I remember being at a product design meeting when Windows RT was about to be released and every feature that we wanted to bring over from our flagship x86 software, our tech lead kept repeatedly saying "no we can't do that. The API does not allow it". Finally we said fk it, let's come back to this in a year or two after Microsoft gets their act together. And we never did.
It's not that Microsoft and co don't/didn't care about ARM. A more accurate description of the situation is a lack of BELIEF or conviction about PC-class ARM.
The M1 situation can be likened to smart phones before the iPhone. No one believed it was possible to make a device that could be operated entirely with the fingers - they all needed styluses.
Microsoft and the PC industry has literally spent billions of dollars on ARM. Microsoft alone lost $990 million[1] on Surface RT, their ARM version of Microsoft surface. Microsoft's next ARM device Surface Pro X has meh sales. HP, DELL lost money on their Windows RT devices[2]
In other words, ARM on Microsoft land has failed not for lack of effort, or some grand conspiracy - just lack of example.
Now that the entire industry can SEE a laptop class ARM processor that does not suck, someone will come up with an appropriate response within a few years. I doubt it'll be Qualcomm.
Microsoft failed to have an emulator for legacy software ready to go on day one.
They also failed to produce ARM versions of their own software in a timely manner.
Heck, Microsoft sold Surface RT as a tablet without producing a version of Office that had a touch based UI.
If you can't be bothered to produce software that supports the features of your own OS, why should anyone else?
They didn't "fail", they were waiting for x64 patents to expire.
Apple introducing M1 macs literally the year the relevant x64 patents expired is not a complete coincidence ;)
Apple took half a decade to do this transition. First including the T1 chip, then slowly growing it, and finally upgrading that to an M1 as they dropped the Intel chip.
And that’s just what we say, internally, it surely took more than that.
MS does a quick and dirty attempt at thing, while they’re also trying out other directions. Nothings gonna work if you don’t have a clear direction.
Exactly as mdasen said: they wouldn't commit to it.
This is, of course, unsurprising, as Microsoft has a long and storied history of refusing to take real risks and only going into significant new territory when Apple has already paved the way. But that doesn't make it less of a fault in Microsoft.
Don't the M1 Macs come with some performant-enough emulation system (that most people didn't consider possible) that allows you to run x86 apps? I feel like this is key to avoiding the chicken-and-egg effect.
Now that Apple has proven it to be possible, others may follow. Ultimately, users don't care about their CPU architecture, they care about being able to run their software.
If you make users choose between a new platform that promises to "soon" be able to run 80% of the software (but currently runs at best 50%) or a slower, more expensive version that runs everything, the new platform has no chance.
If the new platform can run the existing software, albeit "only" as fast as their old platform (because the advances in CPU speed make up for the emulation overhead), this huge obstacle simply disappears.
My understanding is a major contributing factor is that Apple added Intel's memory-ordering to their Arm chips, which allows Rosetta 2 to perform so well. Being Apple, they could drop this in 2-3 years if they wanted to drop Rosetta 2 support.
That's something vertical integration (and not caring so much about long-term compatibility) will get you that would be much more difficult otherwise.
And then there's Tesla who did the cars and the charging network, so every driver can be assured to find somewhere to charge.
We need competition and an open play field or I fear the barrier to entry for new hackers will grow too large.
* from miles behind to ahead in multi-tasking workloads (ryzen 1000)
* drew "close enough" to Intel but Intel had a immediate counter (ix-8xxx vs ryzen 2000)
* Cut the feet from under Intel's HEDT CPUs and rendered them mostly pointless, and managed to keep a "close enough" position despite Intel releasing a new CPU generation soon after (Ryzen 3000 vs Intel 10xxx)
* Took a convincing lead which Intel has no answer for (Ryzen 5000 vs Intel 10xxx)
Intel have certainly stagnated but are promising any day now they'll be out of their slump and on a new process for mainstream CPUs. Maybe, maybe not, but their failures are no guarantee AMD are also going to hit a wall, especially since unlike when Intel planted themselves firmly on top, there are challengers in sight still for AMD.
It is absolutely absurd that one company kicks the rest in the ass.
And at this price point who cares about the RAM upgrades anymore? The lowest end system matches systems far more expensive than an extra $200. All of this is great for most end users.
What happens when open computing goes away? When creativity is dictated by one company. Certainly competition with that company will be banned, as it is on iOS. The term 'most users' will slowly shrink until it encompasses no one but consumers.
This is the wrong direction. We should be trending to even more open computers. Not appliances that can also run python scripts.
No matter how open our software, it still runs on hardware which we can't build. No matter how open the HDL of that hardware, it has to be manufactured on a process we can't replicate.
I really want to see more people focus their energy into building an enthusiast-friendly fab. The idea alone gets so readily dismissed because people focus on how extreme top-end fabs are without considering that there might be alternatives if your priorities/requirements were different. But I think it'll still happen, some day. Free the base layer! Make open source eternal!
Among all the possible platforms for logic, it's hard for me to imagine that there's not at least one which has properties usable for at least some set of applications by enthusiasts.
I am concerned that Apple will close all paths for open software to keep adding life to unsupported older hardware though. I feel the same about Phones and mobile devices as well. Reduce and Reuse come before Recycle for a reason.
I'll be concerned when the Apple goons barge in my house and bust up all non-Apple technology.
Until then I think open computing is perfectly safe. Open computing certainly isn't going away on macOS - despite all your hand wringing about "authoritarian Apple".
Honestly how hard is it to port software to ARM?
Electron apps just work, .NET just works and Java does too. So does every language that isn't C/C++. And even on the C/C++ side, unless you are doing some funky things I doubt it's more effort than adding a release configuration that targets ARM in the build pipeline.
Photoshop falls into this bucket. It's on the C++ side and does "some funky things" in the way of SIMD to eke out more performance. If memory serves, it took them about eighteen months to get an Intel native version out the door after the PPC/Intel transition started.
Any serious audio apps are going to have an equally hard time, they do a lot of hardware tricks in order to lower latency, and since they're not mainstream apps like MS Office or Adobe CS, they have much smaller teams of developers. That whole industry is very slow moving.
Finally you've got CAD and 3D stuff. Obviously that requires good drivers. In fact, that's another way in which Microsoft will have a much harder time with this transition. Apple only has to write a driver for the one audio device that's in every Mac, the one GPU, etc.
I wonder how much of that codebase is shared between Windows and macOS though. It's quite possible that Microsoft could take advantage of a lot of porting work that has already been done for Apple's M processors. If you support Windows/x86 and macOS/arm then it's probably not much more work to create a Windows/arm port. Unless there are compatibility issues with the Win32 APIs themselves?
In my C/C++ experience - it’s a big push that a software company would just rather not make. Even if you already have an ARM SKU for a different OS, all sorts of things can cause trouble. If you’re coding in C/C++, you’re probably pretty interested in performance and you’ll have a lot of hand tuned assembly and/or SIMD operations, and that can be a big pain to port, especially with different compilers and intrinsics.
I can only imagine the conversations that go on at Adobe or Autodesk or others when debating new platforms and SKUs. Given that even Microsoft wasn’t committed enough to ARM Windows to make a x64 emulator for it probably worked against this.
I once had an IA64 workstation that I used for testing a product I was working on with that platform and I can’t recall having anything good to say about it. The workstation itself was big, loud, and ugly. Windows didn’t run all that great and there were constant compat issues. Good riddance.
:) It may be forgotten now, but all the infrastructure Microsoft added for running 32-bit apps on a 64-bit OS was first added for Itanium's sake!
It is indeed a great time to be a Mac user again! I was all set to get a 16GB MacBook Air to replace my 2015 MBA. Then I started seeing videos of games running either natively or under emulation on a 16GB MBA and the performance shown was more than good enough that I think I am now going to hold out for a MacBook Pro or laptop that can at least get to 32GB of RAM and leave my Windows gaming machine behind. 32GB mainly because of my asset subscription addiction in Cities:Skylines. Should have better GPU performance too which never hurts - not that I require top tier GPU for the simulations/strategy games I like. Still like my 1080ti in my Windows box but not expecting that in a laptop - from Apple or anyone else.
They also have their own Linux distribution.
They have also made some very successful consumer devices like the Kindle.
Who knows, Amazon could have Amazon Linux ARM laptops in testing right now.
Qualcomm, AMD, and Intel need an OS which they can exert substantial control and vertical efficiency and integration, and afford a path from x86 to ARM.
That's really only Linux. Windows has dragged its feet and has practically trailed OSX in design/usability/appearance (despite a VAST difference in available budgets) practically since OSX was released.
So it's Linux, or.... what? the Beos/Haiku? ReactOS? Open Solaris?
They need their own OS at a minimum to push Windows. A huge investment in ReactOS/WINE would also help bridge the gap.
https://www.engadget.com/microsoft-arm-chips-report-20583411...
I doubt that is going to happen. Apple is a premium brand, for the premium segment of the market. It is never going to have a majority of the marketshare, it isn't interested in going down that path.
Apple Silicon offers great performance, but a massive chunk of the market cares more about price than performance – that chunk isn't really interested in Apple Silicon, and Apple isn't really that interested in them either.
I've seen the M1 Mac mini available for $625. There will come a point where the M1 is cheap enough for a broad range of consumers, especially compared to the quality of consumer PCs in that price range.
…but a massive chunk of the market cares more about price than performance
True until the price gap is small enough that it common sense says paying $100 more for a Mac is a no-brainer.
There's also the issue of no crapware preinstalled, ads everywhere and software that's free to use for 60 or 90 days, which is typical on low-cost PCs.
Apple is also playing with a 30-35% margin which gives them room to drop prices as needed.
If college campuses are open in the fall of 2021, many of those freshmen will arrive on campus with an Apple Silicon laptop…
I think the problem with ARM on the Windows side is that there's no commitment. Qualcomm isn't going to want to create a new category of processor for Windows machines (ie. a 10-15 watt part) without a huge commitment from Microsoft that ARM will end up as a large portion of Windows future (rather than just a single "look, we made an ARM surface that a few people will buy" project). Without that commitment, Qualcomm will certainly supply Microsoft with mobile phone processors, but those will be very slow by comparison. Qualcomm's mobile processors are half of Apple's single-core performance, nevermind the M1.
Part of the problem is that no one can (or wants to) force the issue. Apple got up on stage and said, "three years from now, we won't be selling Intel-based laptops. If you don't get on the train, you'll be left behind." Microsoft won't do that. Without that commitment, why should a software firm port its applications to ARM? Every software firm should be thinking, "if we don't do any work, Windows on ARM will be miserable and never get traction." Likewise, any chip maker is going to say, "I don't want to invest in ARM laptop/desktop chips until it's clear that ARM is going to be a major part of the Windows ecosystem." Finally customers are going to think, "I'm not going to buy an ARM laptop until it's clear that Microsoft, the chipmakers, and software firms are all behind this." No one is willing to commit to the future because that future won't exist unless they all move in unison.
Apple solves most of that "in-unison" problem. They're the chipmaker, they're the OS maker, and they're the device maker. The only thing Apple doesn't control is third-party devs. However, when you can move three of the four wheels, the other comes along. Apple burned its bridges behind it - or at least is telling the public that. Sure, Apple could abandon its ARM transition and move back to Intel, but realistically they're all-in for Apple Silicon.
The Windows world is going to continue to be stuck in a loop where no one wants to commit. Microsoft introduces a solitary ARM-based machine. The processor is worse than Intel's offerings, apps don't support it, they haven't put the effort into a Rosetta 2 that Apple has (you'll have a compatibility layer, but not as good), and third parties aren't rushing to support it (c'mon, it's one niche device). There's no incentive for any party to work hard on this - even Microsoft. If they put lots of effort into a Rosetta 2 system, that's basically wasted effort if ARM isn't going to be a significant part of the future. Might as well wait and see if the ARM laptop catches on before pouring more effort into it. But that becomes a self-fulfilling failure. Without Microsoft committing its full resources to ARM (or substantial enough resources), it will be a second-class experience which will mean that it will fail and not justify continued investment.
It requires a leap of faith that Microsoft doesn't have right now. It would require Microsoft to put a lot of effort behind software on ARM. It would require Microsoft to commission an ARM-chip worthy of a top-tier device (and probably lose a lot of money on it for a couple generations while people are skeptical of it). It requires Microsoft to get in front of the world and say, "we're going to make ARM a first-class platform for Windows and we'll show that commitment over the next 3-4 years until you finally believe it."
Apple is in an easier position for a few reasons. As I said before, they control more of the stack. There won't be Intel-based laptops a couple years ago for people to compare ARM laptops with. However, the biggest bit might be that they were already making their own chips. Apple was already making chips with double the single-core performance for mobile devices. When Apple launched the M1 Macs, they offered a huge improvement over Intel while lowering power consumption and heat production (and fan noise) by incredible levels. By contrast, when Microsoft puts a Snapdragon into one of their machines, they're usually looking at a slightly slower processor and it gets worse from there without a great Rosetta 2, without app developers on board with porting their apps, etc. Apple's M1 Macs have so many advantages: they're clearly a lot faster, they're clearly a lot cooler temperature-wise, they can run iOS apps (even if that's flawed in some ways), Rosetta 2 offers ahead-of-time translation for a lot of things offering closer-to-native performance even for non-ported things, and app developers are all rushing to get on board.
For a customer, an M1 Mac is so exciting - they're amazing devices with huge advantages and a guaranteed commitment from the ecosystem. By contrast, Windows on ARM basically only comes with disadvantages, no compelling reason to try one, and no buy-in from the greater ecosystem.