News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by newacct583 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @05:56PM (#25402582)
> rule on what the law is, not decide what the law should be

Seems like that's very hard to square with Citizens or Shelby County, both of which overturned quite clearly written laws with long-accepted interpretations.

The textualism stuff is, at best, an excuse used when the court wants to do nothing. It doesn't limit the court when it wants to make changes. In this case, the court took as narrow a step as possible into the minefield that leads to Qualified Immunity. It's a baby step in the right direction, but it's just a baby step.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by dcolkitt on Saturday December 12, 2020 @05:59PM (#25402613)
Citizens United was based on the law being unconstitutional, not the court’s interpretation of the law.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by newacct583 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @06:12PM (#25402701)
I know the reasoning. It was a (very) novel interpretation of the constitution (both the extension of corporate personhood and the notion of money-as-speech were completely new tricks) that allowed it. Again, it's just excuse-making. If you don't want to do something you write a narrow opinion and put the responsibility on congress to provide specificity. If you want to do something big you throw out a law based on the constitution.

In this case, they held the way they did because they did not want to write a broad finding, and absolutely not because their hands were bound by some imaginary principle.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by ravi-delia on Saturday December 12, 2020 @06:41PM (#25402865)
This may be totally untrue, but I had a history professor who said that when a company made an argument that it had equal protection under the law from the 15th Amendment, they managed to hire the only living writer of the amendment as their lawyer. Given that it was written under secrecy, his word was all anyone had to go on.

Regardless, the Citizen's United decision was actually pretty clearly pro-free speech, and abuses by companies may well be cleaned up as time goes on and more cases reach the Supreme Court (or so said Scalia when I asked him, honestly it did sound like he was a little embarrassed about how his opinion turned out)

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by dragonwriter on Saturday December 12, 2020 @07:53PM (#25403292)
> but I had a history professor who said that when a company made an argument that it had equal protection under the law from the 15th Amendment,

That seems...implausible:

Section 1

The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude.

Section 2

The Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

> they managed to hire the only living writer of the amendment as their lawyer. Given that it was written under secrecy, his word was all anyone had to go on.

The Court (and courts in general) don't tend to look to authorial intent as the original intent that matters, but legislative intent (the intent of the body/(-ies) adopting the provision.) So, the word of the “only living author” wouldn’t be the only thing anyone had to go on; they’d have the records of legislative debates. And an authorial position (even if well-documwnted) that wasn't actively considered in legislative debate would probably not be considered to have much weight.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by alexeldeib on Saturday December 12, 2020 @07:34PM (#25403179)
> or so said Scalia when I asked him

When you asked him about it? That piqued my interest, what was the context? Why'd he seem embarrassed? The name drop begs for more details :)

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by ikiris on Saturday December 12, 2020 @07:45PM (#25403243)
I don't believe that Scalia has ever been embarassed by his blatant intellectual dishonesty in efforts to justify a conclusion he'd like to reach.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by memling on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:43PM (#25403546)
> his blatant intellectual dishonesty

Sincerely curious: do you have examples?

Scalia's a controversial justice, to say the least, for a variety of reasons, but I don't quite understand this criticism. (I do understand not liking his jurisprudence or his abrasive style.) He and Justice Ginsburg, for example, were famous friends while holding opposite opinions about how to interpret and read the U.S. Constitution; one would think she would've called him out on blatant dishonesty (intellectual or otherwise)

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by enkid on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:20PM (#25403423)
It's been ten years. Have there been any meaningful restrictions on those rights in that time? I don't know of any.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by Meekro on Saturday December 12, 2020 @06:30PM (#25402797)
Citizens United (the group) was a non-profit advocacy group that wanted to publish a video critical of a politician. The government wanted to stop that video from being published. That is not money-as-speech, it's speech-as-speech.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by newacct583 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @06:44PM (#25402881)
Citizen's United (the case) held that any government restriction on political spending was presumptively illegal and in violation of the first amendment. That is exactly my point. It was NOT a narrow ruling tailored toward the needs of PACs trying to avoid censorship. It was a extremely broad ruling throwing out the whole concept of campaign finance regulation.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by hypersoar on Saturday December 12, 2020 @07:24PM (#25403119)
This is a common and misleading description. I encourage you to read the decision and at least part of Stevens's dissent (which is twice as long as the decision itself). I know it's a lot of pages, but it's got big fat margins.

Now.

(Reposting a comment I made elsewhere)

Before Citizens United, any US majority-owned corporation or union was allowed to make political contributions from a segregated fund. The money in that fund could only come from employees and shareholders. This was, in decades of previous legislation and case law, considered sufficient to protect the 1st Amendment interests of associations of individuals. They can pool their money together for political purposes, put they can't pool it with other people's money.

Before the ruling, Citizens United was allowed to spend money on political activity. They were allowed to spend money on political activity close to an election. They were allowed to spend money, close to an election, to broadcast issue-based political advertisement (e.g., for or against a ballot initiative) on TV. They were allowed to spend money distributing their documentary in any way other than broadcasting it on TV. They could show it in theaters. They could put it on the internet. They could print DVDs and mail them out. They could distribute it to PACs and campaigns for them to spend their own money distributing it, including broadcasting by on TV. They could pay money, close to an election, from a segregated fund, to broadcast their documentary on TV. All they weren't allowed to do was spend money, close to an election, on broadcasting something expressing views for or against a political candidate, on television or radio, to an audience of at least 50,000, close to the election.

Corporations were not banned from electioneering before Citizens United. They were restricted. The laws imposing those restrictions went back until at least the early 1900s. There was a century of case law find some such restrictions constitutional. There was a decision in 2003, just 7 years before Citizens United, upholding the very restrictions that CU struck down. The majority's argument rested on the idea that no "identity-based" restrictions on 1st-Amendment rights are constitutional. But there are such restrictions, e.g. against prisoners, students, and employees of the executive branch. These restrictions remain in place today. The majority invented a 1st-Amendment principle and then selectively applied it to corporations. They did so with no fact-finding in the record of the case on whether the provisions they struck down actually chilled free speech. Fact-finding that the government wanted to do before Citizens United (the organization) dropped the issue.

The majority in Citizens United flipped the table on decades of election law that had survived scrutiny several times before without even claiming that any circumstances had changed. They did it solely because they didn't like the outcome. And they bent over backwards to do it.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by dragonwriter on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:50PM (#25403581)
> It was a (very) novel interpretation of the constitution (both the extension of corporate personhood and the notion of money-as-speech were completely new tricks)

No they weren't. Money as speech, for instance, was a bedrock of earlier campaign finance decisions stretching back at least to Buckley v. Valeo, 424 U.S. 1 (1976).

https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/424/1/#tab-opini...

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by simonh on Sunday December 13, 2020 @07:04AM (#25405994)
Corporate personhood is a very long established legal concept. It even pre-dates the foundation of the USA, with the principle found in India well over 2000 years ago and in the legal status of Medieval guilds. There is nothing novel about it. The very word corporation derives from the Latin "corpus" or body.

I'm a Brit so have not particular standing in this. If I were a US citizen I would deplore the Citizen's United decision, but not on the grounds of corporate personhood (which as I understand it was never mentioned in the ruling), but rather on the grounds that religious freedom should not grant special rights and privileges not available otherwise. It should be a freedom of belief, not a freedom of action.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by mrkstu on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:03AM (#25414051)
Religious freedom (of either type) isn'† relevant in any way to Citizen United as far as I'm aware- can you clarify the nature of your objection?
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by racnid on Saturday December 12, 2020 @06:25PM (#25402765)
If one person has a right to free speech then logically groups of people have rights to free speech, there's really no other way to look at that.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by otterley on Saturday December 12, 2020 @06:33PM (#25402815)
What is so novel about holding that the First Amendment means what it says about the rights of freedom of speech and to peaceably assemble?
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by newacct583 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @06:45PM (#25402890)
Because it holds that right applies to the ability to pay for media space and not to speak or assemble, and to be done by a PAC, not a person.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by otterley on Saturday December 12, 2020 @07:30PM (#25403154)
How do you think assemblies of people get together to speak who can’t all be in the same place at the same time? They have been paying spokespeople since time immemorial.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by newacct583 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @10:49AM (#25407331)
I don't think anyone here is interested in debating the merits of Citizen's from first principles. Suffice it to say that your reasoning is not the one the court chose, so I don't know where you're going with this.

My point was simply the wording above: the court CHOSE to issue a very broad decision in Citizen's, just as it chose NOT to issue one here. And the reason is just simple desire and not any kind of principle. The court wanted to, and that's as far as it goes. You see the same skew in logic in arguments about Roe, where the same people (like you) who think Citizen's is fine for throwing out huge regulatory areas based on a novel reading of the constitution suddenly think it's "judicial activism" to find a right to medical privacy in the due process clause.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by otterley on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:01AM (#25407421)
I was merely responding to your specific comment which seemed to suggest that a holding that groups have First Amendment rights and that they can pay people to represent them was somehow novel.

“It was a (very) novel interpretation of the constitution (both the extension of corporate personhood and the notion of money-as-speech were completely new tricks) that allowed it.”

There is an enormous volume of prior case law that says the same thing.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @07:45PM (#25403245)
What’s the difference between a court opining that a law is unconstitutional and a court interpreting a law as unconstitutional?
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by rayiner on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:47PM (#25404139)
Citizens United was based on the Court interpreting the statute as imposing restrictions on political speech (prosecuting a non-profit for distribution of a movie about Hilary Clinton) that are invalid under the first amendment. That’s not a situation where the court is saying what the law should be; they’re saying what kinds of laws are allowed under the constitution and which aren’t.

Here, the argument isn’t about the constitution. It’s about what “appropriate relief” means in the statute.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by blake1 on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:00PM (#25403939)
The second is analyzing the law, and finding a provision that conflicts with a provision of the constitution. It’s not very formal, but it’s more than opinion.

It’s not quite that pure. If there are self-contradictions in the constitution, then that gives them some choice about what to compare the law to. They ought to balance that appropriately, but their biases surely creep in.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:47PM (#25404140)
The Supreme Court issues opinions. That's the actual word they use to describe what they write. You can either form an opinion or you can discover a truth. The Supreme Court does not discover whether it is true or not that a law is constitutional or unconstitutional. Each member forms an opinion, and whichever consensus opinion includes the majority of justices, that becomes the opinion by which other courts proceed to interpret the law.

You might want to mask "discover the truth" with "finding a provision", but the Supreme Court does not "find provisions that conflict with other provisions", they interpret things to form opinions. In this case 5 of them interpreted a provision to be in conflict with the way they interpreted a provision of the constitution. 4 of them did not share either or both of those interpretations.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by matt_kantor on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:06PM (#25403353)
It's not "interpreting a law as unconstitutional", just "interpreting the law". As in "how does the law apply to this situation?".
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:18PM (#25403408)
So there’s an external source for this objective information, or are the judges making their own individual interpretations of “how the law applies”? If the former, why do we end up with split votes that so often fall down partisan lines? Seems like if there were a correct interpretation of a law as distinct from an opinion of a law, they would all have access to it and we could cut the justices down from 9 to 1. And we could call that judge The Conveyor of Truth.

Also, why are Supreme Court opinions literally called opinions, if they are apparently objective?

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by matt_kantor on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:25PM (#25403450)
I didn't say that it's objective or that there is a single "correct" interpretation of every law.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:42PM (#25403540)
OK. I was responding to parent, which stated there is a difference between a judge's interpretation of constitutionality and literal constitutionality - i.e. that a law can be unconstitutional regardless of whether a judge interprets it to be such. Which is obviously nonsense.

So I'm not sure what your point is.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by matt_kantor on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:02PM (#25403654)
I was responding to the specific question you asked:

> What’s the difference between a court opining that a law is unconstitutional and a court interpreting a law as unconstitutional?

That question was a reply to this comment:

> Citizens United was based on the law being unconstitutional, not the court’s interpretation of the law.

That comment is referring to two different things SCOTUS can do:

1. Throw out a law because it is unconstitutional.

2. Interpret the law by deciding how it applies in a particular case.

They're saying the Citizens United ruling was of the first type, not the second.

You seemed to miss that, so I was trying to clarify it. That's all.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:39PM (#25403837)
> They're saying the Citizens United ruling was of the first type, not the second. You seemed to miss that, so I was trying to clarify it.

I did not miss that. I was responding to it. Perhaps you are not understanding what I am saying.

How did they determine CU was of the first type? Did they interpret it to be of the first type, or is there an objective view of it that simply makes it so? And if the latter, where is this objective view located that all can see? And why did 4 of the 5 justices not have access to see the objective view?

In other words: deciding something is unconstitutional and interpreting something as unconstitutional are exactly the same thing. There is no such thing as unconstitutional outside of interpretation.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by matt_kantor on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:05PM (#25403953)
We read dcolkitt's comment differently.

You read:

> Citizens United was based on the law being [objectively] unconstitutional, not the court’s interpretation of the law [being that it is an unconstitutional one].

I read:

> Citizens United was based on the law being unconstitutional [in the opinion of the court], not the court’s interpretation of [how] the [constitutionally-compatible and therefore still on the books] law [should be applied to Citizens United].

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:22PM (#25404025)
OK. My interpretation seems to be much closer to the words as written. I'd give myself credit for being a textualist, if I didn't think that label was just a scam.

In any case, your read is that the court had an opinion about the constitutionality of CU (which is exactly what it had). And my read is exactly the same: opinion = interpretation.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by HexagonalKitten on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:06PM (#25403679)
A law can be so blatantly and obviously unconstitutional that everyone can see it and refuses to arrest or charge people for breaking it. It's pretty easy to construct test examples, "Bob Smith must pay 2x tax", or "Black people can't do X".

The supreme court doesn't make a law unconstitutional. It already was or wasn't. They provide notice to the system that the law will now be seen as unconstitutional or not.

If they get it wrong (lets say we know because another SC overrules them in the future) it doesn't change the constitutionality of the law, just whether it's enforceable or not during those periods.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:51PM (#25403900)
>The supreme court doesn't make a law unconstitutional. It already was or wasn't.

No. If the Supreme Court is asked whether a law is constitutional or not, they form an opinion on whether it is or is not. The law exists as law up until the moment the Supreme Court is asked and interprets it one way or the other. It does not exist as one or the other until that moment, even though it is the law, and after that moment it only exists as one or the other based upon the majority opinion of 9 people. Laws are not discovered to be constitutional or unconstitutional, because interpretations are not discovered, they are formed.

>A law can be so blatantly and obviously unconstitutional that everyone can see it and refuses to arrest or charge people for breaking it.

That doesn't make the law unconstitutional. It just makes it a bad law. Bad laws can also be constitutional.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by HexagonalKitten on Saturday December 12, 2020 @08:57PM (#25403632)
The SC isn't supposed to concern itself with justice, that's a sticky matter for the legislators. Their job is to make sure that the legislators followed rules (wrote laws which do not contradict the constitution) and that those laws are properly applied.

Yes, every individual judge has their own skills and opinions and as such, sees the legal question slightly differently, and has different legal interests and thus knows some law more than other. We have a nine as a balance between not having enough diverse backgrounds such that we might be missing the critical input some day weighed against the group being to big to be convenient.

> why do we end up with split votes that so often fall down partisan lines?

People are flawed. Let's say some injustice caused you to get into law. You're likely going to be more familiar with that area, and more sensitive to its harms, than another judge. You may not be voting your ideology, you may be there (as a justice) because of your ideology, and you may have your honest beliefs because of your unique experiences.

I often read opinions I don't agree with, but I can see where the justice just had a different life than me and sees things differently.

> Supreme Court opinions literally called opinions, if they are apparently objective?

The only use of objectivity in this thread is yours. But if someone did use that phrasing, they'd mean that the justices should decide the same on the same issue, no matter if it helps a nazi or a nun. Justice is supposed to be blind.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:47PM (#25403884)
>People are flawed.

Sure. But it's not random flaws. Liberal people are flawed to believe rules are written as a liberal would interpret them. And conservatives just the opposite. Because the rules do not exist outside of subjective interpretation.

I may be the only person using the word objective in this conversation, but that doesn't mean everyone else in the conversation is not building their arguments on the existence of objectivity in regards to a judges interpretations.

>I often read opinions I don't agree with, but I can see where the justice just had a different life than me and sees things differently.

That's right. Their opinion is nothing more than their interpretation. A couple of people had the opinion that something was unconstitutional. That doesn't mean it is, just that they believe it is.

Justice is supposed to be blind. And the Supreme Court opinion that CU was unconstitutional helps corporations just as it helps pro-choice non-profits just as it helps pro-life non-profits. But at the end of the day, it was 5 people who interpreted it as unconstitutional. They did not make the discovery that it is unconstitutional.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by HexagonalKitten on Saturday December 12, 2020 @09:23PM (#25403765)
I like textualism. The point of the supreme court isn't to get everything right, it's to kick badly written law back to the legislators. How do you know the text needs fixing if you don't stick to the text?

Sometimes it is just thrown out to cover bias, but that's not its fault.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:09PM (#25403969)
Textualism is nothing more than interpreting something in a way that you believe doesn't align with some older thing you also interpreted in a way. "I believe this new law is incompatible with what I believe this old rule says."

You may be right or you may be wrong, anyone can do it, and anyone who does will mostly come to their conclusion based upon their personal political beliefs. Hence, a reason the Supreme Court has so many partisan split rulings.

Textualism is pure nonsense, used to present a false sense of rationality to an opinion. Any self-proclaimed textualist is either deceiving themselves or attempting to deceive others.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by HexagonalKitten on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:36PM (#25404096)
> Textualism is pure nonsense, used to present a false sense of rationality

No. You're just saying that people have biases and thus everything is a lie.

Textualism is a thing, and exists outside of law. Textualists think that the authors specific words are important. "Why did Tolkien say X? It must matter, he's a careful author."

I value it in the field of law because legal disputes caused by textual confusion can be avoided through careful writing and textualism leads to the type of thinking that is capable of that. And if nobody cared about the words, how sloppy would the thinking also be?

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Saturday December 12, 2020 @10:55PM (#25404170)
Textualism outside of law is fun. Enjoy. In the context of law, and this entire thread, it's nonsense used by people to make themselves think they are smart, or trick other people into thinking they must be smart. In law, everything is textualism, and therefore anyone who claims textualist jurisprudence as a distinct thing they practice are simply attempting to classify anyone else as not smart enough to form valid opinions about what words and phrases mean.
Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by HexagonalKitten on Sunday December 13, 2020 @12:21AM (#25404497)
> In law, everything is textualism

Everything should be. But 95% of everything is really people decrying textualism and actively choosing their ideology.

> it's nonsense used by people to make themselves think they are smart

What nonsense did you use?

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by OpieCunningham on Sunday December 13, 2020 @12:37AM (#25404557)
>But 95% of everything is really people decrying textualism and actively choosing their ideology.

Of course the textualist thinks only he is above ideology. This is how you can tell they're clowns.

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by dang on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:02PM (#25420854)
Please follow the site guidelines when posting here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by HexagonalKitten on Sunday December 13, 2020 @12:46AM (#25404590)
No, I think only those who try have any chance.

Is your rudeness caused by a disability?

Re:SCOTUS rules you may sue government agents for damages wh... by dang on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:03PM (#25420857)
Please follow the site guidelines when posting here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html