I'm wondering if the math worked out that the firm would end up with less than half their investment, it's in their best interest to have a write-off and the founder benefits and potentially comes back to them with a new business later, instead of squeezing the founder for a few dollars.
They would end up with more than the initial $800k if they wanted it.
Let’s take a specific example. General Catalysts 2001 fund is projected to generate a 11.9% annual return per the public disclosure from Calpers. (1, sort for the name). That same fund is shown as a 7.1% net IRR by the state of New Jersey. (2)
The PR is soooo good, per some of the comments in this thread, General Catalyst is totally fine eating a bottom quartile return in a risky asset class (VC), which if you believed was their general behavior would prevent them from fundraising (therefore existing) going forward? Please.
Maybe the fact pattern is as stated, but it seems fishy at best.
https://www.calpers.ca.gov/page/investments/asset-classes/pr...
https://www.state.nj.us/treasury/doinvest/pdf/AlternativeInv...
I only know what's on that Wikipedia page, but it doesn't look like it's as simple as the investor owning a stake, rather there are events that have to be triggered first which were perhaps very unlikely to be triggered.