News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by blakesterz on Monday December 07, 2020 @11:59AM (#25333993)
Wow, apparently that's some BIG money:

"Terms were not disclosed, but a source tells Variety that the deal was easily in nine figures. Since 80% of Stevie Nicks’ publishing catalog was acquired by Primary Wave last week for a reported $100 million, the Dylan catalog probably drew a number well above that."

I read that Imagine Dragons sold all their songs for over $100 million as well. ( https://variety.com/2020/music/news/imagine-dragons-publishi... )

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by robocat on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:14PM (#25335913)
Most importantly, he most likely carefully chose the contractual terms, controlling the use of his legacy how he wishes. And presumably prevents potential problems with disagreements between his descendants about something they all would have differing personal opinions about.

How many times have you seen an artist's oeuvre or author's written works be misused by his or or her descendants?

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by henrikschroder on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:55PM (#25336451)
This was my first thought as well. The likelihood of those who inherit his copyrights to either squander them or being taken for a ride by the music industry is very high.

So him selling them himself allows him to negotiate better conditions and more money, which will do more to protect his legacy than just holding on to them until his death.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by CamperBob2 on Monday December 07, 2020 @04:06PM (#25337529)
Wait, who?

The Grammy-winning Las Vegas-based act is one of the most successful rock bands of the past decade, with hits like “Radioactive,” “Demons,” “Believer,” “Thunder” and “Whatever It Takes” from albums band made their mark with their global smash hits from their album “Night Visions,” “Smoke + Mirrors,” “Evolve” and “Origins.”

I've never even heard of these guys, so the fact that their catalog is apparently worth $100M is making me feel old and out of touch. Oh, well.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by aeortiz on Monday December 07, 2020 @04:11PM (#25337597)
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by briankelly on Monday December 07, 2020 @07:26PM (#25339767)
I would be surprised if you haven't heard Radioactive - it's plastered on many TV commercials and featured heavily on radio.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by conradfr on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @11:02AM (#25347000)
I know the name of the band but not their music. I checked that song and I don't think I've ever heard it but it has 1.2 billion views on Youtube so ...
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by m463 on Monday December 07, 2020 @09:36PM (#25340989)
TV commercials? Radio? Are these bridge words to communicate with older people? :)

I remember feeling old when I ... decades ago ... was talking about CDs and the person I was talking to had never owned one.

And now I suspect you can add "analog OTA transmission of music and videos" to that.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by briankelly on Monday December 07, 2020 @10:40PM (#25341491)
Haha I first learned of them from YouTube (when they tried to appeal to the hipster crowd) but now only hear them because of the TV (football commercials) and the rare cases I'm directly exposed to commercial FM radio. That is, when it isn't a classic rock (The Doors and Warrant) or "new" classic rock (RHCP and Linkin Park) station that some gas station or family-friendly bar/grill least-common-denomitored their way to putting on the speakers.

My Mom is the only person I know who admits to liking them. We tried to get her Spotify but she wasn't interested.

One day, very soon, the Imagine Dragons will be considered classic rock, but commercial radio will have long bit the dust and there won't be any classic rock stations left to call them it.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by whiddershins on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:11PM (#25335012)
Dylan isn’t in the same ballpark as the artists you are mentioning, I would have imagined his catalog to be an order of magnitude more valuable.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by adventured on Monday December 07, 2020 @07:46PM (#25339972)
I consider Tom Petty to be a vastly superior artist to Britney Spears. She has far greater commercial appeal however and her music is worth more today if you're selling a catalog. The same would factor in to selling the Dylan catalog. Dylan's music is not very popular with young people and will not be very popular in the future (see: Elvis, Cher, Neil Diamond, Clapton, Madonna, Whitney Houston, Rod Stewart, Chicago, etc; their music doesn't sell at all like it used to), although I'm sure it'll be redone endlessly. Do young people care about Simon & Garfunkel? Not in the least and they won't tomorrow either. That music will all fade by the year, relegated to a small fraction of the interest it once had, as the primary generation or two that listened to it die.

After 60 years Dylan has sold less than the Backstreet Boys. He produced relatively few hits compared to other renowned, popular artists. His style of music doesn't lend itself to vast commercial success. Someone will pay a premium to acquire his catalog because he's such a great artist and it's a large & influential catalog, however there is a practical limit to that.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by NaOH on Monday December 07, 2020 @08:29PM (#25340448)
You don't seem to be accounting for how widely covered Dylan material has historically been. There are plenty of Dylan songs that as far back as the 1960s brought more sales for others than for him. This has continued throughout his career. For example, one 1997 Dylan song was in the top 50 UK sales in 2010 and all told has been covered by more than 450 other artists. In the last five years, official releases of past Grateful Dead concerts have contained at least 30 Dylan songs. It's 600 Dylan songs and at least 10 times that in cover versions which continue earning money.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by whiddershins on Monday December 07, 2020 @09:08PM (#25340776)
A quick google search shows tom petty has sold 80 million records and Britney Spears 100 million.

I think you are mis-gauging what happens to music over the course of decades. Bubble gum pop and similarly positioned types of hip-hop etc do very well when they are in fashion, but don’t earn as much consistently over the long haul.

Dylan’s catalogue could plausibly still earn 50 years from now.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by sbahr001 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @01:44PM (#25362350)
There is also musical licensing, where a lot of money is made after the initial popularity. Technically, I have seen more bob dylan songs in commercials and movies than I have on the radio. Hey also has a ton of unreleased stuff in there two, which they probably can make a lot of money off of, especially/sadly when he dies.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by hardtke on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:48PM (#25335549)
The only way to justify these prices is movie/TV/advertising licensing which is negotiated for each specific instance. Streaming brings in a fraction of cent per play so his catalog can't be generating more than a million dollars per year at best. Using his music to sell prescription drugs to nostalgic baby boomers watching Fox News is likely the plan.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by jlmorton on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:56PM (#25335683)
> Streaming brings in a fraction of cent per play so his catalog can't be generating more than a million dollars per year at best.

Wow, I think that's wildly off the mark. Bob Dylan probably has several billion streams per year, if not more. On Spotify right now, his top 10 songs have a billion streams. Obviously those did not all occur in a single year, but Dylan's catalogue is deep, and Spotify is hardly the only platform.

One billion streams per year is about $4 million on Spotify.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by olivermarks on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:14PM (#25335900)
I would assume other people have commercial rights percentages within Dylan's organization, management and past agreements, the sale price is highly unlikely to all go into Dylan's pockets.

The big revenue comes from film and advertising licensing, we saw this when Michael Jackson (who owned the Beatles back catalog along with Sony who he was in a vicious battle with).

Despite the claims in this article, Jackson didn't sell out many Beatles songs, it was Sony after he died who enabled and profited from Beatles songs in commercials and films. https://www.biography.com/news/michael-jackson-paul-mccartne...

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by hardtke on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:23PM (#25336004)
I was estimating a few hundred million streams per year (including All Along the Watchtower by Hendrix). The $4 million/billion streams gets split a few ways and the songwriter only gets a portion of that. Radio was more lucrative for songwriters since the songwriters got the bulk of the revenue (no payments to performers).
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by giarc on Monday December 07, 2020 @03:25PM (#25336945)
In a CBC article, they added the following comparable.

"Four years ago, when Michael Jackson's estate sold the remaining half-share that it owned in the artist's catalogue, it fetched $750 million US."

Important to note that Michael Jackson's catalogue includes Beatles, Taylor Swift, Elvis, Sly and the Family Stone etc.

https://www.cbc.ca/news/entertainment/bob-dylan-universal-mu...

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by ginko on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:48PM (#25334681)
I wonder what he'd need so much money for. Especially considering his age.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by sandworm101 on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:21PM (#25335183)
>> Especially considering his age.

A lawyer might call this "cold hand" control. He, like every other rich old person, is probably setting up a complex will to control how his wealth functions after his death (the cold hand from the grave). If he gives a song to someone, that person can do what they want with it. They could keep the money. Sell the song. Or just sit on it and let it never be played again. The dead man would not be in control. But if he convert that song into a pile of cash, and inserts that cash into a trust, then the dead man can exercise more direct/itemized control for many years to come.

Give your house to your son and the day after you die he can sell it. But fund a trust to "administer" the house and you can tell the kid he can live in it but never sell it. Even decades later, the dead hand still controls the house and behavior of the child. Rich people do these things. When I was a law student working at a legal clinic, maybe 1/4 of the clients were old people who wanted to leave their house to their daughter but didn't want her to sell the day after they died. My advice was always to not do this because it burdened the daughter immensely. They didn't care. They wanted the house to continue in the family forever regardless.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by chrisdhoover on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:51PM (#25335597)
Cold hand makes sense. Frank Zappa’s estate left his family at odds. Dylan could avoid that with careful planning.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by sandworm101 on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:03PM (#25335776)
(Generic situation, not an ethics violation): One couple I talked to wanted to give their house to their infant grandson. So long as Billy lived in the house his parents could stay too. (Parents effectively passed over, avoiding some taxation issue.) I had a standard approach to this:

So you don't want Billy to join the army? What if Billy wants to be a fighter pilot? Then he won't then be living in the house. What if he is offered a great job in New York? Do you want him to turn that job down in order to keep his parents living your house? When Little Billy is 50 years old, and you have been dead for decades, do you still want him opening up your will to ask your permission before he makes a life choice? Instead, how about we let him live in the house until he is 25 and then he can sell it?

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by dllthomas on Monday December 07, 2020 @07:29PM (#25339794)
On the one hand, I feel bad about the hard feelings and I'm glad the issue is resolved.

On the other hand, "Dweezil Zappa Plays Whatever the F@%k He Wants – The Cease and Desist Tour" is the most Zappa thing ever to Zappa.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by subpixel on Monday December 07, 2020 @04:07PM (#25337542)
The James Brown estate feud is one for the ages.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by pbuzbee on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:51PM (#25336399)
Do you have any insight into why people want the house to remain in the family? Is it to preserve their legacy, or something else?
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by sandworm101 on Monday December 07, 2020 @03:24PM (#25336939)
When people get old their mobility/independence/memory diminishes. To combat that they try to maintain a routine, a steady state. They fear change. Dynamic young people become scary unpredictable things. The answer is to exercise control in those areas over which you exercise effective control: finance and property. The natural extension of this control during life is to maintain control after one's death. That's what wills are all about.

Imagination also suffers with age. Old people that enjoy their later years want their kids to enjoy the same life... literally. So they leave the house to the daughter so that she can drop into her parents life. The parents cannot imagine that their daughter has her own perspective. They cannot imagine that the only reason the daughter even lives in town is to help take care of her wealthy parents, that the day after the funeral she will be on a plane to california.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by i1856511 on Monday December 07, 2020 @03:15PM (#25336793)
That's right. It's a decision driven by emotion.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by coldtea on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:56PM (#25334812)
After 2-3 million you don't really "need" money for anything yourself.

You take them for family, because you can, to not let it go away, because you want the power that comes with it, and for extravagance. But not for "need".

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by ngold on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:16PM (#25335097)
There's a great story about the police getting a call for a homeless man wandering around a super posh neighborhood. Turned out to be bob dylan, I think he might have been house hunting.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by YetAnotherNick on Monday December 07, 2020 @03:39PM (#25337163)
What do you mean by your so called "need"?
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by coldtea on Monday December 07, 2020 @04:15PM (#25337648)
The casual/dictionary one.

With 3-4 million (less in many countries) all your needs are covered for life. You wont die or have any harmful effect (lack of job, nutricion, housing, clothing, health coverage) when you don't get to have more, except for things common to everybody like natural death, accidents etc.

If you go for more, you do it for various wants, not for needs.

Even when it comes to happiness, there's a plataeu at around that level:

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/map-happiness-benchmark_n_559...

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by YetAnotherNick on Monday December 07, 2020 @05:45PM (#25338746)
> lack of job, nutricion, housing, clothing, health coverage

Minimum wage is enough for this.

And the link you shared couldn't get the analysis more wrong just to come up with clickbaity title. They are taking average happiness of state and average wage, and even then the data doesn't look like it is plateauing.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by coldtea on Monday December 07, 2020 @06:21PM (#25339143)
>Minimum wage is enough for this.

Minimum wage? LOL.

Even with a $80,000 salary, in the US a medical or other emergency (e.g. getting fired in a bad economy), can leave you unemployed, homeless, or living with a big debt. Even worse so for your retirement prospects (or lack thereof).

With a few cool million in the bank you don't need to worry about any of those things.

>And the link you shared couldn't get the analysis more wrong just to come up with clickbaity title. They are taking average happiness of state and average wage, and even then the data doesn't look like it is plateauing.

Missed this part, linked to from the article?

https://www.pnas.org/content/107/38/16489.abstract

Or the fact that "non plateuing" still shows clear diminishing returns...

Why exactly do you think e.g. 10 million will make you any happier than e.g. 5 million (never mind anywhere close to double as happy)?

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by rualca on Monday December 07, 2020 @07:08PM (#25339603)
> Minimum wage is enough for this.

Give a minimum wage job a try for a couple of years and afterwards let me know if you still believe in that.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by YetAnotherNick on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @08:12AM (#25344609)
Can you even understood what I said. I have more needs than "lack of job, nutricion, housing, clothing, health coverage". If I have have 10 million dollar, I wouldn't reject earning another 10 million dollar. I am answering the poster whos said "need" is defined as that for which I think minimum wage could do. My need is dynamic in that case.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by coldtea on Sunday December 13, 2020 @05:58AM (#25405702)
>My need is dynamic in that case.

That's because you confuse wants and needs. Both the historical understanding of the terms and the dictionary definition are different.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by artificialLimbs on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:26PM (#25335273)
Or you have that much money because you need to invent air conditioning, nuclear power, water treatment plants, or Tesla.

Little things like that..

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by coldtea on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:43PM (#25335481)
That's basically the "power trip" case, as you don't really "need" to invent anything.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by zmix on Monday December 07, 2020 @08:29PM (#25340441)
Many inventions, these days, are often the result of expensive research and trial.

Also, inventing is not enough, you need to "develop".

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by toyg on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:16PM (#25335104)
He has 6 children, 2 ex-wives, and I don’t know how many grandchildren. I can think of a couple of reasons they could use some cash.

Also, this settles what could have been a pretty thorny inheritance issue.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by Andrex on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:05PM (#25334934)
It was less likely that Dylan was looking to unload his catalogue, and more likely Universal were just extremely hungry for it. At that point you can name the price.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by robbrown451 on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:05PM (#25334931)
Well I'd also wonder what he'd need to retain ownership for. For some people that's important, but others it's not, especially if they trust the new stewards.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by jchrisa on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:08PM (#25335831)
I figure it's more about his legacy. Better to have the music commercially exploited by experts than by a family office.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by Uhhrrr on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:51PM (#25334728)
"Family" is the obvious guess.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by dfxm12 on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:53PM (#25335628)
I wonder why he needs the liquidity. I'm sure he's making a ton of money from royalties alone. Even to his ancestors, it's probably better off long term, and good enough short term, to leave the catalog than cash.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by jankassens on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:14PM (#25335066)
If he thinks he'd have enough money by selling for $x, he should probably take $x + $y and donate $y to some cause.