News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by Anon1096 on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:14AM (#25419216)
I'm surprised at how much impact the NYT's expose (I would personally consider it more of a hit piece) has had. I naively assumed that PornHub, as a top-10 site on the web would be immune to such a piece, but I guess I was wrong. How many of the members of the NYT and the Visa and Mastercard boards who created on this outcome watched the videos that are now down? Probably a majority of them, but that wasn't enough to stop the moral panic I guess.

As a side note, I think Reddit should now tread very carefully. PornHub had a lot more verification in place for people uploading porn, and even they've now been neutered by a hit piece. Hell, Reddit is somehow still in the iOS App Store despite having copious amounts of porn (and yes, underage porn too even if Reddit will deny it). They're just an opinion columnist's penstroke away from the mob coming to roost.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by Raphmedia on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:24AM (#25419337)
To say this is a hit piece against PornHub is to oversimplify the issue.

The parent company MindGeek (Revenue: 460 million USD) formerly known as ManWin has been receiving such criticisms for years now.

This is not a hit-piece against a small streaming start-up. It's a wake-up call to monitor a tech giant.

https://nymag.com/news/features/70985/ 2011

https://www.philosophyforlife.org/blog/porn-corporations-sto... 2012

https://slate.com/technology/2014/10/mindgeek-porn-monopoly-... 2014

etc.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by miracle2k on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:57AM (#25419807)
These seem all very different critiques. The Nick Kristof article is based on the work of Laila Mickelwait, who has for the last couple of years worked tirelessly on her campaign to shutdown Pornhub. I twas her who has surfaced all the victims in the article.

Though I doubt she will succeed now, she is very clear that the end-goal is not to monitor Pornhub, but to criminally charge it's owners. This is because a criminal case against them, similar to Backpage, would essentially make all tube-porn sites legal unviable.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by tomjen3 on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:47PM (#25420596)
And a very quick google search confirmed what I suspected: she works for a christian organization.

I thought that we had effectively neutered the religious right.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by Andrex on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:53PM (#25420690)
> I thought that we had effectively neutered the religious right.

How could you pay attention to American politics in the last 30 years and possibly still think this?

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by Karunamon on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:17PM (#25421042)
And? How is that relevant?

I really quite loathe this line of argument that the source or even the intentions behind a probably factual statement should be taken into account when evaluating the truthfulness of the statement. It's textbook ad hominem, literally argument to the person.

PH has a demonstrable problem with child porn on its service. I don't care if it's the US government, a different government, a religious fundamentalist, a competitor, a lobbying group, or some random anonymous internet user surfacing that problem so long as it's verifiably true.

Intention factors into evaluation of the speaker, not the content. To do otherwise is to discard important, actionable facts because you dislike the speaker. In other words, it discards logic.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by wolco2 on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:38PM (#25422153)
The stats compared to facebook show the opposite.

100 or so items over three years is a success story compared to any other social network.

You need trust in the messager. If this person has religious objections ignoring that is ignoring reality. The messager is the message

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by Raphmedia on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:51PM (#25423104)
1 rape or child-porn video is already too much.

Comparing to other websites is meaningless and insensitive. We are not comparing performance statistics but broken lives.

Telling the judge that your neighbor is more criminal than you won't help you in any court case.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by wolco2 on Monday December 14, 2020 @04:24PM (#25423535)
Comparing social media sites incidents and take down polcies for these types of sites are not meaningless.

If someone emailed you some material should your emailbox, you or all email be taken away from society? The reality of user generated content being uploaded and breaking a sites tos is all too common.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by Raphmedia on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:48PM (#25421448)
Only 22.8% of the USA is non-religious according to census. Should we ignore the work done by 77.2% of the population?

This is just an easy cop-out to avoid talking about a difficult topic.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by syshum on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:37PM (#25422135)
No, instead we has simply proven the Horseshoe theory of politics.

Liberty, and freedom are under assault from both the extreme right, and the extreme left. Who it seems end up supporting similar policies for very different reasons

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by kmonsen on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:15PM (#25421018)
Kristof's end goal (at least as he states, and based on the reporting) is not to shut down Pornhub, and he tried to balance it with talking to Pornstars to make sure there would be a balance.

I think you are attacking the person instead of the issue. It doesn't matter what her background is as long as there are legitimate issues. And that was certainly the case with backpage, and seems like it was true for Pornhub as well.

I would say Pornhub either is more serious or learned the lesson from backpage, and is moving very fast in shutting illegal things down. I don't think it currently looks like the outcome right now looks like they will be declared illegal.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by manquer on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:46PM (#25420575)
It is hit piece in the sense, it focused a lot on PornHub while arguably the other players are worse in terms of the standards the article stated this as well.

Was it well deserved ? Certainly, they could have been doing more lot earlier. However there are lot worse players and the focus has been a lot more on Pornhub rather than industry in general.

Self regulation by Pornhub is good step forward, but a model which enables only change from one player after pressure from the payment providers is not reliable model. There has to be regulatory change to really protect the victims.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by claudeganon on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:35AM (#25419496)
Jon Ronson's podcast "The Butterfly Effect" also does a great job of breaking down how damaging MindGeek's practices have been to workers and legitimate players in the industry:

https://www.audible.com/pd/The-Butterfly-Effect-with-Jon-Ron...

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by slg on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:33AM (#25419469)
You seem to admit that the accusations are valid, but are also claiming that this type of reporting is a hit piece. How do you square those two?

Also Reddit has been on the receiving end of this reporting before. That has often resulted in incremental improvements as the worst offending subreddits are banned (there used to be an /r/jailbait for example), but their model often doesn't kill that content or the demand for it and can result in that same content being dispersed among smaller and more niche communities that are able to glide under the radar. Reddit has still thrived throughout all that controversy so I don't think it is as big an existential threat as you claim.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by enumjorge on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:01PM (#25419861)
The entire comment borders on nonsensical. Something about how board members should watch videos of alleged sexual abuse, some of it involving minors, before their companies make decisions that could impact PornHub? What??
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by slg on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:17PM (#25420128)
I think that is an uncharitable interpretation of that comment. I read it as OP saying that those people likely watched unverified content that is now down, not necessarily illegal content. It is basically an accusation of puritanical hypocrisy. However the problem with that accusation is that it is extremely difficult to distinguish the unverified and illegal content, especially at scale, and it is why Pornhub went with this extreme measure to remove all unverified content.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by headmelted on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:28AM (#25419408)
I might be missing something here, but if that kind of stuff really is on Reddit then I would want them to be made to take responsibility for having it on their site and suffer the consequences if it is not removed and reported to the authorities.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by TedDoesntTalk on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:42AM (#25419597)
Genuine question: how do you scale content moderation to millions of posts without hiring millions of workers at astronomical cost (who can make mistakes, like we’ve seen with DMCA take down notices, YouTube censorship when not justified, AppStore censorship,even GitHub made these mistakes, etc... some of these mistakes ruin peoples’ livelihoods).

Is there a “right way” to do this that protects everyone?

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by wittyreference on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:01PM (#25419864)
If a business can't run profitably and legally at scale, then that business model is a bad fit for that scale and shouldn't exist at that scale (presuming the laws in question are reasonable, which I think 'banning child porn' qualifies as.)

It's super weird that people seem to constantly start from the premise of, "But their business couldn't possibly [comply with law] profitably at scale! Oh well. I guess until someone comes up with a feasible solution, we'll just have to exempt them from being responsible!"

Imagine if pharma companies went "gosh, but hiring quality inspectors to make sure all of our drugs are untainted just doesn't scale!" I have trouble imagining you saying, "Well, they obviously can't sacrifice scale, so let's just wait and see if a better quality inspection solution comes up."

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by jjk166 on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:56PM (#25420737)
> Imagine if pharma companies went "gosh, but hiring quality inspectors to make sure all of our drugs are untainted just doesn't scale!" I have trouble imagining you saying, "Well, they obviously can't sacrifice scale, so let's just wait and see if a better quality inspection solution comes up."

Every drug has acceptable levels of impurities. There is a non-zero acceptable level of rat feces in your food. Your bank rounds the value of your account to some decimal place. The various parts of your car have some mean time between failures.

In the real world we place bounds on how much bad stuff is acceptable, and these bounds are determined mostly by practicality and economics. "Ban all childporn" is certainly a reasonable philosophy, but it is no better a law than "ban all impurities" which would shut down every drug manufacturer in the world. A real law takes the form "perform these steps or reasonable equivalents to limit X to a tolerable level." You can claim that reddit is not taking a step it is required to by law, but it's not breaking the law just because it hasn't developed a perfect solution to a problem that likely can only be solved approximately.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by TedDoesntTalk on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:14PM (#25424699)
"gosh, but hiring quality inspectors to make sure all of our drugs are untainted just doesn't scale!"

That is exactly why I only but medications from Valisure.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ogre_codes on Monday December 14, 2020 @04:59PM (#25423966)
The only way this comparison to drug companies makes sense is if the drug companies had community sourced supply lines and were selling drugs a third party contributor had made in their bathtub alongside their normal drugs.

> "Ban all childporn" is certainly a reasonable philosophy, but it is no better a law than "ban all impurities" which would shut down every drug manufacturer in the world.

This would be a reasonable argument for a company like YouTube which has spent tens (hundreds?) of millions of dollars putting controls in place. If PornHub had iron tight controls and one of the actors was caught using a fake ID, then it might be reasonable. But they didn't have iron tight controls... or apparently any controls. There was zero verification that participants had signed releases or were of age.

PornHub's controls were complete shit.

Maybe some people want drugs from Pfizer's "Community Sourced" drug program... I sure don't.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by null0pointer on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:54PM (#25420699)
This is an extremely weak argument. At a certain scale, policy becomes about statistics rather than absolutes. This applies to absolutely everything, including the laws themselves. Companies in all industries have to occasionally issue recalls on dangerous or faulty products, just like PornHub or Reddit have to occasionally delete stolen or illegal content.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by mtVessel on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:25PM (#25422796)
> Imagine if pharma companies went "gosh, but hiring quality inspectors to make sure all of our drugs are untainted just doesn't scale!"

What do you mean, "imagine?" They do say that[1], and it's a tremendous problem.

[1] https://www.newsweek.com/2019/07/19/bottle-x-exposing-impuri...

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by travisoneill1 on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:09PM (#25420940)
Terrible example. What if that was true? You think that we would just shut down the companies that make essential drugs rather than change the regulation?
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by colinmhayes on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:51PM (#25420660)
People are going to watch pirated porn. If they can't find it on American sites they'll go to sites that aren't effected by American laws/regulations/journalism. That would probably make trafficking worse as the new site has no reason to take down any videos as their value add is refusal to censor.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by makomk on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:44PM (#25422227)
What you're effectively saying - just like all arguments of this form, which seems to be quite popular lately - is that ordinary people should not be able to share their own content that they create online, because it's too hard to 100% police everything that they do. (Presumably including sending things directly and privately to people that they know, given how much better a channel that is for child porn than somewhere like Pornhub.) That the internet should be a consume-only place for the output of big corporate content factories whose content can be verified. Except framed in such a way as to make this seem like an anti-corporate stance, rather than the massive pro-corporate grab it is.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ralfn on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:36PM (#25420416)
You do realize the success of the platforms is the result of finding legal loopholes.

That's the innovation. What if we are a media publisher but than without worker rights and unions? Youtube.

What if we start a hotel franchise but without any regulation or oversight or liability? Airbnb.

What if we start a cab company but make all our employees independent contractors, ignore all regulations and put all liability and legal risk on the independent contractors?

Silicon Valley is nothing but a bunch of young spoiled boys asking themselves the most American business question of all: have you tried slavery yet?

Business model innovations where you make money while someone pays all the costs.

>Is there a “right way” to do this that protects everyone

There is no investment if you do that, because the competitive advantage comes from the stealing. Nobody is investing in technology. Nobody is doing actual R&D. It's all about the viability of the scam. How profitable is this loophole?

We go out of our way to engineer protocols and technology and platforms that make it impossible to do that the right thing (by design). From p2p networks in the 90ties to crypto currencies. From YouTube to Spotify.

It's a dog eat dog world and I'm not here judging any individual. But let's not be naive.

Theft is the plan. Abuse is the strategy. Fortunes are not built on sweat. The people who work hard are the ones you hire to clean our house. The ones that pick our vegetables.

But we at least show the respect to others to not lie about the true nature of the successes of our industry.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by uxcolumbo on Monday December 14, 2020 @04:27PM (#25423578)
>> We go out of our way to engineer protocols and technology and platforms that make it impossible to do that the right thing (by design). From p2p networks in the 90ties to crypto currencies. From YouTube to Spotify.

I don't understand this bit. So are you saying crypto currencies are making it impossible to do the right thing?

If so, what do you mean by that?

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ralfn on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @06:45AM (#25429366)
>So are you saying crypto currencies are making it impossible to do the right thing?

Cryptocurrencies are designed to subvert regulation and oversight. That's the selling point. That current societal infrastructure to protect innocent (sometimes gullible) people from everything from weapons trade or pyramid schemes.

If you want to 'make it do the right thing', thats already exists and is your wallet. Thats called money. A ledger with a tax identity. A bank account that requires a legal id. There is no point in burning all this electricity to verify those hashes, except to circumvent regulation and law.

I can't start a pyramid scheme and steal money from gullable idiots. Thankfully, an ICO is completely legal (for now). If you want to sell bread to hungry people, use money. If you want to sell guns to a hitman, use a cryptocurrency. Thats why cryptocurrencies are economically viable compared to money. Because they make it harder to apply the laws we voted on democratically, like how you can't sell children for sex.

The reason any money out there is investing into cryptocurrency technology, is because of the expectation of moral subserversion of society. Its a not a side effect. Its the bussiness model.

What do you think Venture Capital considers some startups worth so much money? Because they see the potential of price dumping and becoming a monopolist. If markets were actually properly regulated to always keep competition alive, people wouldn't be investing millions into apps and websites, they would be investing in actual R&D and hard science.

But doing the real work, can never compete, with just plain cheating. You always make more money being the bad guy. Even if a lot of startups have sincere intentions (Facebooks' mission was to connect people, not destroy democracy), the money will chase the decision down.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by Larrikin on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:50AM (#25419700)
This question presumes that they have some inalienable right to scale despite not having solved this problem
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by preinheimer on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:36PM (#25420414)
I think this is a point that tech folks like to sweep under the rug all too often.

All of these sound wrong:

- Walmarts are huge! It's impossible to build fire suppression at that scale.

- Ford builds an insane number of cars every year, it's not possible to ensure each car is safe at that scale.

- The United States burns 20,000 barrels of oil PER DAY. It's simply not possible to ensure a "safe" product at that scale.

- This buffet serves 20,000 plates per day, it's impossible to ensure food safety at that scale.

Each of those problems has been ~solved. Or those business wouldn't be operating. You only need to moderate a million messages if your customers are posting that many. If you can't afford to hire moderators to handle those million messages maybe it's your business model that's the problem, not moderation.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by mytherin on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:08PM (#25421753)
Fire suppression systems fail, cars get recalled or malfunction, people get food poisoning in restaurants or from food bought at a supermarket. Any product, not just tech, runs into problems when manufactured at scale. Tech is more visible because it is newer and in the spotlight. Nobody says "stop manufacturing cars" when one manufacturer issues a safety recall because cars have been around so long. The entire premise of producing 100X fewer cars so we can hand-craft cars and hand-check them is ridiculous - we simply accept the occasional manufacturing defect or product recall as the rates at which they happen are so small. These are all rounding errors, and the benefits of scale far outweigh the cons.

The same applies to tech. Content moderation has been ~solved as well. The overwhelming majority of content on social media platforms, websites, etc is regular, legal content. The illegal content that makes it through the filters and stays up for a significant period of time is a rounding error.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by preinheimer on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:42PM (#25422203)
> Content moderation has been ~solved as well.

I strongly disagree. Pornhub just purged 10 million videos because they couldn't moderate out child porn and rape videos.

There's terrible content all over Facebook

- Using Facebook's own numbers ~750,000 instances of "child nudity and sexual exploitation" were reported by users before being removed in Q3 2020. https://transparency.facebook.com/community-standards-enforc...

- Facebook’s improved AI isn’t preventing harmful content from spreading https://venturebeat.com/2020/11/19/facebooks-improved-ai-isn...

- Despite Facebook ban on Holocaust denial, it’s still easy to find https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/despite-facebook-ban-on-holoc...

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ardy42 on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:05PM (#25424607)
>> Content moderation has been ~solved as well.

> I strongly disagree. Pornhub just purged 10 million videos because they couldn't moderate out child porn and rape videos.

PornHub is not a good example here. Reactive content moderation doesn't work for porn, because it's too hard to distinguish a positive from a negative. Content moderation for porn has probably been solved...by using a per-clearance model coupled with strong identity verification.

> There's terrible content all over Facebook

That's probably true, but the worst appears to be much harder to find. It's a lot easier to detect and ban all porn (especially if you can ban all nudity) than just certain heinous kinds of porn specifically.

> - Facebook’s improved AI isn’t preventing harmful content from spreading https://venturebeat.com/2020/11/19/facebooks-improved-ai-isn...

> - Despite Facebook ban on Holocaust denial, it’s still easy to find https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/despite-facebook-ban-on-holoc...

Facebook seems to have more problems with trickier things, like hate speech, holocaust denial, and mis/disinformation. We have pretty good technology now for recognizing things in images, but we don't nearly technology that good for understanding the meaning of speech and text.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by AnthonyMouse on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:14PM (#25425810)
> scale.

This is the error. The problem isn't scale. If YouTube has 500 hours of video uploaded per minute and some other site has only one minute of video uploaded per minute, the smaller site is no better able to handle it, because they don't have proportionally any more staff than YouTube.

The actual problem is marginal cost.

If you have a Walmart store, it probably costs over a million dollars to construct it, and takes in several million dollars a year in revenue. A $10,000 fire suppression system may be expensive, but it's manageable. And if there are a thousand Walmart stores all over the country that each need a $10,000 fire suppression system, that scales just fine. You have a choice between an unsafe Walmart and a safe Walmart whose proprietors make slightly less profit.

The marginal profit from hosting a given video is pennies. That means any solution that costs more than pennies isn't a choice between unsafe and safe video hosting, it's a choice between having video hosting and not having it. Scale has nothing to do with it; greater or lesser scale doesn't save you from a cost that exceeds your entire margin.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by headmelted on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:54AM (#25419757)
This. It's not the law's job to cater to an organisation's bottom line.

I'm sure someone is going to mention that this is in fact exactly how laws are applied in practice, but that's a separate discussion.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by miracle2k on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:12PM (#25420011)
Note that Pornhub was not convicted, or even legally accused of violating any law. They were just financially deplatformed.

People who would like to change the law should certainly feel responsible to weight potential undesirable effects.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by amanaplanacanal on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:06PM (#25419928)
Isn’t that the whole intent of section 230?
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ogre_codes on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:01PM (#25419869)
> Is there a “right way” to do this that protects everyone?

You do it the way the porn industry has for years. You get consenting actors. You get releases from the participants. You keep track of who is in the videos.

If you are hosting third party content, you verify they do the above.

This isn't like hosting a Disney movie on YouTube. If you screw this up, there are real victims here. There should be some weight and repercussions to posting child porn, revenge porn, or any kind of porn where some of the actors have not signed off on it.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by riffic on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @10:14PM (#25438625)
Content moderation at scale is impossible to do well:

- Any moderation policy will anger someone

- Content moderation is inherently subjective

- Errors at scale result in many errors over time

Mike Masnick goes into this at depth here:

https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20191111/23032743367/masni...

the three points above were taken from the video posted in this comment:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25419822

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by rapnie on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:58AM (#25419822)
Not saying it is a "right" way, but this video of the ActivityPub conference contrasts content moderation of the big centralized platforms to how moderation is conducted on the decentralized fediverse (e.g. Mastodon, Pleroma, PeerTube, etc).

Spoiler: where the latter makes it way more manageable, and for the former it is near undoable.

https://conf.tube/videos/watch/d8c8ed69-79f0-4987-bafe-84c01...

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by disiplus on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:42AM (#25419594)
i don't think reddit is hosting underage porn, and im sure there is some subreddit somewhere that has questionable content (the same as there is copyrighted material somewhere deep on youtube) but i don't think that it is so widespread.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by thatguy0900 on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:10PM (#25419979)
Minors are 100% uploading to popular porn subreddits. There might not be a specific r/jailbait any more(and there probably is), but it's definetely still happening. They just have "18" in the title now.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by 9dev on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:48AM (#25419675)
...just go ahead and scroll through r/gonewild, and you know what the OP meant.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by bnt on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:19AM (#25419275)
What’s worse, Reddit disables NSFW/porn content in Incognito on iOS Safari and prompts you to install the app. How that got past Apple is beyond me.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by andy_ppp on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:24AM (#25419334)
More evidence that Reddit hate their users.

Make something people don't want and force them to use it by building an evil moat?

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by kmonsen on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:11PM (#25420967)
Every platform that grows large/ is successful will eventually "hate it's users" as it needs to be profitable. Currently that means, at least for the solved version, invading privacy/showing ads/selling user information.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by mcintyre1994 on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:31AM (#25419445)
Apple don't have any editorial control of iOS Safari, and I doubt they'd ever reject an app because of a website trying to force you to use it.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by pr0zac on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:45AM (#25419633)
I believe the point they are trying to make is Reddit is tying access to pornography to installing the app, thus making an explicit connection between porn and their app, while Apple bans apps featuring adult content from the app store completely.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ascagnel_ on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:04PM (#25419903)
That ban has been leaky for a while -- HBO & Cinemax have carried pornographic content for decades, yet both have apps in the App Store. On top of that, you could buy HBO & Cinemax directly from Apple before the launch of HBO MAX earlier this year.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by barbecue_sauce on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:23PM (#25420220)
It’s a stretch to call anything on HBO or Cinemax pornographic.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by bigbubba on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:10PM (#25421778)
Cinemax at least shows content that is softcore erotica by any definition. Though from what my [dead] sibling comment says, maybe they no longer have this sort of programming.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ascagnel_ on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:10PM (#25422575)
From looking over their Wikipedia entry, it looks like Cinemax has backed away from adult content, but the last time I was a subscriber (around 2016/2017), their app had a less-than-obvious "late night" section buried in its navigation.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by 310260 on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:56PM (#25421582)
I dunno. Cinemax had the reputation of being "Skinemax" for a while. They've moved out of the business though.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by TechBro8615 on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:57AM (#25419806)
IIRC iOS rule is that adult content can’t be discoverable. That’s why NSFW subreddits don’t autocomplete, for example.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by rootsudo on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:41AM (#25419577)
Best of all, it promises it's anonymous if you install the app.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by mtnygard on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:09PM (#25419962)
That seems to be both an implausible claim and hard for a user to verify.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by quotemstr on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:08PM (#25419943)
That websites can tell whether a user is using incognito mode is an egregious browser bug.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by tt433 on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:36AM (#25419518)
Does Safari have a "use desktop site" option?
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by bnt on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:59AM (#25419835)
Interesting, forcing mobile Safari to pretend it’s a desktop solves the issue.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by tt433 on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:45PM (#25421408)
Yes, unfortunately reddit pays engineers to obfuscate use cases so they can push notifications and steal your attention. The mobile app didn't even have (lasi I checked) a (n intuitive) way to get to r/friends short of actually clicking on a link to that feed a user has posted. The lights are on but it seems no one is home
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by dutchmartin on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:58AM (#25419817)
They do for their current site, but old.Reddit.com is still available with all content unblocked.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by twblalock on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:28PM (#25421190)
> I'm surprised at how much impact the NYT's expose (I would personally consider it more of a hit piece) has had. I naively assumed that PornHub, as a top-10 site on the web would be immune to such a piece, but I guess I was wrong.

The NYT is among a small subset of papers that is read by elites and captains of industry. Most of the people at the top of large credit card companies heard this from the NYT, not from customer complaints or lower-level employees, and they immediately thought about the PR implications.

> How many of the members of the NYT and the Visa and Mastercard boards who created on this outcome watched the videos that are now down? Probably a majority of them, but that wasn't enough to stop the moral panic I guess.

Who knows? But that's not why they are cutting off payments. They are cutting off payments because associating with a pornography site that was called out in an NYT op-ed is a bad look.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by lrae on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:20AM (#25419287)
Wouldn't be the worst thing to happen though, would be great to have a reddit alternative that isn't full of expelled extremists.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by manfredo on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:43PM (#25420534)
Reddit's strategy is to shift blame to the moderators of the subreddit in question. This is really their biggest innovation, delegating the burden of moderation to the users. Then the Reddit administrators effectively need to manage a much narrower set of users. They don't need to manage the hundreds of thousands of users in /r/news, just the few active moderators.

If the NYT or another big outlet publishes a hit pieces, Reddit will just ban or quarantine that particular subreddit. We already saw this play out with The_Donald and a few other subreddits (one on hating fat people, and one with a derogatory slur based on racoons come to mind).

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by bilbo0s on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:27PM (#25421988)
In the case of criminal liability, that won't work.

That's almost the first lesson you learn as a first year back in law school. You can't contract away criminal liability. If there were child porn found on a sub-reddit for instance, the executives are liable. So you have to work overtime to make sure that stuff isn't on your servers. Or if it is, that you are reporting it in a timely fashion. A situation where a video with 10 views that was on your server for 1 day before you reported to law enforcement will be looked at very differently than dozens of videos, with thousands of views, that were all on your site for an average of 3 months before being reported to law enforcement.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by manfredo on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:44PM (#25423011)
No, this is why section 230 exists. Sites are not liable for user generated content. Nobody would ever, ever risk of assuming liability for all of the of millions or even billions of users on a web platform.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by Bootvis on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:24AM (#25419330)
Why do you consider it a hit piece? The main allegation that illegal content was on PornHub is based on facts, right?
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by miracle2k on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:47AM (#25419660)
Illegal content is on Facebook, Twitter, Reddit. The question is if and when it is removed. There are people accusing all of those sites of irresponsibility when it comes to moderating. But roughly, there seems to be no strong evidence that Pornhub did not remove illegal content they became aware of.

More generally, the question is if a porn-site that allows anyone to upload stuff should be legally viable. You may feel that it should not. But make no mistake, Laila Mickelwait wants to shutdown the porn industry, not improve Pornhub.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by Raphmedia on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:08PM (#25421751)
> But roughly, there seems to be no strong evidence that Pornhub did not remove illegal content they became aware of.

There seem to be no strong evidence that Pornhub did remove illegal content they became aware of.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by twblalock on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:25PM (#25422794)
> But roughly, there seems to be no strong evidence that Pornhub did not remove illegal content they became aware of.

It's delusional to think that Pornhub did not know about this content. They only cared when the credit card companies threatened to withhold payments.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by totony on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:37PM (#25424312)
This is clearly false, they've claimed to be using a lot of technologies to preventively detect these issues. Visa has threatened to destroy not only Pornhub, but the whole parent company now. They'll just shut down Pornhub before destroying their company. Looking forward to the next russian-hosted site. It will surely be better, right?
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by twblalock on Monday December 14, 2020 @07:50PM (#25425609)
> This is clearly false, they've claimed to be using a lot of technologies to preventively detect these issues.

Either the technology didn't work, or the claims were false. Either way, Pornhub knew that they were hosting these videos. They just didn't care.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by dragonwriter on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:55AM (#25419764)
> How many of the members of the NYT and the Visa and Mastercard boards who created on this outcome watched the videos that are now down?

Probably fewer than have financial interests in Facebook. Probably the most damaging thing PornHub did in response was pointing to the nearly 6 orders of magnitude difference in instances of child sex abuse between themselves and Facebook. Had they not been willing to point out the hypocrisy and how much worse a far more mainstream (and more American) company like Facebook is, they wouldn't need to be destroyed, just mildly symbolically punished as a distraction from the real problem areas.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by jonnycomputer on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:31PM (#25422066)
I think a lot of readers and visitors to Pornhub assumed that Pornhub was reputable (as reputable as a porn site could be), and were shocked by the expose. They could also have legitimate reason to worry that they might be culpable for inadvertently viewing illegal material, and would be angry at Pornhub for exposing them to that risk.

And lets' be frank. Most people are pretty uncomfortable about talking about their porn habits. Talking knowledgeably about what is on the site reveals them as a visitor. This is something that is difficult for people to discuss, and will only do so from the most defensible position possible.

I am angry at Pornhub too. Stolen content is one thing. But rape and pedophilia is another.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by nipponese on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:12PM (#25420030)
Mastercard blocked charges from them and VISA signaled they would do the same. Pretty simple.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by sumedh on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:59PM (#25425141)
Its the NY Times article and then Mastercard threatened to cut access to their payment platform which is why Pornhub acted so fast.
Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by RIMR on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:36AM (#25419515)
I don't think that the takeaway from this story should be "sites hosting child pornography should be careful of journalists exposing them".

I think the takeaway should be "sites hosting child pornography should stop doing that".

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ogre_codes on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:56AM (#25419797)
> They're just an opinion columnist's penstroke away from the mob coming to roost.

If Reddit is not doing anything about content with underaged actors, rape, and non-consenting participants, then they should face scrutiny.

If someone opened a video store in our city with videos of people's underaged kids, portraying rape, or using footage released without consent. You can bet the local PD would be knocking on their door eventually. There is no reason a corporation should be exempt here.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by OJFord on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:08PM (#25419947)
> If someone opened a video store in our city with videos of people's underaged kids

Comparing to Reddit though, I think it's fairer to say something like 'if someone opened a cafe where paedophiles liked to hang out and chat'.

Yes you'd absolutely expect police might visit in plain clothes to try to eavesdrop, or even raid the cafe, or whatever, but generally assuming there's no reason to suspect the cafe owner's involvement they'd do so minimising disruption to the business so far as reasonable/practical.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ogre_codes on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:26PM (#25420264)
> Comparing to Reddit though, I think it's fairer to say something like 'if someone opened a cafe where paedophiles liked to hang out and chat'.

The difference here is Reddit content is persistent and public. If you are in a cafe, your conversations are transient and can only be overheard by your nearest neighbor. Your cafe would have to have a bulletin board or file cabinets where descriptions of content is posted along with where you can get it.

I'm pretty sure that wouldn't last too long either.

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by OJFord on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:34PM (#25422107)
Hmm.. Or a 'graffiti wall' where customers are allowed to contribute to the cafes eclectic art, but it's not exactly curated?

What I'm getting at is Reddit wasn't started with the idea that it had to vet content, if you put the responsibility for content on the website owner/operator.. I'm not saying it's wrong, but I think it's hard to draw a parallel on the high street, just because of the scale of the internet I suppose.

A debate society perhaps, that keeps rigorous records - in parliament for example, if a Member said something egregious they'd be personally called out on it, apologies (or resignation) demanded, etc. - but it wouldn't be struck from record. People might also think the Speaker ought to have stepped in sooner, etc., but then I suppose that's the problem again - there is and always has been the expectation of moderation there, the record keeping isn't some passive web form -> database, it's human presence.

(I'm honestly not sure where I stand on it, I'm not arguing one way or the other; just thinking - and putting those thoughts into a passive web form -> database that has only some light retrospective moderation. ;))

Re:Pornhub just purged all unverified content from the platform by ogre_codes on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:45PM (#25422237)
> What I'm getting at is Reddit wasn't started with the idea that it had to vet content, if you put the responsibility for content on the website owner/operator.. I'm not saying it's wrong, but I think it's hard to draw a parallel on the high street, just because of the scale of the internet I suppose.

Scale seems to be the recurring theme of defense of illicit content.

I think that's backwards. The scale of these platforms means they have an obligation to be more vigilant.