News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by hilbert42 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @05:57AM (#24846255)
It seems almost unbelievable that in this day and age we could have missed something like this. In my opinion, it put modern medicine into perspective. I've suspected for some time that medicine is actually closer to the dark ages than we like to think it is, and this report seems like a good validation of that notion.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by arminiusreturns on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:02AM (#24847961)
> medicine is actually closer to the dark ages than we like to think it is

I'm not sure it's entirely on point, but ever since my mother was almost murdered by medical malpractice, and then learning about exactly how bad (frequent and severe) medical malpractice is, it's extremely hard for me to not see it this way.

Somewhere close to 300,000 people die a year from medical malpractice, give or take ~50k! Even adjusting for the elderly and comorbidities the number is still huge. I don't know why I never did, but it keep thinking I need to go buy and read Bruce Schneiers book about outliers[1]... it seems crazy how much we ignore much more concrete and repeated issues that cause death and love to focus on outliers that will probably never happen to us.

1. https://www.amazon.com/Liars-Outliers-Enabling-Society-Thriv...

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by fwip on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @04:37PM (#24851902)
This common factoid isn't actually true. The real number is almost certainly less than 10,000 people even with a generous definition, and probably closer to a few hundred annually.

Further reading: https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/are-medical-errors-really-t...

Takeaway:

> (1) [Adverse Effects of Medical Treatment] are not uncommon; (2) the vast majority of AEMTs that occur in patients who die aren’t the primary cause of death; (3) only a relatively small fraction of AEMTs are due to misadventure or medical error; and (4) population-adjusted AEMT rates have been slowly decreasing

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by arminiusreturns on Saturday October 24, 2020 @01:10PM (#24880484)
Well thank you for giving me a different view, now I'm going to have to dig deeper on this. I would say at first glance I already see some methodological cracks, but thanks for the rabbit hole anyway.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by bantunes on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:07AM (#24846294)
I feel like the fact this is rare, big news kind of negates your point.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by dynamite-ready on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:15AM (#24846340)
Agreed, though it also makes me think of the numerous cases of drugs developed with a specific purpose, but then afterwards found to have a completely different effect to what was originally intended.

Medical science is an incredible thing, but science, by definition, does not have all the answers.

A small part of me is actually somewhat surprised, that people (both lay, and professional) are surprised.

Though I am not the best placed commentator to champion this view.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by majewsky on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:21AM (#24846678)
> drugs developed with a specific purpose, but then afterwards found to have a completely different effect to what was originally intended

I don't find that surprising. You have to do the early phases of drug development in model systems like cell cultures for practical reasons: It makes evidence obtained more reproducible and has less ethical concerns than experimenting on humans immediately. It's like how software components usually get implemented and tested in simplified environments (e.g. unit tests use doubles), and just like with drugs, sometimes we find that software components interact with each other in unexpected ways when combined into a whole.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by iguy on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @08:31AM (#24847115)
What seems weird about this is that the process for deciding that an approved drug is useful for a certain condition (not the one it was intended for) is really informal, it seems to rely on common knowledge circulating in the guild.

For the initial approval, we have this very formal process, the FDA wants this kind of data from trials of this size to show this statistical level, etc. All very scientific-looking.

But once it's on the market, random doctors try it out for other conditions. If it seems to work they tell their buddies, tweak the mixtures, share anecdotes. If it becomes widespread, some industry club records this for the purpose of arguing with insurance companies. I am told this off-label use now constitutes the majority of drug prescriptions. All based on (as far as I can tell) no statistically driven testing at all, just stories.

(To be clear, I'm not at all surprised that drugs have "off-target" effects, and may be very useful for things their inventor never imagines. I'm just a bit shocked how pre-modern our system for collecting this knowledge appears to be. But not an expert, and would love to know more.)

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by dynamite-ready on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @02:32PM (#24850674)
You can, almost randomly, take any well known, synthetic drug, and trace a wildly eclectic history of use.

If anyone is interested, the history of anabolic steroids is almost comical... https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/research-reports/ster...

And the period of time over which the change took place, is actually quite remarkable.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by majewsky on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:27AM (#24848771)
> I'm just a bit shocked how pre-modern our system for collecting this knowledge appears to be.

I'm not an expert, but I imagine any more advanced system would be extremely problematic from a data protection point of view (think HIPAA etc.). In a study, patients sign multiple pages of legalese to allow the researchers to collect all the required data. You don't have that with regular patients in a GP's office.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by iguy on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:21PM (#24849298)
Yes that's a hurdle. But even without that, it seems hard to design a good system. If most of the doctors treat the very sick cases (among those diagnosed with X) with drugs Y+Z currently rumoured to work, how do you disentangle the causes of their poor outcomes?

More generally, how do we know it isn't mostly garbage? That seems to be the consensus about most pre-20th-C medicine, and those guys weren't idiots, they were just trying things out and sharing ideas...

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by unishark on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:59AM (#24846557)
Medical research is devoted to diseases, particularly where there's confidence something can be done about it. It's easy to imagine science being weak on something if it doesn't cause life-threatening problems.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by friendlybus on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:51AM (#24846529)
There are many people who espouse a bright and endless increase of medical power, combined with a utopia-lite for our current state of medical knowledge.

There is a lot in the dark and we should not hesistate to point it out. It would be a lie to paper over the cracks with yet another affirmation about it all being figured out and we can go back to sleep.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by trollied on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:42AM (#24846480)
One day in the distant future, people will look back at us having treated cancers with radiation & wonder what the hell we were thinking!
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by projektfu on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:48AM (#24846852)
Honestly, I think cytotoxic chemotherapy will be more shocking. Radiation oncology has made great strides in targeting the dose (cyberknife and other stereotactic approaches). Cytotoxic therapy is still basically poisoning everything and hoping the cancer dies first.

Or, in the case of cancers like multiple myeloma, killing all immune cells and replacing the stem cells.

The future of cancer therapy is likely to be heavily reliant on customization and precise drug delivery, to give an overwhelming dose of poison to the cancer without harming the patient.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by jalk on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:52AM (#24846536)
I hope they will know that there was some level of science (statistics) behind doing so, and not because someone just thought it might help
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by blablabla123 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:35AM (#24846440)
Yes there are some diseases that can be treated very reliably but a large share of commonly occurring issues can't. Also given that modern medicine is largely based on statistics, I have doubts that the sophistication of statistics in use is really appropriate. I think Physics or Psychology do a lot better in that regard. That said, I think many diseases can be treated or prevented with a high success rate without any invasive procedure. For instance the risk of coronary heart disease can be lowered a lot with good diet and mild exercise. It surprises me that doctors never pro-actively mention how to prevent such lifestyle diseases until it's too late. Probably the subject of medicine needs to be broadened a bit.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @08:44AM (#24847236)
"Centuries of scientitic progress being held back by centuries of tradition" seems like an apt cliche to invoke.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by edoloughlin on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:03PM (#24849111)
I've suspected for some time that medicine is actually closer to the dark ages than we like to think it is

Every now and then I see a comment that makes me think HN is closer to Facebook than we like to think it is.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by et2o on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:19AM (#24847549)
Laughable confirmation bias.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by wrinkl3 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:13AM (#24846322)
> I've suspected for some time that medicine is actually closer to the dark ages than we like to think it is

What does that even mean? Nobody's claiming that modern medicine is anywhere close to perfect but the "dark ages" medicine was Humorism, blood letting and faith healing. Surgeons didn't start washing their hands before childbirth until the 19th century. It's really weird to look back at the mind-boggling progress we achieved in the past 200 years and conclude "we're basically still in the dark ages!"

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by garbagetime on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:21AM (#24846374)
Imagine the following.

Here's the spectrum of medical knowledge:

-----------------------------------------

Here's where we were in the dark ages:

--|--------------------------------------

Here's where we are now:

-------|---------------------------------

Here's where people like to think we are:

------------------|----------------------

In this scenario it seems like what you're saying and what your parent said are both true (it is true both that medicine is much closer to the dark ages than we'd like to think, and also that we know a great deal more than we knew in the dark ages).

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by m463 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @08:27AM (#24847090)
I'm reminded of the scene in Mad Men where Roger says something to the effect of "I did everything they said for my ulcer, I drank the buttermilk. and now I have a coronary!"

Also, in the book "The King of Hearts" which describes the history of open heart surgery, the first open heart surgeries were done by sewing the circulatory system of two people together (usually mother and child). that was in the recent past.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by christkv on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @04:00PM (#24851456)
You might find the book The Butchering Art: Joseph Lister's Quest to Transform the Grisly World of Victorian Medicine interesting. Crazy to think that the training to become a surgeon led to a lot of people dying from cutting into infected cadavers during training.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by m463 on Thursday October 22, 2020 @09:42AM (#24857878)
I didn't read the book, but the Joe Rogan interview with the author was a favorite episode. She was the right mix of smart, enthusiastic, craz.... eccentric.

EDIT: Joe Rogan #1272 - Lindsey Fitzharris

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by et2o on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:20AM (#24847564)
We have advanced incredibly far in both treatment of CAD and ulcers. And in CAD, still making tremendous improvements within the last ten years. You don’t really know what you’re talking about at all, citing a TV show.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by halfmatthalfcat on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:28AM (#24847653)
LOL they're making a point using the TV show quote as an analogy to the OP's sentiment, not commenting literally on CAD and ulcers.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by m463 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:52PM (#24849640)
Ha, the show was making a joke and it was relevant.

The point I was making was that in our short lifetimes common medical practices have change directions 180 degrees. The guy who drank h pylori was in our lifetime.

I wonder what common problems and solutions we have today will be changed in the coming 30 years? Maybe there will be a cancer or fat pill and we can eat what we want. Maybe sugar will be banned. Maybe longevity might be conquered? Maybe covid-19 will be viewed like the black plague, which is well understood now.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by adriand on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:26AM (#24846406)
But then we’re in the dark ages for everything, except maybe siege warfare. So it becomes a meaningless comment.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by hamilyon2 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:52AM (#24846878)
I could think of other examples. I mean, we know for sure that electrical motors are not going to be hugely more efficient, because then they will break conservation of energy and bunch of other laws of physics. So, by that measure we are not in dark ages
[dead]
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by WJW on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:18AM (#24847536)
What does that have to do with the efficiency of electric motors? They don't magically get more efficient if you power them with a wind turbine.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by yreg on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:43AM (#24846488)
Yes, on a scale of dark ages to understanding a field perfectly, it's no surprise we are closer to the dark ages.

Well, perhaps we understand basic algebra pretty well.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by adrianN on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:28AM (#24846714)
Life would be pretty boring if it were different don't you think? If almost everything were already figured out after just a few centuries of the scientific method and we wouldn't expect any substantial improvements to be made ever.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by shock on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:52AM (#24847875)
No, one's life would not be boring because of that. There's a difference between things being known to sience and _you_ knowing those things. Even now, you can live your full lifespan without getting bored just learning in depth what is already known to science.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by garbagetime on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:40AM (#24846471)
How do you figure?
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by sy7ar on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:00AM (#24848508)
I have to agree with this. Before I have to exhaust all the medical resources, in my mind, when people get sick, they go see a doctor, the doctor prescribes medicine, and medicine fixes problems. But in reality we're still largely relying on our own defense, e.g. COVID. We rarely have a drug that directly fixes our problem.

I started having really bad insomnia more than a year ago. I went to see a bunch of doctors. Initially, I was given low dosage sleeping pills, which didn't help much. I went to a hospital to get a CT scan because I was having mad headaches, which my family doctor wouldn't refer me. The scan was normal. Finally, I found a doctor who's willing to refer me MRI scan. After waiting for couple of months, the result didn't turn up anything again. Keep in mind I've been suffering 2 - 3 hours sleep a day all these time. I also did sleep study, and sleep study mostly care about sleep apnea, so they couldn't identify any causes again. Then I went to see a psychiatrist, more sleeping pills, which are really antidepressants. Eventually, after a long wait, I was referred to a neurologist and sleep specialist. I've done so much research on sleep medicine at this point, I already knew what he's gonna prescribe me - sleep restriction therapy. That didn't really help altho I gave up after trying for two weeks. I intend to try it again but I can't attempt it now that I'm back to work. So one year later, I'm still messed up with no known cause.

I know insomnia in my case is not a traditional disease, but it goes to show you that if you're not having one of the common diseases then you're shit out of luck.

The human body's extremely complex, but instead of using proper debugging tools, doctors are mostly relying on "console logs" or "print statements". Even if a root cause is identified, often time we don't have the necessary tools to fix the problems.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by TropicalAudio on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:56AM (#24846545)
I'd say "medical knowledge" is too broad of a term to define a finite full spectrum in reasonable terms, as it effectively includes every possible interaction of each part of the human body with every type of physical or chemical condition. More reasonable would be to talk about "anatomical knowledge", which is finitely bound to understanding the expected structure/distribution, function of and communication between each part of the human body to a sub-cell level. We're most of the way there on the first facet, but our models of the latter two are still hilariously incomplete at this point.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by crispyporkbites on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:16AM (#24846647)
People can only see progress and have no idea where we actually are until they look back in retrospect, so I think it's more accurate to say:

Here's where we were in the dark ages:

-|---------------------------------------

Here's where we are now:

---|-------------------------------------

Here's where people thought we were in the dark ages:

----------------------------|------------

Here's where people like to think we are today:

------------------------------|----------

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by JackFr on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:48AM (#24847832)
Chuck Klosterman's book "But What If We're Wrong: Thinking About the Present As If It Were the Past" examines this phenomenon, and while its difficult to make predictions (that's one of the takeaways) it's a terrific lens to look at both the present and the past.

(One of my favorite chapters is imagining 1000 years into the future, where rock and roll is basically only remembered for one artist, who might that be? And why it won't be Elvis or the Beatles.)

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by et2o on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:23AM (#24847593)
Alright, but on the range from nothing to perfect, we are... Far more than 2x the dark ages. More like 1000x.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by JackFr on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:50AM (#24847854)
That's not what Dr. McCoy thinks.

"Dialysis? My God, is this the dark ages!"

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by jpindar on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:39AM (#24848886)
"Sewing people with needles and thread!"
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by wadkar on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:29AM (#24847668)
Progress doesn’t end one day, it’s a process. So what matters is the rate at which we make progress.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by korijn on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:45AM (#24846503)
You seem to imply/think that there is a finite endpoint to your x-axis. I think that is the _real_ misconception here.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by garbagetime on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:50AM (#24846526)
I think the point is equally well demonstrated if you add an ellipses to the right-hand side of the spectrum.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by LanceH on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:56AM (#24848476)
Along these lines I've heard it said that "Doctors don't heal anyone. The get them to the point where their bodies can heal themselves." Sure, there are some exceptions where the body literally can't heal itself, like reattaching something, but the sentiment holds true most of the time.

In another discussion bred from boredom where some friends and I were trying to define entire fields of study in a single sentence (Economics is the allocation of scarcity) one doctor said, "Medicine is about controlling swelling." His response (he was a surgeon) kind of made your point that we imagine that doctors are fixing things and he is saying that he spent most of his time trying to get the body to make it better and not worse.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by fn1 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:39AM (#24846786)
Since that axis really cannot be constructed, I think a better way to present your sentiment is the following:

Is it possible that we still miss a large discovery in medicine, akin to the introduction of evidence-based treatment, hygiene, inoculations or the discovery of DNA?

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by kristopolous on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:48AM (#24846851)
Absolutely, without question. Dozens, maybe hundreds of things that big.

The arrogant assumption of an infinite wisdom of the present is one of the strongest there is.

Ptolemaic astronomy looked right until Galileo came along. It matched observational measurements, just with an unhelpful set of assumptions. We're Ptolemy on countless things whose Galileos haven't been born yet.

It's unsettling to think we're all stupid in ways we'll never know, I know. Sorry about that.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by scoopertrooper on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:24AM (#24846395)
Yes, we've made some great leaps and they shouldn't be discounted, but neural-science is still in its infancy. We still don't know the exact mechanism of action of many commonly prescribed psychoactive medications. We know they work because, unlike in the past, we conduct rigorous studies, but we can only theorise as to why the work and why they don't have the same effect in all patients. This has real implications for how medicine is practiced, which will undoubtedly make our methods look quite primitive to future generations. For instance, physiatrists are still forced into a 'trial and error' approach when finding the correct antidepressant and dosage for each patient.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by ainiriand on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:31AM (#24847693)
What still amazes me is the placebo effect. That is just pure mind-blowing-ness.

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Placebo#Mechanisms

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by LocalH on Thursday October 22, 2020 @01:53PM (#24860962)
I feel the placebo effect characterizes the true power of the mind, of which we’ve only scratched the surface. I think the newfound interest in researching psychedelics also shows some real promise in understanding consciousness.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by pas on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:45AM (#24846502)
I think we know their mechanism of action, but the grim reality is that they don't work that well at low doses, plus there are a lot of side effects even at low doses. (Because their mechanism is so general. Inhibit this, promote that. But those are all over our body. Plus eventually there are tolerance issues - so doctors switch from time to time. But then they have to fiddle with the dose.)
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by tsimionescu on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:46AM (#24846841)
You would be quite wrong. We do know some bits about the effects of serotonin in the body, though I would be amazed if we really understood the whole story.

But more than that, we have no idea what depression actually is, and that goes for any other psychiatric disease unrelated to direct brain damage. It would probably be more correct to call these syndromes rather than diseases, as we do not know the mechanisms causing the disease enough to even be sure if 'depression' is a meaningful diagnosis (in the sense that coughing is not a diagnosis).

We also don't have proper neurological studies of emotional illnesses - there are basically no comparative neurological studies of people diagnosed with depression versus people showing similar symptoms who are expected to quickly recover (for example, people grieving for a lost one). We don't know whether the brain chemistry changes we see in depression are the cause of the disease, or just the way 'sadness'/'lack of motivation' looks like neuro-chemically.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by pas on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:21PM (#24849308)
I think we're in agreement, but perhaps I wasn't precise enough in my phrasing.

I mean we know what they do chemically, but as you said we have no idea what serotonin does. (Which is not true, but it's so complicated that what we know just makes us exhausted thinking about how truly complicated it is.)

> We don't know whether the brain chemistry changes we see in depression are the cause of the disease, or just the way 'sadness'/'lack of motivation' looks like neuro-chemically.

Indeed. Though it's always both. And probably asking whether we could, let's say take a pill every day as prevention seems unfathomable, because so far - again, just as you said - we don't really know what is depression. It's basically too much of feeling down. Feeling down when you shouldn't really be feeling that down, at least somehow "compared" to other people. So it's hard to know when prevention should start and when it's just normal case of the mondays.

However, just as with the nurture-nature conundrum it seems natural to treat it as one thing very tightly coupled with the other. Which makes it likely that any kind of treatment and understanding has to always handle both in a lockstep. (Even if there are a lot of subgroups, some are more susceptible on the chemistry side, some more on the cognitive side, some are simply resilient enough to deal with it with some light touch counseling, some got a very bad ticket in life and need a whole support network to keep the darkness at bay, etc.)

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by oceanplexian on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:33AM (#24847700)
You don't have to look far in health policy to see the lunacy of modern medicine.

Using nuclear radiation to "cure" cancer. Giving patients highly addictive narcotics for pain relief. Giving patients broad-spectrum antibiotics. And don't get me started on the insanity of current events, with mass over-use of disinfectants, conflicting and dubious public health guidelines (Covid 19 spreads 3M in Europe but only 6ft. in the USA, N95 masks don't prevent infection but surgical masks work great, viruses don't spread while sitting but spread while standing in a restaurant). Dark ages? No. But I can see the parallels.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by omanom on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:13AM (#24848058)
How do you decide to attribute something to "modern medicine" versus "The Game of Telephone, Medical Style"?

For example,

>Giving patients highly addictive narcotics for pain relief.

Is the opioid epidemic modern medicine's fault? Or is it more the fault of doctors who over-prescribe coupled with the lack of a sane healthcare system?

Also, are there viable (read: equally effective) alternatives to opioids for pain relief?

>Giving patients broad-spectrum antibiotics

Is the rise of antibiotic-resistant bacteria modern medicine's fault? Or is it more the fault of patients who do not finish out their full regimen?

And again, are there viable alternatives to broad-spectrum antibiotics?

>Covid 19 spreads 3M in Europe but only 6ft. in the USA

Distancing guidelines were meant to provide a general reference point, not magical thresholds at which COVID is incapable of passing over... They're going for a distance that is easily visualized, is situated well up on the "diminishing returns" curve, and (when combined with other measures like wearing a mask) provides an "acceptable" risk of exposure.

Sneezing, for one example, will throw respiratory droplets much further than the recommendation for social distancing.

>N95 masks don't prevent infection but surgical masks work great

I'd like to see a source for this claim if you don't mind, as a quick perusal of the FDA[0] and CDC[1][2] do not show this statement anywhere. Everything I've found states they're fairly equally effective. Everything I've found also says that N95 and surgical masks are not recommended for use outside a profession which requires them:

Q: Should I purchase personal protective equipment such as facemasks or N95 respirators for me and my family?

A: No. Surgical masks and N95s need to be reserved for use by health care workers, first responders, and other frontline workers whose jobs put them at much greater risk of acquiring COVID-19. The cloth face coverings recommended by CDC are not surgical masks or N95 respirators. Surgical masks and N95s are critical supplies that must continue to be reserved for health care workers and other medical first responders, as recommended by CDC.

--

CDC does not recommend using masks for source control if they have an exhalation valve or vent.

Masks are not surgical masks or respirators. Currently, those are critical supplies that should continue to be reserved for healthcare workers and other medical first responders, as recommended by current CDC guidance. Masks also are not appropriate substitutes for them in workplaces where surgical masks or respirators are recommended or required and available.

--

CDC also links to a study[3] that found "Surgical and N95 masks were equally effective in preventing the spread of PCR-detectable influenza". There are plenty of related studies which come to the same conclusion.

>viruses don't spread while sitting but spread while standing in a restaurant

Again, how is this a "modern medicine" issue, or a "conflicting and dubious public health guideline"? They're not saying "the virus won't spread as long as you're sitting down!", they're saying "if you fucks have to go out, at least try to stay apart for everyone else's sake".

[0] https://www.fda.gov/emergency-preparedness-and-response/coro.... [1] https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prevent-getting-si... [2] https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prevent-getting-si... [3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19522650/

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by mjburgess on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:00AM (#24848509)
If by modern medicine you mean only "the best conclusions derived from the best meta-analyses based on the best evidence" then very little of what any doctor does is grounded in that.

I wouldn't call that medicine. I'd call that, maybe, "research biomedical science".

I think OP's comment is precisely that the practice of medicine has very little to do with what top-quality research would prescribe, and is more like medieval reasoning (like causes like, etc.).

Of course the reason behind this is that we dont have much top-quality research; and what "research" we often have is poorly executed and ambiguous (if honest).

What we "need" is 10k "disposable humans" manufactured on-demand, for 100k RCT experiments. What we have is often much closer to astrology.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by omanom on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:24AM (#24848723)
Thank you for the more thorough take on that perspective.

Yes, there are "parallels to the Dark Ages" in the sense that "medical practitioners prescribe treatment based on the best information available at the time".

That doesn't mean medical knowledge, practice, research, and equipment has been stagnant or that medical practitioners should not be trusted with their advice.

Statements like "the lunacy of modern medicine" are not truthful and not productive, especially when the minimal supporting evidence for the statements are misleading at best.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by ThePowerOfDirge on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:18AM (#24846353)
Blood letting is still the treatment for iron overload.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by jankotek on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:47AM (#24846509)
Leaches produce enzyme that prevents blood cloth from forming. It also improves oxygenation. For some wounds, leaches would protect leg or arm from amputation.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by fennecfoxen on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:21AM (#24846672)
* leeches

Leaching is a process in which you percolate a liquid (like water) through something, and it picks up chemicals and carries them out. Brewing coffee, for instance.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by buck4roo on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:59AM (#24846558)
"Rationally designed" drugs do this now. An example: Exjade ;

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deferasirox

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by meheleventyone on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:41AM (#24846475)
Right but only because we know the mechanism of action and it's efficacy. It's also performed in a different manner to blood letting as a historical treatment.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by ben509 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:41AM (#24848897)
Humorism probably produced observable benefits just by encouraging people to eat a balanced diet. Its basic notion that you have different things in your body that need to be balanced is not wrong.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by vixen99 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:54AM (#24846539)
On the other hand, just keeping to the observation, we can at least say that countless pathologists and others over a very long period have failed to identify this anatomical entity. In the main it seems that experts see what they expect to see and if it's not in the anatomy book then it doesn't exist. That's not necessarily perjorative. It's how we humans tend to be when observing the world (including ourselves) around us.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by grishka on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:02AM (#24848522)
For one thing, it feels like we're still very much not confident with anything at all because everything has to be tested in real humans, in real time, before it's considered a valid treatment (clinical trials). I understand why clinical trials are needed — because otherwise we'd still be using mysterious compounds and procedures without having a clue if they actually work — but I believe that at some point we'd become so advanced with knowing how the human body works that we won't have to do that, and so could progress much, much faster, while knowing that our treatments work, and theoretically, instead of experimentally, proving that they should work.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by murgindrag on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @08:37AM (#24847158)
I think you're being a little mean to the dark ages.

Galen was a pretty accomplished medical researcher, and Roman-era medical implements were quite sophisticated, and were well-established by the time of the dark ages. By the late dark ages, we also saw a lot of modern medical techniques coming in from the Middle East.

There's this stereotype of people being filthy, ignorant, and dumb, but it's not really true. And for many of the bad practices from then do persist in poorer parts of the world today affecting likely around a billion people (and some, like homeopathy, even in wealthy parts).

Note that I'm not weighing in on the overall debate about where modern medicine is relative to the dark ages. We've made a lot of progress. I'm just refuting the stereotype of the dark ages.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by wrinkl3 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:48AM (#24847833)
> Galen was a pretty accomplished medical researcher, and Roman-era medical implements were quite sophisticated, and were well-established by the time of the dark ages.

Were those implements actually practiced throughout the dark ages or did they go the way of the Roman road networks?

When people talk of the dark ages they're usually talking of post-Roman Western Europe rather than Asia or the Middle East. I'm not sure if a Bohemian peasant living in 1000 AD would've benefited much from Islamic medicine advancements.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by murgindrag on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:12AM (#24848593)
Wikipedia defines the Dark Ages as lasting through the 15th century, by which point, Islamic medical advancements would have made it into Europe. Obviously, in 500AD, they didn't yet exist.

One of the reason for the decline of the term "dark ages" is that there is increasing evidence that people in this period didn't actually crawl under a rock of ignorance. Large-scale armies and infrastructure projects were gone, but at the same time, a lot more knowledge persisted than is given credit for -- the sorts of things which don't require a massive Roman central government administration to maintain.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by hilbert42 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @01:53PM (#24850315)
Right, I used it as an all-embracing term for 'very old', I'm surprised many have taken the term so literally. Perhaps it's characteristic of HN's audience.

"One of the reason for the decline of the term "dark ages" is that there is increasing evidence that people in this period didn't actually crawl under a rock of ignorance."

Despite my use of 'Dark Ages', I cannot agree with you more. Perhaps you might like to look at this image of a shoulder-clasp from Britain's Sutton Hoo Hoard (it's one of many). Considering both its age and the time in which it was created (and the limited tool available then), to me, this is one of the most remarkable and beautiful objects I've ever seen. It sends shivers down my back when I think of the sheer talent that created it. We are so lucky it's survived essentially intact across the last one and half millennia:

https://www.ancient.eu/image/5107/the-sutton-hoo-shoulder-cl...

(Make sure you click on the image to get the largest view.)

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by rbanffy on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @08:28AM (#24847098)
> medicine was Humorism, blood letting and faith healing.

I suspect the doctors of the 23rd century will be similarly horrified by their 21st century counterparts practices.

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by tomatotomato37 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:26AM (#24847639)
Chemotherapy will definitely be on that list, as when you ultimately boil it down you are posioning someone just enough where the tumor dies before the rest of their body also dies.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by keithnoizu on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:06AM (#24848545)
I'm of the same mind. The way in which new antibiotics are identified for example.
[dead]
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by dang on Thursday October 22, 2020 @03:35PM (#24862427)
Please review the site guidelines and omit swipes from your comments.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by snapetom on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:42AM (#24848909)
You should have to because the original comment was seeping in dramatic hyperbole to fish for points. At the end of the day, I'd much rather live with modern medicine than dark age medicine.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by hilbert42 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @01:06PM (#24849818)
I suggest you read my next post below.

BTW, have you ever thought about the fact that cancer deaths are still very prevalent despite all the hyperbole from thousands of researchers say since 1950—yes, hyperbole deliberately spruced up to attract funding and to gain newspaper headlines.

The facts are straightforward: had 0.1% of the promises about improvements in cancer treatments that have appeared in the many tens of thousands of professional research papers on the subject over the past 70 yeas had actually come to fruition, then the disease would have all but been eliminated by now.

You might say this was justified but it's turned out that this type of hyperbole is not befitting of science, and that it's been largely responsible for the enormous drop in the public's approval rating for science over this time. (I'm not saying it's only cancer researchers (although they top the list), essentially it's all researchers these days.)

Don't say this isn't true, do your research. In the 1950s almost everyone believed in and accepted science—even though this was the time of the A-Bomb and bomb development, back then, people could still differentiate science per se* from the bad applications of science.

Now, 60 or 70 years later, I know scientists who, when, say, they go to a party, will disguise their real professions, so bad is Science's PR. (I'm even in that league but I'm less sensitive about it than some.)

Anyway, I'd suggest to you that in comparison with these professionals, my hyperbole pails into insignificance.

Ha, so you reckon my hyperbole is dramatic and done only to fish for points. That implies you actually think about such matters and consider points important (most of my posts never make it even to two). Franky, these post would altogether be much better of without them. For the record, your assertion isn't true (not that I expect you to believe what I've said).

[dead]
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by dang on Thursday October 22, 2020 @03:35PM (#24862435)
Personal attacks are not allowed here. Please omit such swipes from your HN comments. Your post would be just fine without that last bit.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by mantap on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:00AM (#24847942)
It's quite unnecessary to call people names, and also unwise, people might be tempted to mentally substitute the second person pronoun with a first person one.
Re:Researchers discover new salivary glands in the human head by hilbert42 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:31AM (#24848812)
"Because no one is looking for tissue that secretes saliva (not very interesting medically), coupled with the fact that this requires special PET/CT to find. You are a buffoon."

et2o: yes—a buffoon—that's very likely true, but at least I admit it!

However, you medicos have a damn lot to answer for. Where would you like me to start? Perhaps with the thalidomide fiasco, or more recently the abysmal lack of preparation for COVID-19 even though we knew it was coming decades ago, or the current opioid epidemic, the policies of which were sorted out nearly a century ago with both government regulation and tightly controlled international treaties, all of which have recently been [conveniently] forgotten by the pharmaceutical industry, the FDA, along with a disreputable mob of doctors who disbanded their Hippocratic Oaths for a few shekels from mafia-like Purdue. Right, the law should bring them all to account.

Perhaps the most tragic aspect of the opioid crisis is that the thousands of 'good' doctors stood knowingly by and effectively did nothing, seemingly ethics flew out the window. In words loosely attributed to Edmund Burke: "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing".

"(not very interesting medically)"

Whilst many areas of medical science have done wonders, in others research has been almost non-existent. You're right, certain diseases/subjects are not interesting or boring and concomitantly that they fail to attract funding is a problem, and it's always been that way. In this regard, the trouble is (and has always been) that the self-governing medical profession has never been able to prioritize patients above their own interests, not to mention money. In essence, medical researchers do not exercise granularity evenly over the field of medical knowledge (as you implied yourself); and that's aided and abetted by large pharma, et al whose principal interest is money, not medicine.

___

Lear: My wits begin to turn.

Fool: He that has and a little tiny wit,—

(Lear III/I)