News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by sandworm101 on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:21PM (#25335183)
>> Especially considering his age.

A lawyer might call this "cold hand" control. He, like every other rich old person, is probably setting up a complex will to control how his wealth functions after his death (the cold hand from the grave). If he gives a song to someone, that person can do what they want with it. They could keep the money. Sell the song. Or just sit on it and let it never be played again. The dead man would not be in control. But if he convert that song into a pile of cash, and inserts that cash into a trust, then the dead man can exercise more direct/itemized control for many years to come.

Give your house to your son and the day after you die he can sell it. But fund a trust to "administer" the house and you can tell the kid he can live in it but never sell it. Even decades later, the dead hand still controls the house and behavior of the child. Rich people do these things. When I was a law student working at a legal clinic, maybe 1/4 of the clients were old people who wanted to leave their house to their daughter but didn't want her to sell the day after they died. My advice was always to not do this because it burdened the daughter immensely. They didn't care. They wanted the house to continue in the family forever regardless.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by chrisdhoover on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:51PM (#25335597)
Cold hand makes sense. Frank Zappa’s estate left his family at odds. Dylan could avoid that with careful planning.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by sandworm101 on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:03PM (#25335776)
(Generic situation, not an ethics violation): One couple I talked to wanted to give their house to their infant grandson. So long as Billy lived in the house his parents could stay too. (Parents effectively passed over, avoiding some taxation issue.) I had a standard approach to this:

So you don't want Billy to join the army? What if Billy wants to be a fighter pilot? Then he won't then be living in the house. What if he is offered a great job in New York? Do you want him to turn that job down in order to keep his parents living your house? When Little Billy is 50 years old, and you have been dead for decades, do you still want him opening up your will to ask your permission before he makes a life choice? Instead, how about we let him live in the house until he is 25 and then he can sell it?

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by dllthomas on Monday December 07, 2020 @07:29PM (#25339794)
On the one hand, I feel bad about the hard feelings and I'm glad the issue is resolved.

On the other hand, "Dweezil Zappa Plays Whatever the F@%k He Wants – The Cease and Desist Tour" is the most Zappa thing ever to Zappa.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by subpixel on Monday December 07, 2020 @04:07PM (#25337542)
The James Brown estate feud is one for the ages.
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by pbuzbee on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:51PM (#25336399)
Do you have any insight into why people want the house to remain in the family? Is it to preserve their legacy, or something else?
Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by sandworm101 on Monday December 07, 2020 @03:24PM (#25336939)
When people get old their mobility/independence/memory diminishes. To combat that they try to maintain a routine, a steady state. They fear change. Dynamic young people become scary unpredictable things. The answer is to exercise control in those areas over which you exercise effective control: finance and property. The natural extension of this control during life is to maintain control after one's death. That's what wills are all about.

Imagination also suffers with age. Old people that enjoy their later years want their kids to enjoy the same life... literally. So they leave the house to the daughter so that she can drop into her parents life. The parents cannot imagine that their daughter has her own perspective. They cannot imagine that the only reason the daughter even lives in town is to help take care of her wealthy parents, that the day after the funeral she will be on a plane to california.

Re:Bob Dylan Sells Entire Catalog of Songs to Universal Musi... by i1856511 on Monday December 07, 2020 @03:15PM (#25336793)
That's right. It's a decision driven by emotion.