger of false analogies doing damage, by creating the illusion of understanding something because the wording feels familiar.

There are no doubts similarities, but that does not mean, it is the same.

That happened a couple of times already with progess in technology and then simplified applied technical models to biological life.

So sure, I think so too, that we are on the right track, I am just a bit more hesistant.

Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by quonn on Saturday January 09, 2021 @05:40AM (#25699264)
How is there gradient descent or even a gradient in biological mutations? If anything there could be an analogy to undirected trial & error as in genetic algorithms.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by Erlich_Bachman on Saturday January 09, 2021 @08:06AM (#25700053)
It's directed by the survival and spreading of the virus.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by RobertoG on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:13AM (#25699432)
I think that they are using "gradient descend" when they should be using "space of the problem". Otherwise is a good comment.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by jsinai on Saturday January 09, 2021 @06:42AM (#25699578)
meta, what if it was just GPT-3 commenting and there was just leakage from the ML community
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by mvanaltvorst on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:15AM (#25699733)
Gradient descent is a subset of survival of the fittest, described by Darwin in 1800-1900, and has been in applied in computer science since the 70's. An AGI will probably use some form of gradient descent during its training, yes, but I wouldn't argue that this has brought us even close to an AGI.
Re:Pfizer vaccine appears effective against mutation in new ... by dnautics on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:29PM (#25702311)
This is wrong. Gradient descent derives from multivariate calculus, not evolution.