One reason is to devote an older machine to Linux (M1 models are still new, but they wont be in 3-4 years. And in 6-7 years they might not be supported by new then MacOS releases at all (only security fixes). When someone gets the M4 or MX, they might want to retire the M1 models, or use them for server/supportive roles with Linux on them.
Others just prefer Mac hardware (Linus Torvalds himself was a big fan of the early Macbook Air, which we used with Linux, and has welcomed the M1 model as well) but Linux software for various reasons.
I, for one, ocassionally wish to boot to full native Linux for some stuff. I have several Linux computers I use too, but I usually use those headless, whereas a Mac laptop would be great with a good supported Linux.
>What are you guys doing that you have to install linux instead of running a VM or remotely connecting to a linux box? If it's just for the sake of knowledge I can understand it.
Besides repurposing an old Mac, even running a desktop environment as your primary or secondary driver is much faster and usable with bare metal (as opposed to a VM) and, of course, impossible with remote boxes (X forwarding aside, which is not workable as raw native desktop).
If I buy a 2022 Macbook Air, I'd like to repeat this process for it in 2032. Moore's law is dead, treasure your hardware.
I don't see how it's superior. For that money you can buy Dell XPS or Thinkpad of same quality or better.
> but it falls short on every other metric
So far I didn't see any evidence of that. That may be true in 2011-2012 where not many laptops had hires screens with decent matrices, but definitely not relevant today.
I'm not sure I would say that the XPS is equal or better quality than the MBP though.
The trackpad isn't better than the Mac's and neither is the case construction. I prefer the aluminium unibody to the carbon fibre (rubberised plastic) stuck to aluminium plates of the XPS.
I really like the XPS though and would buy another if it broke. i.e. I wouldn't buy a Mac to run Linux but when Apple finally stop supporting my MBP I see no reason not to install Linux on it and extend its life. Especially as I like Linux as a desktop OS.
https://www.appleworld.today/blog/2020/6/1/apples-mac-get-a-...
It varies by year and place though.
As for Apple, you buy a 3 year warranty with AppleCare for less than the surface costs and that includes accidental damage for a small excess fee per event.
What? Maybe this is true for the M1-based MacBooks now, but I bought my Surface Book 3 with my Microsoft Business account (which was made for me for free when I bought my Surface Book 2 by a manager at the Dallas, TX Microsoft Store) and for $249 I got a three year warranty with three accidental damage incidents, also with no deductible. Yes, I had to pony up for a year of Office 365 for $69 to get the normally-$349 warranty for $100 off, but I already use Office 365 yearly sub anyway, so adding on an extra year of something I was going to buy anyway, for $100 off a 3-year, 3-incident, deductible-free warranty isn't exactly a "hard sell".
Although the only problem I've ever had with Microsoft's hardware products was my original Surface Book, and I'll admit, that was a miserable experience, but I had zero problems with my SB2 and none so far with my SB3.
Having said all that, I might actually switch over to Apple if they had a 15" 2-in-1 like my SB3. In order to functionally replace my Surface Book 3, I have to buy a $1499 12.9" iPad Pro, a $129 Apple Pencil 2nd gen, and a $2299 MacBook Pro M1. Adding Apple Care+ and tax brings the total up to $4670. But I also now have the problem of having to lug around two devices instead of just once as I do with the Surface Book 3. My totally pimped out Surface Book 3 + warranty + Office 365 1-year sub was $4350. That's the Quadro RTX 3000 MaxQ version also.
Right now, the Apple products have the performance advantage, I can't deny that. But they didn't have that when I bought my Surface Book 3, and Microsoft isn't going to sit on their ass. Their ARM-based Surface Pro X is following Microsoft trends perfectly. The first version of all their hardware ranges anywhere from a total joke to slightly underwhelming. But by the time 3rd and 4th iterations, Microsoft has their shit together. I fully expect that in 2-3 years, a Microsoft ARM-based Surface Book 5/6 will be a serious MacBook Pro contender, while also winning over users like me for the 2-in-1 aspect.
As for how many people run Linux on bare metal on the Mac. That's hard to guess. Likely not a ton. But then... not a ton of anyone runs Linux as their primary desktop/ laptop so that's not surprising.
The "fiasco keyboard" period aside (which is now 1.5+ years over, and which reliability aside, some do prefer its feel), Mac keyboards have been quite fine.
But one famous person that used to buy Macbooks to run Linux as a primary one (and used an Air as his daily driver for years) was a certain Linus Torvalds.
(Previously he also used an Apple G5 tower for his main desktop).
https://www.zdnet.com/article/linus-torvalds-reveals-his-fav...
https://www.zdnet.com/article/look-whats-inside-linus-torval...
I have a 10 year old Bluetooth magic keyboard and a 10 year old USB magic keyboard and both work perfectly with windows.
Be warned, they are difficult to Bluetooth pair with windows for the first time, usually takes 10 tries for me.
You also pay a hefty premium for MacOS if you are just running Linux.
You can’t run Linux on the M1 yet, but will this still true when you can? How does price / performance of the M1 air compare to x86 laptops? (Or the Mac mini vs other small form factor PCs?)
There are features that are unique to Linux, like cgroups and KVM, that are nice to use on my main OS. The kernel itself is incredibly configurable and extensible, whereas on macOS the kernel is locked away and Apple has deprecated foreign kext support.
Another example is Linux's native FUSE support. I can use an updated version of sshfs on Linux that isn't available on macOS and solves problems I had with sshfs on macOS. I have to use closed source software to even use FUSE on macOS.
Using Linux on a VM or over SSH to do things I couldn't do on macOS was frustrating, and it's a breath of fresh air to run Linux natively.
Also, I prefer Plasma Desktop to the macOS desktop shell. KWin is scriptable, and KDE is really nice.
> Apple's touch pad experience in MacOS is the best in the market and it is always very different in Windows and Linux.
I disagree with this. Libinput is configurable and its adaptive acceleration profile feels more natural to me.
If Linux had software support for it, it would probably be the best platform for Linux (server) software development.
Same reason you run Linux on a Dell or Other laptop. Because you prefer Linux. In Apple's case, the M1 is particularly appealing right now.
For me personally, this project is mostly interesting as insurance for if/ when Apple ships a version of MacOS I don't care for or stops supporting the M1. That's likely... 10 years out, but you never know.
That said... it would be fantastic to have Linux as a backup.
For "why not Linux on not-M1," I vastly prefer reading and writing AArch64 assembly to amd64... And the battery-life+performance claims of M1 are certainly extremely exciting, coming from a Pinebook Pro (which has the battery life, but pretty wimpy performance by comparison).
I assume it won't be as long in Linux but it'll still be longer than a lightweight and high performance x86 laptop.
Because OSX, besides being a user prison, is certainly far from being as good as their hardware.
I've got an iMac 2020 here, I log into iTerm2 and macports has every things I want, installed cleanly and co-operatively with the Apple frameworks and kernel.
I'm running Firefox and Thunderbird and Office 365, all native. I also have suppler supported clients for iMessage, Whatsapp, Telegram, Skype, Spotify (whether Electron or not).
I have developer utilities like Dash, which is one of the best documentation browsers ever, I have native UI neovim with VimR, I have menu bar utilities for monitoring, cloud sync with Google and Microsoft (and iCloud if I wanted).
How exactly am I in a user prison? I'm running the Beta Big Sur and the only bug so far is that the Karabiner kext doesn't load.
Nope. fact check true. Unsigned software will not run on a Mac without having to jump through hoops to enable each app.
I predominantly use open source software, and a lot is not signed.
I used to dual boot windows for school and when I first switched to windows I had an old laptop's backup in bootcamp. Cross-platform software is much more ubiquitous than 5-10 years ago. For linux I always used another box or just run a VM. Nowadays my laptop can ssh or Remote Desktop into a more powerful machine. I have a custom built widows box, a custom built NAS running FreeNas (FreeBSD), 2 RPi's running Raspbian, and a not always linux box based on old hardware. There is a machine big or small to do things or play with. My VPN allows me to connect from anywhere.
What are you guys doing that you have to install linux instead of running a VM or remotely connecting to a linux box? If it's just for the sake of knowledge I can understand it.
Apple's touch pad experience in MacOS is the best in the market and it is always very different in Windows and Linux. The XPS, Lenovo and smaller vendors really make killer Linux/Windows laptops that have much more options than Macs.