News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by mrfusion on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:35PM (#24891573)
> Both the government and private companies can censor stuff. But private companies are a little bit scarier. They have no constitution to answer to. They’re not elected. They have no constituents or voters. All of the protections we’ve built up to protect against government tyranny don’t exist for corporate tyranny.

- Aaron Swartz

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by dang on Monday October 26, 2020 @04:39AM (#24893974)
No one seems to have pointed it out, so I'll mention that Aaron was clearly paraphrasing Noam Chomsky there. The point about government being partially limited by constitutions and elections while private companies are not is one that Chomsky has been repeating for decades, and the phrase "corporate tyranny" is very much Chomsky's. This is in keeping with his left-libertarian view that workplaces should operate democratically.

It's not that Aaron was plagiarizing—the quote is from a documentary interview (https://www.reddit.com/r/aaronswartz/comments/dpo2ot/both_th...). In that context it's not common to make attributions and the editors would probably have cut it out in any case.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by AniseAbyss on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:52AM (#24894385)
Whenever America disappoints me, and that's basically all the time these days, I remind myself that it has also produced critical thinkers like Twain and Chomsky.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by hackyhacky on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:54PM (#24891718)
I respect Swartz a lot, and he makes many good points. But let's not pretend that Twitter and Facebook hold information monopolies with equivalent power to the government's ability to censor. As proof, consider that we are having this conversation right now, about an article that was published and is freely, legally available online to anyone with a web browser. You can disagree with Twitter's editorial choices, but (as long as we prevent a literal technological monopoly, a prospect that seems increasingly probably) the consequences thereof are in no way similar to government censorship.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by googthrowaway42 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:06PM (#24891809)
The lines get blurry when there is a revolving door between Silicon Valley tech companies and DC.

Recent example from the banning of Bret Weinstein from Facebook: https://twitter.com/Liz_Shepherd/status/1319451084859953154?...

This is a Facebook communications person responding with an official reply to this incident. She describes herself as "Facebook comms, formerly @TheDemocrats and @SpeakerPelosi".

This is an example of power leakage. These institutions do in fact (i.e. de facto, not de jure) have elements of sovereign power given their relationship with the political/ruling class, it's just that they are not directly accountable in the same way that a government is. They engage in censorship for the benefit of the ruling/political class and use political formulae as a mask (TOS violations, "community standards" violations, exhortations to the first amendment, section 230 protections, etc) in the same way governments do.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by disgruntledphd2 on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:29AM (#24894282)
> Recent example from the banning of Bret Weinstein from Facebook: https://twitter.com/Liz_Shepherd/status/1319451084859953154?...

What's most f-ed up about that one is that Liz posts from her personal account. The appropriate thing to do is to post from facebook comms or something.

Overall though, its a continuation of the grand old tradition that appeals to SV tech companies must come from "important" people or trusted sources (like Twitter or here) or they don't matter. It is super disturbing though.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by nl on Monday October 26, 2020 @12:08AM (#24892751)
And Joel Kaplan, head of Facebook Public Policy was one of the people involved in the "Brooks Brother Riot"[1] that shutdown the recount of the 2000 election and took over from Karl Rove in the GW Bush Whitehouse.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks_Brothers_riot

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by flower-giraffe on Monday October 26, 2020 @03:16AM (#24893559)
It’s not limited to DC - Former UK deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg @Facebook VP, Global Affairs
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by hackyhacky on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:14PM (#24891857)
"Power leakage" is inevitable. Everyone has political opinions. Most cops are Republicans. That alone doesn't mean that they're incapable of doing their job competently.

What you're doing amounts to an ad hominem attack: you're criticizing the person delivering the message, rather than the message itself.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by googthrowaway42 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:20PM (#24891889)
I'm not talking about political opinions, I'm talking about highly connected political operatives in positions of power within these companies.

Liz Bourgeois would be an example of such a person.

She was Assistant Press Secretary at the DNC and prior to that was a Legislative Correspondant for Nancy Pelosi and Debbi Wasserman Shultz.

Now she works as "Director, Strategic Response Communications" at Facebook.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by dlp211 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:16PM (#24892239)
This would be a valid criticism if these companies didn't hire top tier operatives from both parties and donate substantial amounts via their PACs to both.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by CamTin on Monday October 26, 2020 @12:01AM (#24892714)
It's not clear why this would be the case. Why should we care which "party" somebody is from when then issue at hand is a revolving door between DC and the Valley? The military-industrial complex has done fine under a two-party system and so presumably will the private-public corporate surveillance state. Everybody in power in the US has to pick one of two letters to put after their name, but they're all part of the same ruling class.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by pushrax on Monday October 26, 2020 @12:44AM (#24892896)
Even if completely neutral with respect to the two parties, the effect of social media as a transport for political information means it has a high involvement in political activity.

Don't pretend those two parties form an ideal set of alternatives; they have many common problems maintained by their duopoly.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by thu2111 on Monday October 26, 2020 @04:43AM (#24893998)
Do they? As far as I know the only example of any identifiably Republican person high up in Silicon Valley is Joel Kaplan, and we know from leaks that Zuckerberg spends a significant amount of his time trying to stop his workforce from lynching the guy.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Fnoord on Monday October 26, 2020 @06:54AM (#24894754)
> As far as I know the only example of any identifiably Republican person high up in Silicon Valley [..]

"Thiel is Silicon Valley's most outspoken Trump supporter" [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Thiel

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Fnoord on Monday October 26, 2020 @11:22AM (#24897127)
Another one just popped up in my mind: Condoleezza Rice @ Dropbox
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by kodah on Monday October 26, 2020 @06:38PM (#24902349)
Would it be possible to compile a list of all of the political operatives (current and former) in tech? Can we make them register in the future?

I didn't know this was happening, but I guess I should have.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by mellosouls on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:32PM (#24892332)
I think that is an optimistic view.

Consider that an overwhelmingly partisan ownership and stewardship of the majority of media, (whether left or right - currently, as the example in the article it's liberal left) has a more insidious power to control the narrative and push counterpoints to the margins until they die naturally, partly because there is in that situation a de facto monopoly.

Government-censored material never actually dies, and has a habit of being leaked (or released on change of government) and causing scandals; Silicon Valley etc-suppressed material has a habit of being sidelined into the anaemic and eccentric irrelevance of the cancelled and the crackpots, and by the time we realise some of them are actually worth listening to, the damage is done.

Especially in the context of a society where "speech is free", and egregious censorship is assumed not to exist, this is arguably even more damaging - the idea that suppression exists is itself dismissed by the mainstream and chattering classes; that isn't necessarily the case in a country under authoritarian, censoring governance.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by acituan on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:52PM (#24892423)
> But let's not pretend that Twitter and Facebook hold information monopolies with equivalent power to the government's ability to censor

Agreed, their narrative shaping capabilities far exceed governments'.

> As proof, consider that we are having this conversation right now,

That is a very poor way of judging it for several reasons; a) we are not currently on Twitter or Facebook, we don't have the same reach nor subject to same corporate normativities b) past performance is not always indicative of things to come.

> You can disagree with Twitter's editorial choices,

Except they claim they are not making editorial choices, and can't be held up to that standard, which a great chunk of the problem.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by RhysU on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:46PM (#24892036)
> But let's not pretend that Twitter and Facebook hold information monopolies with equivalent power to the government's ability to censor.

Those private entities can censor in excess of the government. They are scarier.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by vkou on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:49AM (#24893428)
All that a private entity can do is toss you off their platform.

If every single private website threw you, and your views off the internet tomorrow, you'd return to the age of tyranny and darkness... That ~every human being on earth lived in prior to ~1995. The horror!

In contrast, your government can kill or imprison you, if you say something it doesn't like - but for some strange reason, nerd culture spills gallons of ink on the thesis that private censorship is scarier.

This is a serious case of misplaced priorities.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by RhysU on Monday October 26, 2020 @07:45AM (#24895062)
I do not worry about my particular government unjustly killing or imprisoning me.

The platforms can deny me a voice, can allow lies about me to circulate in my absence, and can cause a mob with pitchforks to metaphorically show up outside my door. Job, career, ability to support my family, place in any community? All gone.

My government owes me constitutional behavior and is answerable for violating it. The platforms owe me nothing and are answerable for nothing.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by thu2111 on Monday October 26, 2020 @04:49AM (#24894027)
Sure, so Chrome and Safari blacklist your websites. You're only back to 1995, the horror.

Then Amazon refuses to sell your books. And VISA refuses to let people buy them, if they find them in an alternative outlet. What's the big deal, you're only rolled back to the 1980s. And then they go a step further and say, if you're assisting in the distribution of these books, we'll cut off your AWS and payment processing services as well. Hey, you're only rolled back to the 1940s. People can still photocopy the sheets they got from a friend manually as long as the companies they rely on don't find out, right?

The problem here is that a small number of large companies are being captured by extreme left-wing political activists who don't recognise disagreement as being legitimate. Trying to figure out how much private sector censorship is OK is a distraction. The problem here is the ever increasing power of Marxists inside large powerful institutions, often smuggling their ideologies in under the guise of 'diversity' or 'inclusion' programs (which are inevitably about conformity and exclusion).

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by vkou on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:34PM (#24901751)
Ah, yes, our means of communication have been captured by the extreme left.

That's why in 2020, when you go on Facebook, you can't even talk about conservative ideas, like Laffer curves, owning guns, reducing entitlements, pooh-poohing (non-police) unions, voting for a republican, the virtues of surprise-billing and of having your health insurance tied to your employer, starting wars against yet another state that most of us can't even place on the map...

But, wait, you can.

If that's how Facebook erases conservative ideas, they are doing a pretty poor job of it.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by disgruntledphd2 on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:33AM (#24894305)
> The problem here is that a small number of large companies are being captured by extreme left-wing political activists who don't recognise disagreement as being legitimate.

While this may be true of the rank and file, the policy people (like Liz upthread or Joel Kaplan) are always political activists/lobbyists because the gig is talking and convincing political organisations of things.

And please note that there's been a bunch of stories about Facebook particularly, intervening on the right-wing side a bunch - how does this support your theory about left-wing activists?

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by stonogo on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:52PM (#24892070)
Get back to me when Twitter has the power to round up everyone who read a given story and have them executed in the street, because that's what government censorship can look like. It's not limited to some partisan nerd toggling a flag in a database somewhere. I think you should probably take this opportunity to re-evaluate the relative powers of these entities.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by onecommentman on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:03PM (#24892147)
I think the discussion is focusing on levels of the US government and what has been experienced by the public under that government since its founding. Actual exercised power by US governmental entities.

The discussion of other governments will probably lead this thread into a swampy delta and it will lose its motive force.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by dnautics on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:06PM (#24892501)
> I think the discussion is focusing on levels of the US government and what has been experienced by the public under that government since its founding

Get back to me when twitter can order an airstrike against an minor and enjoy qualified immunity.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by briantakita on Monday October 26, 2020 @01:57AM (#24893191)
The Chinese Communist Party is being accused of many human rights violations against the Uyghurs, Falun Gong, Christians, factory workers, etc. There are also allegations that the CCP is interfering with the United States government & election process. If these violations are true, then Twitter & the Big Media is complicit in obfuscating evidence of collusion & hidden business partnerships between the Vice President via his family & the CCP.

If these allegations are not true, then the public conversation has been censored & the story of censorship overshadows investigation which would absolve the innocent parties.

Either way, the public deserves to have direct access the truth.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by stonogo on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:41PM (#24892381)
I'm not sure why the artificial limitations on comparison; Twitter and Facebook are wholly active and engaged in markets with governments with such histories. Anyway, if you want such examples, look to the Mexican Dirty War for many, as well as the Banana Massacre. The latter of course was merely a threat to deploy the Marines, but the reasoning announced was not strikebreaking but because the strikers were "subversives"; that is, the US claimed to want them silenced not for what they were doing but for what they were saying.

In the past, I would have said that Posse Comitatus would have prevented such behavior from being directed toward American citizens, but after seeing the mutual-law-skirting nature of the Five Eyes approach, as well as the presence of Federal troops in law enforcement roles in US cities over the past year, I'm no longer confident.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by thu2111 on Monday October 26, 2020 @04:57AM (#24894071)
People are alarmed by these moves because they represent a wider trend in which the left increasingly does not recognise the right as politically legitimate, i.e. they do not believe non-leftists should be allowed to exist. Tech firm activist censorship is merely one visible (or not so visible) aspect of this. But it's not the only aspect.

The very same sorts of people with the very same views are also in government institutions in abundance, as we've seen in recent years with the descent of the various left-wing elites into conspiracy theories about Russia - theories that were then used to try and effectively block implementations of public votes, on the belief that surely the public could not possibly reject their enlightened governance unless they were being manipulated.

This isn't purely a US thing. The UK has the same problems. Recently one of the government's advisors on COVID was complaining (on Twitter!) that the BBC had agreed to unfairly rig a debate she was involved with, but hadn't properly enforced that rigging:

https://twitter.com/SusanMichie/status/1311234012283899904

A lot of the British political class lost their minds over Brexit. You saw incredible things, like politicians running as candidates of the party saying they'd implement the decision, and then switching post-election to the party with saying they'd void the vote and never leave. They had flat out lied to voters about their intentions. That happened quite a few times. There were many other tricks deployed too. They fundamentally didn't believe in the legitimacy of their political opposition and were willing to manipulate the electoral processes to try and "win" despite having lost at the ballot box.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by davvolun on Monday October 26, 2020 @11:22AM (#24897141)
> People are alarmed by these moves because they represent a wider trend in which the left increasingly does not recognise the right as politically legitimate, i.e. they do not believe non-leftists should be allowed to exist.

Those two things aren't remotely the same. The legitimacy of the right in the U.S. is an open question when they participate in direct voter suppression, gerrymandering, continually lose popular votes but still gain controlling power of the strongest apparatus of the government, have used that power to appoint (shortly) 16 of the last 20 SCOTUS Justices going back to 1969 using rules they are quite literally making up on the spot. "Consent of the governed" is a valid question under these scenarios.

But you need to provide some very strong evidence "they [the left] do not believe non-leftists should be allowed to exist." You're using some very strong language based on very weak arguments.

The fact you, presumably, pass off things such as Russian interference in fair and free elections as "conspiracy theories" should, god willing, be absolutely damning to your credibility. Or that "herd immunity strategies," as mentioned in the tweet you link, should be presented as a valid and equal alternative strategy to NOT LETTING PEOPLE DIE; you're arguing flat-earthers should be given equal footing in a debate with NASA.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by CapricornNoble on Monday October 26, 2020 @12:52PM (#24898236)
>>>But you need to provide some very strong evidence "they [the left] do not believe non-leftists should be allowed to exist."

At least one very recent example: https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/oct/12/keith-olber...

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by davvolun on Monday October 26, 2020 @03:23PM (#24900153)
Keith Olbermann, currently hosting on the mainstream news channel of YouTube (/s) after being evicted from actual mainstream news, is the opposite of strong evidence. Further:

> "The hate he has triggered, the Pandora’s box he has opened, they will not be so easily destroyed,” he said. “So, let us brace ourselves. The task is twofold: the terrorist Trump must be defeated, must be destroyed, must be devoured at the ballot box, and then he, and his enablers, and his supporters, and his collaborators, and the Mike Lees and the William Barrs, and the Sean Hannitys, and the Mike Pences, and the Rudy Gullianis and the Kyle Rittenhouses and the Amy Coney Barretts must be prosecuted and convicted and removed from our society while we try to rebuild it and to rebuild the world Trump has nearly destroyed by turning it over to a virus."

The implication "should not be allowed to exist" is very different from "prosecuted and convicted and removed from our society." So even taking a marginalized voice talking from his YouTube channel, arguing that the left believes the right "should not be allowed to exist" is a ridiculous stretch.

You need to read more than just the headlines.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by CapricornNoble on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @12:52PM (#24909252)
His YT channel is small....but he has ~1M Twitter followers. Put in context, that's 2x the followers of TYT's Cenk Uygur, 4x as many as Jimmy Diore, and just a few hundred k short of Steven Crowder. That is not indicative of a "marginalized" voice IMO, and your only defense of his position boils down to "Hey he's not advocating for genocide, just mass incarceration of our political opponents." That strikes me as a tone-deaf position to take on a social media site where hand-wringing over the fate of the Uighurs in China is so en vogue...
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by davvolun on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @05:32PM (#24912175)
Unless you have better evidence than Keith Olbermann to back your statement, I think we're done here. I'm not going to go back and forth about Twitter followers as a valid metric for gauging public opinion on genocide...
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by thu2111 on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @06:39AM (#24906082)
I think you need to re-read your own post.

you need to provide some very strong evidence "they [the left] do not believe non-leftists should be allowed to exist."

You literally start by saying:

The legitimacy of the right in the U.S. is an open question

Perhaps you're using an odd definition of legitimate, but generally for a political movement to be recognised as legitimate means it is allowed to take part in the political process, to be supported by people without suppression and so on. Terrorist groups are not politically legitimate, political parties with voters are. It gets tricky in the unusual cases where political parties and terror groups become closely related, as was seen with Sinn Fein and the IRA.

You yourself are now arguing that maybe the right isn't legitimate because of a bog-standard list of leftist talking points, none of which are obvious or uncontroversial, for example what you call "voter suppression" is more obviously interpreted as enforcing existing laws that define who can vote; calling this "suppression" implies that no such laws do or should exist. But nobody is arguing that, are they?

But you need to provide some very strong evidence "they [the left] do not believe non-leftists should be allowed to exist."

This thread is literally about Twitter shutting down a conservative newspaper that has reported news relevant to an election in which conservatives are competing. The NY Post and the story it reported no longer exists on Twitter. How much clearer a piece of evidence do you want?

And again - hold a mirror up and look at the reflection. Your post ends by saying that I should not be given "equal footing in debate" i.e. that people with those views should be (debate-wise) wiped out, not allowed to exist at all. You are the embodiment of what I'm talking about.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by davvolun on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @10:35AM (#24907817)
"not allowed to exist at all" doesn't mean what you seem to think it does. Nothing you have said bears any more discussion.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by thu2111 on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @08:26AM (#24917897)
It's the other way around.

By "not allowed to exist" I don't mean literally executed in a mass genocide of half the voting population. Using such an interpretation is very bad faith, assuming that's what you're getting at.

I mean not allowed to be visible, to play any part in the public sphere, not allowed to "exist" in the sense of mattering to the structures of power in a country. Being forced to be invisible, forgotten, erased from the written and spoken record. And with that far more rational interpretation you can hopefully see that your views definitely qualify.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by zo1 on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:23AM (#24894247)
> "[...] have them executed in the street, because that's what government censorship can look like."

We're discussing western first-world governments for the most part, and short of some crazy world-altering event or war, they most certainly do not have the actual power to do this.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by pessimizer on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:03PM (#24891789)
This is a forum sponsored by multimillionaires, therefore not responsible to advertisers. Also heavily moderated.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by lki876 on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:28AM (#24894277)
> As proof, consider that we are having this conversation right now, about an article that was published and is freely, legally available online to anyone with a web browser.

As long as you control what a large segment of the population sees, you can orchestrate peoples actions. Censorship has never been absolute or complete and doesn't need to be in order to be effective.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by kodah on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:01PM (#24891774)
You missed the part where this thread was flagged by HackerNews earlier.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by striking on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:14PM (#24891851)
If it was flagged, and then became unflagged, it may have been flagged by the users of HN and then may have been unflagged by mods.

Is it then mods enhancing the freedom of expression by unflagging something, or censoring the community self-moderation? You decide!

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by kodah on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:45PM (#24892033)
Personally I look at it as a barometer for where peoples sentiments fall on a linear path. Who is doing moderation vs censorship has little consequence if you acknowledge that the entire system is distributed and the outcomes are the same.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by raxxorrax on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:03AM (#24894115)
I think the perspective of Schwartz is much better developed instead of just ignoring the negative effects of well visited social media sites removing content on political grounds.

Yes, technically the info is still available.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Synaesthesia on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:53AM (#24893440)
They're unaccountable and significant centers of power (unaccountable to the public), yes maybe not with the power of the government, but approaching it. Is that the kind of rule we want?
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by barumi on Monday October 26, 2020 @03:02AM (#24893493)
> Is that the kind of rule we want?

It's the kind of rule you have since, well, ever.

Does anyone expect to force a private publisher such as the NY Post or even NY Times to publish content against the will of their editorial board just because you see fit?

This issue has absolutely zero to do with censorship. A random publisher not posting something is not censorship. It's literally the editorial board's job to decide which gets published and which is left out. Not posting false or deceitful information forced upon by third parties is also not censorship. Just because you have a personal view that is not aligned with an editorial board's mission statement that doesn't mean the editorial board is engaged in censorship.

This topic seems to boil down to some people wanting the benefits of abusing a publisher's reputation and readership to force-feed their own personal opinion on the public. Not being able to perform that kind of abuse is not censorship.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by etripe on Monday October 26, 2020 @07:53AM (#24895114)
They can either be editorialising, in which case they're a publication, or they can be censoring as a platform. They're not currently regulated like a publication, so they must be censoring, then.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by roenxi on Monday October 26, 2020 @03:39AM (#24893673)
Yes, it is better for power to reside with people who are easily replaced and/or ignored if necessary. I'd rather have Twitter go off the rails than my local council.

However, it is still a scandal and worth bringing everyobody's attention to. I don't think we've ever seen such naked politicking by a tech company in the West. This is a concerning new low for Silicon Valley.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by chroem- on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:53PM (#24891706)
It gets better (worse?) though: reddit has removed any references to Aaron Swartz from its list of founders.

https://www.redditinc.com/

> Reddit was founded in 2005 by two college friends.

> Steve Huffman, Co-Founder/CEO

> Alexis Ohanian, Co-Founder

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by sparky_z on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:59PM (#24891745)
Isn't that technically true, though? I thought Swartz joined them later, months after they had already launched the site.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by nl on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:29PM (#24892313)
Yes, this is true. Aaron always seemed to regard it as a sore point, but he was never listed as a Reddit founder.

I'm aware that PG has called him a founder, but seemingly the Reddit guys never thought of him as one.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by whamlastxmas on Monday October 26, 2020 @01:55PM (#24898991)
Aaron's contract with the reddit founders explicitly gave him a "founder" title. To say he was never "listed" as a founder is misleading - listed where? He definitely was entitled to call himself as much and in most startup contexts it would be hard to claim he wasn't.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by SquareWheel on Monday October 26, 2020 @04:44AM (#24894004)
The quoted section is accurate. Swartz received the title of co-founder as part of a merger, but he never actually co-founded reddit.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by mjfl on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:59PM (#24891749)
why?
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by PaulAJ on Monday October 26, 2020 @03:44AM (#24893700)
Thus it always was. Back in the day in America there were a few big newspapers (basically, USA Today plus a couple of local city or state papers) and three TV channels. They all broadly agreed on what was important and how to present it. That was "the news", and it shaped how people saw the world.

If you were so inclined you could find some alternative points of view in the right newsagents, but mainstream mass-media generally represented a single perspective, and that was the filter through which most people saw the world.

People back then complained that the "Republocrats" were a cosy duopoly. There was no culture war because a large majority of Americans were part of a single culture. (As long as you were white, of course. If you were anything else then nobody cared what you thought).

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by yenwodyah on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:55PM (#24891726)
And at the same time, private companies cannot force you to use their services, or threaten you with violence or imprisonment if you refuse to follow their rules.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by beagle3 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:30PM (#24891942)
This is getting blurry as well, and though you are technically correct, one might have to sue or suffer damages for not following their rules:

My children’s schools requires the use of Microsoft Teams From home (and associated TOS) for them to attend class. There is also a parent WhatsApp group for urgent messages to parents. And as of the pandemic, there is also mandatory Zoom classes.

This is a public school. If I sue I could possibly avoid these - I am not even sure of that. But either way, I and my children will suffer if I don’t comply.

Microsoft. Facebook. Zoom. Coerced de facto to follow their rules; they might cancel my accounts if I don’t behave accordingly - Facebook and Google have certainly done so before.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by unishark on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:51AM (#24893432)
The millions of people locked up in prison would see it as more than a technicality. Personally I'm much more nervous about screwing up some details in following the govt's rules versus a private company.

Getting banned by Google/Facebook and losing all your data in the cloud is just the modern equivalent of losing everything when your hard drive dies. The way to mitigate this danger is the same.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by mschuster91 on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:35AM (#24894317)
> Getting banned by Google/Facebook and losing all your data in the cloud is just the modern equivalent of losing everything when your hard drive dies. The way to mitigate this danger is the same.

No it's not. A HDD failing or getting lost? That can be guarded against with backups.

With getting banned by Google or Facebook? When all your accounts, your identity is tied to that address/account and you get banned, you cannot be reached anymore by people who don't know that you got screwed over.

The obvious solution would be to self-host an email server, but unfortunately that's impossible as it will be mercilessly assaulted by spammers and hackers on the inbound side and you'll be having issues with deliverability on the outbound side.

The real solution would be for legislative and regulatory action that recognizes the importance of identity and forces all email providers to adhere to due process. But unfortunately, worldwide legislators are too old / too incompetent or in the pockets of other people who don't care...

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by unishark on Monday October 26, 2020 @08:15AM (#24895273)
> No it's not. A HDD failing or getting lost? That can be guarded against with backups.

Exactly. Back up your cloud data.

> With getting banned by Google or Facebook? When all your accounts, your identity is tied to that address/account and you get banned, you cannot be reached anymore by people who don't know that you got screwed over.

I thought the fact that I consider this perspective to be absurd was kind of obviously built in to my statement.

You can use a new email to contact people. Especially when you have your backups.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by beagle3 on Monday October 26, 2020 @10:11AM (#24896325)
Google effectively killfiled a domain I run. It took me a few months to figure out, but about 95% of emails sent to @gmail.com or g-suite hosted addresses from that domain (which were, overall ~20% of emails sent), got into a spam folder.

No recourse, no one to talk to; my solution was to switch from a small but reputable ISP I had used for 17 years (and which never had a single spam complaint or blacklist entry in any list I can read) to fastmail for that domain; because Google decided they didn't like something about that setup; already spent a couple of work days no one was paying for to troubleshoot and eventually gave up.

Google+Microsoft+FastMail likely cover 95% of your recipients. If they don't like you, you're going to have a very hard time reaching people.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by mschuster91 on Monday October 26, 2020 @01:02PM (#24898363)
> I thought the fact that I consider this perspective to be absurd was kind of obviously built in to my statement.

It is not absurd, it is reality. With emails you at least can manually walk through the hundreds of sites you have stored in your password manager, hope that the password still works and you did not encounter a site that got hacked and reset all the passwords, and change the email address... but with "sign in with Facebook/Apple ID/..." you are at the mercy of the target site having a fallback login mechanism. (Hint: many don't or it's buggy because never tested)

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by unishark on Monday October 26, 2020 @09:46PM (#24903734)
Ultimately this is just more information in the cloud which you failed to back up.

I end up having to reset forgotten passwords a lot (maybe dozens of times per year) and don't think I've ever encountered a reset situation like you describe. If it's important I can always call them to resolve an account problem. If it's unimportant I can make a new account.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by beagle3 on Monday October 26, 2020 @11:20PM (#24904206)
If it’s an account that’s not tied to anything important, sure; But if it’s tied to a bank account, credit card, utility bill etc, it’s often not as easy to “just make a new account”. You’ll likely need to fax a copy of your id to a fraud department who’ll take their time.

A friend of mine has been unable to convince a credit agency to reset their password as they are out of the country and cannot fulfill the requested authentication task. Wouldn’t be a problem in normal times, as they are back and forth every other month. Except it’s been 7 months since corona disrupted that. They can’t just “sign up for a new account” as it tied to their identity.

I’ve never had this problem myself either. But it’s a real problem.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by unishark on Monday October 26, 2020 @11:38PM (#24904289)
Fair enough, extend the "call them" category to also mean signatures occasionally required by mail. I have had to do that, say with certain rarely-used financial situations. Though not banks, who are very accommodating in my experience (even the notoriously evil ones).

First class mail is working internationally, by the way, to almost every country. Unless they're in Yemen or something perhaps. Keep in mind we were comparing the dangers of corporations to governments. So being in a developing country during a pandemic when there's a communications breakdown with the US also presumably means you can't access a US consulate either. So you'd have the exact same difficulty if it was a govt agency you needed to deal with instead of Google/Facebook/Microsoft.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by beagle3 on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @06:17AM (#24905972)
Said credit agency has sent a physical notice (by first class mail) to the address they have listed, except it is out of date. It's an authentication catch-22, which is easily solvable for anyone inside the country (and would have been easily solvable for that person in their normal course of life without corona). Not yet kafka level, but the it does bring his name to mind.

And, yes, a government agency would cause the same issues. The thing is, government is (supposedly) accountable to the people, but GoogFaceSoft is accountable to their shareholders. The incentives do not align -- but many of the powers (and abuses of power) do.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by dnautics on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:07PM (#24892511)
It's still fundamentally government that made that choice to force you into one service.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by beagle3 on Monday October 26, 2020 @10:12AM (#24896336)
So? Whoever runs that service gets to set and enforce their ToS and you don't get to appeal. So they enjoy many government rights with non of the checks and balances. (They don't get to employ physical violence yet, true).
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by jjk166 on Monday October 26, 2020 @09:59AM (#24896203)
That's the government coercing you, not microsoft. I'm sure microsoft doesn't mind a captive market, but if the government decides to use slack or whatever instead, you're going to switch over to slack regardless of any protest from microsoft.

The companies which seem to benefit the most from the government's power are the ones which would suffer the most from losing the government's current favor. They must bend over backwards to stay in the government's good graces, not the other way around.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by beagle3 on Monday October 26, 2020 @10:06AM (#24896282)
However, if microsoft dislikes me for something I did, they can kick me out; Google has done so with respect to Android APK related stuff, for example.

I'm sure courts can properly resolve this, after a few months, if it did happen ....

It's the government coercing me to comply with Microsoft's TOS that's the problem.

> They must bend over backwards to stay in the government's good graces, not the other way around.

Of course, but they pay for the government's good graces by e.g. giving them free access to all hosted data -- not by making sure the users are well taken care of..

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by jjk166 on Monday October 26, 2020 @11:37AM (#24897325)
If a restaurant owner doesn't like me taking my shoes off, they can kick me out. There is a clear business interest in maintaining an atmosphere where people want to eat, and my bare feet would make plenty of people lose their appetites.

If the government points their guns at me and says eat at that restaurant or else, the restaurant owner has done nothing wrong. It is the government forcing me to wear shoes, not him. Even if he lobbied for a law that made dining at his restaurant mandatory, the government still decided on its own to go along with it - the restaurant owner had no power to make them do it. Forcing the restaurant to allow me to take my shoes off will only make the dining experience of everyone else forced to eat there more unpleasant.

It is dumb that the local school chose a setup that relies completely on Microsoft. You and everyone else negatively affected should be sure to show your dissatisfaction with the school board on election day. But there's nothing wrong with Microsoft having the ability to kick you off if it doesn't like you.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by beagle3 on Monday October 26, 2020 @09:33PM (#24903652)
Perfect analogy.

Unfortunately, said restaurant owner can (and has) kicked people of for sharing recipes that owner thinks it owns (but doesn’t have to prove)

The problem was never with the shoes off crowd.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Anon4Now on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:43PM (#24892012)
You have now been suspended from your Oculus for wrongthink.

My point is, it's not overt like government suppression, but pressure can be applied nonetheless.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Spooky23 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:28PM (#24891929)
I guess. It’s pretty obvious who the Post answers to.

Companies ultimately have shareholders and customers they are accountable to. Even fairly awful companies like Facebook have to meet some minimal standard of conduct to keep advertisers on the platform.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by 0x262d on Monday October 26, 2020 @12:16AM (#24892784)
unfortunately what those shareholders want is the highest possible overall profit extraction from the areas they operate at any cost, which is anti-social and bad.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by dnautics on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:04PM (#24892489)
I have a lot of respect for Aaron swartz, but:

> They have no constitution to answer to.

Do we seriously believe any government follows it's constitution? What is the mechanism for redress should it fail to do so?

> They’re not elected.

Neither are most operators in the government. And even for those operators that are elected, the role of government has expanded to the point where any given elected official has authority over so many concerns that the one you care about is going to be diluted to the point where you may not even want to vote for the thing you care about the most.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by skinkestek on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:33PM (#24892605)
> Do we seriously believe any government follows it's constitution?

Absolutely. Many do. Look at America and their second amendment: there's no way that would fly today if it wasn't in the constitution. Luckily it is and power hungry politicians have to accept it.

Same with the first amendment. Some of these are even are powerful today than before and I hope the fourth amendment will soon see a renaissance.

> What is the mechanism for redress should it fail to do so?

Courts.

Also it affects politicians directly. There was a petition here to give a mountain on the Finnish border to the Finnish people. Many people advocated for this but in the end it was struck down because politicians aren't even allowed to give away land and they know it.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Consultant32452 on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:21AM (#24893287)
>Look at America and their second amendment

In America the right to an abortion is more respected under our legal system than the right to a gun despite what is written in the Constitution.

The law is downstream of culture, and that document only says what 5 Justices say it says.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by skinkestek on Monday October 26, 2020 @03:42AM (#24893689)
I don't disagree with the first part. I think you are right but don't talk more about it: it brings up the ugliest discussions at this place.

For the second part they seem to be lucky to get a good judge now that will not let her own ideas interfere much with her job and instead interpret the constitution as it was written.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by zimpenfish on Monday October 26, 2020 @04:16AM (#24893858)
> interpret the constitution as it was written

Does this mean she'll be ruling that owning people is ok, removing the vote from women, and striking down the 2nd Amendment?

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Clubber on Monday October 26, 2020 @04:41AM (#24893981)
The 13th, 19th and 2nd amendments exist in the constitution, as written:

13th: Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.

19th: The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex.

Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

2nd: A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

Any political and / or legal discussion should start with at least a vague understanding of that document. All our laws and institutions are founded with it.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by zimpenfish on Monday October 26, 2020 @12:14PM (#24897752)
> "interpret the constitution as it was written" > amendments

"was written" would not include "amendments".

Perhaps it was meant to be "is written" and that would definitely include the amendments but then you absolutely do not get to call yourself an "Originalist" because, e.g., the 19th was passed 130 years after the Constitution was written and for damn sure none of the framers were still alive then.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Clubber on Monday October 26, 2020 @04:41PM (#24901124)
Different parts of the constitution were written at different times. Amendments are part of the constitution regardless of when they were written.

Originalists interpret the applicable parts of the constitution as they were written, when they were written.

Search Scalia on the topic and watch some videos. He goes into pretty interesting depth on the subject. It's pretty fascinating.

https://www.c-span.org/video/?292678-1/justices-breyer-scali...

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by skinkestek on Monday October 26, 2020 @03:52PM (#24900537)
Clearly I meant the whole constitution, including every accepted amendment; I suppose they become part of the constitution as soon as they are accepted?

Anyway I think this should be obvious. The subset of people who has long time accounts on HN and who also are for slavery is really small, possibly non-existent.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Consultant32452 on Monday October 26, 2020 @04:39AM (#24893973)
The constitution as it was written allows for amendments. The 13th and 19th Amendments outlawed slavery and gave women the right to vote, respectively.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by zimpenfish on Monday October 26, 2020 @12:16PM (#24897772)
But those amendments didn't exist when it "was written" - if you're an Originalist claiming to interpret the Constitution "as it was written", that excludes amendments. If you change it to "as it is written", sure, that includes them but you lose the claim to be an Originalist given the timestamps on everything after the 12th Amendment since that's 76 years later and I'm reasonably sure none of the framers were alive then.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by Consultant32452 on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:07PM (#24899142)
The 19th Amendment was ratified in 1920. It was written then. The fact that other parts were ratified at different times doesn't stop you from interpreting each part "as it was written." But you know that.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by folleno00 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:31PM (#24892597)
It says answer to, not follows

If the people demand they answer to it, it’s that or off with their heads, usually.

The hard part is getting people to demand they answer.

Lots of cool gadgets and the belief we’re making each other better to dispose of.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by krapp on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:46PM (#24891654)
I mean, I can switch social media platforms a lot more easily than I can switch governments, and corporations don't have a monopoly on violence which would allow their tyranny to lead to torture, gulags and mass graves, but OK.

I guess being banned from a forum is much much worse than being sent to the re-education camps.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by zo1 on Monday October 26, 2020 @08:32AM (#24895419)
The methods have changed, the motivation and net result is the same: opinion and thought control.

Tech has made it impersonal, clinical, obfuscated, random and ubiquitous. There is no need to "send people to gulags" or torture them in order to suppress their ability to sow dissent amongst their peers. That is the sole purpose, even if it's algorithmic and emergent without a central "dictator" controlling what can or can't be said. Essentially only approved opinions and movements are allowed to gather steam, no different to the movement of dissent and mistrust of the government that had to be stemmed previously using gulags.

So yes, you are 100% right it's not the same and we are not being sent to re-education camps. But that doesn't mean certain individuals are not being persecuted through "random" algorithms that target and marginalize them. As another poster here mentioned, censorship does not need to be absolute for it to have an effect. You also mentioned network effects earlier: I would urge you to consider what "network effects" are occurring due to mild and moderate censorship that is not absolute.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by krapp on Monday October 26, 2020 @09:03PM (#24903476)
I don't see social media suppressing dissent at all. I see dissent everywhere - from anti-vaxxers, flat earthers, anti-maskers, BLM, Antifa, neo-nazis and militias. Ideologies and conspiracy theories once confined to AM talk radio and underground forums have become mainstream politics. Pedophiles have rebranded themselves "minor attracted persons" and are campaigning on social media for pedo rights as human rights. QAnon is mainstream enough to win elections. Even conservatives who are, we are told, terrified to speak openly in what they describe as an oppressive Orwellian atmosphere of left-wing censorship, somehow manage to flood social media with right-wing speech.

If the sole purpose of tech and social media is opinion and thought control and dissident suppression, it doesn't seem to be working outside of the obvious authoritarian places like China.

> I would urge you to consider what "network effects" are occurring due to mild and moderate censorship that is not absolute.

Subtle network effects and mild censorship exist everywhere - we typically refer to these networks as "society", "culture", "religion", "family,", "employer," etc. Certainly social networks can modify behavior, but typically it's easier to undermine that effect on social networks (through alternate accounts) than it is in real life, and typically the negative consequences for breaking norms on social media are less severe than in real life.

Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by akhosravian on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:54PM (#24891717)
You could switch off Facebook, Twitter, YouTube or Twitch, but for all but the most influential of people the folks you interact with won’t follow.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by krapp on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:58PM (#24891741)
That's still not tyranny, that's just the network effect. They have a choice about what platform to use as do you and I.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by bitwize on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:20AM (#24894231)
Except that, you know, private corporations usually can't legally jail you or shoot you in the head for expressing the wrong opinions or propagating the wrong info.
Re:Suppression is a bigger scandal than the actual story by dd36 on Monday October 26, 2020 @01:22AM (#24893050)
And now we have forced arbitration with class action bans.