News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The unrealized potential of federation by reificator on Monday September 21, 2020 @08:30PM (#24549773)
> Federated systems just don't work in practice because of inherent problems with them that don't have good technical&social solutions yet. Everything on the Internet (including Internet itself) degenerated from federation into monopolistic centralized services for a reason, and somehow people keep ignoring the evidence, and just keep trying harder.

Email would beg to differ. Google and Microsoft may have a lot of users, but interoperability is astoundingly high.

Yes, there is a high barrier to sending emails from a new provider, and yes, Google/Microsoft have a large chunk of the market. Still, there's little barrier to using ProtonMail or Fastmail or whatever free host you want, and everything interoperates shockingly well. You don't typically have to think about "what if this person has gmail?" or "I don't know if I can send to that host from outlook".

Re:The unrealized potential of federation by thayne on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @12:41AM (#24550915)
Well most people use one of a few big email providers, not small individual mail servers run by tech-savvy friends or family.

I don't think that is necessarily a bad thing, but I think for federated services to catch on, you need big players that provide reliable service and a recognizable brand. The average person is not going to want to search through thousands of small federated servers to try and find one that works for them. And running a single server might be simple and inexpensive, but making it reliable and secure is not.

Re:The unrealized potential of federation by abdullahkhalids on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @02:50AM (#24551656)
> Well most people use one of a few big email providers, not small individual mail servers run by tech-savvy friends or family.

That's just because installing and maintaining your own email server is extremely complicated [1]. Lots of people maintained their own Kazaa/Limewire servers for their friends (and the bigger piracy community) back in the day, because it was as simple as double clicking setup.exe and installing the software, and then configuring it.

Email does require higher reliability than Limewire. But I imagine if someone made a 100$ box that I could plug into my router, and so could 3 of my friends, and that had an email server installed on it or could be easily by clicking a installation file, and the 3 could act in concert to provide email services to the 50 people, maybe you would see more uptake.

[1] I am a tech-savy user who has been looking for a simple solution for a decade now.

Re:The unrealized potential of federation by MaKey on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @10:50AM (#24555075)
> That's just because installing and maintaining your own email server is extremely complicated

It's not anymore [0]. However, good look on getting Microsoft's or other's mail servers to accept your e-mail. That's a big reason why even tech savvy users give up on hosting their own mail server. I've been running my own mail server for over two years now and the situation hasn't improved. My last problem was that a mail server from a government agency straight up refused the SMTP connection and contacting their postmaster mailbox yielded no response.

(For anyone wondering: It's not a problem with the configuration of my mail server, I've checked it about 10 times now. It passes all MxToolbox checks. However, I'm using an .xyz domain which might contribute to my problem.)

[0] mailcow.email

Re:The unrealized potential of federation by abdullahkhalids on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @12:40PM (#24556669)
Come on, this is the installation process [0]. If it's more complicated than apt/yum install mailcow, followed by a nice friendly browser based configuration page, it's too complicated for widespread usage.

This includes, having out of the box configuration, that makes the email acceptable by Microsoft/Gmail etc.

[0] https://mailcow.github.io/mailcow-dockerized-docs/i_u_m_inst...

Re:The unrealized potential of federation by MaKey on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @01:15PM (#24557193)
> If it's more complicated than apt/yum install mailcow, followed by a nice friendly browser based configuration page, it's too complicated for widespread usage.

It's a bit more complicated than that but the simplest solution I know.

> This includes, having out of the box configuration, that makes the email acceptable by Microsoft/Gmail etc.

This is unfortunately impossible. You can have a perfectly valid configuration including reverse DNS, SPF, DKIM and DMARC, yet Microsoft's email servers will still let your mails vanish.

Re:The unrealized potential of federation by gspr on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @02:28AM (#24551517)
> Well most people use one of a few big email providers, not small individual mail servers run by tech-savvy friends or family.

Yes, but importantly, those few big providers federate. That means that the barrier to entry for the little guys is much lower. This situation, while not ideal, is vastly better than the non-federated alternative.

Re:The unrealized potential of federation by MaKey on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @10:58AM (#24555189)
While they do federate, it's a challenge to get them to accept mails from your own mail server. Microsoft's mail servers are notorious for accepting your mails with a "250 Queued for delivery" and then letting them vanish in a black hole. I've also ran into problems with mail servers of government agencies. So yes, while technically possible, self-hosting your mail server sadly isn't viable anymore for the little guy.
Re:The unrealized potential of federation by clusterfish on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @12:03AM (#24550712)
Email was already too big to fail by the time Facebook and Google got big enough to be able to kill it.

Looking at stuff created in the last 10-15 years, are there any federation successes? I can't think of any. (Blockchain excluded for the reason stated in the article)

Re:The unrealized potential of federation by lokedhs on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @12:37AM (#24550891)
What's the definition of success? I spend far too much time on the Fediverse (mastodon) and if success is measured by the amount of time I spend there, it's the most successful service I use.

Of course, there are few if any political leaders or CEO's posting there, but that's not a definition of success to me.

I have thought about what would happen if someone like, say, Musk would proclaim that they're quitting Twitter and setting up a Mastodon instance instead. I'm not sure the Fediverse would be better off if that happened.

Re:The unrealized potential of federation by clusterfish on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @07:50AM (#24553390)
Wide adoption. Especially for social network type apps, which are rather useless without my friends in them.
Re:The unrealized potential of federation by lokedhs on Tuesday September 22, 2020 @08:02AM (#24553488)
To each their own, clearly. I don't think I ever joined a social network because my friends used it (possible exception of FB, but I'm not actually using that one. There could be correlation there).

I have met many new friends on all the networks that I have joined however.