Email would beg to differ. Google and Microsoft may have a lot of users, but interoperability is astoundingly high.
Yes, there is a high barrier to sending emails from a new provider, and yes, Google/Microsoft have a large chunk of the market. Still, there's little barrier to using ProtonMail or Fastmail or whatever free host you want, and everything interoperates shockingly well. You don't typically have to think about "what if this person has gmail?" or "I don't know if I can send to that host from outlook".
I don't think that is necessarily a bad thing, but I think for federated services to catch on, you need big players that provide reliable service and a recognizable brand. The average person is not going to want to search through thousands of small federated servers to try and find one that works for them. And running a single server might be simple and inexpensive, but making it reliable and secure is not.
That's just because installing and maintaining your own email server is extremely complicated [1]. Lots of people maintained their own Kazaa/Limewire servers for their friends (and the bigger piracy community) back in the day, because it was as simple as double clicking setup.exe and installing the software, and then configuring it.
Email does require higher reliability than Limewire. But I imagine if someone made a 100$ box that I could plug into my router, and so could 3 of my friends, and that had an email server installed on it or could be easily by clicking a installation file, and the 3 could act in concert to provide email services to the 50 people, maybe you would see more uptake.
[1] I am a tech-savy user who has been looking for a simple solution for a decade now.
It's not anymore [0]. However, good look on getting Microsoft's or other's mail servers to accept your e-mail. That's a big reason why even tech savvy users give up on hosting their own mail server. I've been running my own mail server for over two years now and the situation hasn't improved. My last problem was that a mail server from a government agency straight up refused the SMTP connection and contacting their postmaster mailbox yielded no response.
(For anyone wondering: It's not a problem with the configuration of my mail server, I've checked it about 10 times now. It passes all MxToolbox checks. However, I'm using an .xyz domain which might contribute to my problem.)
[0] mailcow.email
This includes, having out of the box configuration, that makes the email acceptable by Microsoft/Gmail etc.
[0] https://mailcow.github.io/mailcow-dockerized-docs/i_u_m_inst...
It's a bit more complicated than that but the simplest solution I know.
> This includes, having out of the box configuration, that makes the email acceptable by Microsoft/Gmail etc.
This is unfortunately impossible. You can have a perfectly valid configuration including reverse DNS, SPF, DKIM and DMARC, yet Microsoft's email servers will still let your mails vanish.
Yes, but importantly, those few big providers federate. That means that the barrier to entry for the little guys is much lower. This situation, while not ideal, is vastly better than the non-federated alternative.
Looking at stuff created in the last 10-15 years, are there any federation successes? I can't think of any. (Blockchain excluded for the reason stated in the article)
Of course, there are few if any political leaders or CEO's posting there, but that's not a definition of success to me.
I have thought about what would happen if someone like, say, Musk would proclaim that they're quitting Twitter and setting up a Mastodon instance instead. I'm not sure the Fediverse would be better off if that happened.
I have met many new friends on all the networks that I have joined however.
Each urbit instance is a peer. The stars and galaxies provide discovery and initial routing, which is a pretty neat solution, they're basically fancy DNS servers.
What I think is exciting about urbit, is that each identity can host services. So you can launch a chat room, and it's yours, other peers can show up and say things in it, but this is very different from federation, where there is a sharp distinction between administrators and users.
Anyone who comments in your chat room can have a chat of their own, and the cryptographic identity of you and them is identical and consistent, wherever in the fleet you may encounter each other.
Stability and performance have improved, but there's a long way to go before a smooth one-click user experience is a reality.
But the basic design is solid, and it has a chance precisely because it isn't federated, but distributed. Secure Scuttlebutt is another truly distributed system, of very different design; it's locked in some bad architecture but I found it quite pleasant to interact with.
Don't expect anything useful from Holochain, ever. Just... I don't want to get into inside baseball, but, nah. Never gonna happen.
SSB is neat, but ineed could use rearchitecting. I could imagine ssb-like system + handshake to work quite OK for certain things.
Thanks for info on Holochain. I've been only lurking in there and reading docs, so my understanding is rather shallow and theoretical.
Sure there's a reason federated networks like Usenet died - they were killed off by a combination of the old/new AT&T/Verizon duopoly and various government organizations ( https://www.cnet.com/news/n-y-attorney-general-forces-isps-t... ). Yes, it happened for a reason - the old Bell last-mile monopoly and active government measures to quash it.
What about GNUnet? They’re trying to build pretty much what you described, from the ground up. https://gnunet.org/en/
Superficially it looks to me like bunch of theoreticians overcomplicated everything, and it will never be practical. Probably great project to advance your academic carrier though. But maybe I'm wrong.
Please note: I am being very careful with the claims I am making here. I have a little more than a layperson's understanding of Rome's history (years of Latin classes paying off at last!) but not nearly enough to call myself an authority on governments through the ages.
My point -- my only[0] point -- is that "The Internet started off federated and has become centralized / nobody has gotten federation to stick yet" is not enough of an argument to support "federation is doomed to failure".
My comment does not totally disagree with its parent, which seems to think that alternative approaches may succeed. We certainly agree that it's important to learn from the past.
I'm having trouble wrapping this up, but don't want to spend more time, so I'll leave it on that somewhat unfinished note.
[0] edit: I suppose there is also a secondary point that systems design is, like governance, an inherently social issue. This makes any analysis a lot more complex than if we restrict ourselves to purely technical merits.
If you want a classic example, some of the Greek city states might count. Though keep in mind that many of the Greeks considered sortition (ie random selection) the hallmark of the democracy, and considered that voting would just lead to aristocracy or oligarchy.
The German Free Imperial Cities are an interesting object of study. And there's lots to be learned from eg China as well.
I did intentionally avoid clarifying this (also, technically the US is a republic) because I was trying to paint in broad strokes — I don't think my point needed details to be convincing and so I didn't want to get bogged down in them. I'm happy for the clarification as a reply, though :) A better phrase, which I would have used if I'd thought of it at the time, would be "representative government".
Well, looking at the US at least, they weren't wrong.
Eg the German electoral system is also a bit messy, but seems to work well in practice. That might be a better yardstick to measure what voting can do, before we dismiss it.
(My favourite sortition variant right now:
- everyone can register as a candidate, if they want to - every voter can pick one candidate to put on their ballot - we select a few hundred ballots at random to fill up a parliament
For completeness sake, add some mechanism to handle a single candidate being selected by more than one randomly drawn ballot. Eg you could draw again, or you could give that candidate extra weight in parliamentary votes, or you could form a chain and add a person of the double-candidates choice to parliament, or you could have voters write down multiple candidates in order, and just pick a later one on the voters list etc.
Parliament can then select the executive, like it is already done in the UK or in Germany.)
The sortition system I sketched would still reward specialisation of labour, but there would be fewer threshold effects: if you convince thirty friends friends to ballot for you, you'd have a ten times higher chance to make it into parliament compared to only convincing three friends.
With voting you have threshold effects. In all but the smallest towns, getting thirty people to vote for you has exactly the same outcome as zero votes.
This has repeated a lot in the history of the western civilization.
Spam is ramptant. Running a server is a nightmare.
Standards are a tar pit.
It "works" only for fairly loose definitions of "works".
Using spam-assassin, clamav, and a few recommended tweaks (greylisting, HELO rules, blocking .ads, .party, and friends) and I'm down near zero spam.
And if your not part of the main group, what's even the point of federation? It's practically "servers" at that point.
No amount of technology is going to fix the 'a majority of people don't like you or interact with you' problem though.
That's nonsense.
I run my own instance and don't use any sort of ban list, and I can interact just fine with both the "main" instances, and a whole host of smaller, more niche, instances.
it's more interesting because the UX encourages different styles of posting (no QRTs for dunks, for one) that people are developing into slightly different social idioms. also no ads, chrono timeline, pick your own image crops...
I run my own instance. As far as I can tell, this is false. There are some ban lists floating around, though I'm yet to see a common, standard policy of blocking instances because they don't subscribe to a particular blocklist.
media organizations, pols, and public sector institutions do. Your grandma doesn't need to use Mastodon and it's not about her. It's about those who will be followed and have something important to transmit.
The entire form of current global human society is federated so you can't simply state it does not work. For the internet so far we have a few empires that battle it out, but I don't think they are manageable long term and this has started to become apparent.
Would you care to mention them?
Coke is number one for a reason. Sure there is Pepsi, and yes there are small soda makers that either get acquired or close, but not too many people make their own soda.
For the same reason, there won't be a federated social network...
Unless, people don't even realize they're using one, but that gets back to your point, we'd need a new form of internet.
These problems are so fundamental and universal that you pretty much need "a new form of Internet" that solves them, so then apps running in it can compete with centralized services.
So far the best stab at the problem is Urbit, but mostly because almost nobody else is even trying. Handshake and Holochains are another interesting projects in this space, but more of a pieces of potentially bigger picture.