News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by soneca on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:53AM (#25415596)
What is sad to me looking from the outside it is that it didn’t have to be that way. Most of negative reviews seem to boil down to too many students, not enough support, not professional enough course management. Symptoms of growing pains. But why Lambda School had to grow that much that fast? It didn’t. It shouldn’t. It was at the expense of their students.

Lambda School seemed a great idea from the start, revolutionary even. And the investors (pg mostly) would praise how insanely ambitious the founder was. Then I started following him on Twitter and saw that. He had that drive to be the Facebook of education, the slack of boot camps. But education doesn’t work that way. A new Facebook user can start using it 4 hours a day from the first day and get all the value they expect. A student can’t. Students need time and support to learn. But Lambda and its founder couldn’t wait for that if they wanted to become a unicorn.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:11AM (#25417685)
CEO of Lambda School here.

This is disappointing, of course. We have 180+ people working really, really hard to make Lambda School the best experience it can be. At times we’ll fall short, and, as another poster pointed out, the margin for error is just razor thin; thousands of happy and successful students can be out there, but it’s the ones who don’t make it or have a good experience that cause us to lose sleep (and make it to the top of HN).

We take our responsibility in that regard very seriously; students come to us to change their lives and do something really, really difficult, and anything we do affects people in a very profound way.

To the parent’s point, in this particular instance I don’t think this student's frustrations are the result of too much growth or lack of resources per student. We haven’t really grown over the past year or so, and the school is still very well resourced. We have just north of 2,000 students and ~180 full-time staff members, the majority of which are student-facing. Those may be suboptimally distributed (they are, and always will be to some degree) but a cheap education as a result of aggressive cost cutting this is not. As such, the solution is much less exciting than “need to spend more money” or “need to grow more slowly.”

This student’s frustration comes from a series of changes we made simultaneously (something we avoid doing when we can). Some of these changes worked very well. Some did not. And this is the tricky part: some of the changes that a subset of students did not like are unquestionably for their benefit. So we’re working through those changes as well as debates around the trade-offs around, “Do we want our students to love us or be successful?”

The specifics of what students didn’t like: The first is a mentor/mentee program we set up within the school. Employers tell us literally every day they want students who truly understand the development and release cycle, and work on teams. We created a mentor/mentee program where every student has a chance to do that, and the result of that program so clearly creates better outcomes that employers ask specifically for students who have done that.

Some students love it. Some students see it as one more thing distracting them from writing more code, and believe the only thing that will determine their career success is ability to write code (as you all know, ability to write code is necessary but not sufficient to success as an engineer). We’re digging into the details of how and why it fails when it does. I don’t yet know what we’ll do there but the solution is likely more quiet and subtle iteration to the student experience.

The other change was our slowly winding down of the Team Lead program. We used to have a program where we would hire some students on short contracts to serve as something akin to TAs. Sometimes this worked very well, often times it didn’t work well, and the experience was brittle and unreliable, so we shifted that budget back into full-time roles. Doing so has revealed gaps that TLs were plugging that should have never existed (the majority of which should have been solved by software and not people from the get-go.)

So, Lambda School is not yet perfect and likely never will be. We’re properly resourced and not growing too quickly. We’re trying out best to make everyone we admit happy and successful. Turns out that’s extraordinarily difficult to do, and we’re doing the best we can, and I’m always open to any feedback on what we can or should do better.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by ExLambdaStudent on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:49PM (#25423087)
This, right here, is Lambda's biggest trick. I created a hacker account just because of how much it infuriates me to see Austen doing it again here.

Austen is very very good at finding public criticism and responding to it. In contrast, in Lambda's slack, every criticism is automatically taken to private PM, to get it out of the way as soon as possible and to immediately shutdown any ensuing conversation. (A few times, when that didn't work, they turned off comments altogether.)

Lambda's strategy is to PRETEND to be responsive to feedback, to say a lot of pretty words and act concerned, while actually ignoring all of it.

For example, they created a student survey to see how students felt about removing the majority of paid teachers (team leads) and forcing us to be mentors instead. One of the first questions?

"Do you agree that leadership is an important part of being a successful programmer?" (approximately)

The rest of the survey was the same. They weren't interested in getting feedback. They were interested in pretending to listen to feedback.

Austen is minimizing student frustration in this comment, acting like people are grumbling about minor changes. He's ignoring the many many people who have written out long, articulate, arguments about how the changes damaged their education and removed the value of Lambda for them.

He also acts like he didn't delete every post in the Lambda subreddit that offered criticism over the last three months, without any response.

False honesty in threads like this is how Lambda gets away with being dishonest.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by regretful_llama on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:18PM (#25426563)
Also a lambda student, 100% agree. This was actually one of the biggest selling points for me, I dug up lots of old articles and reddit threads and weighed the criticism against his responses. I thought it was endearing and refreshing and a really good sign to see the CEO have these discussions in public. It still gets to me too, reading his responses in this thread, I still want to believe they will do well by their students, but their track record doesn't hold up. He is just a STELLAR marketer.

In Lambda slack, dissent is shut down immediately by "student success" staff directing you to DMs. Or an individual zoom chat, which is friendly and seemingly receptive to feedback, but ultimately pointless. A student-created poll with 90+ votes was posted after the changes went live, and it was taken down immediately, along with all feedback, to be replaced by their byzantine "More Transparent" survey system, conveniently delayed to be issued on a Friday evening, that could be twisted into yet another glowing report on the exciting new changes.

Lambda has plenty of real feedback and criticism (constructive and otherwise) and they have no interest in it. They make a very convincing show of listening and having meaningful discussions, but look at the form of the substantive changes. They've completely gutted their successful learning structure to replace it with something cheaper, and hide the damage in their reporting. But they're still "iterating" so we'll see, right?

My key criticisms: 1. Waves arms This, all of this. The dishonesty. 2. Removing TLs. The accountability and required meeting every day really made the difference between this and self-study. TLs were holding the program together. 3. Instituting self grading with no human evaluation, even for end-of-module tests. You can join "code review" group calls but it's voluntary, there's no one checking your work at the end of the section. 4. Cutting the curriculum (there is no python instruction) Opting into the "extended curriculum" just means you repeat the same thing twice.

If you're considering joining, also be aware that he deletes comments and tweets, and is the moderator of the subreddit. From what I've seen, the style is to allow the dissent, maybe even engage, and then quietly delete it later after things have blown over. What you see online may be curated even if it seems like it's outside the purview of Lambda official channels.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by WalterGR on Monday December 14, 2020 @04:27PM (#25423585)
”Do you agree that leadership is an important part of being a successful programmer?"

I don’t have a horse in this fight, but the above is a generalization of what’s called Push Polling: polling in a way to change opinions and get a desired outcome, rather than to actually gather pre-existing opinions.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Push_poll

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by digianarchist on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @01:05AM (#25427491)
It’s like when the manufacturer responds to negative reviews on Home Depot. There’s no follow up from the customer so people just assume it was resolved.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by mondoshawan on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:51AM (#25418175)

  Some students see it as one more thing distracting them from
  writing more code, and believe the only thing that will
  determine their career success is ability to write code (as you
  all know, ability to write code is necessary but not 
  sufficient to success as an engineer).
As an interviewer, engineer and lead myself, I'd say your students that think this are pretty darn close. If I get a junior candidate that can't code, I write them off and say goodbye.

I can teach dev lifecycle to a junior, and often need to because every business I've worked at as a lead has a totally different model. I can coach them on inter-team dynamics (and often have to). I can help them with culture fit to a point (if they're willing). What I can't do is teach them to be able to reason and write code and do the engineering work I hired them for.

From the Reddit post (and from other reviews), it sounds like the students are not performing well and sinking without learning this core skill -- most didn't understand enough to code in JS, for instance. This seems like a pretty dire failure in the part of the program itself.

Do you plan on at least giving these students a chance to retake prior units without further charging them for knowledge you should have already taught them?

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:56AM (#25418228)
Certainly agreed that being able to code is necessary. I’d argue it’s necessary and not sufficient.

> Do you plan on at least giving these students a chance to retake prior units without further charging them for knowledge you should have already taught them?

Students are actually strongly encouraged to retake units at no additional cost in order to move on to the next level, and in some instances we require it.

This is actually where some of the greatest frustration comes. It would be easy to close our eyes and wave people along but we have to say at times, “You’re not quite there yet, let’s keep working at it.” That’s not what students want to hear.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by sugarwater on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:18PM (#25420135)
But you implemented changes so that the students themselves determine whether or not they want to flex? That's what happened the last two units for me... For two build weeks I was in a team of 8 people, and in both cases only one other person showed up. There were no repercussions for those that didn't attend build week and they continued on to the next unit regardless of whether or not they were ready. You grade yourself model and you flex yourself model is horrendous. I know some auto-grading has (very) slowly been implemented in earlier units, but essentially I went through 1/3rd of the program without any feedback other than my own, with two terrible teachers that were both new to teaching.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by shay_ker on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:20PM (#25422718)
> This is actually where some of the greatest frustration comes. It would be easy to close our eyes and wave people along but we have to say at times, “You’re not quite there yet, let’s keep working at it.” That’s not what students want to hear.

I hear that this is good feedback, but looking at sugarwater's response that seemingly matches up w/ the original critique, maybe the current situation falls short of what you're trying to do, Austen?

These may be outliers, but from my perspective, the frustrations seem valid.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by sugarwater on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:51PM (#25423102)
It's not an outlier of an experience. My cohort really did go through 2 units with no one looking at our assessments and assignments, and we determined whether or not we passed onto the next unit. It was an organizational mess.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by Saporaku on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:18PM (#25422693)
I think that some of the issue with allowing students to retake is that there is a lot of pressure to continue the program regardless of skill because: A) self judgement and passing leaves the unconfident people at a severe disadvantage regardless of their skill B) it’s not codified in the contract that this is allowed. It’s a worry that a student will be ejected if they are not performing or worth the time investment by lambda. That can look like missing resources or scheduling delays, which do seem to happen. It seems to be a normal event for cancellation for help from a tl or a technical hiccup not to be answered for several days.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by gigatexal on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:09AM (#25418389)
Being able to read and write code in whatever language you claim to be proficient in on your resume is just table stakes imo. Being self taught I learned the whole team based development life cycle on the job. It was stressful. But it took maybe a month or two and I was proficient at git, setting up CI/CD, writing unit tests, and debugging things to just name a few.

I laud you being willing to teach a junior dev but I just find so many places are not open to hiring juniors at all.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by thelastwave on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @12:41PM (#25432648)
> What I can't do is teach them to be able to reason and write code and do the engineering work I hired them for.

Excuse me if I'm missing the obvious, but why can't you teach them that? Seems like it'd be right up your alley.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by mondoshawan on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @01:24AM (#25439688)
Because its a total waste of money -- I'd be hiring someone who does not posess the requisite skills to do the base level job. My job is to create software solutions for the company by using my skills, and lead a team of engineers to produce a better solution. The role I hire a junior engineer for is the same: a much lower requisite skill level, yes, but skill nonetheless. I am not in the business of education -- that is literally what educators like Austen are for.

While the time spent teaching a blank slate how to be an engineer might benefit the person, it is literally throwing money away from the perspective of the company because it's not what I was hired to do.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by soneca on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:57AM (#25418252)
Thanks for your response. I’ll take your word that the mistakes are not due to too much ambition and are not originated by biting more than what you can chew or a “land grab” market strategy. I have no primary knowledge on Lambda School to do otherwise.

But it is worth paying more attention to the frustrated students feedback. The OP one is about lack of team leaders and having “mentors” that are qualified just by having two more months of online classes than them. And it is not the first time a similar issue arises. Lambda School seems to always be justifying mistakes after some disgruntled student testimonial gets some traction.

My personal unsolicited advice: listen more to your students ahead of time and not employers. Employers are full of bullshit. They have a huge list of qualities that they want to see in a candidate, then go on to hire someone that is not at all like that, but the hiring manager liked (for whatever subjective reasons). It seems to be a wrong step to follow employers gospel and go against students expectations. You say that you know more about what students want and need than themselves. I doubt that. Give what students want: confidence that they learned something useful and, moreover, confidence that they can continue to learn about UX/software development through their career. That confidence in their knowledge will earn them jobs, not employers with no skin in the game telling you want they ideally want.

Don’t patronize your students. When you do, it feels from the outside that you are taking shortcuts to people’s education in favor of short term market share growth.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by seem_2211 on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:37AM (#25418717)
> You say that you know more about what students want and need than themselves. I doubt that.

This seems like a bad frame to look at the situation from. We don’t know what we don’t know, and don’t always actually know what we want.

When I went to university there was a ton that I didn’t know. It took me at least a semester to get accustomed to how the institution ran.

If my university responded only to what I wanted and “needed” then I would be quite worried about the education they are serving.

Also optimizing for employer preferences seems to make sense you know... if you’re focused as a vocational style institute?

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:59AM (#25418282)
Hmm, agreed that employers can be full of shit, but I try to look at what they do and who they hire not what they say.

There can never be too many reminders to listen to student feedback. Thank you!

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by jrochkind1 on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:33PM (#25420359)
> The specifics of what students didn’t like: The first is a mentor/mentee program we set up within the school. Employers tell us literally every day they want students who truly understand the development and release cycle, and work on teams. We created a mentor/mentee program where every student has a chance to do that, and the result of that program so clearly creates better outcomes that employers ask specifically for students who have done that. Some students love it. Some students see it as one more thing distracting them from writing more code,

The complaints i have seen around mentors in this thread and those linked are not that they don't see the user of a mentor/mentee program, but conversely that their mentor was not qualified or good at it. That's very different, they like the mentor/mentee program in theory, they don't think it's well executed.

Anyway, with 2000 students enrolled, it's possible that some groups/courses/teams/classes/whatever you call them are worse than others. We may only hear from those in the worst. But then the question is, how do you find out about these "failing" teams quickly, and how do you correct them, so those students still get the quality you aspire for. It's kind of too late after they've had months of a bad experience, they won't get those months back, of their lives, or of your program. What systems are in place to do that; what systems might be possible?

Because the other disturbing thing in linked threads is students who tried to contact you to say the teachers/lessons/other devices weren't up to your standards, and could not get an ear.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by estaseuropano on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:14PM (#25424112)
I have zero skin in the game either way, but this is such a sad and dismissive response. At the surface polite and accepting critique, but underneath that putting all the blame on the student that paid a ridiculous 30k for this. Generalised 'most did like/benefit from this' to discredit the specific critique while not engaging with the issue of why the issues weren't fixed. Supposedly a 1:10 teacher:student ratio but no one fixed the problems mentioned by op or in the Reddit thread. Do they all only work 1h a month?

This post tells me all I ever needed to know about lambda. Clearly an irresponsible organisation more focused on image than value and with no respect for their supposed students.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by ghufran_syed on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:19PM (#25426259)
If they get a tech job paying greater than $50,000 per year, then they pay some proportion of their pay, for a period of years, up to a maximum of $30k. So are you saying the student earned enough to pay $30k? Then they also earned a lot more than that after the program for themselves. If they didn’t earn more than $50k per year for a few years after lambda school, they pay nothing
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by nunya_bidness on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @12:13AM (#25427252)
This is what happens when you suppress complaint and disagreement internally. The truth will come out. It always does. You can choose to ignore that truth or justify your position which this post certainly does. Take any substance and press down on it and does it stay contained within it's original shape as force multiplies or does it expand outward?

Lambda School made 2 promises to students when I joined. 1. They promised that students would always have access to the most up to date curriculum that was offered. This is no longer true. 2. They promised a network that connected students to alumni in an ever expanding community. They started separating alumni from the student workspace in Slack months ago. That community doesn't exist.

These are the 2 most fundamental promises that Lambda School made to students and it has broken both. Add to this incompetence or indifference the damaging changes that have been made to the curriculum and no one can reasonably accept the same price tag, $30K, for the diminished service, unaccountable support and lower quality curriculum product.

Students aren't the only population at Lambda School who are unhappy with these changes that Allred claims, "some of the changes that a subset of students did not like are unquestionably for their benefit". If this is true why is Lambda School losing or in the process of losing key instructors further degrading the quality of the product.

Lambda School can no longer rely on student referrals for driving growth in enrollment. Lambda School current and future instructor departures will continue the downward spiral. Allred seems to believe he can will the bleeding to stop. A bit of humility and self awareness would be a better path for him to consider over his protestations. Those on the inside at Lambda School recognize his words as nonsense.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by ptero on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:51AM (#25418170)
First, kudos for answering and not avoiding a group that you expect to hold (based on the linked post) adverse feelings. Good information, too. Education greatly benefits from more options; best of luck! Now for things that I think need work (I know little about Lambda school, so this is definitely an armchair strategist opinion):

First and foremost, as others pointed, is the growth plans. Education is hard to scale -- good educators deliver fantastic results; a very smart person droning on along a prewritten material adds no value. I doubt there is a way to quickly figure out how good a teacher a new hire is -- it will be clear after a semester or two, but not before. Thus good education needs long-term staff and careful hiring; both hard to scale.

> changes that a subset of students did not like are unquestionably for their benefit

Ouch. OUCH! Anytime someone is claiming that they do something for your benefit against your will, look for other motives. It is perfectly OK to limit options -- it is your business and you do not have infinite flexibility. But claiming it is good for the students rings hollow. Sorry. "We are tracking your web purchases to better serve you" (annoying advertisements).

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by anchpop on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:23PM (#25424196)
I disagree with your last point. In many cases in teaching, the teacher knows the correct path better than the student. One example I've found is that when an experienced teacher says "Practice this. It's boring and you won't enjoy it and you'll wish you were doing something more exciting, but investing skill into it now will pay off later" I very rarely regret listening to them even if it seems totally useless at the time.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by ptero on Monday December 14, 2020 @07:42PM (#25425541)
I have no objection to your example, but it is a very different case; it is convincing vs forcing.

In your example the teacher is arguing to convince you, the final decision maker, that something is long term worthwhile even if near term unpleasant (and most adults who sign up for a class will usually listen to the teacher). The original example is closer to the teacher locking the door and saying "you will not leave until you show me that you learned X". Which is a very different setup that, even if fruitful, few adults will find palatable. My 2c.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by arenaninja on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:27AM (#25417882)
I've never looked into Lambda School but some bits from this stand out to me.

> We have just north of 2,000 students and ~180 full-time staff members, the majority of which are student-facing.

2000/180 = 12 students per staff member. This seems high and "student-facing" is padding the numbers. "Customer Success" people are technically student-facing but not instructors, and number of instructors per student is the most important number that matters for quality

> This student’s frustration comes from a series of changes we made simultaneously

Do not make changes to ongoing cohorts

> Some students see it as one more thing distracting them from writing more code, and believe the only thing that will determine their career success is ability to write code

Isn't this something a school would be able to educate on? Why not introduce group projects (maybe you already have them)?

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:32AM (#25417950)
> 2000/180 = 12 students per staff member. This seems high and "student-facing" is padding the numbers.

It is very, very high.

I’d have to dig to find the exact numbers but about 90 are directly involved in instruction, project management, etc. Not including student support.

> Do not make changes to ongoing cohorts

We really try to avoid doing so, but in some instances it is impossible.

> Isn't this something a school would be able to educate on? Why not introduce group projects (maybe you already have them)?

We do have group projects and do try to educate here. Students will come back a year after being hired and say, “Wow, I thought x was a waste of time but it was extraordinarily useful” all the time.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by borishn on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:40AM (#25418050)
> > Do not make changes to ongoing cohorts > We really try to avoid doing so, but in some instances it is impossible.

You sold students something you can't implement. Apologize and offer a full refund.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:47AM (#25418132)
I suppose it depends on what “changes” means. We specifically tell students (and they even sign a document that says) that we will make changes to aspects of the the experience during their time as a student (e.g. schedule, specifics of curriculum).

Students can be with Lambda for as long as 2+ years. Everything being frozen in time would be to their great detriment.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by thebean11 on Monday December 14, 2020 @04:21PM (#25423493)
> schedule, specifics of curriculum

These are not the changes OP is complaining about. Your responses kind of strike me as misdirection.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by borishn on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:44AM (#25418806)
> I suppose it depends on what “changes” means.

Don't pull Bill Clinton [1].

When enough people complain you made changes that are material and detrimental.

[1] https://slate.com/news-and-politics/1998/09/bill-clinton-and...

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by FemmeAndroid on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:00AM (#25418290)
Why not let them opt in to new things if they really are benefits?
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:03AM (#25418328)
Generally speaking we do, and almost every change we made had an opt in/out option.

The only times we can’t do that (and that’s happened maybe 1-2 times in the history of Lambda School) is when it’s a change to teams of students that run across multiple cohorts.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by FemmeAndroid on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:05AM (#25418356)
So in those rare circumstances, why not offer refunds to those who don't want to stay with Lambda School after the change?
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by ghufran_syed on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:24PM (#25426282)
Do universities offer full refunds for the whole 4 years of a course if they had to change the curriculum while a student was studying there? If not, why such elevated expectations for a school that’s trying to align their interests with that of their students (school only gets paid if the student is financially successful), but not for other institutions that leave their students with massive debt that is not contingent on their student’s success?
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by FemmeAndroid on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @01:06AM (#25427498)
University credits are transferable in a way a partial education from Lambda School is not, and you can pause at any time. Universities do let you stop part way through your education. Most universities do have options to get partial refunds that are more reasonable than the ones Lambda school seems to offer. Instate tuition across the US is also a fraction of Lambda School, with multiple options if you want to transfer credits.

For what it’s worth, major changes in curriculum do lead to refunds at schools. There have been two examples in my education where mid-year I had a graduate level class need to be rescheduled from a night class due to a professor’s illness. Both were fully refunded when I couldn’t fit the class into my work schedule. That seems to be pretty analogous here, and I wasn’t charged a percent based on how many weeks I attended the class before the change. I was just refunded the total amount of the course because I wouldn’t be able to gain its value. It wasn’t even a difficult process to get the refund, unlike the weeks of trying to get support it seems like the person in this situation attempted.

I think I would place ‘elevated’ expectations for refunds on a founder due to the elevated risk of trying a Startup’s unproven, expensive, and risky education model. I don’t think the expectations are ‘elevated’ but I also think your baseline for doing good for students shouldn’t be ‘it’s only as bad as I perceive the alternatives.’ I think we should strive to do better.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:11AM (#25418412)
I can imagine scenarios where a full refund would be make sense, but refund isn’t really appropriate when we’re talking about small changes in schedule, especially when everyone agreed such changes were possible.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by FemmeAndroid on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:25AM (#25418572)
Yeah, that's your prerogative. Personally, I'd eat some bad press by just making it a policy to always have opt-in changes across the board, or offer dissatisfied students refunds. And saying "everyone agreed such changes were possible" when you're essentially talking about the fine text of a contract only one side has the opportunity to define the terms of seems questionable. We aren't talking about two sides in a negotiation coming to a meeting of the minds. You created a contract with those terms, on top of an already questionably structured ISA. You can change the contract to make it more explicitly favorable to your students.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:35AM (#25418708)
How is the ISA questionably structured?
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by FemmeAndroid on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:50AM (#25418875)
See my other thread here about how by not being a progressively structured ISA, you can cause the most harm to students who get the least out of your 'school.' Not to mention your securitizing of ISAs removes the argument for your model that you align your business with the success of your students.

But frankly, if the only thing you took out of this post is that the ISA structure is poor, without considering how you have all the power to set and enforce terms in your contract, I don't think I have much else I can say to try and help you. I think there are a lot of ways you can improve Lambda School to make it better for the people attending. And they don't involve deleting Reddit threads of criticism.

Edit: s/selling/securitizing

[dead]
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:04PM (#25419897)
In the event we finance an ISA of a student who has not graduated we have to refund what we received if a student doesn't graduate.

You are incorrect in your understanding of how ISA financing works. Our interests and incentives remain aligned.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by catern on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:15PM (#25420078)
>In the event we finance an ISA of a student who has not graduated we have to refund what we received if a student doesn't graduate.

Interesting, I didn't know this. I thought you just sold the ISA outright, which would retain some of the incentive but weaken it quite a bit. It's great to hear that that's not happening.

I found https://lambdaschool.com/the-commons/announcing-our-new-isa-... discussing this in more detail. Seems like everyone complaining about Lambda School ISA financing should just read that...

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:22PM (#25420208)
Right now it's technically structured as a sale to an SPV that is owned by Lambda, Lambda gets a small advance (<$5k/student) that we have to pay back before we get any additional cashflows.

It's still completely aligned, we just fast-forward some of the cash so we don't have to raise endless amounts of VC.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by lifteatdev on Monday December 14, 2020 @04:38PM (#25423717)
" Lastly, this arrangement will not affect the student experience during or after Lambda School."

As a student, I can confirm this is a lie. And you know it is because we have told you in Slack, we've told you on Twitter, we've told you on Reddit, and now you have to read about it on Hacker News.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by arolihas on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @11:19AM (#25431672)
It’s interesting that he never responds to current or former students publicly.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by storf45 on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:05PM (#25422507)
Are you okay?
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by sugarwater on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:41PM (#25422189)
"Small" is really exaggerating the changes. Schedule is just a small part of it. But while we're talking about schedule, many parents that are students at Lambda School struggled hard with the increase of meetings after the changes were implemented.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by gu5 on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @09:13PM (#25438201)
"especially when everyone agreed such changes were possible" Looking at this thread, it doesn't seem like everyone agreed.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by nicoburns on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:02AM (#25418308)
> The first is a mentor/mentee program we set up within the school. Employers tell us literally every day they want students who truly understand the development and release cycle, and work on teams. We created a mentor/mentee program where every student has a chance to do that, and the result of that program so clearly creates better outcomes that employers ask specifically for students who have done that.

One thing that jumps out at me is that students who have only just gone through the course themselves may not make the best mentors. They top x% percent probably make excellent mentors, but they rest still don't really know what they're doing themselves. You may want to actually build in some kind of assessment here and have mentoring as a "high performance track" (ideally with this being something the high-performing students can put on their resumes). I've seen this done very successfully in traditional schools (for children).

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:05AM (#25418351)
This may not be a bad idea. We didn’t do this in the past because the benefit is actually more to the mentor than to the mentee.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by nicesnowoman on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:13AM (#25419198)
Former student here. You are a grifter and a liar who is fully aware that students are punished for leaving negative feedback.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by edmundsauto on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:10PM (#25419989)
This is not an appropriate comment. If you can present your issues without personal attacks, it will be a more effective message. If you are a former student, then even though you are frustrated, surely you have specifics in your complaints?
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by yaass on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @04:57AM (#25440768)
Complete lack of empathy in this response. Not even “I’m sorry to hear this” or “sorry that you had this experience.” You just go straight into defence mode instead of genuinely wanting to understand the posters experience. Sorry, but you don’t get brownie points just for responding as the CEO, when it’s evident in this response and others that you don’t truly care about the people that you are serving. You are much more interested in managing the reputational risk of your business.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by shay_ker on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:35AM (#25418700)
Some of the frustrations were also about removing standups, grading yourself, and no attendance. Can you speak to that as well?
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by asdffdsa on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:31PM (#25424264)
I'd suggest you not minimize, disregard, and reinterpret criticism, especially if it's repeated and widespread. It's better to learn from criticism than to try to twist it into something else (into something you think you already know and can control). The latter comes across as disingenuous and only makes the (already obvious to everyone else) problem worse.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by bsradcliffe on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @10:55AM (#25444060)
“We’re properly resourced and not growing too quickly.”

All of this after saying things are suboptimally distributed.

Austen, you constantly snake your way out of accountability and admitting bad things come from your school. Why don’t you just man up and fix the problems and take a hit to your profit margin? Don’t get into education if it’s a money grab, you dumb schmuck.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by simonebrunozzi on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:00PM (#25424557)
I don't know the specifics, but your answer as CEO of Lambda School is a great answer. Most CEOs in your position would have not provided this level of details. Or answered at all.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by thelastwave on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:20AM (#25418514)
This is a fine response that provides real insight into how you see the problem and opportunity costs, and not typical CEO empty rhetoric. Good luck with your platform.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by javaIsGreat on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:33AM (#25419464)
I dont know anything about Lambda's failures to serve students other than most students are upset at paying for less than steller experiences (most of the other prestigious bootcamps share this), but my gut tells me I dont think they grew to fast, its just the calibur of student went down, i feel like the hot new bootcamp of the day is able to get really bright and/or qualified students. More average learners require more time and resources and the nonspecial sauce will NOT get them a dream job in less than a year which is the opposite of what all of the marketing leads u to beleive for all the bootcamps.

Lambda seems to have been trying to branch out to more normal learners.

Students that dont share those bright/already qualified credentials, do benifit a little bit of a "rub" effect by being associated with those bright/qualified students, and get to study/work with them during the course of the bootcamp so everyone wins in the short term. For average learners without significant backround IT knowledge or a prestigious degree, realistically they are going to need more than 3-6 months or a year to get a cushy programming job in the US (which seems to be what all of the bootcamps advertise they can offer students).

I consider myself an average/below average speed learner, took a bootcamp, i was surprised to learn the guy i was pair programming with had a CS degree from MIT lol. Some devs already had work programming experience, but most of us normies benifited by pairing with them and talking to them about problems/code/computers/study habits.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by 908B64B197 on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:32PM (#25422879)
> I was surprised to learn the guy I was pair programming with had a CS degree from MIT lol.

That surprises me.

Someone who could drink from the firehose should not need some bootcamp to learn web dev.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by javaIsGreat on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @01:31AM (#25427625)
I think some CS grads come out of school with a lack of practical framework knowledge, i mean like React or Ruby on Rails, rather than spend 5 months learning/building on their own, these top tier students choose to learn/build in a managed environment so it takes them 3 rather than 5 months. They are promised assistance with applying to jobs as well which can be a nerve wrecking process for a university grad. If you have the money and want to jump into the work force ASAP it makes sense to me.

The in person bootcamps ive found have had great community vibes to them. Fun being surrounded by fellow students/teachers, schools all have fun/studious/interesting faculty and students.

I taught the first few weeks of a FREE intro to software engineering bootcamp and had a few lower tier university CS grads who were happy with the curriculum/services rendered, they would just tune me out when i was covering something they already knew and would study/program while the less informed students would work through problems/Q/A with me.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @02:27PM (#25433980)
> They are promised assistance with applying to jobs as well which can be a nerve wrecking process for a university grad.

Universities tend to have career services offices that specialize in that and which are free for current students and at least recent alumni.

> If you have the money and want to jump into the work force ASAP it makes sense to me.

It's literally delaying entering the workforce, so it really doesn't make sense if you want to enter the workforce ASAP.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by 908B64B197 on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @02:21PM (#25433924)
3 months to learn a framework?

I've seen web dev classes in colleges that are spread out on a semester where they basically learn whichever framework the university decided to teach. Doesn't take 3 months of full time work, more like 6 hours per week including labs.

I highly doubt someone from MIT CS would go that route and pay for a bootcamp, considering how easy it's for them to get internships at companies where they are going to learn it on the job anyways.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by javaIsGreat on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @03:10PM (#25434536)
I agree that a CS from MIT surprised me,

Like i said, if you can spare the cash, and want to do a bootcamp, it might make sense for you,

I wouldnt discredit all of the bootcamps as useless money wasters, everyone has different goals/aspirations reasons for doing a bootcamp rather than jumping straight into the workforce. The MIT CS guy did end up getting a great dev job right out of the program.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by 908B64B197 on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @04:01PM (#25435208)
> The MIT CS guy did end up getting a great dev job right out of the program.

I have no doubts he would. I'm doubting his very existence. Or, pretty sure he didn't pay retail on the bootcamp.

I think going from absolutely no code experience to 70K by doing a 6 months bootcamp is simply impossible. The many articles on lambda illustrate that.

For someone with a real CS or Engineering degree, I wouldn't waste any time or money on a bootcamp unless my employer was paying for it.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by javaIsGreat on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @12:33AM (#25439436)
If you are accusing me of lying im not lol. I assume he got north of 125k for a top dev job not 70k

You could grow a lot as an engineer in three months in the right environment assuming a guided curriculum is able to channel your energies in the right places and teachers/fellow students are able to help as well. I imagine you could also be bored for 3 months, or overly stressed for 3 months, and have negative feelings in regards to that experience. Like most things in life, its not right for everyone and its not wrong for everyone.

I have lots of friends who've paid for coding bootcamps, most are rather content with the services provided. I know some students as well that feel they were swindled out of cash because they weren't able to get a top tier job right out of the program and resorted to previous career path that they were already unhappy with.

I think its great that the good bootcamps that show success are trying to branch out to more normal learners, not just the greatly gifted or qualified (like an Ivy league degree) few, it is a noble sign that these schools are trying to expand using their special sauce to help more averagely qualified student transition into professional software engineering. Ivy league schools, do not do this. They have hundreds of years of success and don't feel the need to teach more students every year. (in regards to their on campus facilities not online programs that clearly dont offer the same experience)

If Lambda or the other top tier bootcamps capped their programs at 10 students a year or cohort, all of whom had ivy degrees or significant personal experience, all of whom who would get jobs immediately out of school, they would better be able to keep their graduation rates/salary rates top notch, they wouldnt have any students complaining online,

I commend them for trying to expand and help more students, and im sure they will stumble and get better as time goes on.

None of the good bootcamp schools that I am aware of just ignore feedback, because they know students will stop going to the school if feedback is ignored as they dont have hundreds of millions of dollars in funding like universities do.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by 908B64B197 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @04:22PM (#25448880)
> If you are accusing me of lying im not lol.

I'm just really surprised. I wonder if he paid retail for the bootcamp, that's all. I could very well see why the bootcamp operators would want a student like that on their graduate lists.

> They have hundreds of years of success and don't feel the need to teach more students every year.

That's what large public universities are for.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by jgalt212 on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:56AM (#25416114)
> praise how insanely ambitious the founder was

It seems to me that VC's often link ambition with intelligence and other assorted skills needed to get the job done.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by papito on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:07AM (#25417034)
I believe Adam Neumann was ambitious, with a "unique leadership style".
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by danjac on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:11AM (#25417688)
I get the feeling some older VCs are playing out their mid-life crises by vicariously enjoying the lifestyles of their "crazier" founders. Perhaps it would be better for the world if they just bought that motorbike or sports car instead.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by papito on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:01AM (#25418297)
It's hard to do when the VC next door just bought a super-yacht that can launch its own mini-yacht, yo.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by etripe on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:10AM (#25417678)
It might also be a simple cases of selecting the in-group for funding rounds. That is, "they're like me, so I'll give 'em cash".
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by lawtalkinghuman on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:20AM (#25417800)
Can't get any more ambitious than Elizabeth Holmes and Theranos.

If only ambition correlated with competence.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by marcinzm on Monday December 14, 2020 @07:49AM (#25416839)
I'd argue that you can hire employees for intelligence and other assorted skills but without an ambitious founder few startups would succeed.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by WJW on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:47AM (#25417423)
It's more that the less ambitious founders would be willing to "settle" for decent-but-not-unicorn outcomes for their companies, which are not the outcomes that VCs are looking for.

The VC-funded startup model will gladly have 99 out of 100 founders go bankrupt as long as the 100th starts a unicorn. Investors will push companies to take existential risks to achieve growth at all costs. Obviously, most founders are not OK with these odds and only the most delusional (if you want to spin it negatively) or ambitious (if you want to spin it positively) will go for it.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by yanslookup on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:55AM (#25417513)
My original comment was too mean spirited, even for this alt account. I think what I meant to say is, Austen Allred does a good job of talking his book on Twitter. He also seems like a great Dad and partner.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by dang on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:58PM (#25422408)
Thanks for the course correction. Small things like that compound into big effects on the community.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by pmart123 on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:13AM (#25417718)
I had a similar impression. His most of his tweets veer off topic from education and feel a little forced.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by austenallred on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:52AM (#25418183)
Haha!

Most of my tweets are randomness from what I’m experiencing or reading about that day.

Am I lonely? Interesting. My family keeps me pretty occupied. Though I suppose I could be to some degree. I suppose we all are.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by nrmitchi on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:05AM (#25418347)
What? Are you following his personal twitter account? Because I am too. Unless I am mistaken, it is a personal twitter account.

I fully expect to see personal stuff on a personal twitter account, and don't expect it to be 100% focused only on the topic of someone's business.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by Tomte on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:55AM (#25415625)
> But why Lambda School had to grow that much that fast?

Isn't that obvious? They have investors. It's precisely what Joel writes about in https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/05/12/strategy-letter-i-...

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by soneca on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:05AM (#25415681)
I know the incentives are there to have exponential Silicon Valley hyper growth. But there are also incentives to be a company that still exists and it is big 20 years from now. And there are ethical decisions that could be made despite of the incentives.

Even being a YC company, I believe it didn’t have to be that way.

Edit: thanks for the link, great article. ”Land grab” is a great term for what I currently think about Lambda School. Except the “land” is people’s life and hopes.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by mxcrossb on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:49AM (#25415958)
A lot of these companies are in the “the only reason it’s a good price is we are burning VC money” and “the only reason we have VC money is our promise to grow” zone. Customers can enjoy watching the slow motion train crash.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by TeMPOraL on Monday December 14, 2020 @07:00AM (#25416199)
That's why I consider startups a Faustian bargain. You get easy access to capital, in exchange for your company's soul. And the devil always comes to collect. The problems start where this deal causes collateral damage on the market - harming customers directly, or indirectly by preventing competitors who aren't looking for an exit from existing.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by pc86 on Monday December 14, 2020 @07:39AM (#25416736)
> indirectly by preventing competitors who aren't looking for an exit from existing.

This is huge, and definitely hurts in the short term, but could it actually be good in the long term? Let's say the break-even price for Service A is $x/mo/user. Nobody really knows the technical problems underlying A, but startups #1-3 get venture funding and start offering Service A for .75x, for a couple years each, burning a few million in some dentist's or VC's capital each and build a huge staff to figure out the tech. Eventually one of the companies gets acquihired and two of them fail.

Bootstrapped Startup #4 opens shop, offers A to 1.15x, and hires engineers from startups 2 and 3 who know the tech inside and out. Consumers get a great product.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by TeMPOraL on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:08AM (#25417650)
I worry that those startups #1-3 burn a good chunk of their money on customer acquisition, not on solving technological problems (though scale creates its own problems too). That money would be unnecessarily wasted. I also doubt a huge staff is needed to figure out the tech part.

But I understand your point: startups can be viewed as economy's distributed R&D. Speculative investment makes a lot of sense - it could be that without startups #1-3, #4 wouldn't exist because it couldn't afford the risk of developing an innovative product. But my main gripe is how VC-backed startups repay the investment - they're being pressured into user-hostile and sometimes antisocial business models. It's so common that these business model became accepted as standard these days! So perhaps a way forward isn't to reduce venture funding, but curtail the socially destructive business models directly.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by fakedang on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:44PM (#25421394)
Imo, bootstrapped startups can only exist feasibly in the B2B space. And definitely not in the B2C space. Would Uber have succeeded if it were bootstrapped (with higher pricing), or would it have spawned enough copycats during its slow growth phase who would soon make it infeasible to scale up and hire the kind of engineers that a venture like ridesharing would need?
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by TeMPOraL on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:05PM (#25424610)
> or would it have spawned enough copycats during its slow growth phase who would soon make it infeasible to scale up and hire the kind of engineers that a venture like ridesharing would need?

Would that be a problem? At least from the point of view of a customer, I don't want a single megacorp owning the market (and let's cut the marketing BS: Uber is not a startup, and hasn't been for a while; it's a multinational corporation). More "copycats" is usually better, as they compete (until they start racing to the bottom, but that's another issue entirely).

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by fakedang on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @01:44AM (#25427694)
I was talking about Uber circa 2009. Were it bootstrapped, we would have seen 5-6 loss making entities competing against each other by 2014 - and Uber wouldn't have likely expanded outside the US.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @02:57AM (#25428044)
I understand. But I don't consider Uber's success a good thing - it was a ruthless company that cornered the market through illegal and antisocial behavior, and unfortunately set a path for other startups to follow. I believe we'd be better off if Uber died very early, and allowed one of their above-board competitors to disrupt the taxi space.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by paledot on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:36AM (#25417298)
And this in capitalism is known as "efficiency".
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by papito on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:10AM (#25417050)
As David Heinemeier Hansson of Basecamp said, paraphrasing: "every time you take someone's [VC] money, you get a new boss."
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by morelisp on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:44AM (#25415930)
> Even being a YC company, I believe it didn’t have to be that way.

YC is a startup incubator. A startup, as defined by YC's founder, is a company that grows fast.

Trying to convince anyone in SV that this is extremely dumb or dangerous or unethical is a waste of time.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by SpicyLemonZest on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:57AM (#25416124)
The sad truth is, there probably isn’t a tradeoff here. ITT Tech survived and grew for almost half a century while offering many students a worse experience at a higher price than the worst I’ve ever seen Lambda School accused of.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by vba on Monday December 14, 2020 @07:47AM (#25416824)
interestingly, from joel "With all of Microsoft’s muscle, money, and marketing skill, they are just not going to be able to break into auctions or instant messaging, because the network effects there are so strong." I remember AIM well (used AOL until they became TalkTalk), but I also remember using MSN messenger even more and being much more ubiquitous, granted that could have been generational (I wasn't a teenager until the mid-naughties). Ultimately it seems MSN did win out.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by eropple on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:33AM (#25417968)
It's funny that you say that, because I grew up in the same time frame (graduated high school in 2006) and I don't think I ever touched MSN Messenger. Where I was, it was AIM all the way.

So perhaps less generational, more just the network effects that existed on the ground.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by whereistimbo on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:58AM (#25418268)
I remember the times where Yahoo! Messenger and MSN/Windows Live Messenger could chat each other. Those were the days.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by michaelcampbell on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:41AM (#25417355)
> praise how insanely ambitious the founder was

If this isn't a warning sign of a spectacular failure, I don't know what is.

Not to mention praising it, after all the ink spilled on "rockstar" "ninja" types and how bad they are, yet they still get kudos and praise.

If you ever have a manager that espouses the "we don't want the heroic cowboy type here", run, because that's EXACTLY what they want.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by UncleMeat on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:13AM (#25417724)
I don’t want heroes on my team. It isn’t sustainable. Heroics are discouraged in performance reviews and promotion considerations. Nobody will die if people aren’t working nights and weekends. If I see people engaging in what seems like heroics I will have a very serious chat with them to understand why they are doing it and make absolutely certain that it isn’t coming from any pressure to do so.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by notwedtm on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:37AM (#25418008)
This reads like an idealized version of reality. Budgets exists, deadlines are a thing. "Don't be a hero" sounds like the mantra of an HR department at an insurance company; not what you want to hear from a founder trying to disrupt an industry.

Heroics can exist without them being a standardized thing. There are occasions when you need people who are willing to move mountains to get something done, and demonizing those kinds of efforts and the people who engage in them will make them scarce when you actually are in need.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by cat199 on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:50AM (#25418167)
> a founder trying to disrupt an industry.

a founder should be 'trying to' make a quality product that fits a need, not 'disrupt an industry' - 'industry disruption' is a consequence, not a goal - if one is seeking the latter without focusing on the former, ones priorities are skewed, and likely for reasons of promoting one's own self-importance.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by tharne on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:00AM (#25418291)
> a founder should be 'trying to' make a quality product that fits a need, not 'disrupt an industry'

This 1000%.

The frequent use of the term "disrupt", just shows how much the culture has descended into degeneracy. When entrepreneurs and their backers are no longer making even a pretense toward things like progress, improvement, or even just running a profitable business, you know things have gotten bad. It seems like the model now is, "Hey, let's see if we can f--- up industry X, who cares if we actually improve anything or if our business is even viable, so long as we turn some established part of the economy on its head."

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by a123b456c on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:19PM (#25420156)
> The frequent use of the term "disrupt", just shows how much the culture has descended into degeneracy.

This is an extraordinary claim.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by tharne on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:43PM (#25420524)
> This is an extraordinary claim.

How so? I would argue that folks using millions of dollars in investment capital with no real goal other than to cause disruption, regardless of whether it helps anyone or even creates a viable business, is what's extraordinary.

Think for a second what a dumb goal 'disruption' is on it's own. That's what bored 15 year old's do to amuse themselves, they disrupt and break things simply to see something, anything, happen. As an earlier commenter pointed out, disruption is often a side effect of making a large change in an industry, typically in business this has meant changing something for the better.

When the side effect of causing disruption becomes the main goal of a business owner rather than creating value of some sort, I really don't know what to call that other than degenerate behavior.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by dukes82 on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:22PM (#25426591)
This evokes a disturbing image of VC's gambling on disruption events, the human costs and other consequences immaterial. Very well put and I wish this viewpoint could be spread further, I found it illuminating.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by Frondo on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:09PM (#25424057)
"Move fast and break things" has a human cost, always, and at times the human cost can be tremendous. Ignoring that human cost is always a little sinister.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by ryanSrich on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:07AM (#25418371)
Semantics.

Founders building potentially billion dollar businesses (not $10m lifestyle companies) need to have a psychotic drive to achieve that goal.

That often creates tough work environments in the early stages of the company. To many people, failing to build that billion dollar company is the same as outright failing completely. They’ll do whatever it takes to get there. I’ve worked with engineers and designers that like this type of environment. I’ve worked with others that thought they did until it came time to actually pull an 80 hour week.

EDIT: Several downvotes, but only one reply. If you have issue with anything I said I'd appreciate a response.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by danielblank69 on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:51AM (#25418907)
I love it how you casually mention $10m lifestyle companies as a chill, comfortable goal :)
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by ryanSrich on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:54AM (#25418947)
I mean, does it really make sense to target a goal of $10m valuation for a VC backed company?
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by danielblank69 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @06:23AM (#25441358)
Of course not. But it is not much easier to build a $10m lifestyle biz without VC help.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by cat199 on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:47PM (#25421433)
this entire thread is about the 'semantics' of work effort - what constitutes 'heroics' and if they are needed / not needed, and what that indicates/does not indicate about the goals/motivation of the person involved -

Irrespective of whether one is building a potentially billion dollar business or 'only' a 10m lifestyle company, the goal and focus should still be on the usefulness of the product and fitting market need, and not 'disrupting an industry' with the product as a side goal - if it's the latter, it indicates the priorities are skewed; from experience, usually when 'heroics' are involved or priorities are skewed, it's ego to blame and not some external requirement.

Further, 'heroics' are context-dependent - if the external requirement actually requires what would be 'heroics' in a normal situation, 'heroics' are simply 'duty' in that case, and there exists a 'that case heroics' that would still be 'heroics' (and therefore indicative of likely-ego-driven skewed priorities)

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by mandelbrotwurst on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:42PM (#25420500)
I didnt downvote you but I'd guess it's because you're calling something "psychotic" that many on this forum aspire to or at least respect.

Maybe you meant something more like "extreme" ?

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by michaelcampbell on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:23AM (#25442182)
> you're calling something "psychotic" that many on this forum aspire to or at least respect.

Both can be true. You've no doubt seen the CEO/psychopath studies.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by viridian on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:13AM (#25417714)
Why would you automatically assume a hiring manager wants the exact opposite of what he/she claims? I tend to take people at their word.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by PragmaticPulp on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:06AM (#25418360)
Take all absolute statements and mind-reading tricks on HN with a grain of salt.

If a manager says they don’t want heroics, it’s not reasonable to assume that they actually do want heroics but they’re somehow trying to communicate that to the team by speaking in opposites.

If someone says they want one thing then asks for the opposite, verbalize that you were following the original directive. Have a conversation like professionals and sort it out.

This HN comments that treat employers and managers like a foreign species that will only lie and abuse you are really not healthy. Learning how to establish healthy professional relationships with your managers as actual human beings is a critical workplace skill.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by numbsafari on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:48AM (#25418144)
Your logic seems rather self-contradictory here:

"I can't believe an organization would _praise_ the rockstar mentality"

"If an organization doesn't praise the rockstar mentality, they are lying".

As others have noted, I tend to take people at their word. Of course, you can also ask people on the team during the interview process if they feel like that's true or not.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by thelastwave on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:08AM (#25418377)
I don't think he said the absence of a positive affirmation, but the positive assertion of a negative value.

Not that they didn't praise rockstars, but they specifically came out against them.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by michaelcampbell on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:24AM (#25442193)
"If an organization doesn't praise the rockstar mentality, they are lying".

The only that's said that is you.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by thelastwave on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:06AM (#25418358)
> a manager that espouses the "we don't want", that's EXACTLY what they want.

How does that work? Sincere question.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by michaelcampbell on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:28AM (#25442232)
IME often they're over-compensating or projecting for a thing they know they want people to hear that they don't want to admit to.

It's "correct" to say "work-life balance" and "no heroes", but it doesn't generally NEED to be said in any normal circumstance; that they do say it is often because they do want the opposite of those things so they feel the need to point it out.

To me it's a form of the same thing that name-callers have when they call their adversaries names and you realize the charge they're levying against others is exactly what they themselves are/are doing; because they know they have whatever bad quality it's on their mind.

Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by ramzyo on Monday December 14, 2020 @09:06AM (#25417627)
It’s interesting you say that, because that’s what I tell people on my team, and I mean it.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by Siira on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:23AM (#25417176)
Perhaps their success rate has gone down, but their absolute successes have grown enough for them to accept it. Perhaps they should add some more expensive tiers for better student support.
Re:Lambda School is the biggest mistake I made this year by czechdeveloper on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:27AM (#25417221)
I can't tell if this is sarcasm or not.