> Interesting, I wonder how this is structured - surely there are items that can come up during due diligence that are deal-breakers for Xenon, and surely due-diligence is performed before the contract is closed?
The company was inherently transparent with everything. A big part of DD is QoE and there wasn't much to audit there. This was a deal term that reduced any walkaway risk.
> I have no idea how they managed to get the investors to walk with nothing, when the founders walked away with so much.
Deal flow and it's not worth their time. Be nice to successfully exited founders and they'll speak your praises for eternity. General Catalyst wants $1B exits. If the founder leads to dealflow that brings that in, the $800k will be an easy ROI.
Now if (theoretically) some founder reading this thread ever has to choose between General Catalyst and another VC, they will ALMOST ALWAYS choose General Catalyst
Over time it will lead to General Catalyst finding a non zero number of 10X or 100X companies because of that
One of the hard parts of the process, from the point of view of the company, is gathering all required documents/materials. I'm guessing a bunch of that work can be "reused", assuming they kept all the documents organized, which they would've for due-dilligence.
Let's say I do a diligence on behalf of PE Firm A (and the deal falls through) and PE Firm B wants to use that diligence because they're looking to buy the company now. Legally/contractually I cannot let that PE Firm B see the diligence report I created, however I have seen situations where PE Firm B would purchase the report from PE Firm A, or the target would purchase it and give it to PE Firm B.
——
This thread comes off as very tone deaf.
As a small minority shareholder the fees to receive a $800k wire round to zero. Plus it’s not $800k, it’s $800k plus whatever the preferred instrument yields on top.
This CEO seems super slimy and the story doesn’t add up. Much more likely he’s lying for some reason or other.
It would be different if you were an angel and that represented more 1% of your total portfolio, but it's just not the case when it's these big VCs.
Or its the cost of a lesson to stay away.
I only know what's on that Wikipedia page, but it doesn't look like it's as simple as the investor owning a stake, rather there are events that have to be triggered first which were perhaps very unlikely to be triggered.
I'm wondering if the math worked out that the firm would end up with less than half their investment, it's in their best interest to have a write-off and the founder benefits and potentially comes back to them with a new business later, instead of squeezing the founder for a few dollars.
They would end up with more than the initial $800k if they wanted it.
Let’s take a specific example. General Catalysts 2001 fund is projected to generate a 11.9% annual return per the public disclosure from Calpers. (1, sort for the name). That same fund is shown as a 7.1% net IRR by the state of New Jersey. (2)
The PR is soooo good, per some of the comments in this thread, General Catalyst is totally fine eating a bottom quartile return in a risky asset class (VC), which if you believed was their general behavior would prevent them from fundraising (therefore existing) going forward? Please.
Maybe the fact pattern is as stated, but it seems fishy at best.
https://www.calpers.ca.gov/page/investments/asset-classes/pr...
https://www.state.nj.us/treasury/doinvest/pdf/AlternativeInv...
If you're not going to make any money and the amount you'll lose won't piss of your LPs then the goodwill from an entrepreneur you like working with is worth more than the cash.
Keep in mind it’s a relatively small purchase price.
It must be tough though to bear your soul like this and take the heat he's no doubt been getting (including here).
> As part of the structure of the deal, Xenon guaranteed I’d take home $3.7m, regardless of what came up during due diligence
Interesting, I wonder how this is structured - surely there are items that can come up during due diligence that are deal-breakers for Xenon, and surely due-diligence is performed before the contract is closed?
> But they were incredibly gracious and both agreed to write off their investment. General Catalyst’s (who had the lion’s share of that $800k) response showed just how classy they are: “We recognize the work that’s gone into the past 7 years and it sounds like this is a great landing spot for the team. We’re grateful for the opportunity to have supported you along the way.”
I have no idea how they managed to get the investors to walk with nothing, when the founders walked away with so much.