given Sonos' track record with the "lol, can't have anyone using an OLD PRODUCT THAT STILL WORKS FINE" thing i'm rather unsure we should really give them the benefit of the doubt here
ref https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21895086 for "recycle mode" fiasco
I don't think there was malice involved. Sonos seems like a company that has a very tough time making money, and since they IPO'd two years ago they are "responsible" to shareholders now (their stock opened at 15 and as of Oct 2 it was 15 -- could be worse!). Bricking old products would give a profit boost if everyone said ok and bought new products, but they underestimated the backlash.
It's the same reason their client sucks -- it will cost a lot of money to make native apps that take advantage of the respective eco-systems. The client suffices for most people so why bother?
That said, I'll go back to being pissed if they release new hardware I want and get rid of the 30% discount.
Open-source the last compatible version of the client and let the community maintain it? Or at the very least publish the API specification and let the community build a new one from scratch?
https://github.com/pascalopitz/unoffical-sonos-controller-fo...
Open sourcing the old version of the software might be too much to ask for various reasons, but publishing API documentation in order to enable third party implementations IMO should be legally required in cases like this.
The higher-end you're going on audio, the more static things become. Yeah, you might take your iPhone dock or Bluetooth speaker and move it around, but if you spend $1000 on speakers (or 10k on building a listening room), you're gonna want the speakers in the sweet spot and left there. If I'm working with that constraints, why is having a wireless smart speaker I have to tether to a phone or hub any better than if I had just ran speaker wire to a receiver? Especially since it still has to be wired for power.
At least I know my amplifier isn't spying on me or monetizing my endless appetite for Rise Against. Because it was built in 1980 but still sounds as good as anything in the same price class today.
Of course, all of this isn't exclusive to Sonos, but from what I understand none of the copycat competitors have matched their ease of use so far.
Make good hardware and sell it at a profit. Problem solved. Sonos still has an edge on the actual audio hardware (that none of the existing "smart speaker" competition can match, besides maybe the HomePod but the lack of Spotify support is a major dealbreaker for a lot of people).
In any case, I don't see how data collection helps with any of this; selling consumer data alone isn't going to be enough to keep the company afloat, and introducing ads into the audio stream itself will be a major no-no (unless the speakers are given for free, but then the costs of that would outweigh the advertising profits). I don't think speakers are a thing that can be monetized with data, full stop - and that's okay.
Most likely the whole idea behind the data collection & analytics is to justify the salaries of their marketing department and give the engineering department something to do (analytics show that X percent of customers loved this new feature, let's rebuild/expand it) while ultimately all that people want is a speaker that plays their Spotify and gets out of the way (and unlike other hardware, people aren't - and shouldn't be - used to replacing their speakers every year).
It really isn't that simple, and I wish people would stop acting like making ANY profit is enough to keep a business around.
First, making a profit isn't enough... you have to make more profit than the people investing money in the company could make elsewhere. If you make $1 for every $100 invested, and some other company can make $2 for every $100, why would anyone invest in the $1 maker? It isn't just about profit, it is about the opportunity cost of using capital on something that isn't as profitable as other capital uses.
Second, let's say the profit margins are actually pretty good, and you make a nice return on this quality hardware you make. However, if the quality actually is really good, what do you do after everyone who needs your product buys it? You either have to build in obsolescence, which everyone rightly hates, or you have to switch to making another product. That switch is expensive, and cuts into your profit margin... assuming your new product is even successful. This is a lot of risk.
What that risk means is that investors don't want to be left holding the bag when your product reaches market saturation and your pivot fails... which is going to make it harder to get investment.
Really, Sonos is a great example of what happens when you follow your instructions to "make a good product and sell it at a profit"... they did that for many years, and made money.... but now most people who want a speaker like Sonos makes already have them, and their growth has stopped. They can still make money on each speaker sold, but they are selling fewer of them. So they are trying to pivot to make money some other way, and it sounds like it might not be going great.
The only sustainable hardware business is to make and sell a huge amount of commodity hardware at small margins, and simply switch to the next thing once some OTHER company does the expensive research and experimentation to create the next thing people want to buy.
No.
Sonos has a very small market penetration and could have continued growing, modestly, with enthusiastic reviews and glowing recommendations forever.
The problem was not that they did not have a business model - the problem was that nobody was going to get filthy rich with that business model. They found that to be unacceptable and did silly things - like an IPO.
Now they're stuck on a path that requires rapid growth. You could have easily predicted, years ago, that any company in this position would do things like drop support for old devices and get pushy with people to adopt their app (although I have to admit, I never would have predicted that they would gut their desktop player and force people to use the app) ... and adopt sleazy and desperate relationships with data brokers, etc.
Fuck them. I wish they knew how much I loved their company, and their product, and how much I hate them now.
There are other boutique audio hardware companies that do not take such a data-heavy approach and they are doing fine. As I hinted in my other comment, Sennheiser or Klipsch are examples.
Does Bose demand this much access to you and your data just to sell you a new WaveRadio or whatever? They even have a dedicated retail presence to maintain!
Depends on their finances, and what the investors are looking to get out of it. And they may need to compete with the compensation offered by FAANG companies who can easily do it with perpetually rising market valuations.
Ability to scale almost infinitely at almost zero marginal costs makes consumer tech products involving decent software quite a difficult business to be in.
The is generally the antithesis of funds that invest in tech, is it not?
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-bose-lawsuit/bose-headpho...
I do agree with your overall point though!
Bingo. That's precisely the reason we need legislation in the US similar to the GDPR. Until all companies are forbidden to collect customer data, companies that don't do so will always be at a profit disadvantage. Once all companies are forbidden from abusing their customers, investors won't have the option of investing in companies that abuse their customers. Which is exactly as it should be.
I would be really curious as to how data collected from a Sonos speaker (without the ability to directly monetize that data themselves for advertising, as nobody would be buying speakers that insert ads) can be worth anything more than a rounding error of their current revenue.
If you're selling an upscale product, you can sometimes collect upscale intel. Something useful for stock trading, perhaps.
And that should mean they do not need to play these games with data collection.
> They are terrified they are going to get squeezed eventually.
Squeezed by what? I wish more manufacturers would just make a simple freaking product that works great for its intended purpose, and nothing else. That should be an advantage to Sonos against all the other companies that refuse to just do that.
when sonos came to market, they were the best repositionable home speaker system, hands down. their primary differentiator was their superb and resilient audio-syncing capabilities (not it's less-defensible content catalog, though that helped as a flanking feature).
they had the chance to become the brand in home audio, and they blew it. phenomenally. likely because they were under-/mis-invested in r&d, and possibly also under-capitalized (often because founders don't want to risk devaluation/dilution).
from that base of home audio, they were perfectly positioned to become the home hub of the future, the nerve center for everything audiovisual (and beyond) in the home. instead, they got distracted by clouds, analytics, big data, and every other tech buzzword floating about. it's business strategy 101, and the perfect business case fodder.
This article (and a post yesterday that said similar) have me making some system tweaks and the Pihole is part way their. I think I’ll just block the speakers at the firewall to keep things simple.
Sonos is trying to deprecate their older models and introduce planned obsolescence. They had a program to brick your old equipment in exchange for rebates on newer models. That was totally wasteful and wanton, and the Internet called them out on it.
They have so many competitors now, including the tech giants which control streaming. Google is in a feud with them and could cut off access.
Sonos is in a very precarious spot.
this kind of negative press does filter out into consumer choices over time. and as @fivre pointed out, they're getting squeezed out by better-capitalized monopolists, losing market- and mind-share to the likes of apple, amazon and google. sonos doesn't have the capital to compete, and lost their first-mover advantage by stagnating rather than leading the market.
(i also block everything but streaming connections for my sonos at the router.)
So for louder, phone connected speakers would you still recommend Sonos? Ie i'm not sure i need the idea of multiple rooms playing the same thing. I'd love it, but my wife wouldn't hah. However i do want (decent) quality speakers in all rooms that i can play music on, and i'm largely satisfied with the bluetooth-phone experience. I'm just not satisfied with my tiny bluetooth speaker quality or sound level.
Any opinion of if i should look into Sonos? Or would cheaper bluetooth speakers fit better?
(edit: Sidenote, the voice assistant option is a downside for me. Otherwise i'd probably own a few Apple HomePods)
Their whole recycling/permanently destroying speakers debacle was also quite annoying.
If you go into expecting the third year and beyond of service to be bonus and that you’re the product not the customer, it’s a great fit for your needs.
If I were going to go for a wifi speaker, though, I'd seriously look at Bluesound's product line. They're a Sonos competitor and they're not nearly as well known, but they're part of the same little group that owns NAD Electronics and PSB Speakers and use amplifiers and acoustics from those sister companies. If you're an audio nerd (or even if you're not), that's a pretty good pedigree. AFAIK Bluesound products work with various voice assistants, but don't build them in.
(Edited to add: I don't own a Bluesound device, but I do own a NAD T758 receiver, which uses an earlier version of BluOS for its streaming/wifi capabilities and it's pretty solid.)
If you want the fluidity of Sonos without the voice assistant, check out the Sonos One SL - it's the Sonos One without the microphone and voice assistant, and is $20 cheaper because of it. There's also the IKEA Symfonisk, which is basically a bookshelf speaker variant of the One SL, from what I've read.
The creepiness factor is a significant problem but I hope to beat it with network changes and send them some feedback. It certainly makes me reconsider further purchases.
To me that's not a dealbreaker, it may be to you.
I've got a few Sonos speakers, and all around they sound great, so I can only recommend them! I've also never had any troubleshooting to do with them.
I know in iOS a bunch of non-obvious APIs are attached to location permissions. Including access to your current WiFi network name, which would be used by Sonos to configure your speaker during setup.
Of course this requires someone to have already uploaded the estimated location of the access point. But loads of apps and OSs do that all the time.
On the one hand you have Apple and their half-hearted (for now) entry, and at the low end you have Alexa/"Talk to it" speakers. These alternatives seem destined to encroach on the Sonos turf come hell or high water.
I will say that for their intended purpose--streaming music to a network connected speaker, Sonos speakers just work great! Their app interface, while not a great experience, functions. When I click "Play," stuff immediately comes out of my speakers. NOW. There is never a delay, never a spinning pizza, never, never NEVER! (anecdata, of course)
So I (me, not you) can't blame them for wildly thrashing a bit on the data collection side. I get it. They are terrified they are going to get squeezed eventually.
Do I wish they would reconsider advertising and related marketing shenanigans as business models? Yes, I do. For now they meet my needs and they just work. It's a trade off I'm (me, not you) are willing to make for now.