What worries me is my desktop has 64Gb of RAM which cost 1/3 of Apple’s usual upgrade mugging.
I think I’ll walk away from this.
Edit: just seen £200 to upgrade from a 8Gb unit to 16Gb.
8GB of RAM for £200 is “get fucked” territory. I paid £240 for the 64Gb in my desktop.
Take a look at your activity monitor and see how many background tasks you laptop is running right now (I currently have 481 and I only have 4 apps actually running).
Compare that to iPad which can run 2 apps max and apple controls all the background activity.
I expected you to say you did something with graphics/media. I guess the VMs could be the difference. I don’t use. But I have 100 chrome tabs open at most times lol.
It really depends on your usage patterns. VM abusers and people who need to keep an eye on more than one project at the same time (as in multiple IDEs) can't do with 16 Gb.
And please don't tell me to start closing software, I'm willing to pay for more ram to have everything handy. Except... I can't.
So far 16GB has been fine on this 2017 MacBook. Wouldn't turn down 32 though :-)
My view into your comment is that you think I'm used to the lag. That's not the case. It's not my only device just my only Apple laptop. My newest device, a iPhone 12 Pro, is an upgrade from my 6s that I surely noticed and knew I would. I had been frustrated by the 6s for a while but held out for 5G.
I'm somewhat impressed by some of these stories about RAM usage - what are people doing?
Please don't.
Don't think so. The M1's RAM is integrated into the SoC package, but it's not actually on the same die.
There's some images showing the discrete RAM modules in Apple's marketing material.
> "Edit: just seen £200 to upgrade from a 8Gb unit to 16Gb."
It's always been this way with Apple. Just in the old days you could pop the modules out and upgrade the RAM yourself.
that gets done for GPUs and CPUs because they're a monolithic die, but AFAIK that's not done for memory chips.
If they intend these things to run software development, audio/video editing, CAD, or any other resource-intensive workloads, there will absolutely be demand for more.
I really don't know much (anything) about the hardware manufacturing world. Is this a common practice?
There are stories that Apple is working on a gGPU so that would free space up on a future Mx chip for additional processors or memory. However looking at the space occupied by DRAM and GPU it looks like a larger die is required for any on board memory expansion.
Cost, performance, light weight - pick two right? Apple seems to have picked a combination of lower cost and light weight. Customers who need more ram probably move up to a MBP.
If you need a 13" MBP that supports more than 16gb of ram, they sell it. It seems unlikely they'll stick with a 16gb limit once they start replacing the higher end devices.
For the current M1 models. You can still get 32GB of RAM on the Intel models.
So they're "low end" only in the sense that you can't get more than 16GB of RAM on them.
I know I use a lot of RAM for compiling and tests, but we have cloud instances with up to 500GB of RAM for that.
Also with the new ARM instructions, I suspect more heavy task like these will be forced to move elsewhere. Businesses might not want to switch for a few years to wait for dev tools/ARM servers to be available.
Keep in mind the rollout of the new CPUs is a 2 year process.
For reference I currently have a 2019 16" MBP, with 64GB of RAM and an 8 core i9. Right now I'm using ~45GB of it, usually its up around 50 or 55. The CPU is at ~10%. While I'm developing locally, the workloads are highly bursty but sometimes they will chew up almost all of the CPU for about 10 minutes.
I used to have a 2016 15" MBP with 16GB (4 core i7) and while I could still run everything, the RAM was always pegged. Before that I had a 2016 13" MBP with 16GB (2 core i7) (I actually swapped with a coworker because I thought his 15" had 32GB). With both of these the RAM was by far the limiting factor, and while the increased CPU cores have been nice, most of the time I haven't noticed. The RAM increase on the other hand is always noticeable. Thus, 16GB is a nonstarter for me.
Edit: To add, I prefer the 13" form factor when I'm not at my desk.
https://www.apple.com/shop/buy-mac/macbook-pro/13-inch-space...
If you need 32 GB with the new ARM chips, you’ll probably have to wait a generation or two.
This is a charitable characterization.
More correct would be to term this limit "absurd" or "clownish".
Even if Apple views the use-cases of these machines as primarily consumption devices and the users of these machines not as creators but as consumers, the bloat of the modern web is expensive and getting more expensive every day.
The end user needs this memory even if they really are just using these as facebook machines.
EDIT: That's not just the notebooks - the mini appears to have this limitation as well (down from 64GB previously).
I webdev (RoR) for a living on a Dell machine with Linux and 8 gigs of RAM. It works beautifully.
Sometimes I browse Facebook and it still works beautifully.
My GF uses my old 2013 MBP with 4 gigs of RAM for college and it works just fine for her. She, too, sometimes browses Facebook.
Besides, this release cycle is 100% optimized for an impressive speed boost, tempered by a need for a more impressive battery life.
The proof will be in the pudding.Time will tell.
No, it can't. If more RAM means it's slower RAM then maybe it can be better to have less of it in some workloads. But otherwise it's never better to have less RAM than more RAM. Better memory management can make the impact of less RAM be less severe, but it's still unambiguously worse.
Especially if you have workloads that actually need the RAM like large ML models or editing 8K videos.
If the purpose of owning a computer is "get shit done", better memory management absolutely can be better than just throwing more RAM at the problem.
Those are not competing in any way. Better memory management does not require nor benefit from less RAM.
Apple doesn't give you a different kernel when you choose the 8GB SKU instead of the 16GB one. It's the same software, just with less RAM. And having that less RAM is best case break-even in "day to day" experience, but never better.
For me personally, I won't even consider a machine with less than 32GB ram in 2020/2021. With 32GB, I never close out of applications that I use regularly, and so it allows me to switch state instantaneously for not that much more money. My workloads are typically read-heavy & multiple GBs - editing/screening/cataloging hundreds of RAW photos, loading of multi-GB games, having about 50 tabs open in FF, etc. After having switched careers I rarely code anymore, and I don't think these are uncommon requirements.
16 is basically useless for dev purposes, unless you're only doing web stuff. And maybe not even then, containers/vms?
Five years later and I still can't buy a new 13" laptop from Apple with more RAM than my 2015 MBP.
Edit: Apparently you can configure a (Early 2020) Intel-based 13" MBP with 32GB of RAM - I was not aware of that. Hope they bring that option to the ARM versions ASAP, especially if the performance gains are as good as Apple claims.