One "cool" point with your friends.
"Check this out dudes! Alexa! Brew coffee"
And when Alexa responds with, "Please add water", you lose two cool points and end up in a deficit.
If you need to remote start your coffee pot, you need to get your life a little more together. If you need remote notifications that coffee is done, the same applies. It's not hard to plan around "Coffee takes about 15 minutes to brew, so I start it before I hop in the shower".
Same applies to other household appliances: the dishwasher, the oven, the washing machine. All I want is to have a set of icons in my computer's tray that change color when a given device is done. This would let me stop scheduling life around the machines, or having to keep the doors to the home office open and headphones off to hear the various beeps. Instead, I could set them to do the work, and go back to doing my stuff fully focused.
In a sane world where tech companies practice anything resembling solid engineering, this would not require the devices to have an Internet connection. Working over LAN with standardized (and already existing) protocols is all that's required. In this world, I don't have any of the conveniences described above, because I'm not crazy or gullible enough to buy an IoT appliance.
I used to be here, had goals of "Tony Stark-ing" as much of my home automation as Ic could and managed to succeed in a lot of ways.
What's weird is where I used to be 50/50 WFH thanks to successfully negotiating it in my hiring, going 100% WFH has made me really appreciate having analog "chores" to do that have nothing to do with the world of digital technology that consumes 8-10 hours of the day. In fact I've started looking forward to them.
The side effects have been interesting, the chores went from "I gotta clear out the dishwasher otherwise I'll have nothing to cook with, I wish I could automate this" to "I'm gonna tidy up and put on some Chuck Mingus because it's a nice break from Zoom calls" and has introduced a lot of deliberate-ness to my world that didn't exist before. And I like it.
Anybody else reach this inflection point in their day to day yet having gone full-remote?
For me, the perfect break from 8 hours of work isn't analog chores. It's playing a videogame. Or working on a side project. Or reading a book. I don't know why is that, perhaps because I just don't tire in front of computers: I can stare at a screen for 16+ hours and my eyes don't even get dry (I contrast that to some of my co-workers from previous jobs, who'd have to take breaks to put saline drops in their eyes near the end of the work day).
This of course puts me in a risk group - I have to actively manage myself to not become a couch potato. I've been working from home for more than 3 years now, so I know I can easily do the "work -> videogame -> sleep -> repeat" routine without ever getting away from a computer for more than 15 minutes. Being married definitely helps with ensuring I don't spend the whole day in front of the screen.
But the bottom line is: even after an exhausting day, I don't find rest in physical chores. Never had. So I welcome every opportunity to get rid of them, as I always feel I have more interesting stuff to do.
I love manual chores. During RSI breaks, (previously pomodoro breaks), five minutes cleaning out the washer, hanging up laundry, weeding a patch of vegetables, pruning a shrub, chopping wood, collecting fruit, feeding chickens or just petting my cats.
E.g. plucking weed in my garden gives me headspace to 'zoom out'. To see bigger pictures. Evaluate if 'm ye entire morning updating the linter' benefits the company at all (no). Or if performance really is an issue for customers in that area. Or if this idea for presentation-models really helps with velocity.
It’s a deep hole when you fall it, but you can have what you want.
ESP8266 and ESP32 chips can be made to to do all sorts of magic and are very inexpensive and easily flashed.
There are a variety of option for programming them from flashing with mostly-premade software (ESPHome) or do it yourself with Arduino. Mine all tie into Home Assistant.
There are a range of sensors that do all sorts of things.
Mine post to a Slack channel for stuff I want to know about.
The time invested is vastly more than the time saved, but I love it.
(One of these days I'll figure out how to properly design battery-powered devices, and build some sensors that aren't hooked to wall warts.)
There is a flame sensor available for Arduino.
Bad jokes aside, it is annoying having wall warts and batteries aren’t a perfect solution either.
I’ve only wired one relay but it does give me pause.
If I could schedule the dishwasher to start automatically at 10 am every weekday, that would be fantastic! If it could remind me to load detergent the night before, that would be even better. And if the dishwasher had a reservoir of detergent that I only had to refill once a month... I’m not saying these little enhancements would be life-changing or anything, and if they cost hundreds of dollars extra, I would certainly pass. But it would be nice.
——
1: (Now I work from home, so there’s no way to avoid hearing the dishwasher.)
If it takes 3 minutes, press start, look at the clock, come back in 3 (or ~1 song later, if that's easier).
I don't mean to be rude, but if a task this simple is difficult for you to manage on your own, you might benefit from a little more organizing and self-discipline in your life.
To each their own (I don't know your life), but in my world, attempting to be "fully focused" every second of the day is a perfect recipe for burnout. Coffee, for me, is about not being fully focused. Like an intentional break from it (i.e, a "coffee break"). Taking the time to prep it, brew it, and drink it, is all a part of the process.
It's a fun experiment to try and optimize every minute of the day around productivity, but its untenable, long-term.
Sure. And that's how I cope with life, really. My watch has a bunch of timers pre-configured on it - a Pomodoro timer, a "pizza in oven" timer, a "baguettes in oven" timer, an "instant noodles" timer, etc. But the list of timers keeps growing, and it's mildly annoying that I have to do it in the first place. So my argument here can be somewhat simplified to: in a world with working IoT, I wouldn't have to manage those timers.
> if a task this simple is difficult for you to manage on your own
I never said I can't manage it. I only said it's annoying to have to be waiting on the kettle. One more thing to juggle in your head.
> To each their own (I don't know your life), but in my world, attempting to be "fully focused" every second of the day is a perfect recipe for burnout.
I don't mean to be rude, but yeah, you don't know my life :).
I'm not trying to optimize my entire day to the minute (I actually did try that, I couldn't handle it - I'm not wired for rigid, inflexible schedules without space for randomness). But due to nature and nurture, I require a constant influx of fresh tea (I average roughly a cup an hour). I drink tea while doing the stuff I'm doing. So during the course of the day, it does intersect the times where I want to be focused - whether on work, on a side project, or on my family.
My philosophy of life is one of eliminating upkeep and maintenance work - things that distract me from what I want to be doing. So e.g. I use a dishwasher to spend less time cleaning up after cooking (and save some water too). "Eating good food" is the only goal I care about here - the cooking and the cleaning afterwards are both means to an end, and the less effort they take, the better. Under the same philosophy, I'd prefer if my kettle could be filled and triggered remotely, and flashed an icon on my desktop (or better, vibed my watch) when it's done.
And to be absolutely clear: we're talking ultimate "first world problem" level here. I'm not suffering because I have a manually operated kettle.
“Siri, 5 minute timer”. Cross-platform solution.
No matter what I need a notification about, it’s the same action every time if I’m boiling noodles or filling the bathtub or preheating the barbecue. No configuration necessary. I appreciate that level of simplicity.
FWIW, I have my Pebble workflow simplified to "long hold down button" as a shortcut to timer list, then scroll to the right timer, "long hold middle button" to start it. It takes about as much time as it takes me to fetch my phone from my pocket. Also, since I do Pomodoros during work day (to keep myself focused), the timer list is usually always open on my watch, so the flow reduces to just scrolling through the list and activating the right timer - i.e. roughly 2 seconds. And, after activating the timer, I don't have a phone to stow back into my pocket :).
(Also, since the timer is active and visible on my watch, I can give an immediate answer whenever my wife asks me how much longer is the cooking going to take :). That one was a side benefit I didn't initially expect.)
> No configuration necessary. I appreciate that level of simplicity.
Yeah, that's good. In my case, I achieve almost the equivalent through pre-configuration: over time I've accrued a bunch of pre-set timers that cover 95% of my day-to-day needs. I rarely need to create a new one.
Anyway, that's what works for me now. I'm not saying this is optimal for everyone.
You set the temp. on the app, and how long to keep warm once it reaches that temp, and it sends push notifications for when it is ready and also done warming.
I have not decompiled the app, nor attempted to MitM it yet.
I also think it’s not tech companies making these devices, they are low margin commodities. And since you’re competing adding a luxury like a notification on your phone, versus 4 minutes of your time. It hard to justify the larger margin.
Presumably they're similar to smart TVs: some consumers may want them, but nearly all OEMs would rather sell a smart one than a dumb one
A lot of powered appliances either heat something up or spin a fan or pump. They don't need information from the internet and any slight advantage is outweighed by their complexity and cost.
I think you are right that manufacturers want to break free from being commodities. I think it is only a matter of time before people realize that they aren't gaining anything from complicating things that used to be simple.
But a coffee machine, toaster or whatever... just... why?!
Even as a life-long techie, and putting aside privacy concerns, there isn't a single compelling reason to want my coffee machine to be connected to the Internet, or even my local network.
> "Smart TVs are different..."
and
> " think it is only a matter of time before people realize that they aren't gaining anything from complicating things that used to be simple."
you're making the same mistake of overgeneralizing, assuming that every (other) smart appliance can't have usefulness outside of its core, dumb functionality, based on one example of that being true.
hopefully we can agree that some smartened appliances benefit the consumer, though not all (as in the case of a coffee maker), even if manufacturers are incentivized to break out of the commodity box by smartifying all the things, consequences and functionality be damned.
I'm not assuming that at all and it has nothing to do with smart TVs. Smart TVs are a place where having a computer inside is something people want.
I'm saying other appliances are different, not because there can't be a benefit, but because the benefits are much smaller and complexity to usefulness ratio is much smaller. Also operating most appliances remotely or with a more elaborate interface doesn't give much benefit. Thermostats might be somewhere in the middle since there is a lot of room for improvement, not just in setting up a schedule or setting them remotely, but in the information they give back to you (how many btus are you leaking out of your house over time, etc.)
So much potential to become a real trojan
Agree with that. Especially if a hard problem stumps me, it's very refreshing to actually focus on making coffee for a few minutes. It clears the head to so something simple and different for a few minutes.
The rest of the day, I want that routine. It's an excuse to go downstairs and play with my kid for five minutes.
Making good coffee isn't expensive and it isn't rocket science. It doesn't even have to be that fresh to still be good. But there are two corners you absolutely can't cut: if you skimp on the quantity of coffee, you waste all you've used; if you skimp on time, you waste all you've spent.
Though I've been drinking black coffee since my teens and never found it bitter when made right. The cream-and-sugar majority might disagree.
For many people, the cost (both labor and monetary) of "good" coffee doesn't come with a corresponding increase in their enjoyment. You won't change their mind.
Instant coffee is not even in the same category as brewed coffee. I am by no means a coffee snob. I do grind beans right before I brew, but they are the lowest priced beans I can find that taste good to me (which is reasonably cheap).
I'd love to just microwave a cup, but that stuff tastes nasty.
I don't believe I have an impaired sense of taste. I'm just highly skeptical of the objectivity of my sense of taste. Marketting and branding probably has more influence than anything else when comparing two drinks in the same category (wine-to-wine, coffee-to-coffee, etc.)
Biased sample. There are many confounding factors why if you cannot tell the difference, it is likely your family can’t either.
I do like the idea of testing my wine drinking friends, who are definitely not snobs. I would bet money they would mostly pick the difference between a normal: Oaked Chardonnay, Reisling, Savignon Blanc, and Cabernet Savignon. I suspect the red wine drinkers could tell some of the red wine varietals too (I would struggle there).
Well, that's a bit of a strawman, isn't it, given it would typically boil down to "vanilla/not vanilla" for most chardonnays?
Coffee.. geeze, much more so. If the only thing available is a jug of brewed coffeewater that you pump out nice and bubbly, as at hotel breakfast bars or conference centres, I have to really 'need' it, and then I pack it with sugar to take the taste away. (I don't ordinarily drink coffee with sugar at all.) Instant, I just can't drink. I could definitely tell you the difference between instant 'coffee' and real, it's not a case of having a preference and better 'notes' like 'essence of snobby bullshit' - one I would be able to drink, and the other I would want to spit out before it even hit my lips.
I think you are concluding too much for the data points you have (of your personal experience).
I have a similar palate (lack thereof) like yours, but even my family members can tell when I've (say) used "too much" garlic in a recipe--when I can't even tell that the garlic is even there in the final product. (I only use it because the recipe says to.) Using a (e.g.) different marinade for chicken does not change my perception of it much when I chow down, but it does for others eating it.
I once heard the explanation that the 'flavour' of a food is made of the taste (tongue), aroma (smell), and even texture of a food. Adam Ragusa made a video on the smell part recently:
* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_O-E-7MMNyE
I suspect that I (and you given your descriptions) may have some kind of lowered sense of smell when comes to intaking foods and beverages, and so do not perceive the "tastes" as much as some other people. For example I cannot tell the difference in a lager, stout, etc, types of beer (they're all 'yeast water' to me), but I know people who love beer so much that if you put down a random one in from of them they could ID the style and often the maker and make.
The flavours that do not exist in your experience may in fact do so for folks who have senses that are more sensitive than yours. Epicurious has a series of videos where experts do a blind taste test on "Cheap vs Expensive" products:
* https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLz3-p2q6vFYUpr-f2wOSQ...
There certainly are folks that pre-judge things by simply knowing which is which beforehand, but to say that 'there are no differences' is swinging the pendulum the other way too much as well IMHO.
Find a few coffee gear testing reviews where they use the same beans, using the same grinder, and yet different brewers cause slightly different results as perceive by the testers.
America's Test Kitchen is a good source, as they often have a dozen-plus folks do blind tests to find the most-liked ("best") product.
And I'm definitely not a coffee snob. But I can tell you that bog standard Tesco "house blend" coffee tastes nicer in a Philips Solimo machine than in an Aeropress, and nicer in the Aeropress than in a cafetière. And Amazon branded Solimo sachets aren't quite as nice as the ground coffee in the machine, but are good enough for every-day use.
Although, personally, I'd question anyone buying these, much less taking out their phone while they're driving to tell a "smart" coffee maker to brew a cup.
Surely a kettle (ahem) boils down to a simple resistor (the heating element) that gets good and hot, boiling the water. P=VI, so if you halve the voltage (wrt the UK) you need to sink twice the current. I=V/R, so if you need to double the current (and voltage is fixed) you need to halve the resistance.
Is the problem that they're rare enough that they're all import kettles safe at 110 but designed for higher voltages?
AmazonBasics kettle (first result for searching kettle) for example is rated 1.5kW.
I'm just sceptical that all American kettles can suck, and mains voltage be the cause. If that were the only reason, and otherwise you'd all love them, you'd have a 'kettle socket' on higher amperage, as for ovens (here too, 32A).
The fact that most IoT is shit doesn’t make IoT a stupid concept.
Rather you sent a command in hopes that it would turn off, and hopefully it reports back correctly.
An IoT oven sounds like the worst possible home attack surface. Especially if it's a gas appliance.
Yes. The reality is they while this is a cool experimental hack, no one in reality is going to bother hacking other people's coffee makers.
A Ransomware-bridge between networks: https://www.hackread.com/how-a-coffee-machine-infected-facto...
Additionally, I was finding most of these devices were actually increasing the time it took to do something rather than enabling some impossible interaction.
I’m short on IoT except for industrial usage, where you are displacing an inspector or a manual data collection. That said those spaces are just as bad as the home devices.