News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by elric on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:16AM (#24886033)
I don't drive. I walk everywhere (combined with public transport for longer distances). I don't think it's a super power as such, but it does keep me relatively fit with little intentional effort. Going from A to B just includes an incidental light workout. Gives me time to think, to unwind, sometimes to read. Can recommend it to pretty much everyone. Some things might take a little longer, but if you have to dick around on HN or watch Netflix, you have time to walk to places.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by amelius on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:21AM (#24886059)
Same here. The only downside is people openly pitying you when you tell them you have to walk to X now. This still makes me feel a loser sometimes for not owning a car. It's stupid, I know.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by ck425 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:56AM (#24886286)
I always interpreted that as them being selfish or idiotic. When I see people drive somewhere that's less than 2 miles away it blows my mind.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by avalys on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:36AM (#24887046)
It takes 30-40 minutes to walk 2 miles. If I have to go to the grocery store to pick up ingredients for dinner, do you really think I should spend an extra 60 minutes walking there and back vs. driving?
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by ChuckMcM on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:46AM (#24887139)
Would it be weird for you if I told you yes? My guess is that if you spent those 60 minutes a day walking back and forth to the grocery you would see tremendous benefit in your life in many areas.

If you have a headset for your phone. Call someone. You're interpersonal relationships get stronger.

If you're working through a issues, spend the time thinking about different alternative approaches.

If you're learning a new subject, review in your head what you've been learning.

If you're preparing a talk, dictate different ways of presenting it to a voice recorder.

If you're stressed out about the world, spend the walk finding things you are grateful for.

If you're in a relationship, compose a poem or two for your partner.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by avalys on Sunday October 25, 2020 @04:46PM (#24889750)
Sure, but does it “blow your mind” that I might choose not to do any of those things and prefer to just get to the grocery store as fast as possible so I can spend my free time on other things?
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by ChuckMcM on Sunday October 25, 2020 @05:12PM (#24889913)
Not at all! Every minute of every day we all choose what we're going to do with that minute and perhaps many of the minutes that follow.

When I make those choices I balance off what I want to do against what I need to do and what I should do and what I could do. That is the essential choice of being an adult.

My experience with walking, before I started walking, regularly, which was forced on me by a requirement to get more physical exercise as part of a weight management program, was that I felt very strongly that I had much better uses for my time than getting slowly from point A to point B. That attitude was supported by my ignorance with regard to what else I could do while walking and so stack time usage.

What I learned by being forced to walk at least 30 minutes a day (its now up to 2.5hrs a day) was that there were things I did while sitting around. Those things included calling people, having meetings, and thinking about solutions to problems or the days events. What I experienced was, that I was no less productive during the day where I spent time walking, and there were tertiary effects that were completely unexpected.

For example, I have always been plagued with the issue that as soon as I lay my head on the pillow to go to sleep, my brain starts kicking up all the things I didn't have time to think about during the day. As a result, getting to sleep could take an hour to an hour and a half. Just laying there, in bed, trying to stop my brain long enough to go to sleep.

Walking massively mitigated that problem. I found, after I had been walking, that I had spent some, if not all, of that time thinking through things that had been pushed aside by the immediacy of email or social media or "honey do" projects. Not only had I thought about them on my walk, I started recording on my phone notes to myself of actions to take to move forward on things I was stuck on. This meant that when it was time to sleep, not only was it much easier to go to sleep, I already had a good idea of the things I needed to get to the next day or in the near future.

That blew my mind. That I had traded laying immobile in my bed for some moderate exercise that effectively took no additional time out of my day and has lead to better sleep and better fitness. It also blew my mind how much more effective 1:1 meetings with direct reports were while walking than they were sitting in an office.

I was pretty ignorant about both the time saving aspects of walking and the effect it would have on my mental acuity and well being. If someone reading this decides to try it out for themselves, it is my hope they will see the positive benefits I have experienced. I wouldn't go back to a non-walking lifestyle now, I have come to rely on those benefits.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by riffraff on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:21PM (#24887397)
or my favourite: listen to audiobooks![0]

I've been taking a 1-2 hours walk in the morning for a few years, which I usually use to get groceries, and miss it dearly when I can't.

[0] Or music, but I admit I don't listen to much of that.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by vram22 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @01:09PM (#24887853)
Agreed. It's also good because of this: :)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24860432

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by smabie on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:47PM (#24887636)
Sounds like you don't understand why people make different choices than you.

To be clear, I love walking, but to say that people are stupid for acting different than you is monumentally narcissistic.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by rfrey on Sunday October 25, 2020 @01:12PM (#24887882)
Where does this come from? Your parent was asked if he thought one should walk an extra 60 minutes to get groceries, he replied yes and gave a lot of reasons why. Completely respectful and polite.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by raffraffraff on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:03PM (#24887275)
I'm in my 40s and have never (and will never) own a car. So I chose to live within reasonable walking distance of places I need to go. I walk everywhere, and carry groceries in a backpack. I do these things without even thinking about it. I'm the same weight I was when I was 19. I wear the same size clothes. I don't bother with gym membership. The way I see it, it's just a different way to live. Kinda like when people say "I'm not gonna have kids because that's not what my life is gonna be about".

Now, this is only possible in a city that was built (at least) hundreds of years before cars. Having visited the US I can honestly say that some cities (not the ones like New York) are designed completely around the car. Trying to walk everywhere in a city like that is futile and you'll just hate life and everyone around you.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by balfirevic on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:21PM (#24887395)
> The way I see it, it's just a different way to live.

The comment you responded to was prompted by this: "When I see people drive somewhere that's less than 2 miles away it blows my mind."

> So I chose to live within reasonable walking distance of places I need to go.

I'm glad that works for you, but - depending on your life interests - it's pretty literally impossible for many people.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by ALittleLight on Monday October 26, 2020 @03:23AM (#24893597)
It may be implausible for most people, but there are probably some people for whom it is an option they haven't considered. I personally rent a car if I need to go out of the city, and walk or (rarely) bus at all other times. Very convenient for me.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by ck425 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:44AM (#24887124)
I'm admittedly biased as I'm tall and have walked everywhere all my life. 2 miles only takes me 25 min.

In that case the whole journey is really 4 miles. I was thinking in terms of a continuous or largely continuous journey (such as walking to the shops and back) being 2 miles.

That said longer journeys can be treated as exercise. Why go to gym for an hour each day when instead you can spend that hour going to places you're going to go anyway.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by WanderPanda on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:31PM (#24887489)
Working out at the gym and walking to the grocery store are very different exercises considering heart rates involved etc. Also in many cases the air will not be very good on the way to the grocery store vs. when you go for a run on a track that you specially chose for running.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by foldr on Sunday October 25, 2020 @02:02PM (#24888378)
That's true if you take the gym seriously. A lot of people would probably get more health benefits from putting that energy into walking more and doing some simple isometrics from time to time. Most people are just spending way too much time sitting on their butts, and a few sessions at the gym isn't really counteracting many of the effects of that.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by balfirevic on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:39PM (#24887559)
Also, you can do actual strength training in the gym.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by achempion on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:54AM (#24887209)
I think it depends. 60 min fast evening walk with your spouse could count as a light workout. I wouldn't count as a wasted time because you're walking, having fresh air and working out at the same time.

If you take a car ride, that time may be considered as wasted.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by einpoklum on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:52PM (#24887681)
1. This is a false dichotomy. Take the bus, or better still - take a bike, if you're in a hurry.

2. It might be better to not always be in a hurry.

3. Try to live in a place that's not so alienated as to have a grocery store that's 2 miles away (unless you're in a rural / countryside area in which case you're probably doing a lot of walking anyways).

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by andrewjl on Sunday October 25, 2020 @02:50PM (#24888804)
I used to do just that some years back. Worked up a great appetite for dinner. And it was a great way to build in exercise into my day.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by mzzter on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:43AM (#24887121)
Depending on one’s pace of life, 60 minutes is not very long, and also gives enough time to enjoy the travel to the store.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by tonyedgecombe on Sunday October 25, 2020 @01:02PM (#24887779)
Mostly I would say you need to be a bit more organised with your shopping.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by rottc0dd on Monday October 26, 2020 @12:26PM (#24897887)
Disclaimer : Kind of tangent-but-not-so-tangent.

I do not use smartphones. I do not remember the exact rationale of how it started. But, it generates a lot of free time for your life. Whenever people question it, I would reply, "Well, it is an experiment I am doing".

Based on how close the other one is you might get a confused nod to how-stupid-are-you as a reply.

The good thing about it is, by default, you do not get to fool around in your free time. The time is only free, if there is do not have other ways to pass it by.

P.S.: But, I am not claiming it is better. But, I find it convenient and quite a bit fun.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by rottc0dd on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @01:37AM (#24904730)
Edit : If there are not other ways to pass it by.

Too late to edit now

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by Impossible on Sunday October 25, 2020 @04:36PM (#24889675)
I love walking and hate driving (even though I've been a car owner for 13 years) and still get this when I choose not to drive. My car was in the shop a year ago and I wasn't working so I walked or took public transit to take my son to daycare (about 1 mile from my home). I had multiple parents offer to give me a ride in a slightly pittying way
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by WorldMaker on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:06PM (#24899132)
I'm similarly a car owner that loves walking and hates driving. I've managed at least a few times to turn that pity on its head, "Seriously? It's like three blocks tops. So much better to just walk it." There's certainly pleasure any time walking directly to a destination is faster than the people taking the time to walk back to their cars, drive them through traffic, and find a parking spot at the destination.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by WhompingWindows on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:36AM (#24886145)
Can you reframe their "pity" as an expression of sympathy? Or is it the way you're telling them "OH, well I HAVE to walk now." Instead, say "Well, I get to walk now, see ya!", show them you're happy with the decision.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by amelius on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:49AM (#24886234)
It could be a combination of both. Usually it starts like: "I have to leave a bit earlier because I have to walk". From then there is pitying/sympathy.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by lisper on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:55PM (#24887714)
I'm a big fan of walking but there is one more downside for me: in warm weather, I often arrive at my destination a sweaty mess.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by solstice on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:19AM (#24893279)
Make a water-cooled undershirt like those for astronauts and get one of those fan attachments for baseball caps. (Slightly wacky suggestion but this is hacker news after all.)
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by lisper on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:34AM (#24893351)
That's a crazy idea. Have an upvote :-)
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by WorldMaker on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:15PM (#24899226)
Another silly option is wear multiple layered suits like it is the early 20th Century again. While all the layers will contribute to overheating and the sweating problem, a part of the reason for the layers in the first place (especially in the early 20th Century before modern air conditioning) was to keep sweat to less visible layers. Make sure you stay hydrated, of course. Maybe go Steampunk with it and have fun picking a weird style all your own.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by lisper on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:29PM (#24899411)
Yep, that's a pretty silly option. It's not the cosmetics of the situation that concern me, it's the physical discomfort.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by tjmaglio on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:27AM (#24886535)
Would you pity someone who was manipulating data by hand or an accountant calculating taxes all by hand without software or at least a calculator to help them? What about someone manually trying to translate some text instead of using a translation service?

The other side of some manual work is that it exercises you in some way- but if there are things that'll speed up whatever it is you want to do and they are generally available, you will be pitied!

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by xnyan on Sunday October 25, 2020 @02:56PM (#24888859)
In the US I pity people who walk (outside of NY, sanfran and a few other places) because it's dangerous and slow by design.

I love to walk. I hate owning a car. In most of the US, there is no good way to get to most places other than by car. Really wish it was otherwise.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by shantara on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:28AM (#24886100)
Same here. Living in a walkable European city helps a lot.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by hibikir on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:30AM (#24886999)
Walking everywhere is not really much of an individual decision though: It's a collective, city-wide decision, as the city's infrastructure and geography decides whether walking or driving are really alternatives.

I was raised in a small city in Spain, population of 180k or so. I walked everywhere, and I still do when I visit: The city has great population density, with an average height of about 6 stories, plenty of pedestrian-only streets, and almost no surface parking. The situation is such that driving would be slower than walking to get most things done, as time to and from the car will often be quite the nuisance.

Later I moved to Madrid. It's a very large city by European standards: Too big to just walk everywhere. However, it's also very dense, and it's also not all that well set up for driving in many routes. Driving might be useful at times, but the subway might be faster, and it's hard to find places that are more than 10 minutes away from a subway station. It's not quite as hostile as my hometown, but you at least might have to make choices.

Now, however, I am living in a mid-sized metro in the US midwest: far smaller than Madrid in population, but easily 4x the total size. The vast majority of the metro area is single family homes in half acre lots. Even downtown is full of surface parking lots, so even living there you'll mostly be walking past asphalt. One person could possibly move to be in walking distance of their job, but good luck doing that with two people. Public transportation is sparse, and, at the best of times, has buses every half an hour, so your typical trip penalty vs a car might be an hour each way. And on top, temperatures will hit 40C in the summer, and -20C in the winter: Not exactly good walking weather either way. Here, walking is not a mode of transportation, but a completely intentional hobby which, in some cases, might take you past a store or a restaurant, weather permitting.

So really, while I am a huge fan of walking, it's not something anyone in my metro area will willingly choose as their primary mode of transportation, and it's the same all over the US: Few of our cities are built for anything but cars, and it's a decisions that is really hard to undo without ripping apart most of the city's construction. Imagine one of our largest buildings: The headquarters of a company you probably know. well over 15 floors, but completely surrounded by surface level parking. Many thousands of spots, one for each worker. you have to walk over half a kilometer before you find any other building: otherwise it's just cars.

So no, around here, I couldn't recommend walking to pretty much anyone, and that's because the decision is made for us. It's the city's urban planning department, over many decades, that decides whether people walk or not.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by elric on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:55PM (#24887716)
> So no, around here, I couldn't recommend walking to pretty much anyone

I don't know about that. Things don't change overnight, and never by themselves. Advocating for a more walkable city is probably a good idea. Might require political action of some sort. Or maybe it just needs a critical mass of frequent walkers.

For the record, I live in a walkable city now, and grew up in a tiny, walkable villagle. Wouldn't even consider moving somewhere that wasn't walkable.

Addendum: a city that isn't designed for people probably shouldn't be considered a city. I'm trying to think of a better name, but I'm stuck on expletives.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by xnyan on Sunday October 25, 2020 @03:09PM (#24888980)
>I don't know about that. ...Might require political action of some sort.

Wow, ok. I live in the raleigh-durham metro area. What is timeline for significant non-car travel for us of literally any kind outside of 40 years and hundreds of billions of dollars? If your answer is "there is none", everyone here already knows that. We are chained to cars with no way out.

>Wouldn't even consider moving somewhere that wasn't walkable.

Not joking: I am really proud of your opinion. Never change. There's not even close to enough of you to intact real transportation change in the US. I wish I was wrong about that, but it's not been my lived experience living in the US.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by afjl on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:20PM (#24891890)
Yeah...my brother lives in Nashville, and they handily voted down a public transit bill recently that would have extended bus services.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by 542354234235 on Monday October 26, 2020 @10:49AM (#24896739)
While that is a pain, I get it. Extending bus services is a band aid on a systemic problem. People don’t want to take the bus unless they have to because buses take forever compared to cars. Buses take forever because they have to stop so often. They have to stop so often because 99% of the US is totally spread out with very low density. And that is the fundamental problem. You can’t just tweak the buses or trains or walk more in a city that has built $100 billion of infrastructure around driving cars. Walkability and public transit just aren’t viable alternatives in a country built around the suburb and the highway.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by WorldMaker on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:31PM (#24899423)
Buses also suffer from the problem that when road traffic is high and public transportation might be a great alternative to gridlock and sitting in traffic, the buses themselves suffer from the same traffic issues. Most people seem to prefer to sit in traffic in a car they control than public buses.

Buses are an incredibly bad public transportation option because they sit so well in a local maxima trap because they look like a viable public transportation and "share" the road infrastructure costs of cars leaving them "cheap investments", so much that cities don't think they need to invest in anything more expensive. But they also share all the detriments of investment in car infrastructure, and thus through self-fulfilling-prophecy expectedly never grow the ridership to encourage cities to push for more investment in public transportation over car transportation.

From that perspective bus services aren't even a band aid on the systemic problem, but a symptom/perpetuator of the systemic problem.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by ck425 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:48AM (#24887159)
Yeah that's a fair point. For me walkability is a key factor in choosing where to live. Thankfully in the UK it's pretty easy to live in walkable places.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by Wowfunhappy on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:53AM (#24886267)
> Gives me time to think, to unwind, _sometimes to read_.

Uh, sorry, what do you mean by "read"? You're not one of those people who reads books while walking down the sidewalk, are you?

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by jaden on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:23AM (#24886499)
I assumed the reading was while on public transportation.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by balfirevic on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:32AM (#24886569)
I don't care if someone reads while walking, but I wonder if you would have been as downvoted if you instead complained about people staring at their phones while walking.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by Wowfunhappy on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:10AM (#24886851)
I should have phrased the comment better, it probably came across as passive aggressive, which wasn't intended. My brain is not working this morning.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by mdre on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:03AM (#24886335)
I used to be one of those and loved it. So?
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by Wowfunhappy on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:07AM (#24886366)
Well, at least in NYC, I tend to narrowly avoid crashing into them on the sidewalk.

Perhaps it doesn't apply to you, but I don't think 90% of people who read books while walking are as good at navigating around obstacles as they think they are.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by noir_lord on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:04AM (#24886341)
Used to do that too and from school after a while you learn to walk around obstacles without breaking your flow.

Got me an extra 40m reading time over the day.

Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by dorchadas on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:43AM (#24887114)
I do this regularly when I walk around our neighborhood or to a nearby park. I usually make sure to hold the book up to help my posture, and look around frequently. Haven't ran into anyone yet, and often saw them before they looked up from their phone and saw me (most people, I've learned, don't walk on the proper side of the road). Allows me to get a lot more reading in, really, and helps me focus and digest what I'm reading a bit more when I want to.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by elric on Sunday October 25, 2020 @12:53PM (#24887687)
Sure. But please don't project your notion of "sidewalk" onto the rest of the world. You can't do this everywhere, for obvious reasons, but it's perfectly fine in most places. Takes a little bit of practice but it's lovely during a daily commute on a familiar route.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by yoz-y on Sunday October 25, 2020 @10:01AM (#24886321)
Could be audiobooks.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by ck425 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @11:46AM (#24887141)
Audiobooks are great for walking. Not sure if that was what the OP was implying.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by fakedang on Sunday October 25, 2020 @05:51PM (#24890230)
What's better is reading HN and walking. I have been walking around 11km each day the past week, reading HN or some articles for my work/side project on Medium. I usually walk in the early morning, before 7, or in the evening in a park, so being distracted isn't an issue.
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by edmundsauto on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:14PM (#24891856)
Do you use tts, or have your eyes on your phone?
Re:‘It’s a superpower’: how walking makes us healthier, happ... by fakedang on Monday October 26, 2020 @02:26AM (#24893304)
Eyes on the phone, I don't go through busy routes.