News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ralfn on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @09:47AM (#25358966)
Most competitive chips in the world are produced by machines made in the Netherlands at ASMI/ASML

The US companies do what they do best: innovate business models and find ways to vendor lock in and own the market.

But who's been doing all the research keeping moore's law alive? Lithography?

For a country as small as the Netherlands, you can wonder if we could afford from a geopolitical point of view to be producing all the world's chips (answer: no, it would force other place to invest highly in competition out of strategic interest).

Hence the strategy of being long term profitable and to just sell the machines to everyone at the same price.

It does make it baffling why Intel is unable to produce 5nn chips with the same ASML machines TSC is using. It must be management failing Boeing style.

As for the rest of Europe. Im sure they can politically do this. But where will the money end up?

It will end up in the pockets of friends and families of politicians that will be in "the management".

So don't expect anything from this. The future most sold chip will still be Apple Silicon or Samsung Exynos in TSC's foundry or Samsung foundry on a machine by ASML using IP from ARM and NVidia

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by yvdriess on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:12AM (#25359263)
> It does make it baffling why Intel is unable to produce 5nn chips with the same ASML machines TSC is using. It must be management failing Boeing style.

ASML machines do not produce chips, they're just ones doing the etching. There is a ton around what you do with it, and how all the rest of the chip is produced.

They don't come with pre-programmed transistor gate templates. Each fab company has its own libraries of extremely specialized designs, doing different optimizations and tradeoffs. As mentioned plenty of times before, the consensus seems to be that Intel tried to pile up too many new improvements, which backfired. TSMC took a more incremental and safe approach. You have to appreciate that a defect that impacts high-volume yield today could have its roots in a design that was put on the roadmap years before.

> As for the rest of Europe. Im sure they can politically do this. But where will the money end up?

If H2020 is anything to go by, the majority of that money will be salaries of people working on big research projects. At worst the project outcome is useless. I don't see how any of the way these projects are structured benefit the pocket lining of managers.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by the_crocodile on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:38PM (#25362201)
A point of clarification. ASML does lithography, which creates the patterns for the chips. The big players in etch (removing layers of material following the pattern) are Lam Research and Applied Materials, both American companies.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by yvdriess on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:49PM (#25367278)
Yep, I used the wrong term there. s/etching/lithography/
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by rjzzleep on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:59AM (#25359970)
And yet it's enough to spark a geopolitical war to block China from acquiring these machines[1], which basically means China has massively ramped up it's EUV investment if you look at semiengineering investment news.

At the same time you can trust that TSMC secrets are no longer secret[2]. A lot of the Taiwanese companies are actually quite bad at security despite Taiwan have some top notch security engineers. I guess it's just old industries general problems.

[1]: https://bits-chips.nl/artikel/asml-is-too-convenient-a-targe...

[2]: https://www.extremetech.com/computing/313599-chinese-hackers...

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by estaseuropano on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:18PM (#25366847)
Sorry but it looks as if you had a view and then googled articles to back this up. The second article is about IP theft and gives no reason to doubt TSMC's integrity. Nor does it give any reason to think Taiwanese companies are worse at opsec than e.g. US or Dutch players.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by rjzzleep on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:17PM (#25369220)
Sorry it's you that didn't read it. China has had a massive cyberop and stole pretty much every secret TSMC had. It doesn't matter whether Taiwan is trustworthy or not if their cybersecurity sucks. Good job for not reading, not understanding and then using a random fallacy to respectfully diss me.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by rmrfstar on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:38AM (#25359632)
> the consensus seems to be that Intel tried to pile up too many new improvements, which backfired. TSMC took a more incremental and safe approach

Can you point to some industry literature that explains this?

If this is true, it is a lot more surprising that Intel is talking about going fabless. You build a lot of expertise by rolling the dice on new techniques that don't pan out on the first iteration. People wouldn't be so pessimistic about Boeing if they had just been overly aggressive in a new airframe design, rather than failing to safely mount new engines on an old design.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by yvdriess on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:52AM (#25359835)
The consensus on HN (search for Intel 7nm, cobalt, ...). It's all speculation at this point. I doubt that Intel would publish details on their processes and its defects so soon.

Intel buying some TSMC capacity does not mean it is going fabless. Nor does it mean Intel is abandoning being vertically integrated.

I like your Boeing remark. It's better to fail at doing something aggressive than to fail to innovate.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by munificent on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:06PM (#25361552)
> It's better to fail at doing something aggressive than to fail to innovate.

I don't think that's a particularly useful way to divide up failures. I think it's better to fail in a way that doesn't kill people than a way that does. Whether you kill people by being too conservative or too aggressive with your design is pretty irrelevant compared to that.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by Symmetry on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:23PM (#25361848)
According to Semiaccurate the new Contact Over Active Gate (COAG) feature ended up causing just as many problems as moving to cobalt.

The original article is here:

https://www.semiaccurate.com/2018/08/02/intel-guts-10nm-to-g...

It's paywalled but Charlie later published something else referring to that article as talking about COAG problems so I don't feel bad sharing the info at this point.

https://semiaccurate.com/2020/08/13/intel-talks-about-10nm-s...

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by _jal on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:47AM (#25359759)
> People wouldn't be so pessimistic about Boeing if they had just been overly aggressive in a new airframe design

Well... yes. That's called judgement, and execs at firms like Boeing get paid positively stupid sums of money to provide the good kind. Which they didn't.

"What's the big deal? If I had left the vat of acid unattended in a locked room, everything would have been fine."

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by oivey on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:51AM (#25359825)
Are they talking about going fabless? I thought they’ve only discussed making some parts at TSMC, not all of them.

They’re not on the first iteration at this point. They’ve been on 14 nm since 2014. 10 nm and to a lesser extent 7 nm is failing after many iterations and many years.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by selectodude on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:28AM (#25360346)
>People wouldn't be so pessimistic about Boeing if they had just been overly aggressive in a new airframe design, rather than failing to safely mount new engines on an old design.

Unfortunately Boeing doesn't have a huge list of customers that are willing to spend what it costs to switch to a new airframe. They sell to airlines what airlines want to buy. Airlines wanted a 737 with higher bypass engines and that's exactly what they got.

Boeing deserves what they get for pushing a faulty design out the door but they didn't do it as some nefarious cost cutting measure. They did it because American and Southwest said they wanted nothing to do with a "797" and threatened to switch to Airbus.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by dtech on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:01PM (#25360764)
Their customers are not responsible for putting a defective product with insufficient operator training which has cost hundreds of human lives.

Maybe they are responsible for pressuring Boeing too much, but Boeing put defective airplanes on the market

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by modo_mario on Thursday December 10, 2020 @05:00AM (#25371908)
> they didn't do it as some nefarious cost cutting measure. They did it because American and Southwest said they wanted nothing to do with a "797" and threatened to switch to Airbus.

so a nefarious moneygrabbing measure?

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ineedasername on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:02PM (#25369536)
I'd probably think just as poorly of Boeing if they killed people with a more innovative/aggressive idea.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by baybal2 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:17AM (#25360205)
ASML never did etchers
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by yvdriess on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:08PM (#25365019)
I stand corrected, I mistakenly thought that was part of the lithography machine.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by pkaye on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:24PM (#25361871)
> For a country as small as the Netherlands, you can wonder if we could afford from a geopolitical point of view to be producing all the world's chips (answer: no, it would force other place to invest highly in competition out of strategic interest).

I used to work for a semiconductor equipment manufacturer a long while back so am familiar with that industry. ASML works on just lithography but there are dozens of other processes needed to manufacture semiconductors. The biggest of those in market share are the US companies Applied Materials and Lam Research. They make a quite a few of those machines. So ASML is an important part but not the only part.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semiconductor_equipment_sales_...

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by absolutelyrad on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:25PM (#25361894)
> Most competitive chips in the world are produced by machines made in the Netherlands at ASMI/ASML

FYI, a LOT of the critical components in ASML come from the US. There's no one country that can make the latest tech end-to-end relying on it's self. China seems to be trying, but it'll be inefficient.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:01AM (#25359148)
>Most competitive chips in the world are produced by machines made in the Netherlands at ASMI/ASML

AFAIK, ASMLs fancy EUV tech comes from a Bay Area company they acquired a while ago and not from the Netherlands.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by yaantc on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:20AM (#25359367)
If you refer to Cymer, they're doing the light source. A critical part of the system certainly, but not the whole. Then mirrors are done by Carl Zeiss in Germany. The blank photomask come mostly from 2 Japanses companies. On such complex systems there's room for many critical providers. Still, the integrated product comes from ASML.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by xadhominemx on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:44AM (#25360554)
The light source is by a very wide margin the most difficult and critical component of an EUV tool. The US still dominates wafer fab equipment - Cymer plus Applied Materials, Lam, and KLA. The only major non-US supplier is Tokyo Electron who is also quite strong. ASM International is a good but niche European supplier.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by formerly_proven on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:11PM (#25360866)
ASML doesn't seem like a niche supplier considering it generates more revenue than all but one of the major suppliers you list.

Applied Materials - 17bn

ASML - 11bn

Tokyo Electron - 10.8 bn

Lam - 9.5 bn

KLA Corp - 4 bn

Cymer (2012, before acqusition) - 600m

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by xadhominemx on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:36PM (#25361193)
ASMI aka ASM International - it’s now a separate company from ASML (formerly ASM Lithography)
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by bazooka_penguin on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:21AM (#25360251)
Cymer is the linchpin of ASML's leadership. Other litho machine developers like Canon and Nikon almost dropped out of the industry because they couldn't develop functional EUV light sources. ASML got around that by buying Cymer. And ASML has multiple other R&D labs and offices in the US handling critical technologies like software and robotics
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by formerly_proven on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:15PM (#25360925)
A quick Google search suggests ASML bought Cymer for the patent portfolio, while the tech didn't quite pan out. It seems like Trumpf is the current supplier of the EUV source.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by tarlinian on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:53PM (#25361397)
This is most definitely not true. Trumpf makes CO2 lasers which are used by Cymer to produce EUV radiation via excitation of liquid tin droplets.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by dragonelite on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:09AM (#25359221)
Yeah i'm always wonder just because the company is located in the EU, does it mean its actually a EU company? Given US institutional investors who probably have big voting power own majority stake in those tech companies.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by joelbluminator on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:26AM (#25359448)
I think ASML's connection to NL is solid, you could say it's a Dutch company. The R&D, world headquarters are in NL and board of directors includes many Dutch people, including the CEO.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by pa7x1 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:19AM (#25359350)
Do you have a reference? AFAIK it's 2 other German companies that are key in the production of EUV photolitography machines; Zeiss for the lenses and Trumpf for the lasers.

I see reference for a company bought by ASML in California, HMI. They were bought in 2016 but the development of EUV technology predates it by many years so I find it unlikely that it had an important role in it.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ju-st on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:12PM (#25360888)
Cymer was apprently the first to produce a EUV light source but their lasers were not commercial viable. Trumpf lasers are used in the commercial EUV machines. https://www.laserfocusworld.com/blogs/article/14039015/how-d...
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by bazooka_penguin on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:16AM (#25360179)
ASML is heavily reliant on the IP of Cymer an American company they bought in the last decade. And a great deal of their R&D is in the US, including things like software, measurement systems and sensors, robotics and automation, and so forth. What the US does best is quietly prop up international companies like ASML (and ARM, whose texas R&D center has been the leader for years) that wouldn't be able to hack it on their own without American talent.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by BostonEnginerd on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @07:29PM (#25367755)
In addition to Cymer, ASML a big R&D and manufacturing footprint in Wilton Connecticut.

Semiconductor manufacturing is really a global effort -- most device makers have fabs full of equipment mostly from US, European and Japanese suppliers. Korean equipment suppliers are also becoming more prevalent. Chinese suppliers are starting to try to gain some market share as well.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by WanderPanda on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:26PM (#25361055)
I don‘t like the vibe of your comment, but you are probably right...
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by Daho0n on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @02:38PM (#25363426)
Go back to /r/murica please.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by arnaudsm on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @10:53AM (#25359870)
> It will end up in the pockets of friends and families of politicians that will be in "the management".

100% agree. Considering the incredible education system and engineers we have, the 2 only things restraining Europe from reaching Silicon Valley level are corrupt politicians and risk-adverse VCs.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by eldaisfish on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:42PM (#25361269)
>Considering the incredible education system and engineers we have, the 2 only things restraining Europe from reaching Silicon Valley level are corrupt politicians and risk-adverse VCs.

I find it telling that it's mostly europeans who make these types of comments. The EU has tremendous barriers to labour mobility that most europeans don't even realise - differing bureaucracy and language being two of the most significant. And i cannot emphasise the bureaucratic hurdles enough when moving countries. Despite the EU crying itself hoarse about labour mobility, only around 5% of EU citizens relocate between EU countries. The majority of that 5% is people moving from poor to richer countries. The comparable number in the US is 20%.

Most rational people realise that despite all its flaws, some of the most key factors in US tech dominance are the existence of a large talent pool, all of whom speak the same language, the existence of a large market all of which operates in the same language and finally VCs willing to take on risk.

Corrupt politicians are not hobbling European tech success any more than corrupt US politicians are hobbling its success. The EU will not reach Silicon Valley's levels of success, at least not in my lifetime.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by arnaudsm on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:05PM (#25361537)
Historically, Silicon Valley was created from government contracts and subsidies, then the VCs joined the party.

It's a chicken-egg problem, and Europe has no chicken nor eggs at the moment. But lots of grain and hay.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by 908B64B197 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:34PM (#25362080)
> differing bureaucracy and language being two of the most significant

It has never been cheaper and easier to operate in several languages. Seriously, translation and internationalization is as cheap as it can get (and most folks in Europe are at least bilinguals!).

What they need to focus on is a unified marketplace and harmonized regulation. Now each tiny country has it's special snowflakes regulations (how to accept payment, who and how to pay taxes, huge amount of paperwork to get employees and ultra-restrictive labor laws). I mean it's good as a job program to keep EU civil servants employed, not so much to bootstrap a tech ecosystem!

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by eldaisfish on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:47PM (#25364669)
I get the feeling you're European. Language is a massive barrier and simply hand-waving that away by claiming that internationalisation is cheap is silly. Language drives a whole host of things and operating in several languages is far from easy. You are also being very generous with claiming that most folks in Europe are bilingual. They may have basic knowledge of multiple languages but can likely function fully in only one. The generations below 30 are likely to be almost completely bilingual. Look at Belgium for example. How many Flemish people can function in French and vice versa?

The fact that the US operates entirely with the global lingua franca is a gigantic advantage that can crush competition before it even begins.

The unified marketplace is one problem but look at what has already been done - EU labour is free to move. Degrees are almost always mutually recognised. What stops further integration? It ultimately boils down to language. This is why a Greek doctor can't just move to Germany. Also why a Spanish lawyer can't easily move to Sweden. Language is a much bigger problem than people here seem to think.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by 908B64B197 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:21PM (#25365234)
> It ultimately boils down to language. This is why a Greek doctor can't just move to Germany. Also why a Spanish lawyer can't easily move to Sweden. Language is a much bigger problem than people here seem to think.

These are all customer service positions (you get a prefix in front of your name but still).

That matters less with tech. You'll have a localized sales team/customer support sure, and that adds expenses, but it's not a huge burden.

Dealing with a huge amount of paperwork, taxes, special local laws of the N jurisdiction you're operating in, now that's a barrier to entry.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by whizzter on Thursday December 10, 2020 @08:33AM (#25373487)
It's actually quite common for Swedes to travel abroad in the EU to study medicine since the entry-requirements to our national medicine programs require very high scores on the high school degrees or aptitude tests (University while free only has limited number of spots assigned out to the best students. If memory serves me right even with a max score on the aptitude test, reserved to some 0.3-0.5% of the test-takers, you will still be put in a lottery pool for the best medschools).

Law degrees might be harder to transfer generally though (easy to transfer in the Nordics at least iirc) but even in the US you need to take the bar in different states, so maybe that part isn't too different anyhow?

Actually, Might become easier in the EU in the future now that post-brexit there isn't any common law countries within the union and with mostly civil law systems it should be easier to unify principles in some sections of the law.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by corty on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:32PM (#25365425)
Even if a bunch of Europeans from different countries do talk in perfect english, understanding every word, cultural differences will make true communication hard. The style of work, management and relationships is just too different. And you just can't give everyone 20 cultural awareness courses...
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by jmnicolas on Thursday December 10, 2020 @02:28AM (#25370870)
> and most folks in Europe are at least bilinguals!

It's mostly northern Europe. Try France, Italy, Spain then you will change your mind.

I'm French, where I work I'm the only one on 200 people that can take a phone call in English.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by Normille on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:26AM (#25360312)

  >and risk-adverse VCs.
I think this is the big one.

I don't know exactly how realistic this is. But from this side of the pond [Europe], it seems like, in the US there are VCs willing to throw millions [billions sometimes] at companies which are little more than a couple of guys with a silly idea, which would get you laughed out of your bank manager's office over here, if you went in asking to borrow a few hundred euros/pounds.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by WanderPanda on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:30PM (#25361117)
I don‘t subscribe to this at all. If there was such a huge opportunity in investing in European startups VCs would take it. Its not like they are nationalistic, they would equalise the arbitrage opportunities in no time
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @02:08PM (#25362891)
That not how VC's work, they invest in places where they know the laws, customs and markets. It is more common for teams to nove to place where there are VC's, thanthe other way round.c
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by 908B64B197 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:28PM (#25361948)
Truth is they do...

I've met a lot of European founders in the valley.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by burntoutfire on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:23AM (#25360269)
Also:

- labor laws (very hard to fire people in many European countries)

- lots of disjointed small-to-medium markets (with different laws and languages) make expansion on continental scale much harder than in the US

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:53AM (#25360666)
>- labor laws (very hard to fire people in many European countries)

That's just not true now and hasn't been the case anymore since like the 2009 financial crisis. In most of Europe it's trivial to fire an underperforming non-unionized employee as the countries have adapted more business friendly laws to remain competitive after the financial crisis. Sure, there may still be some grey beards somewhere with old bulletproof contracts but for anyone entering the tech workforce now, getting fired is a rubber stamp basically especially since tech workers are not unionized and sometimes benefit from less protection than even some blue-collar professions which are unionized.

For example, in Austria you can fire anyone for no reason at all as long as you give them their notice period(usually 1 to 3 months) without them being entitled to any other financial compensation from their employer. Moreover, non-competes are legal here without any form of compensation and you can even fire employees while they're on sick leave. All this legally!

The whole you can't get fired in Europe maybe only applies to Scandinavia or France but it's mostly a meme nowadays.

Actually, contrary to popular belief, tech workers in California might enjoy better protection than tech workers in some European countries. Let that sink in for a bit.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by dtech on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:06PM (#25360807)
Compared to the US it's still very hard to fire people in most EU countries. In large parts of the US you can fire anyone at anytime [1].

On the other hand Silicon Valley is in California and has some of the strongest labor laws of the US, so if this is such a huge factor why is everyone in SV?

Even under the assumption that it's an important factor, would it be worth it for EU to adopt such policies considering the very real human cost?...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/At-will_employment

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by wizzairflyer on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:25PM (#25364275)
I live in Switzerland and the legal status of (tech) employee is roughly the same to what you describe. I wonder if the difference isn't that firing people "at-will" just is less culturally accepted here. I feel we're in kind of a weird spot between Japan and the US in terms of how the general public conceives the relationship between an employee and an employer.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:46PM (#25365667)
I heard about this here in Austria that Swiss laws are way more business friendly at less worker friendly than here, basically reaching at will employment.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by wizzairflyer on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:05PM (#25366635)
It "at-will" in the sense that your employer doesn't need to justify firing you. But I wouldn' compare it to what they have in some states in the US.

However you still have at least 1 month notice, and often more depending on the industry and seniority. Here in Zürich the standard in tech seems to be 3 month (anecdata though).

Where it gets kinda business friendly is that if you are fired for an illegal reason, it's up to you to prove that you were instead of your employer having to prove he fired you for something reasonable. The settlements are also nothing that would deter a company to behave badly I guess.

There is also a good tradition of union-like structure in the professions that need it (the ones where one is easily replaceable basically) that give workers a nice protection and benefits. It's not like in France of course but it's far from the US, based on the stories I gleaned about on HN.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by sharpneli on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:23PM (#25366116)
Non-competes are illegal in California. That’s likely a big reason why it is so successful. As an example neither Intel not AMD would exist if non-competes would be allowed there. Iirc Nvidia too.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ur-whale on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:53PM (#25362556)
That's just Austria which is a comparatively small country.

In the larger ones (DE, FR) labor laws are a nightmare.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by bildung on Thursday December 10, 2020 @04:01AM (#25371452)
It's not hard at all in Germany, I already had to do it a few times. It's just regulated, i.e. you have to follow a defined process (two written warnings first, only then the dismissal) and have proof of what happened.

The range of reasons include coming too late to work, insulting coworkers and even underperformance.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @02:11PM (#25362953)
Labour laws are a nightmare in every country due to bureaucracy but that doesn't mean it's always difficult to fire people. Most companies be it in FR, DE, wherever, have good lawyers on the payroll to advise them o the easiest legal path possible to get rid of undesirable employees. If a company really wants you gone, they'll make it happen one way or another.

France was famous for their approach of making an employees' life miserable in order to make them leave as they couldn't fire them easily. Honestly, I'd rather just be fired and get on unemployment than be subjected to psychological torture every day in a poisonous work environment.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by joelbluminator on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:00PM (#25364887)
> If a company really wants you gone, they'll make it happen one way or another.

Well they usually do it by compensating the employee quite heavily. Psychologically torturing an employee isn't that good for team morale, even if the employee was underperforming. I also don't think it's as culturally prevalent as you imply.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:04PM (#25364963)
>Well they usually do it by compensating the employee quite heavily.

Where outside of the US/UK does that happen? Never heard in Europe that you get paid more so you leave when they can boot you out for free and I talked to lawyers about this. The reasoning behind the generous safety nets in Europe is also to make it easier for employee-employer terminations in case it doesn't work out. The laws here are that employers aren't allowed to abuse you, force you into unpaid overtime, etc. but fire you for free they can otherwise nobody would dare become an entrepreneur/investor in an environment where it's impossible to fire someone.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by joelbluminator on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:20PM (#25365218)
I live in the Netherlands. After 3 years (used to be 2 years up until very recently) a worker has to be moved to a permanent contract. That makes firing a person very difficult.

> when they can boot you out for free

You can't really. It's extremely difficult and no lawyer can magically change the fact that the culture and the courts are in favor of the worker, not the employer.

Now the laws might change a bit, making the terms of termination a bit easier for the employer in the future (we'll see what the next government brings), but in general I expect it to still be quite difficult. So it may be easier to pay the employee 30K extra compensation to let him go then trying a game of psychological torture. And if that sounds unreal to you, know that in the Netherlands employees can get paid up to 2 years if they have a nervous breakdown. And nervous breakdown is quite common culturally. So employees have dirty tricks of their own if the employer wants to play dirty.

Now of course, there are obvious disadvantages to this approach, not necessarily for the employer actually. The employer can protect himself by simply not hiring anyone for more than a couple of years, making "flex work" a real problem in NL. But yes, firing could be hard and I'd be surprised if it's much different in Germany/France etc.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ChuckNorris89 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:32PM (#25365417)
>the fact that the culture and the courts are in favor of the worker

As much as I like being on the side of the little guy, in any civilized society, the courts should be impartial and not favor the employer nor the employee and pass verdicts based on the law and not based on the culture and if the law says you can fire someone who continuously underperforms over a period of time then that law will be applied.

>After 3 years [...] a worker has to be moved to a permanent contract.

That sounds pretty poor IMHO. In most of the EU you're permanent after passing the first year of employment. I've never worked more than 3 years in a place so far, so in the NL I would have never reached permanent status, continuously being at the risk of on the spot termination. I dunno man, sounds pretty bad for me IMHO.

>And nervous breakdown is quite common culturally.

That actually sounds legit bad IMHO if mental issues are the becoming the norm in employment relationships.

>The employer can protect himself by simply not hiring anyone for more than a couple of years, making "flex work" a real problem in NL

I used to work for a top NL based company and this situation was often discussed around the office that NL companies are abusing expat workers from poorer countries by promising them riches in exchange for hard work and sacrifice and instead using them for 2-3 years then rotating them with new workers until they get fed up with this and move back to their home countries. Rinse and repeat. Sounds really good for Dutch business though.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by joelbluminator on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:53PM (#25365759)
> Except that in any civilized society

Gonna ignore that one.

> I used to work for a top NL based company and this situation was often discussed around the office that NL companies are abusing expat workers promising them riches and instead using them for 2-3 years then rotating them with new workers until they get fed up with this and move back to their home countries

I really haven't experienced this at all. Tons of expats I know are on permanent contract (btw - many employers offer a permanent contract after 1-1.5 years if they're happy with the emplyoee, at least that's what I see in tech). Of course people in the hotel/entertainment business may have a different experience. I bet flex work is more common there.

> That actually sounds legit bad IMHO if mental issues are the becoming the norm in employment relationships.

I didn't say mental issues are the norm in the Netherlands, lol. Far from it, it's one of the happiest countries in the world according to research. I'm just saying - the law enables you to take a LONG paid leave if you have burnout. Now some employees actually get burned out, and some are probably abusing it a bit. When you're protecting employees there'll always be people who dishonestly try to take advantage.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by burntoutfire on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:55PM (#25365799)
> Except that in any civilized society, the courts should be impartial and not favor the employer nor the employee and pass verdicts based on the law and not based on the culture and if the law says you can fire someone who continuously underperforms over a period of time then that law will be applied.

Laws have huge margins left for judge's interpretation of what is fair and just in a given case.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by rakhodorkovsky on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:27PM (#25366179)
In Germany it's common for larger, well performing companies to retire older, less productive employees by way of 'Abfindungsprogramm' - programs that offer these employees generous monetary compensation (up to ~2-5 annual salary) in exchange for them retiring early. I know of four people who took such an offer.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by Glawen on Thursday December 10, 2020 @02:24AM (#25370850)
And I never understood why a company would do that
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by joelbluminator on Thursday December 10, 2020 @03:51AM (#25371381)
I believe it's cost effective, firing these people is usually very hard legally.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by Bayart on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:34PM (#25364438)
I've grown to be extremely suspicious of anyone taking labour laws as a barrier to be brought down, as it's always come from people who've got nothing to lose from it and weakening them seems to systematically translate into lower standards of living and higher income inequality.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by petra on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:18PM (#25360971)
Disjoined markets aren't necessary such a big issue. Israel manages to do well, for example. Usually opening a US office is the common method overcoming that issue.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by burntoutfire on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:56PM (#25365816)
Is there even one unicorn originating from Israel though?
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by dannylandau on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:16PM (#25369630)
Apparently based on this website, there are over 41 and counting -- https://www.techaviv.com/unicorns
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by andruby on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:10AM (#25360121)
In my opinion you've hit the major reasons. I would also include that culture, and especially founder culture is different too, and that hampers these "massive scope" ventures. A somewhat more fractured local market (languages, laws, markets, habits) also plays against it.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by whimsicalism on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:25AM (#25360293)
There's also the push-factor of the yawning black void of poverty in the US if you choose to pursue your passion rather than your comparative advantage.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by eastendguy on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:13PM (#25360900)
"corrupt politicians"... really? Do you have any examples of large scale corruption inside EU? I don't. I think the majority of EU politicians are doing fine.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ralfn on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @03:29PM (#25364354)
>Do you have any examples of large scale corruption inside EU?

It doesn't happen with the one large corruption scheme taking all of the money. Its hundreds of small corruptions like a locust.

Here is a fair and neutral attempt to catalog all the schemes in play: https://www.oecd.org/gov/ethics/prevention-fraud-corruption-...

In return: Do you have an example of where the EU paid anywhere below 200% of industry standard price for anything?

I'm not arguing its more corrupt than say the US Congress. Its on par, with some weird extremes. For example: Berlusconi, a prime minister, spending public money on under age prostitutes, serving today freely as a member of the EP. That kind also owned most media companies in his country and implemented favourable regulation and tax exemptions for himself.

Here in the Netherlands, there is something referred to as the 'job carousel'. Where favourable regulation by politicians is rewarded in the future (after a political carreer) by very highly paid gigs in the industries and companies they favoured. Technically legal, and very hard to legislate against. Its a refined form of corruption, but it has all the same downsides. During Corona for example, the Netherlands had trouble getting its testing in order. Turned out we had excluded big commercial labs from consideration because we had represenatites of the 'small artisinal labs' in our taskforce lobbying. A small scale corruption, with heavy economic distortion as a result!

I'm also not perse blaming corruption on the politicians themselves. We are all together responsible for the corporate and governance culture we breed. Yet we shouldn't pretend we currently have the ability to spend/invest money effectively and fairly as a collective.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by joelbluminator on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:03PM (#25364945)
> Turned out we had excluded big commercial labs from consideration because we had represenatites of the 'small artisinal labs' in our taskforce lobbying.

Do u have a link to that story?

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by ralfn on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @07:11PM (#25367535)
The original research came from FTM: https://www.ftm.nl/artikelen/vws-taaleis-duits-lab-testcapac...

https://www.ftm.nl/artikelen/coronatesten-belangen-arts-micr...

However, this stuff is paywalled by now.

https://nos.nl/nieuwsuur/artikel/2346643-testlabs-kunnen-wel...

Or, an easy video summary by Arjen Lubach (has english subtitles): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JUx-kdbKQys

The lobbyist, part of the Outbreak Management Team, is Ann Vossen. And she argued from her experise that there should be specific requirements that effectively kept larger laboratories from being able to be suppliers. Ironically, the trick used was the Tower of Babel (pretending language differences could be a risk)

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by topspin on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:34PM (#25362077)
Nothing that would meet some arbitrary, establishment defined definition of 'corruption.' The fact that the sons and daughters and son-in-laws and daughter-in-laws, extended family and close friends all end up in cushy no-show non-profit chairmanships where they launder corporate donations to family foundations, drive their fleet of foundation owned cars, live in foundation owned mansions and accrue their foundation pensions is the sort of perfectly legal corruption people have in mind. The sentiment appearing here is correct; not a cent of the money invested by the EU in semiconductors will escape the clutches of establishment grandees and instead find its way to anyone that knows how to compete effectively with prevailing foundries, so don't expect to find any European manufactured chips troubling TSMC et al. in this lifetime.
Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by anonuser123456 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:27PM (#25361924)
>It does make it baffling why Intel is unable to produce 5nn chips with the same ASML machines TSC is using. It must be management failing Boeing style.

My understanding is that Intel believed EUV would be very late. As such, it committed to Intel 10nm (TSMC 7nm) without EUV, which turned out to be too complex. At the same time, TSMC banked on EUV early. This gave them a headstart over Intel once Intel started down the EUV path.

The tables could have been reversed. EUV could have been very late, and 10nm non-EUV might have worked better. Hard to know these things when you are making plans 3-5 years ahead.

Re:EU countries team up for semiconductor push by rajesh-s on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:13PM (#25360907)
I thought ASML manufacturing was in Connecticut, USA? I heard this from Ian Cutress on his channel https://youtu.be/JyocuFlQmTc