Once I moved from Nashville to NYC for my label job I met a ton of other men and women whom this same guy gave them a chance too. That's how his career started .. he met a label head at a concert in the 80s who gave him a chance.
Great guy who helped found many popular artist careers in the 90s.
I'm a hobbyist songwriter but pursued it in college at Middle Tennesse State University. I learned you got to be the best of the best and then luck needs to fall onto you as it did for my songwriting classmate, Luke Laird (wrote many Carrie Underwood and country number one songs.. was best writer in class.. not sure how he got his break). During college I was able to intern at record labels and attend fun industry functions like CRS (country radio seminar), NARM and the parties that happened after each day of the event. At NARM in Orlando I went to the events during the day and then found the parties the labels held for record store (2001 when record stores existed lol) people. At one of the parties I met some executives and partied with them and then one introduced me their friend. Her friend was the guy I mentioned and we hit it off, gave him my business card and a month later he left a message on my voicemail (was back in Nashville) saying he wanted to hire me for a marketing job at RCA/Victor (jazz label ... Etta James was on it).
I only lasted 6 months (he forced my boss to hire me and she hated me) in my supposed dream job in NYC, but it was a fun and interesting (witnessed the twin towers falling from Times Square in my office's 41st floor) time in my life.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/former-pepsico-ceo-roger-enrico...
Made CEO at just 38 years old despite coming from a modest background, and engaged in marketing strategies that were very much ahead of their time and dramatically boosted growth.
I would call it "common decency". An uncommon trait for corporate executives.
But there's no reason to elevate the occasional few who are capable of it to "hero" status.
Good leadership is rare, you're right, and I don't think CEOs deserve credit for demonstrating good leadership. Good leadership should be table stakes for that position; the bare minimum.
What needs to change are the astonishingly weak disincentives (and sometimes, actual incentives) aimed at bad CEOs.
If you can worm your way into a CEO position of a company you didn't start yourself, and you DON'T demonstrate good leadership qualities with regularity, then a good old-fashioned CEO-blacklisting seems very appropriate, to me; you just don't get to be a CEO anymore.
The CEO here managed to notice that among thousands, this is the janitor to listen to.
As for CEO being well paid, it is simply because their decisions can make the company lose or earn a lot of money. If a $500k salary earns the company millions, it is well deserved. And when things go wrong CEOs do get kicked out.
So yeah, we can say that spotting talent in a janitor and turning into a lot of money for the company is a CEO's job and the reason he is paid so well, but it doesn't mean he shouldn't be praised for a job well done.
And sure some CEO don't deserve their position, golden parachutes are a thing, but I have a feeling that most CEOs have merit.
CEO pay has risen over 900% over the last forty years:
* https://www.marketwatch.com/story/ceos-are-paid-278-times-mo...
Somehow I don't see the value that they bring to have increased by the same amount. From a Harvard study entitled "Are CEOs Rewarded for Luck? The Ones Without Principals Are":
> CEOs are rewarded for luck. Moreover, pay for luck is as large as pay for general pay for performance. Pay for luck also appears on the most discretionary components of compensation, salary and bonus. Looking closer, we found that pay for luck is strongest among poorly governed firms. Adding a large shareholder on the board, for example, decreased the pay for luck by 23 to 33 percent. This finding weakens two prominent explanations of pay for luck: “Paying for luck is optimal” and “Filtering out luck is impossible.”
* https://doi.org/10.1162/00335530152466269
* https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/sendhil/files/are_ceos_rew...
Another study, "What Makes a Winner? Toward Resolving the Role of Luck and Skill in Sustained CEO Performance":
> This study is an empirical examination of the extent to which luck can explain sustained performance. Using a unique empirical strategy of bootstrap simulations that we compare to actual performances of public companies, we observe that over 95% of the differences in performance outcomes between “top” versus “average” performers can be attributed to luck, even if all CEOs are equally skilled. Through this novel empirical approach, we can better incorporate the role of luck into studies of sustained performance, and our findings suggest that more attention should be placed on the role of unanticipated and even uncontrollable changes on performance.
* https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2827132
No, pay for the CEOs of the 350 largest companies has risen over 900%.
Said 350 largest companies have also grown dramatically; "CEO of the 50th largest company in 2020" (Procter & Gamble, $67B revenue) is a much bigger job than "CEO of the 100th largest company in 1980" (General Foods, $5.4B revenue).
The way it is, you've just made it much harder to actually compare numbers. Just accounting for inflation brings that gap down to 67B vs 17B. Still sizable, but also comparing the 50th largest company to the 100th, so...
If only CEOs were paid so little...
>The average private company CEO total compensation package for 2017 was $2,213,679, but the median was a more modest $350,622.
https://chiefexecutive.net/ceo-and-senior-executive-compensa...
Are you sure? Children listen to janitors just as much as they listen to anyone else. One's job doesn't matter to a child; they know they can learn from anyone. Very few CEOs know this. Hell, very few ADULTS know this.
I didn't intend "an insight a child would have" to mean that such an idea is a basic thing everyone knows, I literally meant "an inside a child would have."
You have to be selective with where you sample your information. Sometimes this filter is too strict (only listening to VP's), but if your filter is too loose then you will spend your days drowning in information that might not be all that useful
I am not saying that all CEOs should listen to all janitors; I'm saying that all CEOs should have, at a bare minimum, good leadership skills.
A CEO, or any leader, has a vision, and inconsequential information is easily cast aside. Our ears can do this quite easily, when we have a conversation in a noisy conference room or whatever.
And, as far as boot licking goes, that's easy to explain. People are under the delusion that if they suck up to the boss enough, eventually they can be the boss. That's wrong on so many levels, but the easiest one to see is that for every N employees at any level of the corporate hierarchy, it only makes sense for there to be at most, say, N/4, or N/10, or, generally, N/k (k > 1) people at the next level. So, your chances of rising further up the ladder decrease the further you go up, provided you stay at the same organization.
That's actually the way it works in general, except that there are a lot of organizations out there; the hierarchy cuts off at a level before it becomes literally impossible to advance; and, even if that fails, one can start one's own organization, place themselves at the top, and then take on the challenge of building that organization to meaningful levels.
But, really, it all amounts to the delusion the bottom 90% of the ladder has that they can eventually join the top 1%, if only they work hard enough! You know, as if it were literally even possible to work enough hours at any reasonable wage to become a billionaire or something. That's the real reason.
It's about working smart, not working hard.
> as if it were literally even possible to work enough hours at any reasonable wage to become a billionaire
With discipline, however, it is very possible to become a multimillionaire. (Live below your means and invest the rest.)
Typically these things are sold up the management chain which can exercise discretion on which ideas are good and which are not. In this case the Janitor had nothing to lose by going directly to the CEO since I doubt his manager had much clout to sell this up the chain
Lol. :)
More often than not, we get nowhere without people in better positions helping us, it would be great if more people would keep an open mind like that. That CEO deserves recognition.
And if you manage to climb higher on the ladder, don't forget to help others like someone helped you before. Pay it forward.