So obviously they didn't choose to remove features, they were forced to rebuild it from scratch.
And along the way, instead of it being a standalone product (which was really only justified because of competition from Yahoo Finance etc.), it made more sense for it to be simply part of Search, and so give simpler results.
Does that make sense? I don't think they torched anyone's goodwill here. It's not senseless -- to the contrary, there was a lot of sense to what they did.
If you want a serious finance tool, Google (or Apple) stock "apps" are probably not going to be the right choice in the first place.
I know the original chart tool was in Flash... I used it and described the features it had. Why after 10 years is the new version less useful than before?
Yahoo finance stayed separate and has been better for it. It doesn't make sense for stocks to be integrated into search - I completely disagree.
I never said anything about Google Finance being the only tool I used. It was a perfect place to start and once I found an interesting security I would move over into something more serious.
Does that make sense?
You not personally finding it useful is not the same as it not "making sense".
A bit more charity may have been warranted but I do see where he's coming from.
The first person said that Google dumbed down Google Finance "senselessly".
So, in context, I definitely took the response's "Does that make sense?" to mean "Was it a rational product decision on Google's part?" rather than "Can you understand this?".
If it made sense, then there wouldn’t be a need to reverse course today.
I think it only makes sense if you look at the incentives of Google as a corporation, and disregard the opinions of the people who used and liked Google Finance.
Anyhow it doesn't seem like Google might have ditched finance for this result. Increase in sheets usage is just a side effect.
I can't see how scaling would be an issue since the tricky/ resource intense bits happen on the client end. We're building interactive charts which are comparable to the Google Finance ones with a fairly tiny developer team.
If Google hasn't migrated functionality, it's because the Finance product hasn't met their goals and they've trimmed the team back.
A conversion made no sense at all. What we ended up having to do (and in hindsight was absolutely the right decision), was creating a new application completely.
The best way to "transition" for Google with Flash would be to probably, similarly, just create a new application.
Who forced them? I have always been Ok with Flash and see no real reason to abandon it (besides driving sales for more powerful hardware which can do the same Flash did on Pentium 2 and with less code).
Assuming you're okay Flash being a closed product of Adobe (which was a huge problem for the web), it was also a bountiful garden of security issues, which Adobe didn't do a great job of managing.
There also are open-source implementation like Ruffle, Lightspark, Gnash etc (I never bothered to try any of them however).
Even the original Adobe Flash player is not dead - it will[1] be maintained by Harman for years to come.
Nevertheless, what I meant to say was nobody really forced or could force Google - AFAIK killing Flash was Google's and Apple's own initiative.
Do you have a recommendation of any free tool?
It went from being a navigation tool too being the "how do I get to consumption" tool.
If it's NIH Syndrome and/or a low-status in terms of Google promotion fuel, we should just say that.
I have no idea what you're getting at with the comment about Google recruiters.
Remember the "Briefcase" sync feature of windows 95... Now compare that to Dropbox syncing... Pretty much the same thing 25 years on. Different UI, same principle.
Then, at some point, Microsoft went ahead and ruined their keyboard when they went to Windows Phone 10 or 8.1 I can't remember, and I've been searching for perfection ever since. GBoard, with it's fucking emoji page is an affront to engineering.
When Microsoft does things like this, and it's not clearly a dumb product decision, it's often to avoid a patent that they don't want to license or fight. I've been using 'simple keyboard' on Android, because it's just a g-d keyboard, but it doesn't do good spell check either. I didn't particularly notice spell check getting worse when I left windows phone, but there was a lot of other stuff going on.
The MS team that did Clippy would like to have a word with you...
It was an awesome piece of software, that nobody knew about.
Remember at the time many people did not have laptops. They often didn't have home internet either. Maybe they had AOL, or maybe nothing. They also didn't have a work VPN or any way to access files on their work computer.
I know I've experienced a point where the decision is made to discontinue something as adding what is needed to move forward will require too much investment versus benefit.
Google Finance used to have all these features. They were already implemented and working fine in 2009! The original chart tool was much better than the current version. You could see every dividend that was issued, splits, add moving averages, etc. Then they "simplified" it by removing all the best features and are now adding them back?
Why would I bother to use this when they have so thoroughly torched their goodwill by senselessly killing off working (and good!) products?