The spirit of the law is not just to save third party lives.
When you cause an accident, you drain society’s emergency response resources (and increase the premiums of those in your insurance pool).
35mph vs 30mph is a terrible example - this is the scenario where pedestrians and cyclists are most likely to be around. 75mph vs 70mph would have been a better example.
Driving at night is more dangerous than at day because of the reduced visibility.
Driving when fewer other road users are around is safer than when it’s busy, but you don’t have perfect knowledge and there may be road users you haven’t seen, especially at night.
There’s no objective moral cliff edge between 70mph and 70mph+ε, but there is one between complying with the law and breaking it. Society collectively draws the line somewhere and you don’t get to unilaterally decide everybody else is wrong. I’ve heard people saying “I was only going a little over 30!” called speedo pedos, because it’s exactly like saying “she was only a little underage!”.
Check out the sibling comments for examples of people who thought they knew better but didn’t.
The thing about Scotland is completely wrong, I have no idea why you would think that.
If this is true, then you need to point the finger at so many things. Rock-climbing. Mountain biking. And it progresses, to "anything even remotely risky", where "risky is now the absolute lowest common denominator".
And of course, so many sports? Banned.
This sort of "walking on eggshells" view of life is quite disturbing to me.
There are plenty of other activities like speeding where the rewards do not justify the risks, and the government has made laws to prevent that risk being taken. Unlicensed aviation, amateur gas boiler repair, knife-fighting...
Example: society, and yes democratic ones, once told black people that they had no rights ; that they were animals; livestock. They also told Jews that they could not vote.
Was society spot on there?
What about the 1000s upon 1000s of examples of immoral laws which can be found, over time, and yes even now, which serves to invalidate the claim that following them is moral? From where I sit, each law must be measured against ones own morality. Failure to do so, is to cast the responsibility each human has aside, to instead wrap yourself in a shell of false righteousness!
I am not claiming "ignore the law", but merely that you may not determine what is 'right or wrong', merely due to the opinions of others around you, nor due to a societal system which attempts to balance thousands of pressures, and then pass laws.
Firstly, courts have repeated struck down sections of laws, or laws in their entirety, for this very reason. And often after those laws have stood for decades. By your logic, by your reasoning, to follow those laws is a moral requirement, yet one minute you are moral, the next immoral?
The stroke of a judge's pen, an argument in Parliament/Congress, and your morals are now right, or wrong?
No.
Your morals must be crafted on your own, examined, re-examined, see battle against your own interpretation of the universe, and grow with time. Laws are not this.
Laws are not morals.
Laws are not to be followed blindly.
To that end, I find your argument to be lacking. You assume that society is "better than the person" at determining "right or wrong". This is not so.
The government is not papa, mama, to be looked to for advice.
If you wish to discuss further, I am happy to, but I will not accept an argument that places legality on some sort of even keel, even subsuming morality.
No. Never.
Your comment isn't really about normality, but instead about an extreme edge case scenario. The only thing worse than a pandemic, might be nuclear war, a massive nuclear accident, or large-scale disaster.
Normality need not be conflated with actions during emergency scenarios.
Lastly -- imagine if people DID engage in more, "only affected themselves' risky behaviour. It would mean more hospital visits, therefore more hospital capacity, more doctors/nurses/etc etc, which would mean more ability to absorb and deal with large scale emergency issues.
That’s an awful lot of people, and if you don’t think that’s a terrible thing then I don’t know how you sleep at night.
What I am saying is not that we shouldn't treat the virus seriously but that we really need a lot not urgency when dealing with topics like speeding and pollution.
If only we had some sort of analogue for doing something vs. not doing something re: COVID. Oh wait, we do.
- Number of Australians dead: 908.
- Population adjusted, 13.1x: 12,000.
- Number of Americans dead: 298,000.
That’s 25x as many. We did something, America didn’t.
Spotting a pattern?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_limits_in_the_United_Sta...
So what might be unacceptable "speedo pedo"ism where you live might be completely normal going 5 miles over the posted speed limit elsewhere. My personal experience is that people tend to drive at a speed they feel safe at, and don't pay that much attention to the signs.
So some politicians and engineers draw a line so that 15% of the population is in violation and will change the speed limit at any point that this isn’t true (if nobody is in violation, they lower the speed limit). You can’t then cast moral judgment on that 15%. It’s intentional criminalization of the citizenry, even though it’s generally with the intent of saving lives.
Or "this road was quiet 20+ years ago", but the city has grown, and now it is a major throughfare, so "Local residents campaigned to get a low speed limit", so that alternate routes are preferable.
Both of the above have happened in my locale.
I laughed at "speedo pedos", but is it though?
One of these crimes is clearly considerably more serious than the other, and legislators agree with me. That's why in UK law minor speeding offences attract a fine and points on your license[0], but no criminal record, whereas offences of pedophilia result in prison time, a criminal record, and addition on the sexual offenders register.
The line of thinking is superficially similar, the weight of the offence isn't, and we shouldn't trivialise serious offences by drawing false equivalences with those that are considerably less serious.
[0] This is generally the case, but if you accrue too many points you can of course lose your license. Similarly, more serious speeding offences attract more serious penalties, and may even result in jail time. There are plenty of other examples but, see, e.g., https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-northamptonshire-34744.... The level of stupidity on display here is truly monumental.
As a person who grew up in the Scottish countryside I can assure you that is absolutely not the case, and drunk driving is _extremely_ frowned upon. In fact Scotland has generally had tougher drink driving regulations than England. (https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-30329743).
This kind of comment could be interpreted as casual racism (casting Scots as child-like alcoholics living in a semi-regulated playground), but I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt, since its a Sunday morning and nearly Christmas.
Really?
In fact, even ambulances crash into each other every now and then at night, because they usually drive without their horns (technically then they aren't allowed to run red lights, only if it's been sounding for at least 15 seconds, but people want to sleep).
It's not just boy racers, but plenty of older men and women who are reckless and inpatient in their usual driving. There are people who think that their luxury cars are an excuse to break the road rules as well as the rules of common courtesy.
Despite the UK having one of the safest road networks in the world, still around 75 people die or are seriously injured per week in car accidents. For a preventable injury that is still far too high.
Road design probably plays part in this; a comparatively wide fully asphalted road probably isn't the best design for 20mph. Traffic calming and all that.
I don't know why the difference between UK and Netherlands, maybe due to differences in income equity and judicial fairness? I imagine the behaviour is worse in countries with worse social fairness (Russia, even US?).
[1] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/ijop.12642
In the UK, it's somewhere in-between the mainland European and American attitudes, where someone with a flashy car is seen as deserving of it through their hard work.
And not everyone who drives like an idiot has a flashy car by the way; lots of those pumped VW things and whatnot as well (in both countries).
The real difference is that road deaths are far less likely to trigger a media circus.
* killed someone
That's enough for me. Don't care what the arguments are, how much they were peer pressured or what their home lives were like. Obviously if the argument is "the cops got the wrong guy" then I'll listen to it.
If it was unclear, the point I'm making is that you are awfully quick to judge someone's guilt based on a web page you read.
Also, you don't get to decide sentences as a juror, so your statement doesn't really make sense.
If we give them the benefit of the doubt why would they try to get rid of evidence that they were driving within legal limits? Especially when they have to deal with several "unreliable" witnesses claiming that they were driving too fast?
You're not responding to the point. The parent was talking about solitary drivers, and used remote parts of scotland as an example.
The parent has a couple of counter examples to that. Seems like the caveats, that sometimes you do actually know you're alone, are exactly the scenarios we're talking about.
Also, even if you crash with nobody around at the time, someone else may crash into the rescue team just arriving to help you.
As for driving 35 in a 30 zone... I can agree that it's not much of an issue if it's next to a school and you drive in the middle of the night: there won't be any children entering or leaving the school at that time. But generally, these racers drive way faster, and don't give a fuck about any of these rules, red lights, etc. They see the roads as a racetrack. On the computer or console, they can play GTA V or whatever, I don't care. Just if they do it in the real world they deserve harsh punishments, as the risk of killing people is so extremely high.
According to a popular UK road safety campaign, if you hit a pedestrian at 35mph you're 2.5x more likely to kill them than if you hit them at 30mph (50% chance vs 20% chance)
https://www.roadwise.co.uk/using-the-road/speeding/the-chanc...
Quick check says yes: https://www.tac.vic.gov.au/road-safety/statistics/summaries/...
Or specifically, not "speeding will kill someone" because we'll always have some level of accidents. But increased speed translates to increased accidents and increased accidents translate to more deaths.
If someone doesn't have the ability to pay, guess who ends up paying? Everyone else.
According to: https://ec.europa.eu/transport/road_safety/specialist/knowle...
That’s 48->56kmh which takes 38% to 66% chance of fatality for pedestrians (eyeballing the graph).
This driver was probably only doing a few MPH over the 40MPH limit which is quite fast enough for a rural road. There is an A-road alternative for those 'in a hurry' but such carnage is a regular occurance.
* @7pm in the morning in the winter the whole area can be fogged up and it was dark. I've driven down and cycled down there when it wouldn't have been safe doing 15mph.
* Animals can be hard to see, even in good conditions. Especially the donkeys, they are grey, on a black road and the sky is normally grey in England. Many of the animals there have high-vis collars to make them more visible at night.
* It depends what section of the road. In one section of that road the visibility is excellent (when there isn't fog). In another stretch even in the summer, the visibility is weird due to much of the road being in partial shade due to the trees.
* Drivers go much faster than the 40mph limit in that area almost all the time, especially on the high visibility parts. It doesn't help that if you come off the M25/A31 you would have been going about 70mph and so doing 40mph makes it feels so slow that you can step out of the car.
* The three A-roads near are either blocked due to heavy traffic especially in the summer (infrastructure in general is a joke in Hampshire and Dorset) or they don't go where you want.
Not at all. I've been driving at what seems like a sensible speed for the conditions and suddenly there is a deer right in front of my car. You cannot see some of the animals until you are right on top of them.
The fact is that there is too much traffic, there is insufficient infrastructure (and you probably can't add a lot because you will spoil the place) and there are animals freely roaming around. It is recipe of animal deaths in that area.
I dunno what the answer is. Paying the police to put up another gatso van isn't going to solve it though.
That might have been true 40 or 50 years ago - but drinking and driving is how regarded very harshly in Scotland both legally and socially.
Yes, the stats show quite clearly that 30mph is the point where pedestrian fatality rates really start climbing. [1]
At 30mph, if you have a collision with a pedestrian there’s a 20% chance the pedestrian dies.
At 35mph it’s 50%
At 40mph it’s 90%
The article mentioned the car was doing over 35mph. Additionally in the U.K. 30mph zones are normally residential areas and city centres, places where pedestrians are very common.
[1] https://www.roadwise.co.uk/using-the-road/speeding/the-chanc...
If we're talking about safety, then the speed limits should be to reflect conditions, but instead what happens is we cap the limit at the lowest value considering worst conditions.
Realistically the way we deal with this is through selective enforcement, the police probably aren't going to give you a ticket for 35 in a 30 at 2am on a monday morning, but it's silly to pretend that conditions don't matter.
There’s a number of police Twitter accounts that you can follow in this theme to learn more.
They clearly do not possess the good judgement that it takes to safely operate a multi-tonne motor vehicle.
Infrastructure for cyclists and pedestrians is often bad.
There is also no zero acceptance for drunk driving. You see people drive to restaurants, have a glass of wine or two, then drive home. Unimaginable.
Speed enforcement seems to be the low hanging fruit. There’s (generally) no judgment call, readily accepted evidence, it’s politically palatable, and it’s like shooting fish in a barrel: there’s always someone you can tag.
It’s a lot harder to tag someone for driving onto the freeway at 30 mph and failing to merge properly. There’s no “merge trap” to witness it so the cop has to basically happen upon it. There’s not always clear evidence, there’s probably some judgment required too. People don’t like the idea of tickets for going “too slow”; everyone acts like it is absurd. You can’t even blame the LEO because he probably knows the ticket won’t stick. Yet this behavior is extremely dangerous and happens all the time.
It makes a lot of sense in terms of road safety as well as noise, and makes little to no difference to journey times.
[1] https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/news/motoring-news/80-of-drivers...
Second, those pointless activities are what we're saving time for. I want to get more work done, and retire sooner, just so that I have more time for my pointless activities. People who don't begrudge every minute they spend in a car, in my view, are failing to maximize the leisure time that should be their chief goal in life.
You can also make other choices that reduce your 15min to begin with. (If the small difference there makes important changes in your life)
> "my 5 min is so important, I'm willing to risk someone's 60 years" (scaled to thousands of people).
The scaling matters! Boston has 1.8 million drivers losing 150 hours in traffic per year, according to https://inrix.com/press-releases/2019-traffic-scorecard-us/. Imagine that all of that traffic was caused by our desire to save a single human baby. 270 million hours lost to save 700,000. Would you agree that's not worth it? That probably those 270 million hours would produce enough economic output to save a different baby instead?
To me, a 75% increase in travel time is high enough and 35 mph is slow enough that I think everyone's 15 minutes is, in fact, worth risking someone's 60 years, once every couple of years. I could be proved wrong about the math, but it seems to me it's mostly an argument about risk tolerance.
In the real world 20mph puts a cap on your top speed only in the few instances you could possibly go that fast. Factor in lights, queueing at rotaries, slowing for emerging traffic, slowing for and then going around cyclists... ad nauseam
They go down that road at 70 mph. They also tend to be very young and incredibly stupid, and incredibly poor at judging risk.
What an absurd comment. Scotland has stricter drink-driving laws than England.
Peak Libertarian fantasy to think this should apply here. Unfortunately, the real world is never so ordered and predictable that you can know for certain whether the country road you're about to speed on is completely empty. Just like you, the rest of us have the right to use that road as well whenever we please.
Even if you were the sole victim in such an accident, you're ignoring all the second order societal costs. Who will pay for the police time spent investigating the accident, delivering the news to your loved ones, and the cost of bereavement leave on their employers? Who's going to pay for removing the wreck and fixing whatever infrastructure (e.g. the road surface) you might have damaged? What about the mental health effects on the unfortunate neighbour who discovers your mangled corpse? And if you're only injured, how about the costs of an ambulance and medical treatment? We don't all live in the USA where that is (supposedly) borne by the individual.
Whether you like them or not, speed limits exist for good reasons.
> doing 35 mph in a 30 mph really going to kill anybody?
Demonstrably yes. Check out this study by the UK's Transport Research Laboratory. The chances of killing a pedestrian rise dramatically from around 10% at 30mph. The likelihood roughly doubles at 35mph. Remember that kinetic energy increases with the square of velocity, not linearly, so even small increases in speed can have dramatic effects on accident outcomes: https://nacto.org/docs/usdg/relationship_between_speed_risk_...
> primarily partake in their favorite illegal motorsport
> after hours, the TruCam II also features night mode
> whereas the first TruCam, which has already reportedly
> been in use for the past six years, only worked during the
> daytime.
I think this really comes down to the letter of the law vs the spirit of it. To the spirit of the law, i.e. saving third-party lives, on a non-busy road doing 35 mph in a 30 mph really going to kill anybody? Is doing excessive speed on an empty well-lit motorway going to kill anybody?
Ultimately if you're only a danger to yourself then personally I think the responsibility is on the individual. For example, as I understand it, persons living in Scotland can drive back home drunk in rural areas as the only person they are ever likely to hurt its themselves.
As a free person I think you need to have the right to make bad decisions and accept their consequences, as long as those do not impact others. For a long time there has been an unwritten rule (at least where I live) where greater speed is generally more acceptable at night with fewer road users. It's not uncommon for the local police to overtake you at 90 mph for example.