News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by bradleyland on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:19PM (#2527182)
The title is a bit of a double entendre. At first reading, I thought the claim was that (once again), Organization X had killed RSS (figuratively). As it turns out, Facebook and Twitter have, quite literally, killed RSS within the scope of their own systems by removing it from key locations.

In my view, RSS was never the right tool for this application anyway. Social networks are naturally conversational in nature, but you're only a part of the conversation while you're there.

In the economy of my attention, both Facebook and Twitter occupy a different position than the RSS feeds I follow. Facebook and Twitter are there for when I want them, but my RSS feed is the kind of thing where I try to at least review every headline. I don't want to miss anything in my RSS reader, but I'm perfectly content to miss out on large portions of what occurs on Facebook and Twitter.

Twitter is probably closer in function to RSS -- for me, anyway -- than Facebook, in that I rely on it for "pushed" information that I rarely respond to (think service outages and status updates). This could, theoretically, have been fulfilled by RSS, but for some reason, I never made use of RSS that way.

I think one of the reasons for this (Twitter as a popular info-push medium) is that you can respond easily through Twitter, even if I only do it on rare occasions. Status blogs provided an avenue for response, but you often had to have an account on every blog... Ugh. Twitter is also great because you don't have to dig through the service website; you simply search Twitter for their company name and follow.

Facebook, on the other hand, is purely entertainment for me. I use it to keep up with friends and converse in a time-shifted manner. I cannot imagine collecting RSS feeds from Facebook streams.

Based my usage patterns, I don't see this as "killing" RSS for me in a general sense. Maybe I'm a dying breed though.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by barrkel on Sunday May 08, 2011 @10:20PM (#2527307)
It's precisely because there's so much crud on Facebook that I consume it via an RSS feed rather than by visiting the site; that way, I can skim through a day's worth of friend updates in less than a minute. In any case, I have facebook.com ad-blocked in my primary browser, and use a secondary browser whenever I need to visit it. I don't visit Facebook much more often than once a week, and I only do if there's a particular update etc. worthy of attention.

I use jwz's RSS workarounds for my Facebook feeds: http://www.jwz.org/blog/2009/12/how-to-use-facebook-with-a-f...

Unfortunately, in the past week, Facebook's RSS feeds have been behaving very erratically. As seen in Google Reader, the update feeds show up as entirely refreshed - all new items - even though only a handful of items are actually new. The links on the RSS items have changed from the proper status update link to flat links to facebook.com. So rather than killing RSS, this move by Facebook is killing Facebook for me.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by nhangen on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:21PM (#2527185)
This is true. The feeds still work, they just hid them from plain sight.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by ankrgyl on Sunday May 08, 2011 @10:10PM (#2527282)
A common "general" application of RSS is news, but this will hopefully be slowly phased out as well. The New York Times offers an awesome API (http://developer.nytimes.com/) which gives you a much better view of their data than their RSS feeds (which they still provide).
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by turbodog on Sunday May 08, 2011 @11:33PM (#2527461)
So I'm supposed to use the NYT's custom API to get articles when RSS has, for years, provided a "general" method for me to do the same thing for not only the NYT but millions of other sources?
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by ankrgyl on Monday May 09, 2011 @12:03AM (#2527514)
No, and that's why they still provide the RSS feed. My point is that in the immediate future, companies like FB, Twitter, and NY Times will experiment with APIs that provide richer functionality than RSS. Hopefully within a relatively short time frame, the APIs will start converging into a standardized, widely adopted replacement for RSS that builds on these ideas.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by Luyt on Sunday May 08, 2011 @11:52PM (#2527495)
Yes, and they want you to install a special 'NYT app' for that, which will be future: every company and news outlet will have its own app.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by ChrisArchitect on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:42AM (#2528492)
haha, and they'll all be based on frontend UI accessing RSS.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by Luyt on Monday May 09, 2011 @10:17AM (#2528766)
I was thinking more along the lines of 'accessing their own specific API (maybe even a private, undisclosed API)'.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by pstack on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:27PM (#2527199)
I have no interest in ever directly using Twitter and there's not enough content on there for me to bother with any workarounds. I currently use RSS for the one Twitter feed I bother to follow and if they ever really do get rid of RSS for their site, I'll just stop using even that. Not that much of a loss.

My habits are such that if you don't offer RSS feeds of information I want, I probably won't ever get your information or go to your site. You're not going to sucker me into "visiting regularly", just because you don't offer an RSS feed. I'll just move on and get what I want somewhere else.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by ankrgyl on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:38PM (#2527220)
I don't think getting you to visit their site is the point of the switch. Twitter and FB are in a position where they have enough addicted users that they can get away with messing with standards. RSS is outdated and slow, and FB and Twitter want people to use their data in a more sensible way, via their flexible APIs.

It's trivial to build an APP that generates an RSS stream for an arbitrary twitter account with their API, and I'm sure someone will soon. But the point is that they are setting a new standard for what can be done streams of structured data, and hopefully more sites will move away from RSS into cool APIs.

Of course, for now at least, there's no standard to this kind of API, but I think that people will eventually figure out what works and converge to it (as is the case with OAuth).

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by pstack on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:46PM (#2527229)
I hear people talk about how "RSS is so slow" all the time, but I still don't understand it. I see no failings or complaints about RSS. I get a headline and then I get an article. Are we talking speed between when content was generated and when it appears in an RSS feed? Honestly, I couldn't care less about that. I'll live if it takes fifteen minutes for an update to reach me. It's not like I'm getting a patient's live EKG readings via RSS.

As for yet another standardized API to replace it. As long as it provides the same functionality to all current services/devices that use RSS, that's fine with me. I would really prefer that it not be driven by Facebook and Twitter, however any more than I want Microsoft Office development teams driving the standardization of ODF.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by ankrgyl on Sunday May 08, 2011 @10:03PM (#2527269)
If you read about FriendFeed's Simple Update Protocol (http://blog.friendfeed.com/2008/08/simple-update-protocol-fe...), you'll find some good arguments about why RSS slow. The crux of the problem is that to get any updates on a feed, you have to request and download the entire RSS feed (which is filled with summary text and is of nontrivial size).

Consider the case of a real-time news aggregator. A news source doesn't update very frequently (say once every 5 minutes), but you want to provide updates super fast (say within 30 seconds). That means on average you have to scrape the entire RSS feed 10 times for a single update. On the other hand, FB/Twitter APIs give you the flexibility to do things like "download items after this id," which hog much less bandwidth.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by ppog on Sunday May 08, 2011 @10:44PM (#2527348)
Looking at that article, the slowness doesn't come from having to download the entire RSS feed. As commenters there note, If-Modified-Since means you only need to download the feed when there are changes. So in your second paragraph, you have to ping the RSS feed 10 times, but you'd only need to download it once.

Rather, the slowness seems to come from the lack of an aggregation mechanism. If I want to follow 100 feeds (e.g. 100 Twitter users), I have to query each of those 100 feeds. Even though I can query them efficiently using If-Modified-Since, that's still slower than firing off one query to find out which of those 100 feeds have updates, and then querying only those which do.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by ankrgyl on Sunday May 08, 2011 @11:23PM (#2527431)
Good point. The reason I didn't bring that up is that the comments suggest that if-modified-since isn't universally adopted by RSS publishers.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by patrickaljord on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:58PM (#2527255)
> Of course, for now at least, there's no standard to this kind of API, but I think that people will eventually figure out what works and converge to it (as is the case with OAuth).

Actually there is but twitter is not interested (for obvious reasons): http://ostatus.org/sites/default/files/ostatus-1.0-draft-2-s...

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by husted on Monday May 09, 2011 @10:05AM (#2528727)
/me raises a me-too-hand.

If I can't read it in Reeder I properly wont read it at all. I don't know (or care) if it's a slow and outdated technology as it seems to work okay for me.

It doesn't benefit me at all if RSS disappears and is replaced with FB or Twitter. Sharing news? Sorry no, the signal to noise levels are already low and I don't need to pollute the internet any further (said the man who is writing a worthless post on HN :-) But I guess it's not meant to benefit me anyway. So RSS will properly die and I'll silently adopt to whatever replaces it.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by eli on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:42PM (#2527223)
UPDATE: Dave Stevens shared a hack around this in the comments that you can use with the Twitter API.

Using a well-documented feature of the API? That is not a hack.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by nikcub on Monday May 09, 2011 @02:08AM (#2527731)
You must have missed the memo where now almost anything you do on a computer is hacking.

Got a form to submit in Django? I'm hacking. Got nodejs to run a sample app? I'm hacking. Integrate a shitty jQuery plugin? I'm hacking. RTFM - nope, hacking.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by thaumaturgy on Monday May 09, 2011 @04:26AM (#2527931)
Ironically, you seem to have forgotten that "hack" is also a synonym for "kludge" -- long before programmers started referring to themselves as hackers as a term of pride and endearment, many writers were referred to as "hacks".

I don't see any problem with referring to using a documented workaround as a "hack" in that context.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by eli on Monday May 09, 2011 @09:06AM (#2528553)
But that's my point -- it's not a hack OR a kludge OR a workaround.

It is the straightforward and recommended way of doing something. Twitter didn't kill RSS, they just stopped advertising it to end users.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by leon_ on Monday May 09, 2011 @02:44AM (#2527783)
just abuse the word. I hate that everything is "hacking" now - so I started overusing the word. whenever I'm doing something I am hacking. (Sometimes it's not limited to computer activities.)

I hope other people will will catch on and overuse the word to the point where it's not cool anymore and everything gets back to normal. (and hackernews can be renamed back to webmasternews)

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by ankrgyl on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:16PM (#2527173)
This is super interesting. RSS has gotten really slow and bad, and a few years ago FriendFeed started to push for improvements with the Simple Update Protocol (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simple_Update_Protocol).

The world should move to a standardized JSON-based, OAuth compliant API, but unfortunately having two big, competing players like FB and Twitter means that things will probably partition into camps. It'll be interesting to see what happens when new websites start publishing content: will they define their own new standard or clone FB/Twitter?

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by kevinchen on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:46PM (#2527230)
99.99% of users will not notice or care.

I can see a use case where devs who don’t feel like building for Twitter’s API will want to use RSS to quickly get a user’s recent tweets. But I don’t think this will significantly impact anybody’s anything, and it feels like the author is exaggerating the consequences.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by chc on Sunday May 08, 2011 @11:08PM (#2527397)
Most users of anything don't care about RSS. Most users also don't explicitly care about the API, either — those are both at a lower level than what users notice. That doesn't mean they're worthless.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by petervandijck on Sunday May 08, 2011 @09:26PM (#2527198)
And thus become even more walled gardens (a proprietary API doesn't count as "open").

The pendulum is still swinging towards "closed", but I sense it's about to swing back.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by follower on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:06AM (#2528383)
> but I sense it's about to swing back.

I'm curious what you're seeing that gives you this sense? From where I'm sitting I see things swinging even further toward closed which is rather disheartening but I'd be happy to be shown otherwise.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by petervandijck on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:25AM (#2528451)
Just the fact that we're so extremely closed now. It just has to swing back at some point.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by hammock on Sunday May 08, 2011 @11:55PM (#2527500)
Does anyone have an example of RSS being used/picked up by the mainstream user?
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by idle_processor on Monday May 09, 2011 @02:09AM (#2527733)
Google Reader didn't die like Wave; that implies some level of success.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by eli on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:32AM (#2528467)
Does anyone actually use Outlook's RSS features? I don't, but it seemed like that at least had potential to break into the mainstream.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by voidfiles on Sunday May 08, 2011 @11:32PM (#2527459)
RSS is awesome, and standards help ease integration, but we need to stop freaking out about RSS.

What we need to focus on is making sure companies endorse open data. Allowing users to get data in, and out in a reasonable format.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by elgenie on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @02:07AM (#2531559)
At least from the FB standpoint, "kill RSS" is quite an exaggeration. The code correcting the oversight that removed the links for RSS feeds in latest redesign of Page profiles should be going out tomorrow (5/10/11). Note that the feeds themselves (e.g. https://www.facebook.com/feeds/page.php?id=9445547199&fo...) were unaffected.

/me added back the Page RSS feeds during a hackathon last year

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by imwilsonxu on Tuesday May 10, 2011 @03:30AM (#2531730)
For me, reading rss is like reading newspapers or books: Better contents polished for readers, but less interactions(with authors or others readers).

On the other hand, reading facebook status or tweets is like listening or chatting with friends. Contents are impromptu and often out of context. However, it's much easier to interact.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by randomgeek on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:52AM (#2528513)
140 char posts are not what one should should subscribe to via. a RSS reader. Though I stand for open standards I don't really think that it is crucial that Twitter and Facebook supports RSS. Especially not Facebook - Twitter because it is more like the medias that I subscribe to; blogs, newssources and so on...
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by pavel_lishin on Sunday May 08, 2011 @11:01PM (#2527385)
> Unfortunately, it seems #2 was not accidental, as it was never fixed.

That does not necessarily follow.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by hollerith on Monday May 09, 2011 @03:03AM (#2527808)
I notice that Google Reader still lets a person subscribe to someone's Twitter.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by smogzer on Monday May 09, 2011 @06:18AM (#2528157)
speaking of rss feeds, does anybody have a list of "social" or "information" (weather like) sites with support for rss feeds ?
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by chopsueyar on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:44AM (#2528496)
"Embrace and extend."

Way to support open source, guys!

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by riams on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:08AM (#2528391)
I've fully abandoned Google Reader for Twitter.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by dholowiski on Monday May 09, 2011 @01:56AM (#2527710)
Rss was just a transitional technology. Twitter and Facebook have made it far easier for normal people to get news updates, and for developers there are API's. RSS will live on for podcast delivery (at least until apple dropsre-invents" podcasting) but other than that, let's just let RSS rest in peace.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by brazzy on Monday May 09, 2011 @05:16AM (#2528030)
Couldn't disagree more. Neither Twitter nor Facebook, and least of all every dinky little site offering a homebrewed API are an even remotely adequate replacement for RSS.

Twitter and Facebook have NOT made anything easier for normal people, they just managed to get the mindshare to force people to deal with their inadequacies, whereas a million different sites offering RSS feeds somehow never turned into something everyone and their dog "had to" use to be cool.

I use RSS daily as my main news source, check Facebook maybe every other day and never could figure out the point of Twitter.

Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by leon_ on Monday May 09, 2011 @02:45AM (#2527786)
news in 140 chars ... reminds me of that movie where they water their plants with soda.
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by eagleal on Monday May 09, 2011 @04:21AM (#2527923)
Re:Twitter and Facebook Both Quietly Kill RSS by chopsueyar on Monday May 09, 2011 @08:54AM (#2528519)
It was an energy drink, "Brawndo", not soda.