News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by cmehdy on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:25AM (#24679262)
This is mentioned in the famous "Don't talk to the police" youtube video (from this point[0] and a minute on): there are just enough laws that even lawmakers and experts don't have an actual count, can't keep track of all of them, and they can say nearly anything.

(These are my words, not the video:) In the bigger scheme of things, you're likely to be guilty of something almost at all times. Whether or not people know, care, or come down on you depends on a variety of factors.

This is pretty much true in any country, it's just that the richest ones have codified it to give the madness more legitimacy.

[0] https://youtu.be/d-7o9xYp7eE?t=279

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by Aerroon on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:03PM (#24679975)
This is why I think our legal system is not really compatible with the world of surveillance. Everyone has something to hide, therefore everyone has something to fear.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by renewiltord on Sunday October 04, 2020 @07:11PM (#24682994)
That's why the universal panoramic panopticon is desirable for society's weak. When all can spy on all, everyone's crimes are public and whether you're the homeless man on the streets of SF or celebrated lawyer Jeff Adachi, the programmatic police will come for you.

Fair, just, unbiased. And therefore a scary situation for people like me who willfully violate the law but are generally safe from prosecution. This is power and advantage I don't want to give up.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by stuaxo on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:45PM (#24683532)
Except we don't have universal access to really good lawyers.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by ignoramous on Monday October 05, 2020 @12:06AM (#24684468)
...or "fuck you" money.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by StavrosK on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:13PM (#24680080)
Where's the incompatibility? Sounds exactly on the money to me.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by Aerroon on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:22PM (#24680150)
If you want a society that doesn't run on corruption then it's incompatible.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by jessaustin on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:44PM (#24680335)
You and I want that, but let's not assume anything about the people who decide these things.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by kortilla on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:09PM (#24680548)
Lets. Any model that depends on intentional evil at every level is likely wrong.

The more likely reality is that politicians think they are doing what their constituents want by passing laws to address what they are currently complaining about. And constituents rarely complain about existing laws so the only natural way for the government to go is more laws and more regulations.

When’s the last time you heard a politician run on the platform of getting rid of laws? Even the Republicans who run on less regulation generates far more legislation than repealed.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by craftinator on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:56PM (#24682192)
> Any model that depends on intentional evil at every level is likely wrong.

This is unfounded (do you have any sort of backing for this ridiculously bold claim?), historically inaccurate (in nearly every generation, there's at least one mass-murdering regime born), and isn't actually relevant to the question (evil at every level discounts those who aren't involved, those that are victims, and those that are powerless to stop the evil).

The rest of your comment is spot on. The unfortunate truth is that people who are elected have the skills required to be elected, not the skills required to lead. Our legislative system is designed to encourage childish bickering, which is attractive to people with old faces and childish personalities. The system is built around the idea that the president will be the "adult in the room" and apply a considered direction to the children to mediate their bickering; it seems that doesn't work well.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by jessaustin on Sunday October 04, 2020 @07:23PM (#24683061)
You think evil requires intention? I have no idea what "model" you might be talking about.

On HN we are often downvoted for cautioning against unwarranted assumption. Meanwhile elaborate theories that just happen to affirm how great life is for everyone we care about in this best of all possible worlds are quite popular. In 2020. Good grief.

The fact that no politicians campaign in a way that would appeal to most citizens is no surprise. Our congress passed the trillion-dollar covid bailouts (that contained nothing to help normal citizens get health care) nearly unanimously.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by aksss on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:31PM (#24684324)
Evil is ironically done with the best of intentions.

For the record - the federal bailout helped many business owners I know personally keep people on the payroll, and many unemployed friends (from food service and travel industry) able to keep paying their rent. With COVID’s 99% survivability rate for most of the working population, I think those benefits took priority over a healthcare stipend. Not trashing the idea of fixing healthcare at all, but given a limited bag of cash and choices to make, keeping people housed and fed en masse is arguably higher on the priority list than a healthcare half measure (if that).

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by jessaustin on Monday October 05, 2020 @02:33AM (#24685112)
I begrudge no small business anything they got. What they got, however, pales in comparison to the "open the Fed" measures that gave all the big guys access to trillions of dollars of "free" capital. Just as in the last recession, this giant transfer from the public to the assholes will destroy small firms and reward 2B2F firms.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by numpad0 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:31PM (#24681171)
Maybe he’s assuming a dystopia run by an all knowing and always consistent computer?

A legal system that no one in a functioning society can live without causing offenses will lead to a non-functioning state, if enforced.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by freeone3000 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @03:40PM (#24681695)
It's actually worse for selective enforcement. That allows essentially prosecution for nothing against anyone currently out of favor with the powers that be. It obscures this deliberate corruption by hiding it behind a veneer of legalism, and allows apologists to claim "if they didn't want to be arrested, they shouldn't have done X". It erodes the idea of laws being backed by justice, and makes them simply another tool of the powerful against the powerless.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by baskire on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:47AM (#24679428)
It doesn’t help that politicians face as much hardship in removing old laws as adding a new one.

Leading to us always creating laws and rarely removing them.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by curtis3389 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:56AM (#24679921)
All laws in a democracy should have to be re-affirmed by the populace on a regular basis. That is, every law should be required to have a sunset date.

It's insane that we can be born into the tyranny of rotting corpses.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by gumby on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:08PM (#24680035)
I’d agree but then there will just be an annual law that blanket renews all the laws that would expire in the upcoming year.

How about laws without cute names and that began by describing the problem they intend to solve? I have been told they are written that way in russia though I have no way to verify.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by leetcrew on Sunday October 04, 2020 @07:42PM (#24683148)
> I’d agree but then there will just be an annual law that blanket renews all the laws that would expire in the upcoming year.

maybe so, but every so often you get a happy accident. the patriot act missed its most recent deadline for renewal and is still not in effect (though not for a particularly good reason).

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by jonkho on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:48PM (#24680375)
How about law as a subscription service? The maxim is if it has value in people’s eyes, then people should be willing to pay a monthly fee for it, voluntarily and without coercion.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by gumby on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:31PM (#24681165)
A big part of government function is managing externalities (pollution, food safety, roads etc) -- things that are not economic when purchased individually. They suffer from a free rider issue: I benefit from clean air whether I pay for it or not.

In addition I don't know enough about traffic safety to figure out what the best speed limit is for certain roads, nor how the road should be constructed (especially given local environmental conditions, estimated use etc). It's cheaper overall to outsource it to people who know. Otherwise how can I decide if I want to subscribe to that safety rail at the edge of a certain roadway?

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by throwaway0a5e on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:38PM (#24683487)
>A big part of government function is managing externalities (pollution, food safety, roads etc) -- things that are not economic when purchased individually.

Says you.

Damn near every government (from local to national) has a charter more along the lines of "do these specific mostly administrative things that we agree are best done at this level".

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by NikolaNovak on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:54PM (#24680436)
Taxes are pretty much that, but I suppose "with coercion".

Otherwise, if it's truly pick and choose... how much thought did we give to this? :)

Will everybody pay equally for each law, or rich people pay more?

If rich people pay more, and they decide they don't like the tax avoidance laws, will they be disproportionally funded?

If everybody pays the same, this will be proportionally harsher for poor people.

Most people will not pay for 97% of the laws which may be overall important but don't impact them directly - e.g. I live in Toronto so don't car about fisheries laws, etc.

Some people will not pay for laws they personally don't want to abide buy - from speeding tickets to financial regulations to fitness of goods and services etc.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by leetcrew on Sunday October 04, 2020 @07:47PM (#24683177)
I don't think this would work, but it does remind me of an idle thought I sometimes have. some nonprofits allow donors to make conditional donations. for example, you might donate to a school, but stipulate that the money can only be spent on the theater program. I wonder what would happen if taxes worked the same way. you have to pay the same amount no matter what (and maybe some gets preallocated towards nondiscretionary spending), but you would get to pick from a few broad categories where your tax dollars go. would probably be a disaster, but interesting to think about. from a certain perspective, it might increase the "legitimacy" of government programs.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by throwaway0a5e on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:40PM (#24683496)
I think "just give it to the feds instead" should be a checkbox on everyone's state taxes. It would give the states a clear monetary reason to make their inhabitants not resent them.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by chordalkeyboard on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:27PM (#24684306)
That would be nice if you could also elect to give your fed monies to the local gov’t. That way the different governments could compete for the provision of good government.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by thotsBgone on Sunday October 04, 2020 @06:17PM (#24682695)
Incorrect. If everyone else pays for it and I don't, then I benefit. Tragedy of the commons. My winning strategy is never to pay.
[dead]
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by dang on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:48PM (#24684101)
Please don't take HN threads further into ideological flamewar. We're trying for something different here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by Aerroon on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:01PM (#24679963)
I think so too. The government has to pass a budget every year. Would it really be too much to ask of them to reaffirm old laws every 10-20 years?
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by smegger001 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:42PM (#24680318)
> think so too. The government has to pass a budget every year. Would it really be too much to ask of them to reaffirm old laws every 10-20 years?

You realize the federal government shuts down every so often fro days to months because they cant get there act together on the budget. can you imagine the chaos that would insue in the current political climate if one party or the other thought they could hold a major law hostage to what ever cause they want.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by freeone3000 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @03:44PM (#24681724)
Most governments manage to pass a budget every year. The American government's exceptional incompetence should not be treated as a foregone conclusion -- and their inability to pass laws speak more to the innate unfairness of unaffirmed laws than anything else! Imagine if they would simply have to defend every law like the Assault Weapons Ban. We'd have fewer laws. Fewer by FAR.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by tialaramex on Sunday October 04, 2020 @06:33PM (#24682796)
> Most governments manage to pass a budget every year.

Not exactly. Two things are going on here that makes the US "special". I would argue they're both design mistakes in the US government, its proponents will doubtless chime in that it's supposed to be like this, and presumably they are proud of the results...

1. Appropriations bills. In most countries it is seen as a foregone conclusion that the government should continue to operate. Politicians steer, but in their absence the ship of state continues onwards on auto-pilot. The US has never entirely worked that way, and last century the GOP intentionally destroyed some of the mechanisms to let it keep running in their absence, because of course they did. So, Congress must explicitly pass bills at least once per year that say the government will pay for things, or else important government functions just stop. Nothing like these Appropriations Bills exists in most countries.

2. Separate Executive. In most democratic countries there is ultimately a single elected power, even if it looks on the surface as though there are two or more political power centres, one of them is actually running everything. In this situation there is no conflict between policy and budget, so of course a "government budget" will pass.

One of the few upsides to another US civil war is it's likely that there would be an opportunity to redesign the US government in the aftermath. We've learned a lot about how to design governments since the 18th century.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by srtjstjsj on Sunday October 04, 2020 @07:14PM (#24683012)
How often does a civil war lead to a better constitution?

China? Vietnam? Korea?

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by leetcrew on Sunday October 04, 2020 @07:51PM (#24683201)
the obvious answer would be the 13th, 14th, and 15th amendments to the US constitution after the american civil war.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by chordalkeyboard on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:29PM (#24684313)
So once? Or twice (counting the USian revolution)? There have to be more examples than that!
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by nradov on Sunday October 04, 2020 @03:59PM (#24681830)
That is an acceptable outcome.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by yunruse on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:10PM (#24680555)
This is a moot point anyway; laws can be overwritten with new laws. Perhaps requiring a supermajority (2/3) to remove would be useful, but even still, _having_ the laws put into question would be a remarkable use of time, keeping law orderly. I suppose the US Code might help with that effort; in the UK it's a tad more disorganised.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by gogopuppygogo on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:00PM (#24680914)
The amount of grifting you’d end would put up some really deep pocketed defenders of the current system.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by vixen99 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:40PM (#24680298)
That's not going to happen.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Acts_of_the_Parliament...

I'll leave it to someone else to tot up how many laws we're considering here.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by dec0dedab0de on Monday October 05, 2020 @03:54AM (#24685533)
I have thought this for a long time. I also think they should have to be voted in by the public, with a higher percentage required as the geographical area expands.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by godelski on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:22PM (#24681091)
This is why I always liked the idea of automatic sunsetting of laws. If it worked as expected, pass it through again. If it had loopholes, patch and reissue (better than applying patch to patch to patch). If it didn't have the effect you wanted, let it slip by. It is always beneficial to review your work and analyze it. There needs to be a good mechanism for this to happen within a government and automatic sunsetting forces this issue on lawmakers. Of course, there are other things that can help too.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by smaryjerry on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:37PM (#24680732)
Also lawmakers have pretty much put sourced their jobs to unelected committees. They realized they don’t know anything about a topic and also can’t be bothered so they appoint these committees Who put into place “regulations” instead of laws that are basically the same thing but without oversight or accountability - they don’t get voted out if people don’t like it, and most don’t even know who these people are.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by cortesoft on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:09PM (#24681898)
> They realized they don’t know anything about a topic and also can’t be bothered so they appoint these committees

It is literally impossible for any single elected official to know enough about every topic they need to legislate in order to make good laws. This isn't because they "can't be bothered", but because there are only so many hours in a day. They have to delegate.

Now, we can argue they do a poor job of delegating, but the problem isn't in the act itself.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by 0134340 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:20PM (#24680624)
Anyone have a rough estimation of the laws made vs laws repealed? This is what I wonder and worry sometimes. It seems we're constantly making far more laws than repealing and slowly but surely caging ourselves in. Our parties seem to be in a blind race downhill to see who can implement the most laws to block the other parties but I feel we're just "cleaning" ourselves into a corner.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by yreg on Sunday October 04, 2020 @06:38PM (#24682820)
I'm not american, but I listened to this Planet Money podcast[0] and they talked about how Trump planned to enforce the following rule:

>If congress wants to add a new regulation, they have to find two outdated regulations and remove them.

I have no idea how it went.

[0] episode including transcript: https://www.npr.org/transcripts/659049880

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by dragonwriter on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:10PM (#24684224)
Well, since regulations are created by the executive branch and not Congress, which makes law and to which the President can't dictate rules, the proposed rule is meaningless, so enforcing it is a non-issue.

Also, “a regulation” is not a particularly useful unit of size.

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by lenkite on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @02:49AM (#24695294)
Supposedly it helped a bit according to the below: https://www.forbes.com/sites/waynecrews/2020/06/29/how-donal...
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by xkcd-sucks on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:02PM (#24684177)
That would have to include a rule about scope, so that it doesn't end up as two old laws concatenated into one new law

...this would be good for other reasons too, like unrelated riders tacked onto appropriations bills

Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by anm89 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:37AM (#24679358)
Funny I think I internalized that rant from that video, because I had forgotten about that video but I'd definitely seen it before.
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by Enginerrrd on Sunday October 04, 2020 @09:44PM (#24683833)
What's even worse is it's disturbingly easy to not just break the law, but it's surprisingly easy to commit a felony. That's a situation that just shouldn't be. In my opinion, a felony should almost universally be something either egregiously reckless or done with nefarious intent, and it should be something that people can universally agree is an obvious problem. (And by that, I mean an ACTUAL problem, not a side-target of the thing that's really of interest.)
Re:French bar owners arrested for offering free WiFi but not... by kubanczyk on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:14PM (#24680589)
Laws are source code. Currently it's all spagetti and applying even simplest proven tricks from software domain would yield immensely good results. Like, duh, removing goto.

Software is crap, law is so much worse.